When Does In-House Property Management Start Making Sense?

Question

For investors scaling their portfolios:

At what door count did you decide to bring management in-house rather than using third-party management?

Was the decision primarily about cost savings, operational control, or scalability?

Jim Johnson · Answer

Good discussion — the shift usually happens when management stops being a service and starts becoming an operation.

For many investors, the tipping point is somewhere around 20-40 doors, depending on property type and how concentrated the portfolio is. Below that, third-party management often makes sense because the fixed overhead of staff, systems and oversight can outweigh the savings.

When portfolios grow, a few factors usually drive the change:

• Operational control — faster decisions on leasing, maintenance, and capital projects
• Cost efficiency — management fees start to exceed what an internal team would cost
• Consistency — standardized processes across units and vendors
• Scale efficiency — enough units to keep staff fully utilized

Operational control — faster decisions on leasing, maintenance, and capital projects

Cost efficiency — management fees start to exceed what an internal team would cost

Consistency — standardized processes across units and vendors

Scale efficiency — enough units to keep staff fully utilized

That said, door count alone isn’t the whole story. Geographic concentration matters a lot. Thirty units spread across multiple markets is very different from thirty units in one area.

In practice, many investors land on a hybrid approach for a while using third-party managers in some markets while building internal systems where the density supports it.

Richard F. · Answer

Just to add to @Drew Sygit's comments, investors's seem to completely discount the value a qualified PM brings to the table regarding the myriad of laws and regs that you need to know. Lesson's always come with a cost.

Drew Sygit · Answer

How much is YOUR time worth?

How much of YOUR time will it take to bring it in house?

DIY owners NOTORIOUSLY sell their time short by not realizing how much time they actually spend doing it themselves.

Richard F. · Answer

Well, from the PM side, a loose "rule of thumb" is you need one staff person for every 50 units under management.At some point, that typically looks like: Accounts Payable, Accounts Receivable, PM, Reception/Admin. Staffing expands as unit count grows to include Project Manager, Payroll, Leasing Agent, Maintenance Supervisor and specialized trades and helpers.

You must have solid systems in place to grow without chaos. Figuring those out "on the job" with multiple units can get very costly.

When Does In-House Property Management Start Making Sense?

When Does In-House Property Management Start Making Sense?

Most Popular Reply

4 Replies