Downdraft stoves gone out of style?

Question

Need a new stove put in.

The existing system is downdraft but I don't see anything decent below $1400 and options are limited. I know they are less efficient than the overhead fans but this house was installed with one a couple decades ago.

For going with a range hood, the cost is $200, installation is $500... which is fine, but ductwork will have to be put in and creatively. The ceiling above just is a no go zone from 3 different contractors and I've looked around with a flashlight myself. It has to be done over the island (island range hood) as otherwise we have to tear out cabinets/sink adding more work. The quotes average around $1800. So with a new stove, it's $3k.

Is the extra $1600 worth it , or is a downdraft good enough?

Pat L. · Answer

My SIL had one in an old place they bought & the smell after cooking was rancid, then it caught fire. It also had a grill component to it??? Tough to get all the grease residue out after decades of use & the fire/insurance claim paid for a complete overhaul.

Mike Reynolds · Answer

Downdraft has had it's day pretty much. The grease gets trapped in the pipe after time and causes a smell. Do away with it and go with something else.

Boone Rodriguez · Answer

I'm in this same boat right now.  I'm about to jump into researching alternative options but thought I'd check the forums first to see if anyone else has run into this and found a more budget friendly solution.  (First time posting here btw, but have listened to the podcast for a bit).

Here is what my pm said below. I'll post what I end up doing when we're finished.   Not a big fan of replacing downdraft ranges!

Downdraft stoves gone out of style?

Most Popular Reply