Let’s talk about data.
There is a complicated set of assumptions that go into calculating demand. That includes income growth, net migration, jobs growth, qualitative assumptions about desirability of an area, etc.
I am sure that many of these look great for Austin. I am sure that people are moving there, I am sure that people are getting good jobs, I am sure that Austin is a wonderful place to live, and the very high expectations for the city’s bright future are all realized without obstacle.
However, I prefer to start my analysis with supply. Supply data and forecasting, unlike demand data and forecasting, is easy. There are no qualitative assumptions. There are no mysteries. There are no complicated models to build out. All new supply is permitted, and easily traceable. Developers usually have expensive bridge debt on their construction projects, and a heavy incentive to deliver their inventory as rapidly as possible. While it is possible that some construction gets abandoned, the reality is that most projected supply will be completed, and will immediately get absorbed by the market.
Here is the supply forecast for 2024 for the largest metros in the country:
I don't need someone's demand forecasts.
I can tell, right here, right now, that Austin is the worst major metro to invest in rental housing stock in 2024. Rents are going down. Or if they go up, they will lag behind virtually every single other large metro in this country.
Again, I don’t care how great someone thinks Austin is, or how much relatively worse someone thinks a city like Chicago is.
Austin is going to perform worse, both for multifamily asset values and rent growth, than Chicago, in 2024, and likely into 2025 as well.
Sometimes, it’s that easy.
When there is 5.5 times as much relative inventory getting introduced to Austin compared to Chicago, the “growth” of Austin relative to Chicago really doesn’t matter much. ALL of the demand side analysis will be overwhelmed by the cruel reality (for landlords) of the supply onslaught facing that city.
On the bright side, affordability for renters will definitely be going up!
I know I will not make friends with investors, syndicators, realtors, and lenders in Austin by sharing this brutal reality with them. But, it’s far worse to leave people confused about what’s going to happen. I have tried to be as vocal about this as possible for the last two years including in Q1 2024, and Q1 2023.
Now, when supply stops coming in at this incredible rate, Austin investors will see a return to rent and price growth. In 15-30 years, this will all be noise, and properties values and rents will have increased.
In the meantime, buckle up. It will not be fun.
All this said, I know nothing of the other types of real estate in the sector. It is very possible, for example, in Austin, that valuations of office, retail, industrial, self-storage, or something else responds favorably to the changes happening in the city and could be a great buy.
But housing? I’m a bear.
Let’s come back in a year and see how it goes though. Could always be wrong!