First-Time Real Estate Investor with ~$600K Available: What Would You Do in My Positi

First-Time Real Estate Investor with ~$600K Available: What Would You Do in My Positi

Reston, VA · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 5 votes

Hi everyone! I'm pretty new to real estate investing and would love some advice on where to start.

I'm currently finishing up my second bachelor's degree in Computer Science and will most likely end up working in NYC as a software engineer after graduation. I've previously interned at AWS and have another internship lined up at Coinbase next summer, so I'm hoping to land a full-time role with around $200K in total compensation by 2028.

With how volatile the SWE job market has been lately, I'd really like to build additional sources of income outside of my career. I've been interested in real estate investing for a while, particularly owning rental properties and becoming a landlord.

For context, I currently have around $200K saved up, and my father is willing to contribute another $400K, so I'd potentially have around $600K to work with. I definitely don't want to put all of that into a single property, though.

I'm currently based in Northern Virginia and am familiar with the DMV area, but I'm open to investing elsewhere.

My initial thought was to purchase a fourplex in a more affordable market like Atlanta, Texas, or Virginia. However, since I'll most likely be living in NYC, I'm also wondering if buying a duplex there and house hacking would be a smarter move, especially with potential first-time homebuyer benefits and owner-occupied financing options.

Another thought I had was purchasing an investment property under my father's name to preserve my first-time homebuyer eligibility for when I eventually buy my own home, but I'm not sure whether that would actually be beneficial.

I'd love some advice from more experienced investors:

  • Given my situation, what investment strategy would you recommend starting with?

  • Are there any particular cities or markets you'd recommend for a first-time investor?

  • Would you prioritize house hacking in NYC or buying a rental property in a more affordable market?

  • Would purchasing under my father's name make sense, or would the potential complications outweigh the benefits?

I'm still very early in the learning process and not set on any particular strategy, property type, or location. My main goal is to build long-term wealth and generate additional income alongside my career.

If you were in my position, what would you do? I'm open to any and all suggestions, including completely different approaches I haven't considered. I'd really appreciate hearing from more experienced investors. Thanks in advance!

5Reply
1,082 views

23 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Amber StoutPro Member
    Lender · Tampa/Saint Petersburg, FL · Member since 2014 · 392 posts · 156 votes
    6d

    Hi Sage! First off, you're in a position to get started, especially with the capital you have available.

    I'm a real estate investor myself and a mortgage broker, so I'll give you my perspective from both sides.

    Personally, I'd explore the house hacking route before jumping into an out of state investment. One of the biggest advantages is being able to leverage owner occupied financing on a 2-4 unit property, potentially with as little as 3–5% down depending on the loan program and your qualifications. That allows you to preserve more of your capital for future investments.

    I'd also be careful about purchasing under your father's name solely to preserve first time homebuyer benefits. You don't necessarily need to be a first time buyer to qualify for low down payment conventional financing later. One thing I'd want to understand is whether your primary goal is monthly cash flow or long term appreciation. That would really influence which direction I'd go.


    Would love to connect further and understand more about your long term goals.

    • Reston, VA · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 5 votes
      6d

      Thanks so much for the advice! For my first property, my primary goal is to generate positive monthly cash flow rather than focus on long-term appreciation. I'd ideally like to build a portfolio of rental properties over time and gradually create a steady stream of passive income outside of my SWE career.

      I'm definitely open to house hacking, but since I'll likely be working in NYC after graduation, I'm not sure how feasible that would be given how expensive housing is there. That's why I'm also considering investing in more affordable markets where the numbers might make more sense from a cash flow perspective. I'm still very new to all of this, though, so I'm open to any suggestions or advice on what might be the best approach!

  • Diana KhanPro Member
    Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 837 posts · 307 votes
    6d
    Quote from @Sage K:

    Hi everyone! I'm pretty new to real estate investing and would love some advice on where to start.

    I'm currently finishing up my second bachelor's degree in Computer Science and will most likely end up working in NYC as a software engineer after graduation. I've previously interned at AWS and have another internship lined up at Coinbase next summer, so I'm hoping to land a full-time role with around $200K in total compensation by 2028.

    With how volatile the SWE job market has been lately, I'd really like to build additional sources of income outside of my career. I've been interested in real estate investing for a while, particularly owning rental properties and becoming a landlord.

    For context, I currently have around $200K saved up, and my father is willing to contribute another $400K, so I'd potentially have around $600K to work with. I definitely don't want to put all of that into a single property, though.

    I'm currently based in Northern Virginia and am familiar with the DMV area, but I'm open to investing elsewhere.

    My initial thought was to purchase a fourplex in a more affordable market like Atlanta, Texas, or Virginia. However, since I'll most likely be living in NYC, I'm also wondering if buying a duplex there and house hacking would be a smarter move, especially with potential first-time homebuyer benefits and owner-occupied financing options.

    Another thought I had was purchasing an investment property under my father's name to preserve my first-time homebuyer eligibility for when I eventually buy my own home, but I'm not sure whether that would actually be beneficial.

    I'd love some advice from more experienced investors:

    • Given my situation, what investment strategy would you recommend starting with?

    • Are there any particular cities or markets you'd recommend for a first-time investor?

    • Would you prioritize house hacking in NYC or buying a rental property in a more affordable market?

    • Would purchasing under my father's name make sense, or would the potential complications outweigh the benefits?

    I'm still very early in the learning process and not set on any particular strategy, property type, or location. My main goal is to build long-term wealth and generate additional income alongside my career.

    If you were in my position, what would you do? I'm open to any and all suggestions, including completely different approaches I haven't considered. I'd really appreciate hearing from more experienced investors. Thanks in advance!

    @Sage K, if I were in your position, I'd first figure out where I plan to live and how I want to manage the property before choosing a market. House hacking could be worth exploring if you'll actually be living in NYC, but with your career plans still developing, I wouldn't rush into buying there. As for putting the property under your father's name, I'd be careful with that approach. It may not be necessary to preserve first-time homebuyer benefits, depending on the program, and it could create complications with ownership.

    In my experience with previous clients as a real estate attorney and broker in Maryland, I've seen how important it is for family members investing together to be clear about their arrangements from the beginning. For example, if your father contributes $400K while you handle the property, you'd want to agree on whether that money is a gift, loan, or investment, who owns the property, and how profits and responsibilities will be shared.

    I appreciate you sharing your plans, @Sage K! It's great that you're thinking about these things before making your first purchase. Family investments and property ownership are areas I work with, so your question caught my attention. Wishing you success, and happy to stay connected!

    • Reston, VA · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 5 votes
      6d

      Thanks so much for the advice! I'll most likely be living in NYC after graduation, so I'm leaning toward investing in a more affordable market outside of NYC, especially since my main priority is generating positive monthly cash flow and NYC real estate is so expensive.

      You also bring up a great point about structuring the investment with my father. We haven't worked out all the details yet, so that's definitely something we'll need to discuss before moving forward. Really appreciate your insight!

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5d

    Welcome, Amber, and congrats on building that kind of runway before your first deal. Two things that help here: your plan to be in NYC means any property you own will be managed from a distance, so pick the market and the team first and the property second. And on buying under your dad's name, that gets tangled fast (title, financing, taxes, who owns the equity), so run it by a real estate attorney and a CPA before you decide anything.

    On house hacking in NYC, owner-occupied financing is great, but 2-4 unit prices there usually make it hard to cash flow, and most owner-occupied loans expect you to actually live there for a year or so. Since you want cash flow, I'd lean to a cheaper market you can buy remotely.

    Columbus, Ohio deserves a look for that. A lot of the deals I see there hit the 1% rule and cash flow after every expense, most with $20K-$30K of built-in equity at purchase, and single families mostly run $120K-$180K with multifamily starting around $200K. With $600K you could spread across a few doors instead of one big bet. Landlord-friendly rules help too. Happy to connect and introduce you to lenders and property managers here who work well with out-of-state investors.

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    5d

    @Sage NA since cash flow is the goal and you'll be managing from New York, one option nobody has put on the table yet: in an affordable market, look at 4 and 5 bedroom single family houses rented by the room, not just fourplexes rented by the unit.

    Each bedroom goes to a separate person on their own lease, everyone shares the kitchen and living room, and on the right house the rooms add up to well more than the whole house would rent for. It also takes the edge off vacancy, because when one person leaves you are still collecting from the rest instead of sitting at zero on a unit.

    It isn't free money, so if you model it, change these lines: you pay every utility and internet, you furnish each room and the shared spaces once, you pay a cleaner for the kitchen and bathrooms on a schedule, and rooms turn over more often than families. Our rule is a house has to clear $1,000 a month after the mortgage and every one of those costs, or we pass.

    Two checks before you fall for any market. Call the city and ask how many unrelated people can live in one house, because that number decides whether rooms work at all. And from a distance, the team matters more than usual: you need a local cleaner and handyman you trust, and a manager who actually does rooms, since a lot of managers only lease whole units.

    On your dad's $400K, the attorney's point is the right one: agree in writing whether it's a gift, a loan or a share of the property before you buy anything.

  • Investor · Member since 2026 · 13 posts · 3 votes
    5d

    Sage, one thing I haven't seen mentioned yet. Since you're a student without W-2 income, most conventional investment loans are going to be tough right now. They want income history, and a future job offer usually won't cut it for an investment purchase.

    That's where DSCR loans come in. They qualify you off the property's rent vs. the full payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance), not your personal income, so they work well for buying rentals out of state. You'll usually put more down and pay a bit higher rate than conventional, and some lenders tighten things up for first-time investors with no landlord history, so ask about that early.

    Also, how your dad's $400K is set up matters to the lender. A gift, a loan you have to pay back (which counts as debt), or him going on as a co-owner/guarantor all get treated differently. I'd figure that out before you go under contract because they're going to want a paper trail on those funds.

    And on the NYC house hack, owner-occupied loans expect you to move in pretty quickly after closing and live there about a year, so only go that route if you're actually going to live there.

    Once you narrow it down to a market and have a property in mind, I'm happy to run the numbers with you.

  • Denise SuppleeBusiness Member
    Realtor · Willow Grove, PA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 667 votes
    5d

    If you're going to be living in NYC, I'd be careful about buying in a market you don't know well just because the numbers look better. Being a long-distance landlord means you need a really good team on the ground. I'd also ask yourself if you actually want the job of being a landlord while you're building a career. There are ways to invest in real estate without managing properties yourself, and that's something I'd consider with the amount of capital you're talking about. As far as putting a property in your father's name to preserve first-time buyer benefits, I'd talk to a lender and CPA before doing anything. There may be benefits, but there can also be complications. You don't have to figure out the perfect strategy right away. Take your time, learn the numbers, and decide what fits the life you want.

    Spark Rental Co-Investing Club585 Reviews
  • Marc MoraPro Member
    Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2026 · 359 posts · 53 votes
    5d

    @Sage NA, your dad's $400K is what I'd sort out first. Whose name it's in and whether it's a loan or a stake will shape your first deal more than the city does. Raising capital is familiar ground for me. I'd be open to talking through the setup with you if that's useful. Does your dad want a vote on the purchase? Since you're not set on a strategy, which ones have caught your interest? I can talk strategy as well.

  • Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
    5d

    Since you'll be working in NYC, I'd at least look at a two family in the outer boroughs before going out of state. I've been selling on Staten Island about 15 years and a lot of first time buyers live in one unit and rent the other, which can cover a good chunk of the mortgage even if it doesn't cash flow on paper while you live there. Just run the numbers both ways, what it costs you living there and what it would rent for fully once you move out, because that second number tells you if it's a keeper long term.

  • Pittsburgh, Allegheny County · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 36 votes
    5d

    Sage, with that much capital the biggest risk is putting it to work too fast, so I'd buy one property, run it for a year and learn from it before buying the next one. On the father's-name idea, you generally count as a first-time buyer again after three years without owning a home, and owner-occupied loans don't require first-time status anyway, so titling it to him mostly adds complications about who owns, borrows on and is liable for the property. If NYC prices make a house hack unrealistic, pick one out-of-state market you can actually visit, with a manager you've interviewed, and underwrite it with real tax bills and insurance quotes rather than percentages. Also agree in writing with your dad whether his $400K is a gift, a loan or an equity stake before you spend any of it.

  • Remington LymanBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    5d
    Quote from @Sage NA:

    Hi everyone! I'm pretty new to real estate investing and would love some advice on where to start.

    I'm currently finishing up my second bachelor's degree in Computer Science and will most likely end up working in NYC as a software engineer after graduation. I've previously interned at AWS and have another internship lined up at Coinbase next summer, so I'm hoping to land a full-time role with around $200K in total compensation by 2028.

    With how volatile the SWE job market has been lately, I'd really like to build additional sources of income outside of my career. I've been interested in real estate investing for a while, particularly owning rental properties and becoming a landlord.

    For context, I currently have around $200K saved up, and my father is willing to contribute another $400K, so I'd potentially have around $600K to work with. I definitely don't want to put all of that into a single property, though.

    I'm currently based in Northern Virginia and am familiar with the DMV area, but I'm open to investing elsewhere.

    My initial thought was to purchase a fourplex in a more affordable market like Atlanta, Texas, or Virginia. However, since I'll most likely be living in NYC, I'm also wondering if buying a duplex there and house hacking would be a smarter move, especially with potential first-time homebuyer benefits and owner-occupied financing options.

    Another thought I had was purchasing an investment property under my father's name to preserve my first-time homebuyer eligibility for when I eventually buy my own home, but I'm not sure whether that would actually be beneficial.

    I'd love some advice from more experienced investors:

    • Given my situation, what investment strategy would you recommend starting with?

    • Are there any particular cities or markets you'd recommend for a first-time investor?

    • Would you prioritize house hacking in NYC or buying a rental property in a more affordable market?

    • Would purchasing under my father's name make sense, or would the potential complications outweigh the benefits?

    I'm still very early in the learning process and not set on any particular strategy, property type, or location. My main goal is to build long-term wealth and generate additional income alongside my career.

    If you were in my position, what would you do? I'm open to any and all suggestions, including completely different approaches I haven't considered. I'd really appreciate hearing from more experienced investors. Thanks in advance!

    Find a cheaper market than NYC and build out a solid team with a good Realtor, Property Manager, lender, and contractor

  • Ryan BakerBusiness Member
    Lender · Strongsville / Cleveland, OH · Member since 2026 · 197 posts · 54 votes
    4d

    Hi Sage, a couple things to think about. On the NYC duplex, owner occupied financing on a 2 to 4 unit gets you in with a much smaller down payment, so most of that cash stays free for reserves or your next property. On an out of state fourplex you'd be using investor financing, usually 20 to 25 percent down, and a DSCR loan lets the rent qualify the deal instead of your income.

    Buying in your dad's name changes whose credit and income the lender looks at and who owns it, so run that by a CPA and an attorney before you decide.

    If you want to see what each path looks like side by side, give me a call, my number's in my signature below.

    – Ryan

  • Investor · Costa Mesa, CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4d

    I would reconsider buying in an "affordable market" like many inexperienced investors do. Consider what makes it cheaper. Higher maintenance, higher evictions and a poor tenant pool. Fewer but better properties is usually a better strategy for profitability.

  • Hersh ShahBusiness Member
    Realtor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2016 · 129 posts · 82 votes
    2d

    Hi Sage, others have covered the NYC house hack and your dad's $400K well. Since you named Atlanta, here's an honest comparison of the three markets for a quadplex, from someone who works in Atlanta:

    1. Atlanta has strong job and population growth and is generally considered landlord-friendly. The catch for your plan is that metro Atlanta is overwhelmingly single-family. True quads are scarce, mostly older buildings, and often priced for appreciation rather than cash flow. You can find value outside of the city that have a good mix of both.

    2. Texas hs no state income tax, but property taxes often run around 2% of value and insurance has climbed, so those two lines can eat a lot of the rent. Underwrite with real quotes, not percentages.

    3. Virginia you know well and knowing the area is worth a lot. Northern Virginia rarely cash flows, though, so Richmond or Hampton Roads are the more realistic options there.

    Two things that apply anywhere:

    1. Base the property tax on your own price. As an investor you won't keep the seller's homestead exemption, so the seller's current tax bill understates yours.

    2. Plan on professional management from day one for accurate underwriting

    Happy to compare notes on Atlanta anytime.

    Hersh Shah Group4.9114 Reviews
    View Page
  • Ryan BrownPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 140 posts · 46 votes
    2d

    Sage, the thread has covered the NYC house hack, your dad's $400K and DSCR loans really well, so I'll add one more option: multifamily may be one of the better places to find a great price right now.

    Higher rates have cut down on the number of buyers. Many of the investors who were paying top dollar for small apartment buildings a few years ago were relying on cheap debt, and at today's rates they can't make the numbers work, so they've stopped bidding. Some sellers are under real pressure. Their loans are maturing, their adjustable-rate or bridge debt has reset higher, their expenses have grown faster than rents, or they're just tired of managing. Fewer buyers plus motivated sellers is when you can negotiate on price, ask for seller financing or a credit for repairs, and sometimes take over an existing loan with a better rate. That's much harder in the single-family market, where you're still competing against people buying homes to live in.

    With $600K, that could look like a 5 to 20 unit building instead of a few separate fourplexes. Buildings with five or more units are valued mainly on their income, so you're negotiating on numbers, not emotion. The management also scales better: one roof, one location and one team. I'd still keep Stephany's point in mind. Don't make a deal cash flow just by putting a huge amount down. The goal is to buy at a price where the deal works with normal leverage.

    There are risks, too. A lot of these sellers are motivated for a reason. Look for deferred maintenance, rent rolls with tenants below market or behind on rent, and expense numbers that look better on paper than they do in the bank. Get the actual operating statements, insurance and tax bills, not a broker's estimate, and get a thorough inspection on every unit, not just a sample. As a first-time buyer managing from New York, the property manager matters even more on a building like this, so find one with experience in your size of building before you make an offer.

    If I were in your position, I'd pick one market you can visit, find a good manager and an investor-friendly agent there, and start looking at small apartment buildings that have been sitting on the market. A buyer with cash is in a strong position right now, and multifamily is where that advantage may count the most.

  • Austin JonesPro Member
    Realtor · Richmond VA · Member since 2023 · 50 posts · 17 votes
    1d

    Hey Mr. Sage, I'm a realtor and investor in the Richmond, VA area. To give you an idea of the local market, fourplexes around here typically range from $600K–$1M, so you would still have plenty of capital left over after putting 20-25% down.

    The only potential benefit to preserving your first-time homebuyer eligibility would be access to certain federal or state down-payment assistance programs or grants, assuming you meet their requirements.

    Feel free to reach out if there's anything I can help you with!

  • Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2024 · 34 posts · 12 votes
    1d

    Sage, the thread's covered your dad's money well, so one thing nobody's mentioned: credit history. With private lenders on long-term rentals, DSCR loans need at least two tradelines on your credit, with about two years behind them. As a student, pull your report and check that before anything else.

    The upside is a DSCR loan doesn't need the job offer. It qualifies on the rent.

    And if you buy out of state as a first-timer, plan on a property manager. Lenders often require one.

    I run a lender, so weigh that.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    23h

    Having $600K to work with before your career has even started is a great spot to be in, and not wanting it all in one property is the right instinct. A few tax pieces will shape which direction makes the most sense.

    On your dad’s $400K, decide early whether it’s a gift or a loan. A gift above the annual exclusion just means he files a gift tax return, and with the lifetime exemption where it is, no tax is owed. A loan needs a written note charging at least the applicable federal rate, or the IRS treats the missing interest as if it had been charged. Buying in his name is where I’d slow down. The property, the depreciation, and the gain would all be his, not yours, and if he transfers it to you later as a gift, you take over his basis and the recapture that comes with it. And if you ever live in a property he owns without paying market rent, your unit counts as his personal use, which limits his deductions.

    The other thing to plan around is your income. At $200K in NYC, rental losses are passive and mostly suspended, because the $25K allowance phases out completely at $150K. Depreciation won’t touch your W-2 unless you go the short-term rental route and materially participate. While you’re still in school with a lower income, though, you can use up to $25K of rental losses against your other income, so a purchase in the next year or so actually gets more out of depreciation than one after you start working. With New York and NYC income tax on top, you’ll also file a return in whatever state you invest in, and claim a credit on your New York return.

    Feel free to DM me, I’d be happy to share a few resources that might help.

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 74 votes
    16h

    @sagek6 Since you'll be managing from NYC, I'd underwrite every market the same way before choosing one: 1) put the property manager's full fee schedule (monthly fee, leasing fee, renewal fee) in from day one; 2) get real insurance quotes and look at the actual tax bill, because both vary a lot between affordable metros; 3) base rent on recently leased comps, not asking rents; 4) carry a CapEx reserve sized for the age of the housing stock, since cheaper markets often mean older roofs, sewer lines, and electrical; 5) if you use DSCR at 20-25% down, stress-test the ratio with a month or two of vacancy. A market that still works with all five is worth a closer look. Which two or three markets are you comparing now?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.