Landlording & Rental Properties

11 Ways to Boost Tenant Retention for Higher ROI

Expertise: Landlording & Rental Properties, Real Estate News & Commentary, Personal Finance, Real Estate Investing Basics
139 Articles Written
real estate-investment

Want higher ROI on your rental properties? Easy—slash your turnovers to the bare minimum.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

Turnovers mean vacancies, during which you’re not bringing in rents, yet still paying the mortgage. It’s not just the mortgage, either. You’ll probably need to repaint, you might need to replace the carpets, and you’ll need to clean the unit thoroughly.

Then there’s the marketing—advertising the vacant unit, showing it, holding open houses, collecting and processing rental applications, running tenant screening reports on all applicants, plus calling employers and prior landlords.

And if you pay a leasing agent or property manager, they may well charge you a month's rent for their labor as well.

The bottom line is that turnovers will devastate your bottom line. So how can you minimize your turnovers and keep your properties occupied at (nearly) all times?

The trick is to retain your good renters for the long haul. You want them “snug as a bug in a rug” as my mother used to say. You want them so comfortable in your property that the idea of moving is a headache they would only consider under the most pressing need.

Here are 11 ways to boost your tenant retention rate, to keep those rents flowing and the work at a minimum.

11 Ways to Boost Tenant Retention for Higher ROI

1. Know your market.

You could have the best relationship in the world with your renters, but if your property is outdated or overpriced compared to the available property down the street, your renters will move.

Keep your finger on the pulse of your neighborhood and market. Know what your competition is charging and why. Most importantly, know how their properties and amenities compare to yours.

The trick is to step into the shoes of a renter living in this neighborhood. What appeals to them? What are their expectations?

Related: 7 Types of Tenants I’ll Never Rent to

Every quarter, go walk through a vacant rental unit offered in the neighborhood. Put yourself in the shoes of a prospective renter, and channel your inner method actor. What amenities jump out as appealing? How modern is the feel inside the property? What’s your impression of what it’d be like to live there?

If possible, attend open houses and talk to the prospective renters. Ask them their thoughts about the property. Ask them what they think about certain amenities.

You can (and should!) also conduct exit interviews with all of your own outgoing tenants. Why are they moving? What would they have liked to see from you or the property manager? What might have induced them to stay?


2. Learn your tenants’ dream improvements list.

Don’t stop at interviewing outgoing tenants or prospects at neighboring properties. Your best resource for understanding what your renters want is, well, your own renters!

When you conduct your semi-annual inspections with your renters (which you’re doing, right?), ask them, “What are your dream property updates if you could wave a magic wand?”

Compile a list of in-demand property updates. Some might be outlandish, but others will be affordable updates that will raise the property’s desirability for years to come.

Keep updating this list, and every once in a while, choose the update with the best return on investment.

When you inform your renters, tell them you listened to them, and because you value them as renters, you’re going to make XYZ improvement. They’ll feel valued, and they’ll (of course) want to stick around and enjoy this new property update.

3. Start a “friends to neighbors” program.

Have a multifamily building or own multiple single-family properties in the same neighborhood? Here's a win-win strategy for everyone involved.

Everyone loves the idea of their friends or family members moving close by and becoming neighbors. And the close ties of having your friends as neighbors is difficult to give up.

Announce to your renters that if they refer a friend or family member, you’ll give their friend a $300 voucher to help cover their moving expenses. That’s important. though—your incentive has to go to the friend, not to your renter. People can tell when their friends are acting in self-interest when referring something to them.

Win #1: You fill your vacancies faster, as your renters become marketing agents on your behalf.

Win #2: Your renters form deeper ties to your property because their close friends are now their close neighbors, too. They will be much, much less likely to move away.

4. Screen applicants like your incomes depends on it (because it does).

There’s a lot to be said about the finer points of tenant screening, which can fill entire articles and ebooks. But tenant screening is one of the most important activities that landlords and property managers undertake, and it has a direct impact on your turnovers.

Bad tenants end up needing to be evicted—or at the very least, non-renewed. In other words, signing a lease with bad tenants is just setting yourself up for quick, expensive turnover.

And it doesn’t stop at tenants who will fail to pay the rent or even those who pay but damage your property. Also, screen out “house hoppers”—renters who hop around frequently from one home to the next. If you want to minimize turnovers, lease to renters who are stable and have a history of living in one home for long stretches (three or more years, ideally longer).

5. Keep quick-reference files on all renters.

Do you remember all your renters’ children’s names? Do you remember all their hobbies or what’s going on at their jobs?

Of course not. So keep a quick, short-‘n-simple digital file on your computer for each set of renters. A few notes will cut it; just note whatever was going on in their lives the last time you spoke.

You should be able to pull up these files in the time it takes to dial a renter. You can then spend 60 seconds warming up the conversation by demonstrating how much you remember about the renter and their family.

“Hi, Mrs. Blake. How are you doing? I remember the last time we talked, Timmy was about to start a new school. How’s that going for him?”

“Hi, Mr. Smith. How are you doing? The last time we talked you were training for a triathlon. How did it go?”

Your renters will be surprised that you remember these little details about their lives. It sets the stage for a much friendlier conversation, and they’ll be left with the impression that you think of them as human beings, not cash machines.


Related: The 11 Most Common Questions Asked by Tenants—Answered

6. Consistently raise rents—and offer strategic relief.

There are plenty of reasons to raise your rents every year, even if only marginally. Higher revenue, of course. And you don’t want rents to get too far below market levels and then jar your renters with one big rent hike.

Then there's setting expectations for your tenants: Rents go up every year. It's a fact of life, like rainy days or inflation. Your tenants should come to simply expect incremental rent hikes every year, while also knowing that you won't gouge them with a massive jump.

In setting these expectations, you also set the stage for a better option. Every time a lease comes up for renewal, offer your renter three options for renewal:

  • Option A: Continue on a month-to-month lease, with an incremental but real rent hike.
  • Option B: Renew for another year’s term, with a smaller rent hike.
  • Option C: Renew for a two-year term, and lock in that smaller rent hike for a second year.

If they know that rents will increase for them next year, then it becomes a real incentive to lock in a good rent rate for the next two years.

Set expectations!

7. Call when sending important notices.

Have a lease renewal coming up? Is the rent late and you’re filing for eviction? Call them!

Yes, by law, you often have to send certain notices in writing. But that doesn’t mean you should leave it there.

Speaking with your renters on the phone before they receive a cold, hard written notice will establish a dialogue, rather than an edict from above. You want to have a relationship with your renters, albeit a professional one.

This gives you a chance to explain the lease renewal options and varying rent hikes. It also gives you a chance to learn exactly why a tenant missed their rent payment. It shouldn’t affect whether you file for eviction or not—you should always file eviction like clockwork; this is a business—but it does give you context.

Your renters will appreciate the human connection of a conversation, rather than just receiving certified letters in the mail or a notice taped to their front door.

8. Call before entering the property.

The same concept applies to entering the unit. Yes, you have to give written notice, but a phone call is an appreciated human gesture.

Even if it’s an emergency and you aren’t legally required to give written notice, you should still call.

It demonstrates a respect for the renters’ privacy. Sure, to you, the property is an asset. It’s your business and your property. But to the renter, it’s their home, where they cook dinner for their kids, relax after a long day of work, shower and sleep. It’s their refuge from the world.

The phone call need only take 60 seconds, but it’s an important gesture, and your renters will appreciate it.

9. Prioritize responsiveness.

When there’s a repair problem in your property, it’s urgent.

It’s urgent for you because the longer a problem festers, the more damage it creates.

It’s urgent for your renters because any problem in their home is inherently urgent.

When your renters report a problem, jump on it immediately. Keep a rolodex of contractors of every skill set and every price point, so you can call a repair pro as soon as you get off the phone with your renter.

If there’s a delay for some reason, explain it clearly to your renter, and stay in communication with them every few days even if there’s nothing to report. It sends the message that it’s a priority for you, and you’re on top of it.

10. Send holiday cards to your (good) tenants.

When December comes around, send holiday cards to any renters you want to keep. If you’ve screened your tenants well, that should be almost all of them.

Holiday cards are more meaningful if they’re faith-specific, so if you know what holiday your renter celebrates, send a card for that specific holiday.

Address the card to each family member by name, including each of the children. It’s more personal: “Bill, Amy, Peter & Sally Jones” rather than “The Joneses.”

The cards and envelopes should be handwritten. They don’t have to be long—a couple warmhearted sentences will suffice. If you don’t have the time yourself, have an employee or virtual assistant write and send them.

If you want, you can include small (e.g. $25) gift cards to universal retailers like Best Buy or Amazon. It might even be tax-deductible! But no pressure.

Sensing a theme? The best property management combines human relationships with business best practices.

11. Prune your money tree.

Prune away the dead branches. Toss out the rotten apples. Use your plant metaphor of choice, but get rid of your bad tenants.

Bad tenants are expensive. From property damage to eviction filings to pushing your good renters to move away, you can’t afford to keep bad tenants.

No matter how well you’ve done with any of the above tips, good renters won’t stick around if their neighbors are loud, deal drugs, or are just plain rude, disruptive jerks.

Every month, look at which renters’ leases are coming up for renewal soon. Send non-renewal notices to any renters you have doubts about. If you have to ask yourself whether they’re worth keeping, you already have your answer: non-renew them and get better renters in there.

Landlords constantly look for excuses and justifications to keep bad renters because they don’t want the hassle of a turnover. But do yourself a favor and get rid of bad tenants now, before they cause more damage to your property and cause more of your good renters to move away.

The formula is extremely simple: Keep your good renters, get rid of your bad renters, and you’ll find your costs down and your management much lower-maintenance.

What’s worked well for you to keep renters long-term?

Share your tips or your turnover horror stories!

G. Brian Davis is a landlord, personal finance expert, and financial independence/retire early (FIRE) enthusiast whose mission is to help everyday people create enough rental income to cover their ...
Read more
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, MO
    Replied over 3 years ago
    This is a very important and too-little-discussed topic amongst investors. Very good list, although I would also add to prioritize quality maintenance. Good maintnenace is the best tenant retention out there IMO.
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Proactive maintenance is a great addition Andrew! And I agree, real estate investors (like everyone else) are all about cure, just reacting when something goes wrong, and don’t pay attention to prevention.
    Chris Low Investor from Redding, California
    Replied over 3 years ago
    This article is very timely as we’re about to buy our first rental. I really like your suggestions, especially asking the tenants what their dream improvements should be. We started by flipping houses, so we tend to look at a property and think of all the things we would do if we were trying to flip it and get top retail dollar. It’s been a mind shift to think of it through the eyes of a landlord. It’s important to use that any house we own is clean, safe, has well performing mechanicals and has some curb appeal because we want our tenants to WANT to live there. But since we won’t occupy it ourselves, it would be really hard to notice certain things so asking for their input makes a lot of sense. Thanks again for a great article!
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Thanks Chris! Yeah it’s an important mindset shift, to see through the eyes of your renters as much as possible. It helps both when choosing a property to invest in, and in managing it. Best of luck with your first rental!
    Whitney Tutt Investor from Mableton, Georgia
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Good article! I like the tips on holiday cards and gift cards and addressing each family members’ name in the card. It’s the small things that count! Thanks again!
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Thanks Whitney! I totally agree, small gestures like that take very little time, but make a huge impact on how your renters think of you and the property.
    Lacey S. from Carrboro, North Carolina
    Replied over 3 years ago
    I’m curious about suggestion #3 – how do tenants react when they refer someone who wants to move in but then you choose to rent to someone else who applied first or because their friend did not meet screening criteria? I could see this creating bad blood and the idea with most of these tips was to create a good relationship. Not sure I want to be the “mean landlord” who did not rent to their cousin/friend/sister because they had bad credit or some “past troubles.” Any experience with this happening Brian?
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    I’ve never had bad blood come of it. Your renters understand that you have screening criteria, and that other applicants may have applied first. As referred renters apply, you can always just say “We’ve had other applications as well, but we understand you’re friends with Jim and Wendy, so we’ll see what we can do.” If you rent to them, great, if not, it’s not the end of the world.
    Lacey S. from Carrboro, North Carolina
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Well at the moment I only have one rental property so not something I really have to worry about but good to know that it works for you!
    Leslie Hamilton Investor from Evergreen, CO
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Thanks for sharing these ideas! What a great way to make your tenants feel valued and want to stay. We have encountered way too many shady landlords, especially in the lower income areas where some of our properties are located. We’ve heard of things like landlords showing up unannounced at 6am and entering without knocking and not returning security deposits or providing the proper communication about the deposit. We thoroughly screen our tenants, so we haven’t had any problems with them. We like them and want them to stay. As a work at home mom of two littles, I try to teach my boys to “treat others the way you want to be treated.” I think a lot of the landlords we have interacted with need to be reminded of the Golden Rule.
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    It’s very true Leslie – 95% of business relationship questions can be answered with just the Golden Rule. I actually think that tenant retention is something landlords ignore at their peril, when turnovers are where most of the costs and labor come from in managing rentals.
    Sean Haardt Rental Property Investor from Boonsboro, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Thank you Brian for another great article. I’ve been a member of BP for about 8 months now and am new to REI. Your articles are a huge help. I was out today with my wife looking at a duplex, still hoping for my first buy and hold property. Articles like this help us newbies minimize the risks while gaining some confidence that we can achieve this first big step. Thank you again and I look forward to your other posts.
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Thanks Sean! Much appreciated. Buying a 2-4 unit property and house hacking is an excellent way to buy your first rental property, and get advantageous financing for it too. Feel free to shoot me a PM and keep me posted on your progress!
    Jerry Xiong from Fresno, California
    Replied about 3 years ago
    Great tips you have here Brian. Thank you for sharing some creative ways of retaining tenants for higher ROI. I like the metaphor that you have share and have also given a real life example of it. Bad tenants are expensive. From property damage to eviction filings to pushing your good renters to move away, and these are good reasos why not to keep bad tenants.
    G. Brian Davis from Baltimore, MD
    Replied about 3 years ago
    Thanks Jerry! I’m a huge believer that your renter retention rate is the biggest driver of your ROI.