Landlording & Rental Properties

20 Questions to Ask a Prospective Property Manager

20 Articles Written

Real estate investors interested in building wealth by acquiring property and holding for long-term rentals will be well served to find a good property manager. But with hundreds of management companies out there, how can you find the good ones?

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

If you are just starting out and only have a few properties, you may want to manage them yourself, at least for a while. This is a great way to learn what potential issues can arise and how they can best be fixed. As your portfolio of properties grows and you begin investing outside of your local area, however, you will want to have a method for finding and retaining good property managers.

Finding a good property manager is not always easy. The barrier to entry is low. Everyone thinks they can be a property manager. Many people think the job is easy money. I’ve worked with a lot of property management companies over the years, and I’ve found that it is worth taking the time to find the right one. If you don’t, you’ll end up spending as much time managing your property manager as you would have spent managing your property if you’d done it yourself.

To help you find the best property manager out there, I’ve come up with a list of 20 questions to ask. Use them all or pick and choose to fit your situation.

Related: Property Management Companies: Is it Smart to Hire One for Your Rentals?

Questions to Ask Property Management Companies

  1. What are your fees? Do you charge a flat fee or a percent of rent?
    Seven to 12 percent of rent is typical, but you may be able to negotiate a lower percentage depending on the circumstances. For example, if they will be managing multiple properties for you, they may cut you a deal.
  2. Do you have references?
    Get references of both current and former clients, and call them all. Search the internet for reviews. Ask around.
  3. How many properties are you managing? Do you manage both short-term and long-term rentals?
    These days, many property managers are involved with managing short-term rentals through sites like Airbnb and VRBO. Short-term rentals are a different business and can take up a lot of a property manager’s time. Make sure they have the time to focus on your long-term rentals.
  4. How long have you been in business?
    You want to make sure they’ve been in business long enough to have a track record and evidence they plan to stick around.
  5. How many people work for your company, and what are their roles?
    You want to know who is taking care of business behind the scenes. If your contact leaves or goes on holiday, you want to know who to contact. You also want to get a sense of the infrastructure. Are they trying to do everything themselves, or do they have a support staff?
  6. Do you have electronic and automated systems set up?
    These days, property managers should have client portals and electronic payment systems set up for convenience and record keeping. For example, is there an online portal where you can go to generate reports and see property accounts in real time (instead of waiting weeks for a monthly report)?
  7. How often do you check in on tenants and properties? Do you do an annual walk-through?
    A good property manager will check in with the property and tenants even if they haven’t heard from them. Some tenants won’t report needed repairs and damage leaving you and the property manager in the dark. You don’t want to find an unpleasant surprise when the tenant moves out.
  8. Who keeps the damage deposits?
    Don’t let the property manager keep them. While most people are honest and trustworthy, I did have a property manager steal the tenant damage deposits, which ended up costing us a lot of money to replace the deposits!
  9. What financial institution do you use?
    Try to get the management company to work with a bank account at your financial institution instead of letting them put rent receipts in to their own account. This usually only works with larger properties and portfolios though.
  10. What do you charge for evictions?
    Hopefully this never comes up, but it is better to know upfront than to be surprised if an eviction is necessary.
  11. Will you advertise and show a property while it is occupied, or do you insist on properties being vacant before you will start advertising them for rent?
    If the latter is true, this will lead to one to two months of lost rent every time a tenant switch happens.
  12. How long does it take you to turn a property around in between tenants? Can you do it in 24 hours or does the owner have to lose weeks to a month of rent every time a tenant change occurs?

Group of diverse people are seated and waiting for a job interview in a waiting room with white walls and light colored floor

Questions to Ask About Tenants

  1. Do you conduct credit and criminal background checks on prospective tenants?
    This is easy to do these days and a must.
  2. What is your philosophy on tenant selection, getting properties rented? Do you try to get top dollar and raise rents aggressively or do you prefer more of a value play?
    The rent amount is ultimately the owner’s decision, but if your property is outside of your local area, you will most likely rely on your property manager to know the market. It is beneficial if you and your property manager have similar philosophies on tenant selection and where to set the rental amount.
  3. Do you take photos of the property before and after move in and out?
    They should, and this is easy to do. Documentation of the property condition is critical should any disputes arise.
  4. Do you offer a tenant placement guarantee?
    If the tenant is evicted or moves out before the lease term is up, will the property manager find a new tenant for free?

Questions to Ask About Repairs

  1. How do you handle tenant calls for repairs? Do you try to solve the problem before sending out a repair person?
    I’ve found that often the problem can be handled by asking a few questions and the tenant doing a few easy tasks. This can end up saving a lot on unnecessary repair expenses.
  2. Do you establish a threshold dollar amount on repairs above which you always call the owner? If so, what is that dollar amount?
  3. Who do you use for repairs? Electrical, plumbing, appliances?
    Do they have a handyman that they try to use for most repairs or do they use outside vendors? If they have a skilled handyman you may get quality work for less.
  4. What is your philosophy on repairs and replacement?
    Do they try to find the least expensive solution since this is a rental, or do they prefer a value solution so the repair or replacement will last? Different owners and property managers have different approaches. You want to find a property manager that shares your same philosophy.

Related: How to Choose the Right Rental Property Manager

I’ve found that maintenance costs are THE biggest problem with outside managers. One thing to delve into when interviewing prospective property managers is how their company treats maintenance. Do they treat maintenance like a profit center, or do they just pass along costs they get from outside vendors to owners?

Management companies that treat maintenance as a profit center (either by marking up third-party bills or by employing their own people and then billing owners at a higher hourly rate) generally have higher maintenance costs. This can kill your profitability so watch out for this.


There are some great property managers out there and they can provide a valuable service to you, particularly as your portfolio grows and you expand beyond your local area. Before hiring, spend some time, do your research, talk to others and then conduct a thorough interview before making your final selection.

Are there any questions you can think of that I’ve missed?

Share them below!

Ian Colville is the Managing Partner of CCM Finance. Ian is a native of Minnesota (born in Rochester). He brings both a formal education (BA in Economics and MBA) as well as industry experience to ...
Read more
    Account Closed from New York City, New York
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Excellent article ! A good starting point to discuss with prospective property managers
    M. Ian Colville Lender from Minneapolis, MN
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Thank you Nilokas!
    George Hoover Real Estate Agent from Westlake, OH
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Great article Ian. We are just starting out as commercial property managers, so that helped. Do you have a couple of quick tips on how to land our first client? We are networking pretty heavily and are on social media. Thanks!
    M. Ian Colville Lender from Minneapolis, MN
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    We only manage our own properties so we’ve never had to prospect for clients for this specific business but we do plenty of prospecting elsewhere. If I were you, I’d tour all of the buildings near my office (why not try to find clients that are convenient for you?) and see which ones appear to be under performing where you know you could make a difference. Those are the property owners who are experiencing some pain. Contact them and tell them your ideas for making improvements. I’ll bet you’ll find some owners who are willing to talk at least. Once you successfully re-position one building, you’ll have clients lining up at your door.
    Mohammad Kadiwal from Plainsboro, NJ
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Great Article! I am seeing a property manager this weekend so this list is going to come in very handy!
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, MO
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Great and important list! There are a lot of bad managers out there so it’s very important for investors to vet them thoroughly.
    Steve Johnson Rental Property Investor from Hampstead, NC
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    This article came just in time as I’ve been thinking about what questions I should ask potential property managers. Thank you, Ian, for writing this up.
    M. Ian Colville Lender from Minneapolis, MN
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Great, Good luck in your search!
    Todd Ortscheid Property Manager from Senoia, GA
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Some great advice here, but some bad, to be honest. My thoughts as the owner of a medium-to-large management company in two states: 1. I’m not going to give you owner references to call, because I know I wouldn’t want people calling me. Many management companies won’t, because they respect their clients’ time and privacy. Instead, check the Better Business Bureau. If you check review sites like Google and Yelp, don’t look at the star rating, look at the reviews themselves. In this business, getting bad reviews from tenants who are angry about late fees or getting charged for something from their security deposit is a way of life. Check to see if they have a lot of owner complaints. If so, steer clear. If the bad reviews are all tenants who think they shouldn’t have to pay a late fee, then ignore the 3 star rating. 2. There are pros and cons to both philosophies of whether to list a property that is occupied or wait until it’s vacant. Don’t write off a management company just because they only show vacant properties. Instead, compare apples to apples. Ask the companies you’re considering to all show you their vacancy rates. That’s what really matters. 3. Claiming that companies who mark up maintenance will cost you more money is just flat out wrong. Two things to remember here: 1) ALL management companies are making money on maintenance one way or another; either they mark up the invoice (which is probably heavily discounted from the vendor due to volume), or they have their own in-house or sister maintenance company where they’re charging you a markup without telling you, or they’re charging the VENDOR a “preferred vendor fee” and the vendor is then inflating the cost of the invoice to cover it. Yes, all of these are taking place. EVERY management company has to make money on maintenance one way or another, because they’d all be bankrupt if they didn’t. So what you really should be doing is instead asking for what they typically charge for a given repair, such as a hot water heater replacement, and then compare apples to apples across your potential manager choices. 2) A management company that doesn’t charge for maintenance can’t afford and has no incentive to make sure that your property is properly maintained. This will cost you FAR more down the line than a small markup on the invoice.
    Account Closed Property Manager from San Antonio, TX
    Replied almost 2 years ago
    Great points Todd.
    Jessa Claeys Managing Editor from Denver, CO
    Replied 10 months ago
    Hi, Ian! Loved this piece. Thanks so much for writing. :)
    M. Ian Colville Lender from Minneapolis, MN
    Replied 10 months ago
    @jessa thank you!