Rehabbing to Sell vs. Rehabbing to Rent: Which is a Better Strategy?

Rehabbing to Sell vs. Rehabbing to Rent: Which is a Better Strategy?

4 min read
Dave Van Horn

Dave Van Horn is a veteran real estate investor and CEO of PPR Note Co., a $150MM+ company managing funds that buy, sell, and hold residential mortgages nationwide. Dave’s expertise is derived from over 30 years of residential and commercial real estate experience as a licensed Realtor, real estate investor, and private lender.

Beginning his career in construction and as a Realtor, Dave bought his first investment property in 1989. After years of managing his own construction business, Dave became a full-time real estate investor, specializing in fix and flips, buy and holds, and eventually commercial projects, before moving into note investing in 2007.

Over the past decade, Dave has also invested his time into becoming a connector and educator, who helps others achieve success. He focuses jointly on helping accredited investors build and preserve wealth with his group Strategic Investor Alliance and with general audiences through the annual MidAtlantic Real Estate Investor Summit.

Dave has also shared his strategies and experiences with real estate and note investing via hundreds of articles published on the BiggerPockets Blog and with his acclaimed book Real Estate Note Investing.

Dave has been featured on the BiggerPockets Podcast twice (shows 28 and 273), as well as episodes of familiar podcasts, including Joe Fairless’ Best Ever Show, Invest Like a Boss, Cashflow Ninja, and many others. He also has been a guest of Herb Cohen’s on Executive Leaders Radio, which airs nationwide.

Dave is a licensed Realtor with eXp Realty with CRS and GRI designations.

Dave’s LinkedIn
PPR on LinkedIn
PPR on Facebook

As a Guest you have free article(s) left

Join BiggerPockets (for free!) and get access to real estate investing tips, market updates, and exclusive email content.

Sign in Already a member?

Recently, I had a tenant move out of one of my townhomes, and I decided to fix it up in order to sell it. I had owned the property for a while, and the area was starting to change. With taxes, township rental license fees, and inspections on the rise, the cash flow just wasn’t what it used to be.

Sure, I had entered originally entered this deal with the intent to keep it as rental, but sometimes you just have to shift strategies.

When it comes to the type or scale of the rehab, a lot depends on your exit strategy.

Scale of the Rehab

When fixing up a property to sell, whether it’s a new property or an existing rental, the cost is usually more than if you’re fixing it up just to rent it out.

With a rental, the focus is more on functionality. If things are just a little outdated, it may only make sense to replace them once they’re completely worn out.

When fixing up a property to sell it, it may make sense to upgrade a lot of the features in order to move the property quickly and for a good price.


Rehabbing to Sell

But, when you’re fixing up to sell, how fancy do you get?

For example, do you use some two-tone paint or custom colors in the kitchen and bath, or do you use all one color, which is more common in a rental property? Do you upgrade some of the electrical fixtures or the flooring (with tile or nicer carpet), instead of using your go-to fixtures and flooring for a rental property that costs less or that can handle more wear and tear?

Another big question is how far do you go in upgrading certain parts of the house (whether that be the kitchen, bath, basement, or even the garage)? After 30 years as a real estate agent, I learned that if you can show the buyer a nice kitchen and bath, the deal is usually done. It’s a huge selling point.

Related: 4 Painful (But Invaluable) Lessons Learned From a Rehab Gone Wrong

The other thing to remember, though, is that you don’t want to over-improve for the area. It may even make sense to check out your competition by going to see some of the other homes for sale or rent in your property’s surrounding neighborhood.

Cons to Selling

Probably the biggest con to fixing up a rehab to sell it is the taxes, more specifically the short-term capital gain tax, which applies if the house sells and settles in less than one year after you bought it. For example, if you are able to own it for a year and a day, your taxes would be cut approximately in half since the profit on the sale would now be a long-term capital gain. Unfortunately, we all have this silent partner in the house flipping business, and his name is Uncle Sam.

Also, what happens if the property you fixed up isn’t selling, even after you’ve tried many incentives, which don’t seem to work? In my area in the Northeast, if you don’t sell by Thanksgiving, you have a good chance of sitting on the property through the winter, including paying for the heat and snow removal, until the spring market reappears.

This happened to me once, and I was forced to rent it out, as well as run the risk of the new tenant messing up my really nice house that had been renovated to sell.


Rehabbing to Rent

Fixing up a property to rent it out may be a little less expensive, but it comes with its own set of concerns as well.

For instance, it may be hard to refinance the property when completed. Banks usually like to see a property that’s passed all the code inspections and is rented to a good tenant with at least a one-year lease.

Some other problems you may encounter could be the loan-to-value they’ll allow or the possibility of a higher interest rate since it’s a rental property, and you also run the risk of getting a low appraisal on the after-repair value.

Another thing to remember is that now you’re dealing with tenants and/or a management company, too.

Many successful real estate investors try to get around this management and maintenance piece by selling the property on a rent to own basis instead of just keeping it as a normal rental. This way, they’ll have lower taxes upon the sale since it’s been over a year.

Also, the tenant would likely have more of an owner’s mindset while living in the property and would usually be responsible for minor repairs and upkeep. This is where the lease option strategy could be most effective, and it could be a way for the real estate investor to stay out of the repair business, too.

Related: Why Subpar Rehabs by Real Estate Investors Create a Losing Situation for Everyone

But the worst case scenario is where you fix up the property to sell, and it doesn’t sell or rent. Now you’re potentially in trouble since you have no cash flow coming in at all.

That is why timing is so important. Of course, you should have your exit strategy in mind before you enter the deal, but you should also know the market and be prepared to shift strategies if necessary.

For me, I prefer the “fix and flip after a year and a day by selling on a lease-option” strategy, but I’m also interested to hear what strategies other folks on BiggerPockets would employ.

Which do you prefer, fix to flip or fix to rent, and why?

Leave your comments below!