Business Page

Stutts Properties Inc.
Property Manager
4.2 stars
180 Reviews
Markets served
Florence, AL
Muscle Shoals, AL
Sheffield, AL
Tuscumbia, AL
Killen, AL
Rogersville, AL
About us
Stutts Properties Inc., established in 2005, is a full-service property management company specializing in sales, leasing, management, and maintenance. Our team of seasoned professionals excel in residential property management, handling both single-family homes (SFH) and multi-family homes (MFH). Whether you're an investor or an accidental landlord, we are the local experts you can rely on because no one manages more third-party properties in the Muscle Shoals/ Florence MSA than us.
Specialties
Long-term rental: 12+ mos.
Single Home/Townhome/Condo
Multi-family: 2-4 units
Multi-family: 5-19 units
Multi-family: 20-49 units
Multi-family: 50-99 units
Multi-family: 100+ units
Other Property Management Services
Mid-term rental: 1-12 mos.
Reviews (180)
4.2 stars
180 Reviews
4.2 stars
180 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Bobby Jackson
I used Stutts Properties between 2022 & 2025, and I highly recommend them if you’re looking for a house or apartment to rent.
They have rentals of all types with many renting for $900 & less per month.
The individuals there are great to work with, and Stutts has a great iPhone app where you can easily pay rent & submit maintenance requests.
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Peggy Freeze
The very nicest people that I have ever rented from. Their maintenance team is friendly and always prompt to to take care of any problem that arises. The portal for paying rent and requesting a service call is very easy to use.
1.0 star
4 months ago
Reviewed by
MEWBOURN RACING
Absolutely terrible, was in a house that leaked, had mold, heat/ac barely worked, plumbing issues, and foundation issues. THEY WOULDNT FIX ANYTHING. EXPECTS 2,500$ TO MOVE OUT AFTER MY FAMILY SUFFERED WITH SICKNESS DUE TO THEM NOT FIXING ROOF LEAKS FOR 6 MONTHS. After repeated texts and requests they finally fixed one spot OUT OF 3!! NEVER RENT FROM THIS COMPANY THEY ARE A SCAM OUT FOR JUST MONEY! Oh yea and also wants a 60 day move out notice which is ridiculous cause who knows they are moving 60 days in advance.
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Chance Wisdom
They were very easy to deal with and made the entire process as easy as it could’ve been. They kept in communication throughout the entire process and answered every question we had.
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Brandy L. Hines-Cooper
I couldn’t have done this without Agnes! I needed so much support and guidance through the process, and she was there for me every step of the way!
I thank everyone at Stutts for their help, but especially Agnes!
Looking forward to working with them throughout the next year!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Rebecca O
My family and I have lived in many rental properties around the country due to work and Stutts Property Management was the best company to deal with by far. They went above and beyond assisting in the rental home search for us since we were not yet in state. They matched us with the perfect rental home in a great area. Anytime we needed a problem fixed they were there to help.
I also met business owners who have properties they manage and they have also been satisfied with Stutts.
We highly recommend Stutts Property Management for all of your property management needs!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Preston Wood
I enjoyed living in an apartment building managed by Stutts. The maintenance requests were super easy; Jason is really kind. Lots of great people work for this company (easy to work with) and even greater neighbors. The pricing was decent enough - also Florence is a beautiful place to live. Recommend.
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Doug Brown
I have rented from Stutts Properties for almost 9 years. It has been a very good experience. Stutts properties have been very fair to us and are concerned that we are happy where we live!!! They have made positive changes over the past couple of years to function more efficiently. They have been very professional in their management of the property we live in and worked to resolve issues with the property when they arise. One of the things I greatly appreciate is their desire to improve effectiveness and make advances in how they operate. Thank you Houston and all your staff for all you do for us!!!
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Bobby Jackson
I used Stutts Properties between 2022 & 2025, and I highly recommend them if you’re looking for a house or apartment to rent.
They have rentals of all types with many renting for $900 & less per month.
The individuals there are great to work with, and Stutts has a great iPhone app where you can easily pay rent & submit maintenance requests.
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Peggy Freeze
The very nicest people that I have ever rented from. Their maintenance team is friendly and always prompt to to take care of any problem that arises. The portal for paying rent and requesting a service call is very easy to use.
1.0 star
4 months ago
Reviewed by
MEWBOURN RACING
Absolutely terrible, was in a house that leaked, had mold, heat/ac barely worked, plumbing issues, and foundation issues. THEY WOULDNT FIX ANYTHING. EXPECTS 2,500$ TO MOVE OUT AFTER MY FAMILY SUFFERED WITH SICKNESS DUE TO THEM NOT FIXING ROOF LEAKS FOR 6 MONTHS. After repeated texts and requests they finally fixed one spot OUT OF 3!! NEVER RENT FROM THIS COMPANY THEY ARE A SCAM OUT FOR JUST MONEY! Oh yea and also wants a 60 day move out notice which is ridiculous cause who knows they are moving 60 days in advance.
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Chance Wisdom
They were very easy to deal with and made the entire process as easy as it could’ve been. They kept in communication throughout the entire process and answered every question we had.
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Brandy L. Hines-Cooper
I couldn’t have done this without Agnes! I needed so much support and guidance through the process, and she was there for me every step of the way!
I thank everyone at Stutts for their help, but especially Agnes!
Looking forward to working with them throughout the next year!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Rebecca O
My family and I have lived in many rental properties around the country due to work and Stutts Property Management was the best company to deal with by far. They went above and beyond assisting in the rental home search for us since we were not yet in state. They matched us with the perfect rental home in a great area. Anytime we needed a problem fixed they were there to help.
I also met business owners who have properties they manage and they have also been satisfied with Stutts.
We highly recommend Stutts Property Management for all of your property management needs!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Preston Wood
I enjoyed living in an apartment building managed by Stutts. The maintenance requests were super easy; Jason is really kind. Lots of great people work for this company (easy to work with) and even greater neighbors. The pricing was decent enough - also Florence is a beautiful place to live. Recommend.
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Doug Brown
I have rented from Stutts Properties for almost 9 years. It has been a very good experience. Stutts properties have been very fair to us and are concerned that we are happy where we live!!! They have made positive changes over the past couple of years to function more efficiently. They have been very professional in their management of the property we live in and worked to resolve issues with the property when they arise. One of the things I greatly appreciate is their desire to improve effectiveness and make advances in how they operate. Thank you Houston and all your staff for all you do for us!!!