Skip to content

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions

Business Page


business profile image

Stutts Properties Inc.

Property Manager
4.3 stars
229 Reviews

Markets served


Florence, AL
Muscle Shoals, AL
Sheffield, AL
Tuscumbia, AL
Killen, AL
Rogersville, AL

About us


Stutts Properties Inc., established in 2005, is a full-service property management company specializing in sales, leasing, management, and maintenance. Our team of seasoned professionals excel in residential property management, handling both single-family homes (SFH) and multi-family homes (MFH).  Whether you're an investor or an accidental landlord, we are the local experts you can rely on because no one manages more third-party properties in the Muscle Shoals/ Florence MSA than us.

Specialties


Long-term rental: 12+ months

Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units

Other Property Management Services

Mid-term rental: 1-12 months

Reviews (229)


4.3 stars
229 Reviews
4.3 stars
229 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews

reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by Emily Presley
We love our new home and the process with Stutts was very easy and hassle free…this was so amazing since I moved from another state…working with Cristian at Stutts allowed me to do everything online fast and efficiently!!!!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Bryant Perry
Had a couple of small repairs that needed to be made. They were arranged and completed in timely manner. Thank you so much! Great Job
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Nikki Yarber
Jason with Tri-Cities Services did a great job! Went above and beyond to repair the toilet issue (and another related issue) quickly and effectively!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 months ago
Reviewed by Peggy Freeze
I am very pleased to renew my lease at Bentbrook Village with Stutts Properties! I have never rented from any nicer people! They are prompt and efficient with any service call that I've had and respectful when they are in my apartment!🙂
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 months ago
Reviewed by Jennifer Griffith
They take care of thier tenants! I woke up this morning with no air-conditioning in my house. I have a dog that stays at home. I put in a maintenance request with Meld this morning at 8:00 AM. A couple of hours they had a technician at my house to fix my unit. I was listening to my coworker. Say that they have been waiting a week to get someone to check their unit. I was just in tears, but those guys take care of thier tenants and I'm very thankful for that. I have leased from them for three years and They haven’t jacked my rent through the roof and they take care of anything that needs taken care of.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
5 months ago
Reviewed by Michelle Young
This place was a very pleasant place to live. I would have liked to stay longer but I could not afford it on my own. The electric bill was extremely high compared to what im use to. Almost $300 per month.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
Edited 7 months ago
Reviewed by henriette kiwele
I would like to appreciate Stutts properties for the caring and wonderful work that they have been doing, every time we request for a maintenance inspection they always show up and fix the problem, you are really doing a great job
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Umut Ege
Very sketchy company. I reached the company for a rental, and was told the unit is available and sent an application, made my payment. I also went to drive to check the place and after a 2 hour drive i was texted, that the unit was not available. After talking with “Christian”, was told the building was already rented and that was a mistake it showing is available. Mind you they just changed the rate of the rent on the website, and it was active and available, also confirmed by them. I than asked for my refund for the application fee and started being ghosted all day yesterday. Their customer service and phone number is useless, as it is an AI robot that will tell you will be called if they ever feel like it. I was reached by “Nina” today after another attempt to reach them, and was told “we were reviewing your request for the refund. And unfortunately we would not be able to and refund, this is not something we refund. We can review other houses”. Typical click bait - if i apply for a house that was not available, and i was told as available, and the company was aware, in good faith they should refund me my application fee rather than bait me into other properties. I would never rent from this company, so they can enjoy my application fee. In any case, I will make sure several people in shoals/florence area be aware of their sketchy business practice.
reviewer image
2.0 stars
|
8 months ago
Reviewed by Drew Griffin
Fees, fees, fees. Every ridiculous fee they charge is pocketed by the company, not the homeowner. So they’re heavily incentivized to stack even MORE fees. They hand you a cute directory then ignore every phone call. Thank god my homes owner took it back from them, I was not looking forward to tenancy under this company 👎
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
10 months ago
Reviewed by Carylon Ivy
The problem I had with a leaking pipe was fixed right away so I didn't have to worry about a high water bill. Thanks to the fast reaction of the maintenance man.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by Emily Presley
We love our new home and the process with Stutts was very easy and hassle free…this was so amazing since I moved from another state…working with Cristian at Stutts allowed me to do everything online fast and efficiently!!!!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Bryant Perry
Had a couple of small repairs that needed to be made. They were arranged and completed in timely manner. Thank you so much! Great Job
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Nikki Yarber
Jason with Tri-Cities Services did a great job! Went above and beyond to repair the toilet issue (and another related issue) quickly and effectively!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 months ago
Reviewed by Peggy Freeze
I am very pleased to renew my lease at Bentbrook Village with Stutts Properties! I have never rented from any nicer people! They are prompt and efficient with any service call that I've had and respectful when they are in my apartment!🙂
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 months ago
Reviewed by Jennifer Griffith
They take care of thier tenants! I woke up this morning with no air-conditioning in my house. I have a dog that stays at home. I put in a maintenance request with Meld this morning at 8:00 AM. A couple of hours they had a technician at my house to fix my unit. I was listening to my coworker. Say that they have been waiting a week to get someone to check their unit. I was just in tears, but those guys take care of thier tenants and I'm very thankful for that. I have leased from them for three years and They haven’t jacked my rent through the roof and they take care of anything that needs taken care of.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
5 months ago
Reviewed by Michelle Young
This place was a very pleasant place to live. I would have liked to stay longer but I could not afford it on my own. The electric bill was extremely high compared to what im use to. Almost $300 per month.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
Edited 7 months ago
Reviewed by henriette kiwele
I would like to appreciate Stutts properties for the caring and wonderful work that they have been doing, every time we request for a maintenance inspection they always show up and fix the problem, you are really doing a great job
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Umut Ege
Very sketchy company. I reached the company for a rental, and was told the unit is available and sent an application, made my payment. I also went to drive to check the place and after a 2 hour drive i was texted, that the unit was not available. After talking with “Christian”, was told the building was already rented and that was a mistake it showing is available. Mind you they just changed the rate of the rent on the website, and it was active and available, also confirmed by them. I than asked for my refund for the application fee and started being ghosted all day yesterday. Their customer service and phone number is useless, as it is an AI robot that will tell you will be called if they ever feel like it. I was reached by “Nina” today after another attempt to reach them, and was told “we were reviewing your request for the refund. And unfortunately we would not be able to and refund, this is not something we refund. We can review other houses”. Typical click bait - if i apply for a house that was not available, and i was told as available, and the company was aware, in good faith they should refund me my application fee rather than bait me into other properties. I would never rent from this company, so they can enjoy my application fee. In any case, I will make sure several people in shoals/florence area be aware of their sketchy business practice.
reviewer image
2.0 stars
|
8 months ago
Reviewed by Drew Griffin
Fees, fees, fees. Every ridiculous fee they charge is pocketed by the company, not the homeowner. So they’re heavily incentivized to stack even MORE fees. They hand you a cute directory then ignore every phone call. Thank god my homes owner took it back from them, I was not looking forward to tenancy under this company 👎
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
10 months ago
Reviewed by Carylon Ivy
The problem I had with a leaking pipe was fixed right away so I didn't have to worry about a high water bill. Thanks to the fast reaction of the maintenance man.

Our Team


Huston Kennedy