Business Page
Red Door Property Management
Property Manager
4.5 stars
459 Reviews
Markets served
Indianapolis, IN
Carmel, IN
Zionsville, IN
Whitestown, IN
Lebanon, IN
Westfield, IN
Noblesville, IN
Fishers, IN
Cicero, IN
Sheridan, IN
McCordsville, IN
Fortville, IN
Greenfield, IN
New Palestine, IN
Greenwood, IN
Whiteland, IN
New Whiteland, IN
Avon, IN
Brownsburg, IN
Pittsboro, IN
Danville, IN
Plainfield, IN
Licenses, Designations or Certificates
Indiana Real Estate Brokers License - RC51000846
About us
At Red Door Property Management, we specialize in providing exceptional property management services that empower real estate investors to achieve their financial goals with confidence. Located in the heart of Indianapolis, we serve as trusted partners to local and out-of-state investors, offering comprehensive management solutions for long-term and short-term rental properties. With over 20 years of experience in property management, investment rehabs, and real estate investments, our team has a proven track record of maximizing ROI while delivering peace of mind to property owners. Whether you're a first-time investor or a seasoned pro, we understand the challenges of managing rentals and are here to handle the hard work so you can focus on growing your portfolio. At Red Door, we pride ourselves on: Transparent Communication: We believe in keeping you informed every step of the way, offering clear insights into your property’s performance. Maximized Returns: From strategic marketing to tenant screening and cost-efficient maintenance, we’re dedicated to increasing your rental income and long-term asset value. Cutting-Edge Technology: We leverage the latest tools to provide seamless communication, detailed financial reporting, and efficient property oversight. Tailored Solutions: We know no two properties are alike. That’s why we craft customized strategies to suit your investment goals and property needs. Our team understands that your rental property is more than an asset—it’s your investment in the future. That’s why we’re committed to treating every property we manage as if it were our own. Whether you're looking to turn a single-family home / multifamily property into a cash-flowing rental or manage a portfolio of short-term vacation properties, Red Door Property Management is here to help you unlock your investment’s full potential. Let’s work together to open the door to smarter property management and greater financial freedom. Contact us today to see how we can help you succeed!
Specialties
Long-term rental: 12+ months
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Other Property Management Services
Mid-term rental: 1-12 months
Short-term rental: less than 30 days
Reviews (459)
4.5 stars
459 Reviews
4.5 stars
458 Reviews
1.0 star
1 Review
5.0 stars
3 months ago
Reviewed by
Richard Butler
Red Door, good afternoon. Paul, the inspector, was very thorough on elaborating the transition with the property management team. Also showed me the replacement for the furnace filter. Address any questions or concerns during inspection. Nice job overall.
1.0 star
Edited 3 months ago
Reviewed by
Nathan Lewis
Signed a lease 3 weeks before the move in date. Expressed a few issues that I wanted resolved. Lou told me no problem he would handle it. That was a lie. Lou told me they do long term leases. That was a lie. At move in the property was nowhere near ready. He said it was cleaned prior to move in. That was a lie. The trash cans were full. He said that would be taken care of. That was a lie. Lie after lie after lie. After this lease I will not go back to a red door property. If you are a home owner I would list your property with someone else.
Update. 1/30/26 Moved in and now one shower doesn’t work and the other leaks through the floor.
Update 2/8/26. They came when I left the review to look at the leak. Cut a hole in the ceiling said yep it’s leaking then left. Still have a bathroom I can’t use and a hole in the ceiling. If I owned this company I would be ashamed of how my employees treated tenants
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Brian Woodward
I started working with Red Door in January 2025 as a solo entrepreneur/business owner. They have been great to work with throughout the whole year! All interactions have been professional, clear, honest, and helpful. Keith has been very clear and has followed through on their commitment to taking care of their vendors. Invoicing and payment has been quick and painless. Kris has been amazing in responding to questions and helping with scheduling! For a company (Red Door) that has hundreds of properties and probably thousands of calls, emails, and questions, the speed at which Kris has made things happen is amazing. As a solo business owner there are so many things that have to happen in order for work, business, and customer care to go well, I can only imagine what it is like for a bigger company. There were many good, great things that happened in 2025 and Keith, Kris, and Red Door were one of those things! Thanks guys!!!
3.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Charles Fields
Red door was a good property management company. The issue we had were more with the actual landlord. Not going into details. Just make sure you get everything in writing! Landlord tried to charge us up and above our deposit. We fought back, red door agreed with us. They went up to bat for us. We're now get a refund. Thanks red door.
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Tina D
I have had a wonderful experience with Red Door Property Management. Carmina Boado has been a pleasure to work with. She is incredibly professional, thorough and an excellent communicator. She kept us updated every step of the way and made sure we had everything in order for our move to a new home. She was outstanding and I would highly recommend Red Door Properties Management.
5.0 stars
7 months ago
Reviewed by
Miguel Arellano
We moved two weeks ago and it was great, the home is amazing, great space, very comfortable and beautiful views in a great location. We are very happy in this new home. Carmina is a very nice and kind person, she is very dedicated to her work and she is always there to help. They respond to the application very quickly. We liked a lot to apply in Red Door. Really recommended!!
1.0 star
about 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Douglas Haven
SLUM LORDS SLUM LORDS SLUM LORDS SLUM LORDS
I am writing to express my deep dissatisfaction with the management of the apartment complex located at 10301–10291 Medallion Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46231, where my late father-in-law resided.
My father-in-law passed away on February 7. Since then, I have been in regular contact with the management regarding the return of his security deposit. As of today, May 7, I have yet to receive it. Despite daily emails, the responses I receive are inconsistent and the reasons for the delay keep changing. I have documented all correspondence and am willing to share it if needed.
Additionally, the condition of the apartment was unacceptable:
Water Leaks: The first-floor units frequently experience leaks. The entire building smells of mildew, and the odor lingers on personal belongings.
Appliances: The refrigerator in my father-in-law’s unit malfunctioned multiple times and was never properly repaired.
Pest Infestation: There were ongoing issues with mice and rats. Spraying one unit only caused the pests to move to another.
I have photographic evidence of the conditions and am willing to share it with anyone interested. In my opinion, the term “slumlords” is too generous for this management company.
I strongly advise others to avoid renting at this location and urge the management to take responsibility for their properties and tenants.
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Dawn Grizzell (MamaGrizX4)
We had family gathering together from five different states. We were there for a memorial and liquidation of the family estate. This property was everything the listing said it would be. It gave us a great place to be a family together. We will treasure our time there. The back porch was a wonderful place to view sunsets!!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Stacy Ayres
This property was everything the host described it to be. It exceeded my expectations as it was super clean, beds were extremely comfortable and the location was very convenient. The host was very kind, super helpful and responsive whenever I had questions. Definitely am looking forward to coming back to stay here again!!
1.0 star
about 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Douglas Haven
SLUM LORDS SLUM LORDS SLUM LORDS SLUM LORDS
I am writing to express my deep dissatisfaction with the management of the apartment complex located at 10301–10291 Medallion Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46231, where my late father-in-law resided.
My father-in-law passed away on February 7. Since then, I have been in regular contact with the management regarding the return of his security deposit. As of today, May 7, I have yet to receive it. Despite daily emails, the responses I receive are inconsistent and the reasons for the delay keep changing. I have documented all correspondence and am willing to share it if needed.
Additionally, the condition of the apartment was unacceptable:
Water Leaks: The first-floor units frequently experience leaks. The entire building smells of mildew, and the odor lingers on personal belongings.
Appliances: The refrigerator in my father-in-law’s unit malfunctioned multiple times and was never properly repaired.
Pest Infestation: There were ongoing issues with mice and rats. Spraying one unit only caused the pests to move to another.
I have photographic evidence of the conditions and am willing to share it with anyone interested. In my opinion, the term “slumlords” is too generous for this management company.
I strongly advise others to avoid renting at this location and urge the management to take responsibility for their properties and tenants.
5.0 stars
3 months ago
Reviewed by
Richard Butler
Red Door, good afternoon. Paul, the inspector, was very thorough on elaborating the transition with the property management team. Also showed me the replacement for the furnace filter. Address any questions or concerns during inspection. Nice job overall.
1.0 star
Edited 3 months ago
Reviewed by
Nathan Lewis
Signed a lease 3 weeks before the move in date. Expressed a few issues that I wanted resolved. Lou told me no problem he would handle it. That was a lie. Lou told me they do long term leases. That was a lie. At move in the property was nowhere near ready. He said it was cleaned prior to move in. That was a lie. The trash cans were full. He said that would be taken care of. That was a lie. Lie after lie after lie. After this lease I will not go back to a red door property. If you are a home owner I would list your property with someone else.
Update. 1/30/26 Moved in and now one shower doesn’t work and the other leaks through the floor.
Update 2/8/26. They came when I left the review to look at the leak. Cut a hole in the ceiling said yep it’s leaking then left. Still have a bathroom I can’t use and a hole in the ceiling. If I owned this company I would be ashamed of how my employees treated tenants
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Brian Woodward
I started working with Red Door in January 2025 as a solo entrepreneur/business owner. They have been great to work with throughout the whole year! All interactions have been professional, clear, honest, and helpful. Keith has been very clear and has followed through on their commitment to taking care of their vendors. Invoicing and payment has been quick and painless. Kris has been amazing in responding to questions and helping with scheduling! For a company (Red Door) that has hundreds of properties and probably thousands of calls, emails, and questions, the speed at which Kris has made things happen is amazing. As a solo business owner there are so many things that have to happen in order for work, business, and customer care to go well, I can only imagine what it is like for a bigger company. There were many good, great things that happened in 2025 and Keith, Kris, and Red Door were one of those things! Thanks guys!!!
3.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Charles Fields
Red door was a good property management company. The issue we had were more with the actual landlord. Not going into details. Just make sure you get everything in writing! Landlord tried to charge us up and above our deposit. We fought back, red door agreed with us. They went up to bat for us. We're now get a refund. Thanks red door.
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Tina D
I have had a wonderful experience with Red Door Property Management. Carmina Boado has been a pleasure to work with. She is incredibly professional, thorough and an excellent communicator. She kept us updated every step of the way and made sure we had everything in order for our move to a new home. She was outstanding and I would highly recommend Red Door Properties Management.
5.0 stars
7 months ago
Reviewed by
Miguel Arellano
We moved two weeks ago and it was great, the home is amazing, great space, very comfortable and beautiful views in a great location. We are very happy in this new home. Carmina is a very nice and kind person, she is very dedicated to her work and she is always there to help. They respond to the application very quickly. We liked a lot to apply in Red Door. Really recommended!!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Dawn Grizzell (MamaGrizX4)
We had family gathering together from five different states. We were there for a memorial and liquidation of the family estate. This property was everything the listing said it would be. It gave us a great place to be a family together. We will treasure our time there. The back porch was a wonderful place to view sunsets!!
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Stacy Ayres
This property was everything the host described it to be. It exceeded my expectations as it was super clean, beds were extremely comfortable and the location was very convenient. The host was very kind, super helpful and responsive whenever I had questions. Definitely am looking forward to coming back to stay here again!!
