I spoke with him a couple years ago and walked away understanding that he indeed is engaging in securities trades.
There is lesson here for note newbies - these partials you attempt to play with can be viewed as securities. That is why I always have and always will tell note investors to stay away from partials. They are more of a security than a loan.
Partials separate the debt from the secured interest in real property. That my friends is by definition an non-exempt security. It is pretty black and white.
Not all the notes are partials. Some are first deed, low value notes that pay an average 14%. I did use my ( self directed) Health Care Savings account to purchase this. You can call Mr. Warr. He is very approachable and knowledgeable. There has been a lot of bad mouthing him and it may be true, it may not. I am just offering my experience thus far. Never missed a payment. American Note Warehouse brokers these notes just like many other people do. You still have to do your due dil. He has a podcast too called "I been think'in." I enjoy his point of view. It may be simplistic but it is to the point.
Hello@Sandy Uhlmann What note servicer do you use with JW I spoke with him a while back and he wanted to do the servicing himself and I didn't think that would be a good idea
so he gave me a couple names of companies I could use but I also had a couple of my own.
I just wanted to know how did you deal with the loan servicing issue . He told me if they didn't pay he could "scared them" into paying ...which that coupled with what I read on Bigger Pockets turned me off. If his notes are good the Cash Flow from them could be great because the notes "particles are so cheap compared to the cash on cash return you get from them every year....but I just dont want to be scammed have no time for that.
I was/am concerned about the same thing but more from the perspective of accounting and reporting income to the IRS rather than from the aspect of borrower compliance with payment. Its nice to have a servicer to handle that aspect but it does cut into your profit. For that reason, I decided to purchase the note with my HSA. I can log in every month to my SDIRA account and make sure the payments arrive and because it is in my SDIRA I don't need to worry as much about reporting income because it is taxed when I use it when I retire. With my other investments I use FCI or Madison management as my servicer. Darren Eady's product comes with servicing included in the cost but the cost of his first trust deeds are in the $30,000-$50,000 range. (Servicing fees are passed onto the borrower I believe) Thus far, I have never missed a payment and they often double up payments or pay extra. These small notes are very appealing because most of them will double in a little over 5 years and then you can purchase another one and rinse and repeat. I am aware that the risk is there. I am getting ready to purchase another one within my HSA though because so far it has paid well. I have talked to JW several times and I always tell him to pick me one where the borrower is someone that he deals with all the time and that has NEVER defaulted on a payment. Can't hurt to ask. I do check out the house and compare my purchase price against the zestimate and do some other minor due dil.
Worst scenerio, they stop paying, you foreclose and get the house, although you may not want it, you could probably sell it and at least get your money out of it since most of these are in the sub $20,000 range.
Anyone know if the case is ongoing against James Warr? What was the outcome?
This past Saturday JW Warr of American Note Warehouse spoke at the Dallas REIG in Arlington. I wish I found this thread last week. It would be a heck of a coincidence if there were two men named J. Warr selling notes in the Austin area.
@Paul B., It's the same fellow for sure. As many others have pointed out, he is easy to get in touch with. I prefer email to a phone call and he responded to my inquiry about the case. As far as I can tell, he has not done anything wrong or been brought to court. The whole question hinges on whether he is selling securities. Many other clearinghouse like his have specific disclaimers that I didn't immediately see on his site which might be the issue.
In any case, his model seems to be a good one, but I am so new to this I can't really say. If anyone has some good resources for investing in notes, let me know since I think this is more my style.
@James Stines ALL notes are securities.. just some are expempt from registration.
when you sell partials.. there is a school of thought that you are engaged in selling unregistered securities.. Also partials if you don't know the other owners are about as tough to unwind as can be humanly possible in the event of a default .. much better to do whole notes unless your the only owner.
you can simply write in and get a opinion from your division of corporate securities or what ever you call them in Texas.. give the scenario they will tell you if it needs registration or not.
@Jay Hinrichs not all "partials" are structured the same way. I am not disagreeing with your comments on securities, but speaking to dealing with defaults. When we sell a partial, the partial owner is the owner of the note. If it defaults, they have the right to pursue foreclosure and wipe us out on the back end. This is also why we offer a guarantee, and buy back defaulted notes, as we will pursue a mod or foreclosure. We do not sell partials on a spread model, or use a fictionalized model, but a reverting ownership instead, if that makes sense.
Well, it all sounded good: small notes of about $10,000 to $20,000, which means there is not only a low barrier to entry for a beginner, but you can more quickly roll the proceeds into another note, which allows for faster compounding of returns. The returns are around 15%, which is solid for a passive investor. The term is only a few years, apparently less than the time that a county forecloses for non-payment of taxes in the states where he works (e.g. Michigan), so the risk of being wiped out is reduced. All his education is free online. He makes his money selling the notes: it sounded a lot like he collects a closing cost from the borrower. The default rate is less than 1%, and he "takes care of it" when it happens. There tends to be a good amount of equity (50%+, e.g. a $15,000 note on a $30,000 house) so you still come out ahead after paying fees to foreclose and sell the property.
One of my questions (which he receives often) was, why aren't more people doing it - he claims to be the only big time operator in small short-term notes. He said it's too small for most investors, since the origination and servicing costs are high. I have learned on this site that many investors think $30,000 houses in the Mid-West are not worth touching, so that could be part of it too.
Having said all of that, I believe there is far more to learn before I jump into this world. Surely there are many more challenges that I haven't even contemplated. Even in this thread, I can see that some of his dealings may not all be in compliance with securities regulations. So I will keep learning about notes. I really am only interested because I need an outlet for some IRA money. My primary focus is multi-family syndications. My investable cash goes there, and while self-directed IRAs can be used too, there are tax implications which I would rather not deal with. So I want something more simple for my IRA money.
Question for the group...I just finished a call with JW Warr and I was planing on buying notes though his company "American Note Warehouse" while doing my research I stumbled upon this thread which started 2 years ago. Based on this information alarm bells are ringing loud. Has anything changed with regard to his status in this industry and is it best to avoid advancing my dialogue with that organization. Simply looking for Opinions.
I just saw an youtube video of JW Warr on notes investment. It sounded good but I had to do my research, and from my research, one of the links brought me here. It's very reassuring to see BP has a thread on it. I really appreciate the comments and opinions this community provide.
In general, when one does his research of due diligence on something like this or on a private lender, I suppose we run a research online (BP, news articles, reviews, BBB, business license, customer references, company history...) What other things could one check to raise the information intelligence which in turn reduces the risk?
A new investor pointed out James Warr was speaking at a New Jersey event as recently as January, and he was indicted by the Texas State Securities Board 2 years ago... https://www.ssb.texas.gov/news-publications/james-...
I have a friend in Dallas who invested with this guy and got totally screwed. From what I understand - and this is third hand information, of course - he's basically stealing from Peter to pay Paul and then not paying Paul. I have about $75K ready to invest but was warned against going with Warr's company because of pending litigation for securities fraud in Texas. I read online that he is going to trial at the end of September. Realize that not everyone is perfect but how can he keep selling mortgage notes if this situation in the courts is taking place?