Young Sales Person out of College

Young Sales Person out of College

Member since 2025 · 9 posts · 11 votes

Hi everyone,

I got a good paying job and would love to house hack in my area but it does not make sense vs renting. It's 2x the cost of just renting. It seams impossible to find/do in the Orange County area.
Has anyone been able to do it recently? I am saving up money right now. Would love a few minutes of your time to talk through and find a deal in my area. 

Please feel free to add/DM me. 

I am also looking into out of state investing in PHX as an alternative. 

8Reply
432 views

Most Popular Reply

Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
10mo

Can you explain how it is 2x the cost of renting? 

Key things to keep in mind that make house-hacking great:

Rent is 100% interest. Just money out the door with no return. 

There are no other investments available with only 3-5% down/ 95-97% leverage. You are using mostly other people's money (the bank). 

There are no other investments available where you have this much control and can actively create value appreciation while learning on the job.  

Owner Occupied rates are ~1% less than investment property.

Low-risk way to learn about being an investor/ landlord and see if it's for you. 

You have to live somewhere anyway, might as well make it an investment and let your house mates pay down your mortgage with you instead of paying down your landlord's mortgage.

Your local market is expensive because it is desirable, has strong fundamentals and likely has high appreciation potential. That's a good place to invest. 

Other markets are less expensive because they are less desirable, have weaker underlying fundamentals and will likely have less appreciation plus higher risk. That's not as good of a location to invest. 

The three golden rules of real estate are location, location, and location. 

If you buy right you can capture equity immediately. 

If you combine house-hacking with a "live-in flip" and complete a value add while you live there, you can force a lot of appreciation very quickly.

Even if the mortgage payment is double what you would otherwise pay in rent, your housemates are paying a big chunk of it and you will likely be paying less than you would to rent. Part of your mortgage payment goes towards principle: your housemates are paying down your loan for you and buying your property for you over time. 

Tax benefits. You need this if you have a good job.   

Real estate is local. The farther you invest away from home, the higher the risk. 

If you are young, this is the best time to do it as it becomes less optimal as you get older. 

Do as many house-hack/ live-in flips as you can until your lifestyle or family situation rules out the strategy. Buy the ugliest house on the best street you can afford and fix it up to the quality of the surrounding properties to make it worth as much as those. I did this for my 1st 3 properties and gained life-changing appreciation quickly which set me up really well to shift into conventional investment properties by the time I was ready to have a family instead of housemates. House-hacking was literally life-changing for me in the best way possible that's why I'm a big fan.

Good luck!  

See this reply in the discussion

26 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Nicholas L.Pro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    10mo

    @Matthew Davis

    the point of a house hack is not to cash flow, it's to build equity.

    certainly you don't want to be preposterously negative after you move out.  but break even or even slightly negative is OK.

    does this help?

    happy to help further

    • Member since 2025 · 9 posts · 11 votes
      10mo

      @Nicholas L. Hey! Thx. Yea ik u will still be neg. But its like 2k a month to rent and its like 2.5-3k a month if i were to own even with house hacking from what ive ran. 

  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10mo

    I've never house hacked in California but affordability is definitely a concern for sure. It's very possible the numbers don't work. However, here are the questions I'd ask:

    1. could you add additional sf or a bedroom or unit to the property? This will help drive cash flow.

    2. Have you ran the numbers with rent by the room, MTR, or STR? You'll probably have better luck at that point with making the numbers work.

    Just a few ideas to help see if these ideas can improve cash flow or make sense for you. 

  • Member since 2016 · 7 posts · 3 votes
    10mo

    Hi Matthew,

    I've been an OC homeowner since the 90s and have used my OC house as a rental since 2007. But I own more than 10 other rentals and they are all in other states than CA. The reason is obvious - the cash flow that you get renting out a house in CA would not cover the mortgage (unless you pay mostly cash and accept a very low ROI). Simply put having a rental in CA makes no sense (unless you have a specific reason to hold onto the house) because the economics make no sense. My specific reason for having a rental in CA is because me or another family member might decide that we want to live in it later. This is why even when I lived in CA I bought all my rental properties out of state (values in CA have always been too high relative to rent and the pro tenant laws are another negative). But now the problem is that the value of the out of state properties have tripled (or more) in the last 10-15 years but the rent has only doubled. This means that with the current high mortgage rates I cannot continue to expand my rental business (even out of state) because the rent would not cover the mortgage and associated expenses. But it still makes much more sense to buy rental properties out of state (midwest or south) than CA. Until prices and mortgage rates drop the stock market makes more sense for me. It's sad that young people can't buy in OC but that's just reality now.

    Good Luck,

    David

    • Member since 2025 · 9 posts · 11 votes
      10mo

      @David L. Ok that's what I've been looking at. Good to know I will continue to pursue this strategy. Thank u. 

  • Kerlous TadresBusiness Member
    Realtor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10mo

    Hey @Matthew Davis, I’d recommend looking out of state, where you can actually snag a property that cash flows from day one. From my experience, it’s better to own a winning deal elsewhere than to force a losing one at home just to live there. Since you’ve got a solid income, you can use that to scale a remote portfolio while keeping your housing costs low where you are.

    Kerlous Tadres | Reafco Real Estate542 Reviews
  • Joe HomsBusiness Member
    Flipper · Mission Viejo, CA · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10mo

    @Matthew Davis you have some options, even in the OC.  I would suggest networking with others in your area: 

    OCREIN - Reading the Crystal Ball and Predictions for 2026

    Good Investing...

  • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    10mo

    Can you explain how it is 2x the cost of renting? 

    Key things to keep in mind that make house-hacking great:

    Rent is 100% interest. Just money out the door with no return. 

    There are no other investments available with only 3-5% down/ 95-97% leverage. You are using mostly other people's money (the bank). 

    There are no other investments available where you have this much control and can actively create value appreciation while learning on the job.  

    Owner Occupied rates are ~1% less than investment property.

    Low-risk way to learn about being an investor/ landlord and see if it's for you. 

    You have to live somewhere anyway, might as well make it an investment and let your house mates pay down your mortgage with you instead of paying down your landlord's mortgage.

    Your local market is expensive because it is desirable, has strong fundamentals and likely has high appreciation potential. That's a good place to invest. 

    Other markets are less expensive because they are less desirable, have weaker underlying fundamentals and will likely have less appreciation plus higher risk. That's not as good of a location to invest. 

    The three golden rules of real estate are location, location, and location. 

    If you buy right you can capture equity immediately. 

    If you combine house-hacking with a "live-in flip" and complete a value add while you live there, you can force a lot of appreciation very quickly.

    Even if the mortgage payment is double what you would otherwise pay in rent, your housemates are paying a big chunk of it and you will likely be paying less than you would to rent. Part of your mortgage payment goes towards principle: your housemates are paying down your loan for you and buying your property for you over time. 

    Tax benefits. You need this if you have a good job.   

    Real estate is local. The farther you invest away from home, the higher the risk. 

    If you are young, this is the best time to do it as it becomes less optimal as you get older. 

    Do as many house-hack/ live-in flips as you can until your lifestyle or family situation rules out the strategy. Buy the ugliest house on the best street you can afford and fix it up to the quality of the surrounding properties to make it worth as much as those. I did this for my 1st 3 properties and gained life-changing appreciation quickly which set me up really well to shift into conventional investment properties by the time I was ready to have a family instead of housemates. House-hacking was literally life-changing for me in the best way possible that's why I'm a big fan.

    Good luck!  

    • Member since 2025 · 9 posts · 11 votes
      10mo

      @Steve K. 

      Here’s a real example from Orange County to illustrate what I’m seeing:

      Duplex in OC

      • Purchase price: $1,250,000
      • 5% down: $62,500
      • Loan: ~$1,187,500
      • Rate (owner-occupied): ~6.75%

      Monthly costs

      • Principal & Interest: ~$7,700
      • Property tax (1.1%): **$1,150**
      • Insurance: ~$200
      • Maintenance reserve: ~$500

      Total monthly cost: ~$9,550

      Market rents

      • Other unit rents for: ~$3,500–$3,800

      My net out-of-pocket:

      ~$5,700–$6,000/month

      For comparison:

      • Renting a room or modest apartment in the same area: ~$2,500–$3,000/month

      So even while house hacking, my monthly cash outlay is roughly 2x what renting costs, before vacancy or capital expenditures. I understand the long-term benefits (leverage, appreciation, learning), but this is the short-term reality I’m trying to reconcile in high-cost OC markets.

    • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
      10mo
      Quote from @Matthew Davis:

      @Steve K. 

      Here’s a real example from Orange County to illustrate what I’m seeing:

      Duplex in OC

      • Purchase price: $1,250,000
      • 5% down: $62,500
      • Loan: ~$1,187,500
      • Rate (owner-occupied): ~6.75%

      Monthly costs

      • Principal & Interest: ~$7,700
      • Property tax (1.1%): **$1,150**
      • Insurance: ~$200
      • Maintenance reserve: ~$500

      Total monthly cost: ~$9,550

      Market rents

      • Other unit rents for: ~$3,500–$3,800

      My net out-of-pocket:

      ~$5,700–$6,000/month

      For comparison:

      • Renting a room or modest apartment in the same area: ~$2,500–$3,000/month

      So even while house hacking, my monthly cash outlay is roughly 2x what renting costs, before vacancy or capital expenditures. I understand the long-term benefits (leverage, appreciation, learning), but this is the short-term reality I’m trying to reconcile in high-cost OC markets.

      Some thoughts... Investors don’t pay retail prices, that’s what I mean by “buy right”. For this duplex example to work I’d want to get it at a steep discount in order to capture equity immediately. What if you could get it for just under $1M, and let’s say that the surrounding properties are worth $2m so with a little work over time fixing it up you can gain multiple 6 figures of forced appreciation? Then it starts to make a lot more sense.

       It takes work making offers, finding off market deals and motivated sellers, not just buying “off the shelf”. This is what RE investing is as opposed to buying retail, and this is where working locally becomes an advantage. Network, connect with agents that have deal flow, drive neighborhoods and find those properties that are the ugly duckling surrounded by more expensive properties and call the owners to see if they would consider selling, do some marketing campaigns like mailing letters, make lots of aggressive offers, negotiate hard once under contract on inspection items, and get a good deal.  

      You should be able to do better than 6.7% right now also. Most owner-occ loans are under 6 now.  I just had a client do a 30yr. with a temp 1-0 buydown at 4.99% for the first 2 years then adjusts to 5.99%. Structuring this way helps with the immediate cashflow situation and by the 2 year mark the value add will be complete and you can increase rents on the rented units or if rates have come down can refinance. Talk to some good local lenders especially local credit unions.  

      What about a large house instead of a duplex? I don’t know your market super well but just looked at some 5 bedroom houses in OC online. This may be a better option than a duplex. In just a few minutes looking I saw a few with 200-300 days on market in the $1-1.2M range, with nearby properties over $2M. You could negotiate super aggressively on one of these, get in to a great location for $800-900k where surrounding homes are $2M+, capture equity on the purchase by negotiating well, live in 1 room and rent the other 4 to pay less than you would be if renting and have housemates help pay down your mortgage, and fix it up while you live there to force a lot of appreciation.

      How do the numbers work on something like that? I find that single family homes in good locations appreciate better than multi-family as well, and are better value add plays. 
  • Nicholas L.Pro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    10mo

    @Matthew Davis

    totally fair.  can you 1. expand the area you are searching in and/or 2. look for a fixer upper?

  • Joe HomsBusiness Member
    Flipper · Mission Viejo, CA · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10mo

    @Matthew Davis have you ever thought about assumable loans?

    SFR in Riverside

    • Purchase price: $560,000
    • 5% down: $80,000
    • Loan: ~$485,000
    • VA loan (2.875%)

    • Monthly costs
    • Principal & Interest: ~$2,900
    • Property tax (1.1%): **$   513**
    • Insurance: ~               $   200
    • Total monthly cost: ~  $ 3,613

    Market rents

    House hack the 2 rooms: ~$2,000

      My net out-of-pocket:

      ~$1,613/month

      For comparison:

      Beats renting a room and paying someone else.  Learn this an more by networking with the right people.

      Good Investing...

      • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
        10mo

        Here’s another idea and something I did on my second and third deals to make the numbers work better: When making offers ask if the seller is open to seller financing. What I did was interest-only loans with the sellers so the payment was lower. Learn about seller financing options and get creative. The benefit to the seller is they may be able to spread out their capital gains tax hit, they make more money off the sale due to collecting the extra interest payments, some sellers are looking for more passive income and are tired of landlording, or it might be the only offer that they have so they may consider it even if they don’t love it. Good tool to have in your kit as a beginning investor. 

      • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
        10mo

        Also don’t just compare what you’d be paying in rent to what you’d be paying for a mortgage. Factor in all the ways you will make money owning real estate instead of renting: tax benefits, principle pay down, and appreciation. Especially appreciation. I just googled average appreciation in OC over the last 20 years and the index looks like a ski jump (with a gap jump in 2008-2010 but other than almost straight up). You will have up years and down years of course but the median price didn’t get to be over $1M there by accident. Looks like you can expect 6% average annual appreciation very conservatively, historical average over the last 20 is 9.5%. Thats huge. Compare that to hopefully making a few hundred per month off an out of state rental in a market that barely appreciates. I would buy there for that reason alone personally. My market is similar and the appreciation is what was really life-changing for me. 

      • J CastroBusiness Member
        Lender · Florida · Member since 2025 · 777 posts · 270 votes
        10mo
        Quote from @Matthew Davis:

        Hi everyone,

        I got a good paying job and would love to house hack in my area but it does not make sense vs renting. It's 2x the cost of just renting. It seams impossible to find/do in the Orange County area.
        Has anyone been able to do it recently? I am saving up money right now. Would love a few minutes of your time to talk through and find a deal in my area. 

        Please feel free to add/DM me. 

        I am also looking into out of state investing in PHX as an alternative. 


        Hey @Matthew Davis, welcome to BP!

        House hacking in Orange County is still possible, but you’re right—the numbers are a lot tighter than they were a few years ago. Prices and rates pushed most OC house hacks into negative or break-even territory unless you find something with an ADU or strong room-rental potential.

        A big advantage in a high-cost market like OC is having an investor-friendly realtor on your side. Someone who actually understands cap rates, cash flow, co-living setups, ADU potential, and rental demand can help you find properties that don't show well on the surface but make sense once you run the numbers. Traditional agents rarely look at deals that way.

        Here’s what most investors in your situation are doing right now:
        1. OC House Hacking Is Tough, But Not Impossible

        The deals that do work usually fall into one of these categories:

          • Properties with detached ADUs
          • Homes with converted garages or ADU-ready layouts
          • Large single-family homes that support co-living / room rental
        • Small multifamily where FHA/Conventional 3–5% down financing helps offset high prices

        If you’re analyzing strictly as a traditional rental, the math will rarely work in OC. But if you include short-term rental, medium-term rental, or room-by-room strategies, you can still find workable deals.

        2. Renting is cheaper than buying — that’s normal in high-cost markets

        You’re not doing anything wrong. Orange County is one of the strongest rent-to-value markets in the country. Most investors here don’t buy for cash flow — they buy for:

          • Appreciation
          • Tax benefits
        • Forced equity through ADU additions
          • Long-term wealth creation

        So don’t let the “rent is cheaper” comparison discourage you. That’s common in coastal markets.

        Many Orange County investors live OC and invest in AZ, OH, IL, TX, FL, AL and few other state in the Midwest. You’ll build wealth faster by getting your first property — even if it’s out of state — than by waiting for the “perfect” OC house hack.

        You’re doing all the right things—good job, solid income, stacking cash, and thinking strategically.
        You’re closer than you think.

        If you end up finding something in OC or out of state and want to see if it qualifies for one of our investor loan programs, feel free to reach out.

        We can run the numbers, check DSCR, and see exactly what financing looks like so you know if it's a smart move before you make an offer.

        Best of Luck!

        JCREIG Capital Funding
      • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
        Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
        10mo
        Quote from @Matthew Davis:

        Hi everyone,

        I got a good paying job and would love to house hack in my area but it does not make sense vs renting. It's 2x the cost of just renting. It seams impossible to find/do in the Orange County area.
        Has anyone been able to do it recently? I am saving up money right now. Would love a few minutes of your time to talk through and find a deal in my area. 

        Please feel free to add/DM me. 

        I am also looking into out of state investing in PHX as an alternative. 

        Hey Matthew, welcome to BP! Totally get where you’re coming from—Orange County is crazy expensive right now, and house hacking locally can feel impossible because the cost of buying often ends up way higher than renting. That’s actually why a lot of people I know who were in the same spot started looking out of state, and markets like Columbus, Ohio have been a game-changer. You can still find properties in the $120K–180K range that hit the 1% rule, cash flow from day one, and have strong long-term appreciation because the population and job growth here is really strong, plus big companies like Intel, Amazon, Google, Honda, Facebook, Microsoft, and LG are investing heavily. It’s also very landlord-friendly, which makes managing rentals much easier, especially if you’re starting out or investing from out of state. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!

      • Wale LawalBusiness Member
        Real Estate Broker · Houston | Dallas | Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
        10mo

        @Matthew Davis

        I think you are right. House hacking is difficult in Orange County because prices are so high in comparison to rents, unless you find an unusual value add deal, it usually does not pencil locally. While you are building capital here, I must say it makes sense to consider looking out of state to markets like Houston, Phoenix etc. where rents are higher in comparison to purchase price.

        Good luck!

      • Alfath AhmedBusiness Member
        Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
        10mo
        Quote from @Matthew Davis:

        Hi everyone,

        I got a good paying job and would love to house hack in my area but it does not make sense vs renting. It's 2x the cost of just renting. It seams impossible to find/do in the Orange County area.
        Has anyone been able to do it recently? I am saving up money right now. Would love a few minutes of your time to talk through and find a deal in my area. 

        Please feel free to add/DM me. 

        I am also looking into out of state investing in PHX as an alternative. 



        You should look into columbus as well for value-add deals if you do out of state investing. Ton of tech companies are investing here like intel, google, amazon. Good market for cashflow and strong appreciation.

        I've got 28 units here and sold over 120 properties this year to OOS investors here.



      • Marc RiceBusiness Member
        Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
        10mo
        Quote from @Matthew Davis:

        Hi everyone,

        I got a good paying job and would love to house hack in my area but it does not make sense vs renting. It's 2x the cost of just renting. It seams impossible to find/do in the Orange County area.
        Has anyone been able to do it recently? I am saving up money right now. Would love a few minutes of your time to talk through and find a deal in my area. 

        Please feel free to add/DM me. 

        I am also looking into out of state investing in PHX as an alternative. 

        Hi Matthew, if you are interested in out of state investing, you should focus on both cash flow and stable appreciation as your first investment strategy. Do not look for value add properties now; target rent-ready/turnkey properties. You will also need a good team of an Agent who knows the market really well and a PM, GC and Lender. Happy to help!

        Marc Rice | Investor Friendly Agent at Reafco Tailwind Team574 Reviews
      • Real Estate Agent · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
        10mo

        Keep in mind in real estate you make money four different ways:

        1. Cash Flow

        2. Appreciation

        3. Loan Buy Down

        4 Tax Benefits

        I've had clients who look at low cash flowing properties and justify it by the large loan buy down and appreciation. Keep in mind 3% appreciation on a $1M property is $30K versus 3% appreciation on a $100K home is $3K. An argument can be made that you are building wealth faster with higher priced properties. The same principle applies to the rents. So it might look like 2x more on paper, but the loan buy down alone might make up some of that difference. 

        I started out with house hacking in Los Angeles and used the appreciation to leverage (either HELOC or sell) to buy out of state. The same can apply to your OC property.

      • Rental Property Investor · Allentown PA, United States · Member since 2016 · 567 posts · 442 votes
        10mo

        Have you considered buying a place that has the potential to add an ADU?

      • Realtor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2016 · 100 posts · 38 votes
        10mo

        @Matthew Davis Hey I am a realtor, mortgage broker and a house hacker in LA. I help clients house hack so that they are not house poor while building equity along the way. If you are looking to pursue this, I would like to learn more about your situation and see if I can be of help. Cheers - Vinay

      • Arman AhmedPro Member
        Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 975 votes
        10mo

        @Matthew Davis

        Hey Matthew — out-of-state markets in the Midwest offer lower entry costs, strong cash flow, and faster portfolio growth compared to pricier areas like Orange County or PHX. You can get started with house hacking or small multifamily properties without overextending, and a solid local agent and property manager let you operate virtually while handling inspections, contractors, and management. It’s a great way to build experience and cash flow before tackling larger deals.

      • Adam MaddoxBusiness Member
        Chino Hills, CA · Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 1 vote
        10mo

        You’re not wrong — OC is really tough for traditional house hacking right now. In a lot of cases the payment does come out way higher than renting if you’re looking at standard deals.

        That said, I do have house-hacking clients in LA paying about the same as they were in rent by doing it the right way, and I’m seeing other house-hack opportunities within driving distance of OC where the numbers still make sense. OC itself usually requires more creativity — ADUs, value-add layouts, or properties that aren’t obvious at first glance.

        I also do a lot of out-of-state investing and help clients buy cash-flow-positive rentals in markets that make sense, so if living in OC and investing elsewhere makes more sense, I can walk you through how to structure that too.

        Happy to talk it through and help you strategize a realistic plan. Feel free to DM me.

      • Bo SmithPro Member
        Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 378 votes
        9mo

        OC is brutal for house hacking, you're right. One thing that helped me: look at properties that need work but aren't teardowns. Sometimes a duplex that needs paint and flooring gets overlooked by other buyers, but the numbers work if you can handle basic rehab. Are you open to properties that need some sweat equity?

      • Bo SmithPro Member
        Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 378 votes
        9mo

        OC is brutal for house hacking, you're right. One thing that helped me: look at properties that need work but aren't teardowns. Sometimes a duplex that needs paint and flooring gets overlooked by other buyers, but the numbers work if you can handle basic rehab. Are you open to properties that need some sweat equity?

      Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.