Amityville, NY Investment Properties for Sale
Browse homes for sale and investment properties in Amityville, NY. Refine your search by price, property type, or more.
Best cash flowing properties in Amityville, NY
      Active
      
        
          $320,000
        
      
      
        
          1
          bds
         |
        
          1
          ba
         |
        
          700
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1992
        
      
      
        615 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-661
          
          Cash flow
        
            -10.8%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            3.6%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.8%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $625,000
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          1,639
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1900
        
      
      
        45 County Line Rd, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-1,063
          
          Cash flow
        
            -8.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            4.0%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.7%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
        
          12 out of 13 properties for sale in Amityville, NY
        
        
                  
      
    Limited Results Shown
Create a free account, or log in to reveal all property listings and enjoy the complete experience.
      Active
      
        
          $785,000
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          1,698
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1966
        
      
      
        84 Lebrun Ave, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-2,746
          
          Cash flow
        
            -18.3%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            1.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.5%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $849,000
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          2,546
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1911
        
      
      
        51 Sterling Pl, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-1,985
          
          Cash flow
        
            -12.2%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            3.3%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.6%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $859,000
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          1,495
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1949
        
      
      
        7 Swartout Pl, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-3,601
          
          Cash flow
        
            -21.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            1.0%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.4%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $649,999
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          1,656
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1956
        
      
      
        37 New Point Pl, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-1,696
          
          Cash flow
        
            -13.6%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            2.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.6%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $779,000
        
      
      
        
          5
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          2,304
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1927
        
      
      
        62 Central Ave, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-3,305
          
          Cash flow
        
            -22.1%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            1.0%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.4%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $849,999
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          2,258
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1953
        
      
      
        50 Towne St, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-3,729
          
          Cash flow
        
            -22.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            0.8%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.3%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $1,149,000
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          2,932
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1922
        
      
      
        33 S Bay Ave, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-5,021
          
          Cash flow
        
            -22.8%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            0.8%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.3%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $779,000
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          1,900
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          2004
        
      
      
        7 Cottage Pl, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-3,250
          
          Cash flow
        
            -21.8%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            1.1%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.4%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $899,000
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          2,000
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1998
        
      
      
        282 S Ketcham Ave, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-3,291
          
          Cash flow
        
            -19.1%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            1.7%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.4%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
      Active
      
        
          $1,750,000
        
      
      
        
          
          bds
         |
        
          0
          ba
         |
        
          0
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1900
        
      
      
        38 Park Ave, Amityville, NY 11701
      
      
            $-7,215
          
          Cash flow
        
            -21.5%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            1.1%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.2%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio