Unless money is no-issue (and it always is) buying a house is a game of compromises, and it helps to have a clear idea of what features are must-haves and what are nice-to-haves.Depending on your response me and my team would love to help you, or refer you to another agent that is best suited for your goals.

But you need to look at the interest you are paying to decide which debt is worthy to reduce.I believe you are compromising a fair amount of income per month, and seems to be risky.On the other hand the 3 doors that cost 850k for an income of 38000 minus tax and maintenance does not seems to be attractive.Are you playing capital appreciation game?

It is, and has always been, a grey area and we've all done our very best, without compromise, to keep things legal, safe, and fair for all.Another thing to consider on discussions like this is the intention of the discussion itself.

It does not compromise the buyers safety. 

If that scenario compromises cash flow too much, then getting a CA MF with upside would be another option, as discussed above.

No, it’s just how to sensibly become wealthy and not screw it up..... which to me is the best compromise of all.

Two lessons learned as they pertain to BRRRR investing which compromises nearly 100% of my buy and hold portfolio. #1 Always try to negotiate a vacant property, even if you have to compromise on price.

We want to do it the right way the first time so we do not compromise our relationship and prevent any unforeseen events.

That 8% rate was friends & family a couple years ago -- these days, there are plenty of high-net-worth individuals who are happy to lend at that rate (or just a bit higher) for a relatively secure return with an experienced/successful rehabber.You will most certainly be able to find rehabbers willing to do a 50/50 split -- and maybe even better -- but, these days, those are typically going to be the newer investors who present greater risk, will require more due diligence and will need more oversight and hand-holding to ensure you get your money back.In my experience, hard money lenders are hurting for business these days -- I know plenty of HMLs who are sitting on a lot of cash and are willing to compromise on rates to work with more experienced investors. 

Plus, since they are there like it's been stated already, they could just flat out say that they are service animals and you cannot do anything about it.As a good business decision, I would suggest working with the tenant to find a compromise that is a win-win for everyone.