My first out-of-state turnkey was a bust (sort of)

My first out-of-state turnkey was a bust (sort of)

Rental Property Investor · Beverly Hills, CA · Member since 2014 · 472 posts · 272 votes

Just thought I'd share a story for any others out there considering buying a multi-family out-of-state, sight-unseen, from another BP member who markets and manages properties.

I found a deal on the BP Marketplace in the Cleveland, OH area. It was marketed as turnkey and ready to go. The numbers looked great and the person marketing the property had a positive reviews. Everything appeared peachy so I decided to move on it.

I knew early on, that I wanted this first remote sight-unseen investment to go well for a few reasons. One, I didn't want to lose money (who does?) and second, I wanted a positive experience to give me that mental motivation I need to push me to do something that is normally outside of my comfort zone. One of the ways I told myself I'd do this is to make sure to get the property appraised and make sure I get the property inspected.

Long story short - I got the property under contract. Once it was under contract, I was told that the owner was still finishing up some carpeting in the unit. I thought to myself, "that's strange - I thought this property was all ready to go." Nevertheless, it's just carpet so I move on to scheduling an inspection. 

The day of inspection comes around and the BP member who was marketing the deal and managing everything on the ground informs me that the utilities are not on and that the owner is still finishing up some work. Frustrating, because again - I thought the property was already ready to go and I would have expected someone, either my guy or the seller, to anticipate needing the utilities turned on. So we reschedule the inspection.

A week goes by and I check in to see how the inspection went, and low-and-behold - one of the units still doesn't have the gas turned and work is still continuing on the unit requiring we yet again delay inspection a week.

At the end of the day, I backed out of the deal. None of the issues were that big of a deal, but there was something about running into this many problems just getting to the inspection that rubbed me the wrong way. I don't expect every acquisition to go 100% smoothly, but I was operating under the premise that the property was ready to go. If that wasn't the case, then who knows what else might be hiding for me to deal with in the future. I've purchased several homes in the past and have never needed to reschedule an inspection, let alone more than once.

It's a shame - I was really pumped about it and I've already sent a ton of referrals to person who sourced the deal, but it just didn't pan out.

I wonder what the community thinks about this situation and if I could have or should have handled it any differently.

It was a great learning experience either way. On to the next one!

9Reply
360 views

Most Popular Reply

Brie SchmidtBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
12y

I almost bought from a turn key company and found out during inspections that they were not really turn key.  Luckily for me, my out of state market was only 90 minutes away.  

If I were buying in a market I could not access easily, I would network on BP and find a local investor who is not involved in my deal and pay them to attend the inspection on my behalf and give their opinion as a disinterested third party.  

See this reply in the discussion

104 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    Originally posted by @Ben Leybovich 

    "Now - it's good to see @Chris Clothier jump in on this.  I've never heard anyone speak poorly of Memphis Invest or Clothier brothers, and though I wouldn't be caught buying turn-key SFRs or small multi ever, they are the only reputable source on BP as far as I can tell..."

    Ben--I agree with what you say about @Chris Clothier but I don't agree that they are the ONLY reputable turn-key source on BP.

  • Investor · Westminster, CO · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    @Jay Hinrichs, I am curious why you sold 350 out of area SFRs?  Was it just to buy some investments locally?  If we were to sell all of our Out of Area SFRs and buy locally, our monthly income would drop 75%.  And as for the original poster, I wouldn't really call it a BUST, it was just a NO GO.  To me, a BUST is when you actually purchase a loser.

  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    Originally posted by @Ben Leybovich 

    "Now - it's good to see @Chris Clothier jump in on this.  I've never heard anyone speak poorly of Memphis Invest or Clothier brothers, and though I wouldn't be caught buying turn-key SFRs or small multi ever, they are the only reputable source on BP as far as I can tell..."

    Ben--I agree with what you say about @Chris Clothier but I don't agree that they are the ONLY reputable turn-key source on BP.

     I did want to say that I appreciate some of the responses about my family's companies.  We have worked very hard for our reputation and have to earn it every day.  

    For what it is worth, I would also agree that there are several high-quality people on these forums who run Turn-key operations who have a great deal of integrity with the way they do business.  We all are held to a high standard because there are many, many other companies who are simply selling whatever they can sell to whomever will buy it.  They lack integrity and all of us pay the price for it.  

    The best companies will all give the same advice when it comes to buying a passive investment or turnkey or whatever you want to call it - you are responsible for your decisions.  Do not take anything someone says on faith.  Make everyone earn your trust and your respect and your business.  Protect your money at all times and be patient - ask questions.  When you are comfortable that the company  has met your expectations, move forward.  

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    Does Jay Hinrichs always have the most sage advice or what? Just give your money to Jay and watch it grow...he does not take money like that I know but I can wish:)

    thanks,

    Matt

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Mike McKinzie 

    AS you well know owning and managing 350 homes is HUGE JOB and from my perspective not a fun one... I only lend money now.. so I never hear about the 3 T's or any of that stuff anymore and it does not matter if you have PM you still need to engage them answer there e mails their cash calls etc etc....and being very selective were my funds go and who they go to ( lots of experience at lending ) I mitigate my down side pretty well these days.. ( now in all fairness I got killed along with a lot of other lenders back in 07 and 08) so it was not all wine and roses.:) but now with the values reset and HML or private lenders being able to set their terms better I think the risk reward is far better than owning with much less work... I think many investors when they get some serious cash saved up will gravitate to lending... And doing deals.. as opposed to owning sfr's... Just a lot of work... and a lot of the work just is not that fun.. then take where mine were at, All mid west and south east Memphis to Atlanta we were spread over C and B... you just get tired of getting reports of break ins condenser theft.. move outs trashed units... evictions etc etc... Although Atlanta treated us VERY VERY well... We double our money there.. And that was because we beat the hedge funds to the draw picked up 50 or so then sold to the hedge funds before prices peaked.

    If I was going to get back into the rental game I would only buy A class triple net lease or West coast apartments were vacancy rates are non existent and management is truly professional not just someone managing 200 doors who may or may not be in bizz next year..And the tenant base is far and away different than what you get in the mid west with sub 800 dollar rents on SFRs... Now if your SFR's are 1000 plus things changes drastically but so does cash flow as those houses cost much more.. It really depends on the asset. But buying 30 to 50k homes in the mid west with 700 rents is just a lot of work IT JUST IS based on my personal in the field first hand experience.. Heck I even moved to the South for almost a year and was in it everyday... But hey that's just me...

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Mike D'Arrigo 

      Your product although  TK or I think you sell turn key is some of the nicer stock you will see in the space from my experience of investing or lending since 2002  in... Detroit , Chicago, Memphis , Indy, Jackson, Birmingham, Charlotte, Atlanta and Orlando.. with a few dabbles in Fort Myers... Oh and lately Texas been funding a few deals there. I just got a lot of negative feedback from TExas landlords over the years  Foundation issues and Property tax's  but Texas is booming no one can deny that... I think the play there is to forget buy and hold buy and RETAIL  find the hot neighborhoods buy and do a retail rehab and sell... I am familiar with a few that are doing really well. Along with New construction on in fill in Austin... those would be what I would be doing in Texas.

  • Engelo RumoraBusiness Member
    Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Matt R.:

    Does Jay Hinrichs always have the most sage advice or what? Just give your money to Jay and watch it grow...he does not take money like that I know but I can wish:)

    thanks,

    Matt

    Hey Matt,

    You can't beat the "old dogs" at this game hehe

    I am sure Jay won't mind me calling him that as I remember him referring to himself as an old dog on the Aussie forum haha.

    @Jay Hinrichs has worn a white shirt with a red cross on his back and to be honest so have I many times assisting unsuspecting Aussie investors that got screwed by turnkey sharks.

    I have been in the US for 2 years now and have seen every trick in the book to swindle or hide numbers in your favor. Its a pretty sad practice and I always preach the they #1 key is to have trustworthy people around you.

    Thanks for reading and have a great day.

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    @Jay Hinrichs 

    Thanks for the compliment. I agree with you on TX. I think it's a better fix and flip retail play than buy and hold. Taxes and insurance are too darn high for good cash flow.

  • Investor · Westminster, CO · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    @Jay Hinrichs , none of my out of state rentals rent for under $1,000.  All properties are Class A.  I have had NO cash calls this year.  My main PM has over 5,000 houses under management, not much fear of them being gone tomorrow.  Only three of my out of state rentals have a mortgage.  All out of state PMs do a Direct Deposit.  In other words, I have made owning rentals about as passive as possible.  The number one type of email I get states, "Your tenant has renewed their lease."  Out of state investing can be hassle free!

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Mike McKinzie 

      there you go you and I totally agree on this....

    The DANGER zone is 30 to 50k rental that rents for 700 HUD... that is the danger zone.

    Or the 70 to 90k TK that rents for 800  same deal...

    Your in a completely different class. I own 11 homes in Madison MS that I bought go zone.. paid 175 to 225k a piece for them brand new for the accelerated tax benefits being an accountant I am sure your familiar ,,, those all rent for 1200 to 1600 and I manage them myself no need for PM these are all white collar no section 8.

    Your portfolio is not what Most TK companies sell... And those that buy these low end rentals if they live in the community they can make them work. but out of state forget about it  is my opinon.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Mike McKinzie 

      and based on your stellar portfolio you have more votes to post than anyone on BP your a rock star !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Rental Property Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2013 · 476 posts · 294 votes
    12y

    Just reminding everyone that is reading here, a plane ticket + rental car and budget hotel/airbnb is cheap insurance when investing out of state.  

    Go see the property you're thinking about buying, then go see another 10, spend some time in the neighborhoods, buy your proposed property manager lunch and then go buy a couple other local players lunch.  Meet with contractors, meet the ladies running the desk at the prop management company (bring donuts).  Figure things out.  Shake hands.  Get to know each other.  Make everyone on the ground understand you're hands on and involved.

    If you're spending 20k, 30k, 40k, 50k+ and taking on the risk of a rental property... 1k plane+hotel+car rental deal is cheap insurance that will pay dividends.

  • Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2011 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    I'm going to investor shame you. You're in Beverly Hills. I know so many investors right now buying rentals in Long Beach, Palmdale/Lancaster, central L.A. - all much closer than Cleveland. What were you thinking?!

    Glad to hear you jumped ship before it sank cuz it sounds like it was already going down. Shop local. You can find just as good deals here as you can across state lines. Those who seek find. Those who don't... don't.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Aaron Mazzrillo 

      Aaron do you sell any properties to people that live in Cleveland and want to buy in LA? Or people that live in any other mid west or east coast city that want to come to LA area and invest in cash flow rentals????  Probably few and far between.

    So why is it that So many LA based and West coast based investor need to go out east to invest? 

    One reason I can think of is there is not enough demand in these towns locally to keep up with all the inventory there is... And or West coast folks will pay more than locals will if the locals pay the same amount as out of state there would be no need for WEST coast based marketing companies hawking these properties.. The locals would have it all bought up.

    From my experience the only out of state investors that come to the west coast are usually big players looking for A grade investments and knowing that CA offers a real chance at appreciation. Although here in PDX we get quite a few Californians buying simply because it is much closer price point somewhat cheaper but cash flow is not any better... Average rental here would return 4 to 6% MAX...

    However the fix and flip retail and new construction is booming here.... Again much larger price points than mid west we can't buy lots for less than 100k in most instances...

  • Rental Property Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2013 · 476 posts · 294 votes
    12y

    @Aaron Mazzrillo I imagine the OP was thinking cash flow.

    Compare ROI in Central LA vs Midwest. And whatever ROI you're pulling in Central LA will surely have to be leveraged, no?

  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:

    I'm going to investor shame you. You're in Beverly Hills. I know so many investors right now buying rentals in Long Beach, Palmdale/Lancaster, central L.A. - all much closer than Cleveland. What were you thinking?!

    Glad to hear you jumped ship before it sank cuz it sounds like it was already going down. Shop local. You can find just as good deals here as you can across state lines. Those who seek find. Those who don't... don't.

    I think the challenge of seeking in CA is why so many buy turn key in the Mid-West. Most new investors want to scan the MLS, make offers and buy something. Not so straightforward here. But I agree with you. Plenty o' good rental deals in CA.

  • Real Estate Investor · Milpitas, CA · Member since 2014 · 26 posts · 19 votes
    12y

    I am doing due diligence on turnkey companies and one of the recommended company is Memphis Invest. I know that @Chris Clothier mentioned that he runs things differently (honesty, integrity, customer service), yet I'm researching his property management group and the reviews are, simply put, atrocious, both on YP and Google Reviews. I am not making any accusations here, just presenting the facts as I found them. I will readily admit that what I found may be wrong and my information may not be correct.

    The conflicting advice on here is great and of course, the investor is solely responsible for his or her purchase. However, based on the supporting evidence, I am not so sure if there is such a thing as a true "turnkey" investment.

  • Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2011 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Aaron Mazzrillo 

      Aaron do you sell any properties to people that live in Cleveland and want to buy in LA? Or people that live in any other mid west or east coast city that want to come to LA area and invest in cash flow rentals????  Probably few and far between.

    So why is it that So many LA based and West coast based investor need to go out east to invest? 

    One reason I can think of is there is not enough demand in these towns locally to keep up with all the inventory there is... And or West coast folks will pay more than locals will if the locals pay the same amount as out of state there would be no need for WEST coast based marketing companies hawking these properties.. The locals would have it all bought up.

    From my experience the only out of state investors that come to the west coast are usually big players looking for A grade investments and knowing that CA offers a real chance at appreciation. Although here in PDX we get quite a few Californians buying simply because it is much closer price point somewhat cheaper but cash flow is not any better... Average rental here would return 4 to 6% MAX...

    However the fix and flip retail and new construction is booming here.... Again much larger price points than mid west we can't buy lots for less than 100k in most instances...

     I think the number one reason is a lack of sound financial education and number 2 reason is just plain laziness. Due to the cost of living here in California and the opportunity to be paid very well, it is easy for a lot of people to see paying $50K or less for a property as being a good deal. For many, they see the cost of obtaining a local property and just dismiss it as unfeasible. Then, they discover or are lured to that nice looking house or small apartment building out in CornHusker, IN for $30K and can't believe a property that will rent for $700/month can be purchased for $30K. "Oh, the cash on cash return!" They cry. So they pull the trigger without really doing any research. Rarely do any of them actually get on a plane, rent a car and go see the city/town or the property. If they did, it would probably be the last time they think about such nonsense. And I'd bet less than 1% actually look at any demographic or economic data with the exception of the latest "Best Places to Live" article on Yahoo's homepage.

    Buying rentals here in California, SoCal specifically, works very well. I have so many friends still buying more than one rental per month. I've picked up 5 so far this summer. My buddy bought a house for $400K. Because of its location, he uses it as a vacation rental. Last month he netted just over $8,000. Now he is in escrow to buy another for $500K. Not my business model, but he's making it work. Most of my rentals that I am currently acquiring are in the under $200K retail price range and I'm paying significantly less than that. 

    For fun and out of curiosity, I just did a quick (really quick) search on the MLS. I found a nicely rehabbed 2 bed, 1 bath house in Long Beach that sold for $190K. From a private seller, I'd be able to buy that house for around $125-$130K. I ran it through Zillow and they say it will rent for $1,500. A $130K house that rents for $1,500 with an equity capture of $60K gross works for me. Paying $30K for a $40K house (even in a 10% yearly appreciation market will go up a whopping $4,000!!) that rents for $700 and is 1,500 miles away (one way) makes me furl my eyebrows and shake my head. Some people mine gold, but the world needs scrap collectors too I guess.

  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    @Kevin D. - Its good that you are doing your due diligence and you should always look to uncover any sticking points for you to question.  But, those questions and their answers should paint a full picture...when taken as a whole. 

    There is no such thing as a Turnkey investment.  Many of us who have been doing this for a long time have said this many times on here.  Turnkey is a marketing term.  It has been so over-used at this point and by so many different companies operating differently, that it really does not mean a thing at this point.  Simply because two properties say turnkey does not mean they can be evaluated side by side.  Turnkey does nothing more than tell someone that a property has some passive qualities to it when you are looking from 30,000 feet.

    As for the first part of your post, I am going to assume that you were not questioning my honesty or my integrity or our companies commitment to customer service.  We have worked very hard for four very specific groups of people that are very important to our company.  

    1.  Our team - which is made up of almost 50 great people now working full time in 3 offices.
    2.  Our Clients - we have a very big responsibility and take that very seriously.
    3.  Our Tenants - this is a very important group because keeping them happy makes properties perform better, which makes the Client happy.
    4.  Our Vendors - we are a local economic engine spending close to $15 million with over 80 local small businesses.

    So service, honesty and integrity are not buzz words - they are exactly why we are on the Inc. 500/5000 list of fastest growing private companies for the third year in a row.

    As for  our property management company and your due diligence.  Here is the link you read on Yellow Pages about Premier Property Management Company of Memphis http://www.yellowpages.com/cordova-tn/mip/premier-property-management-gp-462627383 .  Just for reference sake, there are 4 complaints on there and we are managing just over 2,000 properties in Memphis right now.  I will take those results all day long.  

    I am not sure if you have ever managed property before, but I can assure you, we have had angry people in our offices say much worse things that what those 4 posted on Yellow Pages.  It comes with the territory when you are telling people "no".  I do always find it interesting that the posters either have one post or have deleted their post or as with the one gentleman, three posts all about different property management companies and how poor they all are.  I also find it interesting that if you are willing to pay sites like this with a bad review, they will remove it.  All you have to do is subscribe and you can post a response and a written request.  No thank you - I can live with 4 bad posts.

    Either way, I've never seen Google Reviews and I can imagine they are are going to be as few as YP, but probably exactly the same.  As for your questioning if we are different or not - here are our numbers as of July 1 and I will let you decide.  These numbers are for Memphis only:

    Average Rent:  $978
    Average Deposit:  $1,023

    Memphis Vacancies:  92
    Memphis Owners (July 1, 2014) 913
    Memphis Properties (July 1, 2014) 2033

    2nd Quarter number:

    Leases Closed (Q2) 205
    Leases Closed with rent above our company zip code average (Q2) 146
    Leases completed and renewed  (Q2) 130
    Move Outs (Q2) 109

    These numbers show that rents are rising on a majority of the properties we are renting.  They show that more renters are choosing to renew their leases rather than move out and that our average rent and deposit is well above the local average.  We also run a vacancy rate on any given day right now hovering close to 4%.

    We had roughly 30 tenants take us up on our free financial education that is partnered through a local non-profit.  Thats a hard one to get them to do, but it is free and it is designed to help them get better management of their money. 

    As for customer service, it is funny that you mentioned that in your post.  We are not perfect, by any stretch, but when it comes to customer service, this is where we try to excel.  Every tenant call gets a return phone call and if there is an issue, we call again to insure they were satisfied.  

    For our clients (property owners), they get a phone call from a customer service team member, every month.  Every month we call and ask how we are doing, if they received their payments, their statements, any paperwork that may have been included.  We ask if they have any questions or concerns and what we can do to help them.  Needless to say, we have built excellent and very open relationships with our clients and that has directly benefited our companies growth.

    Both sets of calls are made on behalf of Premier Property Management and both are done 100% to make the tenant and the property owner feel more comfortable and secure with the company they are doing business with.  It is why tenants stay in our properties now approaching 4 years!  It is why we have investors who have bought property with our company multiple times over several years.  It is why we sell 67% of our monthly properties on average to existing investors building portfolios.  We are not a turn and churn company looking for the next sucker that many liken with the term Turnkey.  

    There are many high-quality companies out there that have systems, departmentalized companies and full teams in place to help investors succeed.  Call it turnkey, call it passive investing, call it whatever you want, but make sure you do full due diligence on a company before moving forward and look at the whole picture.  Not just the data they give you or what you find online or what a referral says, but the whole picture.

    You have to have your facts and your data together to run a company the way we have and we have no problem telling a tenant, a vendor or even a potential investor that we are not a good fit and they need to look elsewhere. For us, we want to provide the best of every service we offer and we are only willing to offer that service to those that recognize and appreciate the difference between a company that will say yes to anyone and everyone in an effort to make money and a company that is willing to say no.

    Sorry to everyone on here, especially @Joshua McGinnis  for posting such a long response that was about my company.  As an owner of a company I run the risk of coming across as not giving advice but instead trying to pump my company.  Again, I apologize, but felt compelled to answer and give the full picture to the statement made about my company and what appeared to be questioning our integrity, honesty and customer service.

  • Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2011 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    Maybe some day I'll sell everything I own in California, give all the proceeds to @Chris Clothier  and let his company hook me up with a bunch of rentals he can manage so I can go live in a hotel on the beach. I think that's a solid exit strategy!

  • Engelo RumoraBusiness Member
    Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:

    Maybe some day I'll sell everything I own in California, give all the proceeds to @Chris Clothier  and let his company hook me up with a bunch of rentals he can manage so I can go live in a hotel on the beach. I think that's a solid exit strategy!

     lol

    The Bahamas?

  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    @Aaron Mazzrillo - My plan was to turn this over to my kids in the future and hit Manhattan Beach!  That was of course after I invested in southern Cal. with you.  Now, if my kids just don't screw it up we'll be good!  

    We will still be in Southern Cal in August and hopefully we are able to connect while there.

  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Aaron Mazzrillo 

    For fun and out of curiosity, I just did a quick (really quick) search on the MLS. I found a nicely rehabbed 2 bed, 1 bath house in Long Beach that sold for $190K. From a private seller, I'd be able to buy that house for around $125-$130K. I ran it through Zillow and they say it will rent for $1,500. A $130K house that rents for $1,500 with an equity capture of $60K gross works for me. Paying $30K for a $40K house (even in a 10% yearly appreciation market will go up a whopping $4,000!!) that rents for $700 and is 1,500 miles away (one way) makes me furl my eyebrows and shake my head. Some people mine gold, but the world needs scrap collectors too I guess.

    A $1500 rent for a $130K purchase isn't  too hard for savvy and diligent CA buyers. But the $60K "equity capture"?  That's your thing and my thing but we both know that's a skill set not everybody has, or will even attempt to develop in their investment career. 

    We're off topic as this thread is about turn key, but I always like to see people talking sense about CA real estate.  I'm assuming you're talking from experience with low valued out-of-state rentals? While doing some research last year your name popped up as an owner in a rust belt area. Did you exit on that?

    Actually, turn key is alive and well in some of my rural California farms, but they are bad deals.  Bad areas, bad rehabs, difficult tenant pool, bad property mgmt.  I get calls from such owners periodically but they are so over encumbered and they refuse to take a loss on the sale. They like to delay the inevitable by taking a hit each month.  

  • Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2011 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Aaron Mazzrillo 

    For fun and out of curiosity, I just did a quick (really quick) search on the MLS. I found a nicely rehabbed 2 bed, 1 bath house in Long Beach that sold for $190K. From a private seller, I'd be able to buy that house for around $125-$130K. I ran it through Zillow and they say it will rent for $1,500. A $130K house that rents for $1,500 with an equity capture of $60K gross works for me. Paying $30K for a $40K house (even in a 10% yearly appreciation market will go up a whopping $4,000!!) that rents for $700 and is 1,500 miles away (one way) makes me furl my eyebrows and shake my head. Some people mine gold, but the world needs scrap collectors too I guess.

    A $1500 rent for a $130K purchase isn't  too hard for savvy and diligent CA buyers. But the $60K "equity capture"?  That's your thing and my thing but we both know that's a skill set not everybody has, or will even attempt to develop in their investment career. 

    We're off topic as this thread is about turn key, but I always like to see people talking sense about CA real estate.  I'm assuming you're talking from experience with low valued out-of-state rentals? While doing some research last year your name popped up as an owner in a rust belt area. Did you exit on that?

     I own in five states so I have standing in the out of state / turnkey argument. LOL

  • Investor · Westminster, CO · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    @Aaron Mazzrillo , I currently own a home in Santa Ana, CA.  The average sales price in that zip code is $707,000.  I am getting $1,700 a month rent on it.  Could I get a better return out of state?  While I don't mind you hawking the virtues of investing in Southern California, I do take issue with your criticism of those who choose to invest elsewhere.  I used to own a real estate office in Santa Ana and another office in Riverside.  There are still active Realtors in OC and RC that I trained!  So let me ask you, what would a 2,000 square foot house, built after 2001, cost and rent for in Orange Crest, or Indian Hills, or Lake Hills, or La Sierra, or any other middle class area in your market.  I wouldn't count Rubidoux, Moreno Valley, or other war zones.  I just closed on a house, in the suburbs of Dallas, for $142,000 with a tenant already in it paying $1,450 a month.  It was built in 2007.

    Remember, every investor has a different style.  Just because something works for you does not mean everyone else has to do it that same way!  The original poster backed out of an out of area deal, not because of location but because of unprofessionalism by the marketing person.  I retired at age 50 with a comfortable income.  Others may want more before they retire and others may want less, to each their own.  I applaud everyone's success!  I try NOT to criticize someone who does it differently, but I will criticize those criticize others.  We are all after the same goal, to SUCCEED!?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.