Top 10 Mistakes New Rental Property Investors Make in Cleveland
Investing in rental properties in Cleveland, Ohio, is a fantastic way to build wealth, secure passive income, and benefit from the city's strong real estate market. But as someone who's navigated the highs and lows of this market—flipping over 100 properties, owning 30+ rentals, and guiding over 100 clients—I've seen firsthand the common pitfalls that new investors often face.
To help you avoid the mistakes that I've personally experienced (often painfully), here’s a list of the top 10 errors made by first-time rental property investors in Cleveland—and exactly how you can steer clear of them.
Mistake #1: Not Conducting Thorough Market Research
New investors frequently jump in without fully understanding the nuances of Cleveland’s diverse neighborhoods, leading them to invest in areas that don't match their goals.
How to Avoid It:
Do your homework on each neighborhood. Cleveland areas differ greatly—Ohio City, Tremont, Lakewood, West Park, and Shaker Heights each offer different tenant bases, rent potentials, and appreciation prospects. Know what type of property matches your investment goals: stable cash flow, appreciation potential, or a mix of both.
Mistake #2: Underestimating Repair and Renovation Costs
New investors often overlook hidden repair costs, leading to blown budgets and diminished returns.
How to Avoid It:
Always perform thorough property inspections and get multiple contractor estimates. Consider adding a contingency of 10-20% to your renovation budget for unexpected expenses. This protects your cash flow and profitability.
Mistake #3: Poor Tenant Screening
Choosing the wrong tenant can be extremely costly, leading to late payments, evictions, or even property damage.
How to Avoid It:
Set strict screening criteria. Run credit and background checks, verify employment and income (aim for income 3 times rent or greater), and request references from previous landlords. Being thorough upfront helps avoid costly tenant turnover down the line.
Mistake #4: Misjudging Cash Flow and Expenses
New investors frequently fail to account for vacancy periods, management costs, maintenance, taxes, and insurance, resulting in negative cash flow.
How to Avoid It:
Use conservative financial projections. Always factor in vacancies (at least 5-10%), property management fees, taxes, insurance, maintenance (10-15% annually), and capital expenditures. Use accurate rent comps rather than overly optimistic projections.
Mistake #5: Ignoring Cleveland’s Landlord-Tenant Laws
Many beginners overlook critical landlord-tenant laws, exposing themselves to fines, legal disputes, or costly evictions.
How to Avoid It:
Study local and state landlord-tenant regulations thoroughly. Be compliant with Cleveland’s lead-safe certification requirement, fair housing laws, eviction processes, and habitability standards. When in doubt, consult a knowledgeable local attorney or property manager.
Mistake #6: Overpaying for Properties
New investors often get emotionally attached and overspend, reducing profit margins and limiting cash flow.
How to Avoid It:
Always analyze deals objectively and run clear calculations before offering. Understand market comps and keep emotions in check—stick closely to your predetermined criteria. Partnering with an experienced Cleveland agent specializing in investment properties can significantly reduce this risk.
Mistake #7: Failing to Assemble the Right Team
Investors attempting to manage everything alone often face overwhelm, delayed timelines, and missed opportunities.
How to Avoid It:
Create a solid local support network. Your team should include an experienced real estate agent (who understands investment properties), property managers, contractors, and a reliable lender. These experts can save you time, money, and stress.
Mistake #8: Ignoring Financing Options
Beginners may not explore all financing avenues, limiting their growth and profitability.
How to Avoid It:
Evaluate multiple financing strategies. Traditional mortgages are great, but consider house hacking (owner-occupying a duplex or triplex), seller financing, private lenders, hard money loans, and partnerships. The right strategy can drastically improve your returns.
Mistake #9: Over-Improving Properties
Many investors overspend on unnecessary upgrades that won't meaningfully increase rental income or property value.
How to Avoid It:
Match renovations to the neighborhood and target tenant profile. Invest in clean, functional upgrades that tenants value—fresh paint, updated kitchens, new flooring, fixtures, and appliances. Avoid luxurious finishes unless they're standard in that neighborhood.
Mistake #10: Not Planning an Exit Strategy
Investors who don't plan their exit strategy upfront can become stuck with properties that no longer align with their long-term goals.
How to Avoid It:
Always define your exit strategy early—whether it’s holding long-term for cash flow, leveraging equity to buy more properties, selling at market peaks, or executing a 1031 exchange. Clearly defined exit strategies help you make informed decisions aligned with your financial goals.
Real-World Case Study: Avoiding These Mistakes
Here’s a quick example from my own experience: Early in my investing career, I underestimated renovation costs on a property in Garfield Heights. I didn’t account for plumbing issues that surfaced mid-project, and this pushed me $12,000 over budget. The lesson? Always build contingencies into your budgets—something I've strictly adhered to ever since.
Quick Recap: 10 Mistakes to Avoid for Cleveland Investors
- Not conducting thorough market research.
- Underestimating repair and renovation costs.
- Poor tenant screening practices.
- Misjudging cash flow and expenses.
- Ignoring landlord-tenant laws.
- Overpaying for properties.
- Failing to assemble the right team.
- Ignoring alternative financing options.
- Over-improving properties.
- Not planning a clear exit strategy.
Final Thoughts and Next Steps
Investing in Cleveland rental properties can offer tremendous returns, stability, and growth—if done wisely. By avoiding these common mistakes, you significantly increase your chances of success and profitability.
If you're thinking about investing in Cleveland rental properties or have any questions, I'm here to help. I've personally navigated these challenges, and my goal is to help other investors benefit from the lessons I've learned.
Feel free to reach out anytime via call or text at 216-789-6736. I’m always happy to discuss strategies, opportunities, or help you avoid the costly mistakes I've seen—and made—over the years.
Happy Investing,
Jack Krusinski
216-789-6736
Cleveland Real Estate Agent & Investor
Comments