Airbnb vs Long-Term Rentals: Which Are Best For New Investors?

Short-term rentals are hot—but are they worth it for beginners?

If you're just starting out in real estate investing, you've likely asked yourself: Should I buy a property to rent long-term, or jump into the booming world of short-term rentals like Airbnb? Both strategies offer unique advantages—but also come with distinct challenges, especially when market dynamics are always changing. Here's a breakdown of the pros, cons, and key legal factors to consider before you make your move.

Long-Term Rentals: The Traditional Approach

Pros:

• Stable, Predictable Income: With a traditional 12-month leasing strategy, you should have consistent monthly rental income - ideal for reliably covering your mortgage, insurance, and maintenance costs.
• Lower Time Commitment: Property management of long-term rentals is generally less intensive. Once tenants are placed, you’re mainly dealing with occasional maintenance and lease renewals.
• Easier Financing: Many lenders prefer the stability of long-term rentals, making it easier for new investors to qualify for investment loans for buying new properties.

Cons:

• Slower Cash Flow Growth: While dependable, long-term rentals generally don’t offer the same earning potential that short-term rentals can - especially in vacation hotspots or other popular neighborhoods.
• Tenant Risk: One bad tenant can cause months of headaches, from missed rents to property damage and costly evictions.
• Limited Flexibility: Once you lock a tenant into a lease, you lose access to the property for personal use or strategic purposes until the lease ends.
• Large Up-Front Investment: The only way to acquire buy and hold properties is to purchase them.

Legal Considerations:
Landlord-tenant laws are well-established and vary by state. You do need to make sure you understand eviction rules, security deposit limits, and fair housing laws. You may also need to register with your city as a landlord.

Short-Term Rentals: On The Rise

Pros:

• Higher Income Potential: In high-demand markets, short-term rentals can earn double - or more - what long-term tenants would pay monthly.
• Flexible Use: You can block off dates to use the property yourself, or adjust pricing based on demand.
• Tax Deductions: Operating a short-term rental can qualify you for different deductions as a business, including cleaning services, furnishings, and more.
• Acquisition Flexibility: Investors can grow their short-term rental portfolio not only by purchasing properties but also by renting homes from traditional long-term landlords

Cons:

• High Turnover, Higher Effort: You'll be coordinating more frequent cleanings, check-ins, and maintenance—or paying a management company to do so.
• Market Sensitivity: Travel demand fluctuates seasonally and during economic downturns, making your income less predictable.
• Initial Setup Costs: You’ll need to fully furnish the property and possibly invest in amenities to attract guests and get good reviews.

Legal Considerations:
Many cities have recently cracked down on short-term rentals. You may need a permit, be subject to special taxes, or even face outright bans in some areas. Always check local zoning laws and HOA restrictions before buying if your intent is to rent the property as a short-term rental.

So, Which Option is Better for Beginners?

Ultimately, this question depends on your goals, time, and tolerance for risk.

If you’re looking for stability, easier management, and a more hands-off experience, long-term rentals are often the safer choice for first-time investors.

If you’re open to more active involvement and want to potentially earn higher returns in the right location, short-term rentals can be lucrative—but come with more management time and occasionally legal hurdles, depending on the market.

For new investors with limited funds, short-term rentals can offer a key advantage: the ability to control and profit from a property without needing to buy it. In many cases, investors can negotiate a lease agreement where they rent a property long-term from a landlord and then effectively sublease it on platforms like Airbnb. As a result, short-term rentals can provide a more accessible entry point into real estate investing, allowing new investors to generate cash flow even if they don’t yet have funds to buy a property.

The Bottom Line:
Start with what fits your financial resources, time and skill set today. You can always pivot strategies as you grow. The best investment is the one you can afford and are ready to manage well.

Learn More Here!  Real Estate Tips and Tricks