I have a full time job as a CPA so I wouldn't be able to be boots on the ground as much as I'd like in the actual construction.

This allows a tenant not to be stuck in a long term lease if life happens, but also allows me a safety cushion for cleaning, posting, and filling the vacancy.If it were me i would open the communication with them a bit and let them know they are liable for the full lease term, but due to their excellent rental history and care of the unit you'd like to work with them on their needs.

Obviously there are a lot more ways to make money in RE while you are still working a full time day-job.

There isn't even a thought or decision here... had they come to you with a heart tugging humanizing story at least there is a chance you might consider especially if you feel the circumstances extraordinary, or be upfront and honest about whatever hardship they are facing and perhaps you have a solution that works for everyone - but a threat? 

I won’t take the 1% discount; I plan to demand full service and high level of pickiness in selecting tenants etc.

I’m a full time realtor/investor here in Louisville.

Both myself and my wife are debt free (just paid off the student loans in full!)

My current job is flexible and steady so I would likely work full time while trying to begin as I don't want to lose my consistent income. 

I'd do your full process.

I live 30 minutes outside Chicago and I'm attempting to start a second career as a real estate investor and agent.I've been a full-time career Firefighter/Paramedic for 13 years and I want to find another career to transition into so I can leave the fire service in 8-10 years.