Mortgages & Creative Financing

How Remaining Flexible Resulted in a $54,000 Profit

Expertise: Mortgages & Creative Financing, Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice, Personal Development
43 Articles Written
Isolated Colorful and Flexible Bouncy Plastic Spring

As a real estate investor, it's important to exercise due diligence but also remain flexible. If you refuse to be flexible, you'll likely miss out on some deals.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

Couple due diligence and flexibility with a mentor or advisor, and you're in even better shape.

This was illustrated perfectly when one of our partners was putting together her second deal. The sellers were a young couple in Tucson, Ariz., who were moving out of town. They had listed the house, but it was later canceled by the Realtor. Instead of listing the house again, this couple took us up on our offer.

Related: How Follow-Up Gave Way to This Investor’s First Deal

Finding a Middle Ground

The sellers were very set on selling the house for $200,000, so we worked out a deal to pay the balance of the mortgage and the equity that they would receive at the end. This made both us and our sellers happy, which is always important in a deal.

When buying, the price broke down to $173,450 for the actual purchase and $26,550 for the equity. We set it up as a sandwich lease. Our payments ended up being $1,350 per month for 24 months (actual mortgage payment). We also worked in a cushion to take the deal to 36 months if needed, but we based all numbers on the 24-month agreement.

We charged the tenant buyers a monthly rent of $1,662, leaving a spread of $337. We called that payday No. 2.

As with all of our deals, we create three paydays (cash now, cash monthly, and big backend cash-outs when sold). This property followed that same formula:

  • Payday No. 1 is the down payment from our tenant buyer. In this instance, because we were able to be flexible, this payday came in the form of large payments spread across 24 months that totaled $22,200. Sometimes it’s all up front, but more often it’s over time.
  • Payday No. 2 comes from the spread between our monthly payments to the bank and the monthly rent we collect from the buyer. For this deal, the amount was $337 per month for 24 months, which works out to a total of $8,088. Think about creating $300 to $1,000 per deal for the second paydays only. What would that do to your monthly cash flow, lifestyle, and bank account?
  • Payday No. 3 comes from the backend cash-outs when the property is sold. When we go to list this house, we expect it to sell for $219,900. The backend revenue will total $24,533. Keep in mind, the third payday also includes all principal paydown from the mortgage we pay monthly.

happy family at desk signing papers with real estate agent

Related: 2 Tips to Help You Land That Great Deal — Even if it Looks Like a Goner

Creating a Win-Win Scenario

When considering all three paydays together, this deal created a total profit of $54,000—pretty typical for this specific partner. She later revealed that she was trepidatious about the couple she sold to; their credit history wasn’t great and other indicators suggested they weren’t exactly the most responsible.

Fortunately, they turned out to be amazing. The wife was pregnant at the time, approaching her due date when we signed all of the paperwork. She and her husband now have four boys under the age of 13 and a fifth from a previous marriage. They had a lot on their plate, but they really stepped up and ended up being fantastic to work with.

I have to say, the positive energy produced by helping buyers and sellers come together to create positive scenarios like this one makes this job a pleasure.

The moral of this story is to be open to negotiating. Had we not agreed to pay them the equity on this deal, we would have missed out on a profit of $54,000.

If you can be flexible but still ensure a deal will be profitable, you will open yourself up to a whole new world of possibilities.

When was a time flexibility paid off for you? Have you ever missed out on a deal by being inflexible? 

Leave a comment below.

Chris Prefontaine is the best-selling author of Real Estate On Your Terms. A real estate investor with over 27 years experience in the field, Chris is the founder of
Read more
    Nick B. Investor from North Richland Hills, Texas
    Replied over 1 year ago
    Hi Chris, Great story but I think it has a few gaps (or maybe I misunderstand something): – you did not mention how the original owner got paid $200K that they wanted. I can only assume that they got the down payment and still are waiting for the 24 months to pass to have their mortgage balance paid off. Am I right in this assumption? – if you buy it for $200K and sell for $220K, your profit is $20K. Add $8088 from the lease payments and we arrive to $28088. Where does $54K come from? – you have not sold it yet but already know what your profit is going to be in two years. Isn’t it a bit premature? What if the market goes down and the best you can sell for is $190K? – what happens if a tenant-buyer stops making payments to you? Thanks Nick
    Account Closed Specialist from Middletown, RI
    Replied over 1 year ago
    – if you buy it for $200K and sell for $220K, your profit is $20K. Add $8088 from the lease payments and we arrive to $28088. Where does $54K come from? Owner never gets a down payment and we get principle reduction on our payments to them. – you have not sold it yet but already know what your profit is going to be in two years. Isn’t it a bit premature? What if the market goes down and the best you can sell for is $190K? This one is done but generally speaking we would never sell for less – just rent to ride it out or sure, sell for $190k and still profit due to principle paydown and down payment. You may want to subscribe to Deal Structure Sunday videos on our Youtube channel and you’ll get many more of these. My best selling book also walks you through how the paydays work. Hope that helps!