Updated 2 days ago on . Most recent reply
Hilton Head Island Condo Market: What’s Really Happening in 2025
If you’ve been eyeing Hilton Head Island condos — whether for short-term rentals, snowbird escapes, or long-term appreciation — you’ve probably noticed the tone shifting this year. The market’s not falling apart, but it’s definitely finding a new rhythm after several years of wild appreciation.
I’ll break down what’s happening right now with condo prices, how the 2025 summer rental season performed, and how values stack up compared with last year.
Condo Prices: Still Rising, but the Fever Has Broken
Between September 1, 2024 and September 1, 2025, the median condo/villa price on Hilton Head Island ticked up roughly 5 – 8 %, depending on property class and location.
- Villas and condos that were around $500K–$520K last fall are now averaging closer to $545K–$560K.
- The high-end and beachfront properties (think Sea Pines, Palmetto Dunes, Shipyard) led that appreciation — some even saw double-digit jumps.
- Entry-level condos and older complexes have flattened or gained only 2–3 %.
Translation: Prices are still inching up, but buyers finally have room to breathe again.
Inventory has risen by about 20 – 30 % over the last year, and average days on market are stretching toward the 90-day mark. That means sellers can’t assume a same-day offer anymore — and buyers can negotiate without feeling rushed.
Occupancy This Summer: Busy, But Not Crazy
Summer 2025 brought solid numbers, though not the record highs of 2022–23.
- Average annual occupancy: roughly 62–65 % across the island.
- Peak summer months: most well-located condos were booked 80–90 % of nights (especially June through mid-August).
- Average Daily Rate (ADR): around $480/night for premium units.
Shoulder seasons (April–May and September–October) have cooled off a bit, and the off-season is getting quieter. The short-term-rental crowd is still strong, but travelers are booking shorter stays and shopping harder on price.
Bottom line: summer rentals remain profitable — just don’t count on full occupancy year-round.
Year-Over-Year Comparison (Sept 2024 → Sept 2025)
| Metric | Sept 1 2024 | Sept 1 2025 | YoY Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median Condo/Villa Price | $510,000 | $550,000 | +7.8 % |
| Avg. Days on Market | 65 days | 94 days | +44 % |
| Active Condo Listings | 347 | 417 | +20 % |
| Annual Occupancy (STR) | 64 % | 62 % | −2 pts |
| ADR (Avg Daily Rate) | $465 | $480 | +3 % |
Quick take: modest price gains, slower sales pace, slightly softer occupancy — classic “late-cycle plateau” behavior.
What’s Driving the Shift?
- Higher carrying costs. Insurance, HOA dues, and cleaning fees have all crept up.
- More listings. Some owners are cashing out after multi-year appreciation.
- Tighter lending. Second-home and investment loans carry higher rates, shrinking buyer pools.
- Regulatory attention. The town is actively re-evaluating short-term-rental policies — no new bans yet, but owners should stay tuned.
What It Means for Investors
- For buyers: this is your first real negotiating window in years. Look at stale listings and price-reduced units.
- For current owners: trim expenses and keep units top-tier — travelers are getting picky again.
- For STR operators: underwrite conservatively (60–65 % annual occupancy) and keep a buffer for slower winter months.
The fundamentals — beautiful beaches, limited land, and steady tourism — are still unbeatable. The market’s just maturing from sprint to marathon.
Quick Tips for Condo Investors on Hilton Head
- Focus on location (walkable to beach, golf, or harbor).
- Avoid HOAs with runaway assessments or poor reserves.
- Upgrade smartly — linens, lighting, and outdoor spaces get the best ROI with travelers.
- Network with local investors and property managers (there are active meetups year-round).
Final Thoughts
Hilton Head’s condo market isn’t “booming” — it’s stabilizing, and that’s healthy. Buyers finally have leverage. Owners with well-run rentals are still making strong returns. And newcomers can get in without overpaying for the first time in a while.
If you’re active on BiggerPockets and watching coastal markets, Hilton Head deserves a close look right now — especially if you understand the rhythm of a seasonal rental market and value quality over speculation.
Got experience renting or buying on Hilton Head? Drop your numbers and neighborhood in the comments — let’s compare notes and help each other make smart coastal moves!
- Ron Williams