Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
Copied
Photo
Copied
Photo
Photo
Photo
Photo
See all photos

$1,999,999

For Sale - Active
35 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
9 Beds
5 Baths
5,646 Square Feet
1.40 Acres Lot
Built in 1890
For Sale - Active
Units n/a
Checked: 10 hours ago
Updated: Sep 20, 2025 at 10:32AM

Investment Summary


Monthly Cash Flow
-$10,435
Cap Rate
-0.2%
Cash-on-Cash Return
-27.2%
Debt Coverage Ratio
-0.03
Internal Rate of Return (5 years)
-22.2%

Property Description


1.40 Acres Lot
Built in 1890
For Sale - Active
Units n/a

Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer. This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four working fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.

Build Your Team


Quickly find investor-friendly professionals who can help you succeed in real estate investing at any stage of the investing journey.

Avatar
Avatar
Avatar

Agents

Match with investor-friendly agents who can help you find, analyze, and close your next deal

Find an Agent
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar

Lenders

Get the best funding…find investor-friendly lenders who specialize in your deal strategy

Find a Lender
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar

Property Managers

Transition to passive investing. Find a trusted property management partnership that lasts.

Find a Property Manager
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar

Tax Pros & Accountants

Taxes and financial reporting made easy—find experts to create tax savings strategies, file taxes, and more

Find a Tax Pro

Location


Property Details


Parking

  • Garage Spaces: 3
  • Spaces Total: 0

Bedroom Information

  • # of Bedrooms: 9

Bathroom Information

  • # of Baths (Full): 4
  • # of Baths (Total): 5.0

Interior Features

  • # of Rooms: 18
  • Basement Description: Full, Partially Finished
  • Fireplace: Yes

Land Information

  • Land Use: Residential
  • Land Use Subtype: Single Family Residential

Lot Information

  • Parcel ID: 0500394.0002.00027.000
  • Lot Size: 60984 sqft

Property Information

  • Property Type: Single Family Residence
  • Style: Other
  • Year Built: 1890

Tax Information

  • Annual Tax: $25,395

Utilities

  • Water & Sewer: Private, Public
  • Heating: Natural Gas
  • Cooling: Ductless, Wall/Window Unit(s)

Location

  • County: Suffolk

Listing Details


Listed by:
Margaret T. Smith SRS CRB CIREC CB
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
(516) 578-7153

Source:
OneKey MLS
MLS#: 847363
OneKey MLS

Investment Summary


Monthly Cash Flow
-$10,435
Cap Rate
-0.2%
Cash-on-Cash Return
-27.2%
Debt Coverage Ratio
-0.03
Internal Rate of Return (5 years)
-22.2%

Purchase Details

Find an Agent

Purchase price:
$1,999,999
Amount financed:
-$1,599,999
Down payment:
$400,000
Closing costs:
$60,000
Rehab costs:
$0
Initial cash invested:
$460,000
Square feet:
5,646
Cost per square foot:
$354
Monthly rent per square foot:
$0.46

Financing Details

Find a Lender

Loan amount:
$1,599,999
Loan to value ratio:
80.0%
Loan type:
Amortizing
Term:
30 years
Interest rate:
6.500%
Principal & interest:
$10,113
Property tax:
$2,116
Insurance:
$182
Private mortgage insurance (PMI):
$0
Monthly payment:
$12,411

Operating Income

Find a Property Manager

% Rent Monthly Yearly
Gross rent:
$2,600 $31,200
Vacancy loss: (6%)
6% -$156 -$1,872
Operating income:
$2,444 $29,328

Operating Expenses


% Rent Monthly Yearly
Property taxes: (81%)
81%-$2,116-$25,396
Insurance: (7%)
7%-$182-$2,184
Property management: (8%)
8%-$208-$2,496
Repairs & maintenance: (5%)
5%-$130-$1,560
Capital expenditures: (5%)
5%-$130-$1,560
HOA fees: (n/a)
n/an/an/a
Total operating expenses: (106%)
106%-$2,766-$33,196

Cash Flow


Monthly Yearly
Net operating income:
-$322 -$3,864
Mortgage payments:
-$10,113 -$121,356
Cash flow:
-$10,435 -$125,220