Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Dan N.

Dan N. has started 31 posts and replied 118 times.

Quote from @David M.:

@Dan N.

Sorry, that doesn't make sense. If paying for the LLC is the least of your concerns, then the Due on Sale clause is a moot point. The LLC would have its own mortgage, and you can afford it. What refinancing issue would you have?

Out of curiousity, what sort of legal/legislation do you focus on?  I ask since I just noticed you are marked as the "#1 Legal & Legislation Contributor" on the Board right now.


 Hi David,

Maybe I didn't clarify my situation well enough in the initial post. I am purchasing the property on my name, because it is a conventional loan and if I create an LLC with zero income, I would only be eligible for a DSCR loan, which at the moment, I have no reason to use. After the the purchase the property will be placed on my name, and then I would have to transfer it to the LLC. That is where I am afraid the due on sale clause will be triggered.
Then, let's say I transfer it to the LLC successfully without triggering the due on call sale and in 2-3 years I will want to refi. The LLC with 1 property will have a monthly cash flow of $200-$300, hardly enough to qualify for a refi. So, I will have to move the property back under my own name, refi, then move it back to the LLC.

Regarding me being #1 Legal and Legislation Contribuitor" - it must be a bug in their algorithm lol. My guess looking at the Legal and Legislation board is that this post seems to be one of the most engaged posts on the board, otherwise, I have no idea why they would slap that tag on me.

Quote from @David M.:

@Mark S.

Oh is this what the OP is going after? I thought he just didn't want to pay for having the LLC.

This is why the boards keep saying to be careful about the LLC... Too many reasons / ways how people do not operat the LLC correctly.

Certainly, consult a qualified professional... But, you need to separate the accounting / taxation from the legal aspects. Yes, the IRS disregards the LLC entity only for single member LLC. But, that is only for taxation purposes. Just think about it --- the IRS has no way of rule that a State formed entity no longer has legal standing.

Or, did you realize that LLC's can elect to be taxed as a S Corp or C Corp? Partnerships too. Does that "give them" limited liablility? I believe not since their underlying formation hasn't changed with the State.

Another example... We've had threads where investors have said 'their accountant lets them deduct tons of expenses so they pay no tax' etc... So, their accountant is playing fast and loose to hide their income, but in fact they are helping to pierce their client's LLC's corporate veil. The limited liability is a legal matter, not an accounting matter.

I hope this helps.  I'd be happy to chat if you'd like.

Just to clarify, paying for the LLC is the least of my concerns. I am more afraid of triggering the due on sale clause and having issues with refinancing the property 
Quote from @Darnell Lockett:
Quote from @Dan N.:
Quote from @Konstantin Ginzburg:

@Dan N.

The LLC is meant as an additional layer of liability protection. The LLC is a business entity that is separate from you as an individual. This will ensure that anyone who attempts to sue; will only have access to the assets of the LLC (in this case, the property in the LLC); as opposed to having access to your personal assets. This is not meant as a substitute to liability coverage; but an additional layer of protection. The properties I currently own, have both liability coverage as well as the liability protections of an LLC associated with them.


 Hi Konstantin,

But if the LLC is a one man show, I understand that it does not protect my assets in any such way.
Forgot to add also that if I want to refi from within an LLC, I would have to transfer it back to my name if I am not mistaken.

IF you decide to close in a LLC...everything you do from a lending perspective moving forward is done in the LLC's name. There'd be no need to put it back into your personal name for anything mortgage or lending wise. 


 What I don't understand about this matter is the following. Currently, a conventional loan uses my personal income to decide if I am qualified.
If I put a $140K property in an LLC that has $200 monthly cash flow, how on earth would I qualify for a refinance of that property if I can only show that the LLC is generating $200/mo?

Quote from @Darnell Lockett:

Hi @Dan N.. First I'm not an attorney, so I'll offer no thoughts about whether putting it in a LLC provides adequate liability protection. As an investor and Mortgage Broker I personally put our properties in LLC's so the my personal debt-to-income ratio isn't impacted. We use DSCR loans which allow unlimited properties that can be closed in a LLC. Conventional loans also allow you to close in a LLC, but you will run into limitations as far as the number of properties you can finance. Closing in a LLC with a DSCR loan is so much cleaner and easier. There's no need to look at or verify any of your personal income, debt, bank statements or anything of that nature. Ultimately...there's no right or wrong way to close the loan However, it's whatever is best for you.


 Hi Darnell,

Great input. Since I have no debt or mortgages on my name, I have a few to go prior to having to worry about DTI.
However, you intrigued me on how you are getting deals to work with DSCR loans above 8% (that is what I have been quoted) ??

Quote from @Joshua Knapp:

I strongly suggest strong asset protection through the use of legal entities such as LLC's. An umbrella will do nothing to protect you in the event someone brings suit. While umbrella policies are a great idea, you need the legal protection an LLC provides. My advice and take it for what it is, establish a holding company in Wyoming, Nevada or Delaware where asset protection is strongest. Establish the property LLC's as a subsidiary of the holding company. If you really want to build strong asset protection, have the holding company then pencil up to a trust. I would not recommend any asset staying in your name. An LLC provides a corporate veil of protection to you. Yes it's true, by transferring deed from you to an LLC could trigger a due on sale. However, go ask an asset protection attorney how many times that's actually happened. A risk worth taking in my opinion. The alternative is leaving yourself exposed and say someone brings suit to you personally which has ramifications for anything in your name. Conversely, if someone were to go after your property and you are listed as the owner, you would be exposed personally which means anything in your name including bank accounts. Protect yourself.


 Hi Joshua,

What about refinancing? If I move the property to an LLC and in a few years I want to refinance, I would have to move back to my personal name, refinance, then move back to the LLC. Doesn´t this cause issues?

Hi Mark

valid remarks, however in this case, I will be financing with a conventional loan. Does that fact impact your recommendation in any way?

Quote from @Luka Milicevic:

I'm always surprised to see the number of experienced investors saying no to LLCs.

It just goes to show there are MANY ways to go about this business.

One of my best friends is a RE attorney that specializes in construction litigation. He says owning property outside of an LLC is financial suicide. Granted, he has seen the worst of the worst. He has repeatedly told me that it just takes one lawsuit to wipe out your life's work.

Everyone mentioning umbrella insurance is spot on, and I 100% agree with getting an umbrella policy. It's an insurance policy though, and what do we know about insurance? They will attempt to not pay in anyway they can. Insurance doesn't cover everything. You can get sued for 10 million other reasons that won't be covered by insurance, but that someone will have a claim to your assets. 

In my state of TN, it's not expensive to open an LLC and it's not expensive to maintain one.

It is nothing more than a LAYER of protection. LLC is a "limited" liability company, not an "eliminate liability" company. It's just another layer....

I would not own property outside of an LLC. Even as a single member. If you maintain it properly, don't co mingle funds, then it's a legitimate entity. When you co mingle funds and don't maintain it properly, a judge is going to look at it as an extension of you and basically void the protection it's supposed to provide.

I am all about as much protection as possible. Insurance + umbrella insurance + LLCs and Trusts! 

Happy investing


 Hi Luis,

The costs associated to the LLC are the least of my concerns.

I am more concerned about

1. Transferring the title from my name to the LLC and triggering the due on sale clause.

2. Having to move back an forth a property from personal title to LLC to personal to LLC when I want to refinance.

If these two issues were non-existent then indeed there would be no risk in having the LLC. But from everything I was able to gather till now, there actually seems to be more risk involved with these 2 issues when owning an LLC versus not owning one.
Happy to receive any insight you have about these two specific topics.

Quote from @Nate Marshall:

Speaking as someone who has 45 LLC's I recommend them. Wyoming was the first state to ever offer LLC's and yes for a one person LLC you do have benefits and protection. It's called COPE (Charging Order Protection Entity).

I have 5 LLC's outside of Wyoming.(3- Colorado, 1- South Dakota and 1- Alaska). 3 Holding Companies in Wyoming. 37 LLC's.

Too many benefits too list. They offer a lot of information at wyomingcompany.com and they can even help with trusts. 


 Interesting. What about the use of LLCs with mortgages on your personal name? Any friction there? (triggering due on sale clause, refinancing and having to move title back to personal name etc)

Hi Tim

Regarding the loans being on the name of the LLC, I foresee two problems

1. They will only be for holding the property, so they won't generate enough profit to qualify for another loan to that LLC

2. If I want to refinance, I will have to move it back to my own name for the same reasons.

Am I missing something regarding this aspect of it?