@Account Closed
How's it going. Well if I were you I'll take a look at both. But what type of investments are you looking for exactly? SFH or MFH? Do you just want buy and holds or open to flips as well? What ROI are you looking for?
My only concern is that your using media stats as your decision maker. Chicago is painted so negatively in the news it's been that way since Obama got in office. I don't remember what city was in the spotlight as the "bad" city before he took office(I think it was Detroit or New Orleans) because I was so young in 2008 but the news media makes up stories and really exaggerates things out of proportion. Now with that being said has Chicago went down a little bit In quality of life? I would say yes but it's not the warzone that's portray in the media. There are some very nice neighborhoods in Chicago. On the west side and the south side for investors to invest. The north side is already very well developed so it's going be harder to find any buy and holds in those neighborhoods(unless you are looking for flips and those are very hard to come by and when they do appear they are gone in a couple of days if not the same day) I could list off some nice neighborhoods in Chicago but if you want me to just send a PM.
There has been a more people leaving over the years but it's because of things like the high taxes so the common thing for some people to do is move to Indiana if they are closer towards the south side and to Wisconsin/Milwaukee if they are towards the west or north side. Sometimes after they move a lot of people STILL come back to Chicago on the weekends to do whatever it is they want to do because the distance between those cities isn't far. Another common thing people that reside in Chicago that want a change of scene is move to places like Houston, Dallas, Atlanta or some city in Florida which is ok as well. Sometimes a change of scenery is what some people need.
Moving on.....that doesn't mean you can't find quality rentals or flip deals in Chicago because they are out there and in decent neighborhoods. Just not as plentiful right now because the market is very tight right now. But that's mostly everywhere from the threads I have read on BP. Usually when an investor wants rentals from us we offer them a minimum of 11-12 cash on cash return(although it could be higher) and for flips a 20% ROI we have our own property managers? Two rehab crews, and a few realtors we work with so there's no worries for our investors no matter the location.
There's deals all over chicago and it's suburbs and things are going very very fast when they do appear. Speaking of Indiana we find deals for investors there as well. North west Indiana is concerned an extension of Chicago suburbs and the taxes are lower and Indiana is in general a more investor friendly state overall compared to Illinois.
So you might want to be open to those other states as well. But again that doesn't make Illinois / Chicago a bad place to invest because some very good deals do come up and I'm sure we could find you a very nice ROI in Illinois or Indiana. Let me know if you want any more details on what I have said. I don't want to make this post too long because it's some more things I could explain in much more details but send me a PM if you want more details about the information I gave.