Here are my thoughts:
Originally posted by @Taylor Horowitz:
I own a property in Colorado that I was an owner occupant in for 4 years and then moved in with my significant other. For the past year, it has been a rental that cash flows about $250/month.
That's not bad, but what are your long term financial goals, and is this approach going to get you there effectively?
I have decided to sell and have notified the tenants that the property will be listed in the coming weeks.
Even though it is a stable investment (there is upside on rents, positive cash flow and should have a nearly zero vacancy rate), I have decided to sell because I have almost made back from renting it what I put down and going to be listing it for 190% of what I paid for it as well as the factors below.
That's a nice return for five years.
Now as the listing date gets close, I am starting to re-think selling it.
Arguments for selling:
- I don't trust the HOA and dues have been going up steadily in the past 5 years and some potential high cost items need to be taking care of.
Hmmm, expensive assessment ahead? That could cut into your profit for sure.
-Cashing out while the market is high and have stockpile of cash to invest in a less expensive market or if there is a drop in the market having cash on hand.
Yes, it's a pretty great time to sell, especially if you are in the lower price range (I know that's relative in Boulder, lol)
But as others have mentioned, going to a different market can be dicey- don't forget to budget for your time (a few trips a year) and overestimate what you think your property management will cost when you run the numbers. Whether you'll have a lot of good options locall may depend on the amount of cash you'll have on hand after a sale. It's hard to do a lot with a little right now.
-Unit needs about 10k in rennovation/maintenance
Make sure you're accounting for that when your contemplate your listing price. If you don't, you may end up having to adjust your sale price upon inspection objections anyway.
-Variable rate mortgage and only refinancing options are non-warrantable
Probably not an issue for you if you refi, there are plenty of lenders who will do that (Elevations CU, which is right in Boulder, is one). You probably want to have a little list of lenders that can do it to give to potential buyers if you put it on the market though.
Arguments for keeping
- Stable rental income.
- Upside on rents
- Continually Strong real estate market (Boulder, CO)
All valid!
I am having trouble getting past the emotional aspect of selling the first place I purchased while I feel there are strong arguments for keeping or selling. Any input or feedback would be much appreciated.
You can reframe the emotional attachment by picturing it as the great savvy move that launched you towards financial success rather than your "first home". You can be just as proud of selling something as you were of buying it.
I would base the final decision on a long term financial plan. If you don't have one of those yet, take your time and do some reading and studying -- on BP and elsewhere too. Real estate investing is a great financial tool, and the one that makes the most sense to me. But it's not the only one.
I'm sure it will all become clear. You've got two more years before you lose your personal residence tax exemption so you don't need to rush.