All Forum Posts by: James Hartley
James Hartley has started 2 posts and replied 8 times.
Post: Cleveland Turnkey Package Deal!!! 3 Homes! 100% Managed!

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Hey Tom,
Could you send me more info and all the photos for these? Some of the images aren't showing (last 3)?
When you say conventional financing is accepted, how would that work for the package?
Looks like a couple of the leases are up soon, what happens then?
Cheers
Post: Math check: Cash vs Mortgage - Rental returns after tax

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
@Soh Tanaka Thanks for that! I didn't realize you get a better mortgage after 6 months - what sort of rate improvement can you expect and why?
Post: Math check: Cash vs Mortgage - Rental returns after tax

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Hi Everyone!
This is my first non-introduction post, hoping this great community can help me out! I'm also new to real estate investing, so please give feedback and point out mistakes!
I'm looking at a $70K SFH that rents for $850, I'm buying cash but thinking about whether to finance (delayed mortgage) or not. I'm looking to build up a passive income stream over time, but I make a good salary at present. Here's my comparison between the two options, can you please check my maths?
**Cash**
$70K cash payment
$10200 annual rent, or $9690 with 5% vacancy
Expenses: $1600 tax, $500 insurance, $969 property management (10%), $510 repairs (5%), $510 capex (5%)
Net Income: $5,601 or 8% of $70K before tax
Property tax is 26% land, 74% improvements, so $51,800 depreciated over 27.5 years is $1,884 per year
$5,601 income, of which $3,717 is taxed, $1,884 tax-free
Assuming 40% tax rate
= $3717 * 0.6 + 1884
= $4114 after tax (5.88%)
**Mortgage**
$14K downpayment (20%)
Mortgage: 4.5% at 30 years fixed on $56K
$10200 annual rent, or $9690 with 5% vacancy
Expenses: $1600 tax, $500 insurance, $969 property management (10%), $510 repairs (5%), $510 capex (5%)
$3408 Mortgage payments ($900 principal, $2508 interest in the first year)
Net income: $2193 before tax or 15.66% on $14K
Property tax is 26% land, 74% improvements, so $51,800 depreciated over 27.5 years is $1,884 per year
$2193 income, $1209 taxed, $984 tax-free (1884 depreciation - 900 mortgage principal)
Assuming 40% tax rate
= 1209 * 0.6 + 984
= $1,709.4 after tax (12.21%)
Does my calculation look correct?
I know I'm just treating the 5% capex as deductible when it's not (to simplify things), it would need to be depreciated over time. How would factoring this change the comparison?
Thanks in advance!
Post: Newbie from Brooklyn, New York

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Originally posted by @Suvir Salins:
Hey James,
I'm currently in Sydney, Australia and invest through Ohio Cashflow. Engelo and his team have been fantastic. I highly recommend them. You can read my review of them here on BP at this link.
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/92/topics/185...
Send me a colleague request and I'd be happy to talk any time mate and answer your questions. Recently helped another Aussie connect with OCF and he too is loving it. If we can do it you certainly can from NY!
Cheers,
Suvir
Thanks Suvir! Will definitely give your review a read and check out Ohio Cashflow. Did you buy cash or get a mortgage (in AU/US)?
Just listened to the episode with Engelo and it was great to hear a strong Aussie accent on the podcast haha!
Post: Newbie from Brooklyn, New York

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Originally posted by @Chris Grenzig:
James Hartley I just moved to the Bushwick area about 2 months ago. Let me know if you wanna grab a coffee sometime.
Hey Chris, I actually moved out of Bushwick a few months ago, cool area. Would love to grab a coffee and hear about your experiences.
Post: Newbie from Brooklyn, New York

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Originally posted by @Steven Perre:
Hey James, nice to see a NY transplant here. Reach out in any capacity if you need help (and I'm able to help).
Another new poster! Thanks buddy, would love to hear more about what you're doing!
Post: Newbie from Brooklyn, New York

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Would love to, and will have to listen to your podcast to find out more about Ohio Cashflow!
Post: Newbie from Brooklyn, New York

- Brooklyn, NY
- Posts 8
- Votes 5
Hi BiggerPockets community!
I'm looking to get into real estate investing after having worked for 10 years in tech, investing primarily in the stock market. I'd love to get to the point where I can sustain my lifestyle without having to work, so I'm going to need a lot of knowledge, good people, and rental properties!
I've lived in Brooklyn, New York for 4 years, but originally I'm from Sydney, Australia (another expensive market) and will probably return one day. I'm currently working in marketing tech, so I'm trying to figure out if there's a way I can provide some value based on my career experience.
Hope to meet you soon,
-James
P.S. Do you have suggestions for someone working full-time on where to find a good value turn-key rental?