Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew Porcaro

Matthew Porcaro has started 8 posts and replied 434 times.

Post: FHA 203K & House Hacking

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327
Originally posted by @John Ross Valderama:
Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
Originally posted by @John Ross Valderama:
Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
Originally posted by @John Ross Valderama:
Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
Originally posted by @John Ross Valderama:

Hello,

I decided to stop listening to podcasts and get off my rear to start getting my feet wet. I am thinking about doing the FHA 203K loan for a fixer upper. Since it's an FHA loan would I know that I need to live in the house, so if that is the case would it be possible to rent out the remaining rooms?

 Yes and yes.

The bigger challenge is getting an FHA 203k offer accepted to begin with. Without that, nothing else matters.

Listing agents' eyes gloss over when they see a 203k offer and they start talking about the "HGTV Effect." When the term "203k" is mentioned in any real estate office, stories start to pop out about the buyer who estimated that $150k of reno would cost $40k, which killed the deal and screwed that listing agent's client. These listing agents, of course, are advising their clients on which offer to take, and which to throw in the trash without even countering. 

The real question is: what are you doing to overcome that? 

 From what you're saying if I can get my numbers down within a reasonable ballpark I would avoid both problems. I would just need to contact a contractor for a side by side walkthrough and get estimates on what needs to be fixed. After words it would be calling local business to see the costs of parts and labor.

Or did I just over simplify that?

 I don't think you oversimplified, but I also don't think you're aiming for the right target. 

Focus on getting the offer accepted. Zoom in like a laser-beam on that. If that doesn't happen, nothing else matters

I talk about FHA 203k at work probably about 100 times a year - twice a week.

I see a ratified (seller signed) purchase contract w/ FHA 203k in mind about 5 times a year.

The investor's reno budget estimates weren't garbage, and we actually close one, about once or twice a year.

What are you doing to make you one of those 5 in a hundred? We will get to making you one of those 2 out of 5, but first you need to be one of those 5 in a hundred before that is even relevant.

If you were in my shoes with a FHA 203k loan what steps would you take to improve the chances of having the offer go through?

 Your profile says that you're interested in wholesaling. Minus the whole "I can't afford this property and I can't close and I'm not in a position to close and I'm probably lying to you," try the wholesaling marketing stuff that you like. Again, minus the actual wholesaling aspect. The marketing stuff is on point, it's simply the "ability to actually deliver" that screws up wholesalers. Incidentally, this marketing stuff is how most real estate agents drum up listings (they also can't actually close on & buy the home, most of the time, which in their cases is fine since that is not what they are selling).

A seller signed fully ratified purchase contract crossed my desk this week. The appraisal will come in at least a quarter million dollars above the contract price. This buyer wasn't focused on the financing, he was focused on getting the offer accepted for the best price possible. 

I should probably change that. Wholesaling is what got me interested in REI, but doing my research I found that isn't the best method for me, I would like to try it in the future.

I will be focusing on rental properties using the BRRRR strategy. I want to use the FHA 203K loan to finance my first rental property, live in it for a bit while fixing it up and renting out the remaining rooms while I build equity in the property and in 6 months I want to refinance pay back the FHA loan and use what I got to invest in a second rental(I will still be living in the first rental, which is the one we're talking about).

With your advice I would first need to focus on getting the deal accepted. From what you're saying a FHA 203K loan is extremely hard to get accepted by a seller.

 I would't say it's "extremely hard". I'd focus on Fannie Mae Homepath properties if possible. When the federal govt is involved, it seems like they're more privy to accepting offers, as to show that they practice in participating in their own stimulus plans (203k being a first time buyer incentive program)

My 203k offer got accepted no problem. I offered a little below asking, with my preapproval letter, and the paperwork got started immediately. 

The challenge for me was everything after that offer was accepted. The paperwork is tedious, long-winded, repetitive, and downright frustrating. You need to look exceptional on paper (ample savings account, w2 employee, etc). 

As the other poster said, construction costs are often wrongly calculated. While that's pretty much the nature of all flips, in this case you're at the mercy of what the bank approves you for. Anything above and beyond that is sometimes added with a holdback, but it will increase your monthly payment, and slow down the project. 

Start sifting around and putting some offers out there. All of this is irrelevant until you have a pre-approval letter in hand and start offering on foreclosures. 

Post: Looking at my first deal possible duplex fix and hold

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

Also, another thing to point out is you cannot do the work yourself on a 203k. You may be able to do it on a streamlined 203k, but I don't believe that's allowed either. You need an approved, licensed, bonded, and insured general contractor to sign off on the work and provide a detail estimate of what needs to be done. 

Post: Looking at my first deal possible duplex fix and hold

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

I may be wrong, but I'm fairly certain that you cannot get a "business" 203k loan. 203k loans are owner occupied first time home buyer loans. They're strictly governed so that businesses/investors don't use them, since they provide a lot of assistance to first time home buyer types. You also cannot transfer ownership to a business entity with these mortgages (or many other conventional owner occupied mortgages in general).

This deal obviously relies mostly on what you can get it for, what you think market rent is, and how much you will need to pay each month for your mortgage payment. 203k monthly payments tend to be high, since you're allowed to put down as little as 3.5% of the purchase price + you need to pay PMI + you are financing the construction cost as well. You will need to sufficient W2 financials to show the bank that you're able to afford the payments.

Post: Starting out as landlord and financing?

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

They can definitely run projections, my lender did it on my refinance before I even had anyone in the property. It is a slippery slope though, there's a lot of proof you need to provide to get past the red tape. 

Post: Refinance rental property

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

It really depends on how much equity you have into the property and what it's current appraisal value is. 

Do you own it free and clear? Or did you just finish the rehab? 

Banks will refinance on up to 70% of the appraised value. If you don't have enough equity in the property to allow for that, you may not be eligible. 

Post: House Hacking Question: How much should I put away ?

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

Honestly, I have an account dedicated to taking in only rent each month. I don't touch that money. Any "profit" I make on my property is basically held there as a rainy day fun, until it grows large enough to be parlayed into another deal. 

Post: Does this BRRRRR strategy make sense or am I missing something

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

I think your idea is fine, but I don't think you need to use Hard Money if you have the ability to open a 203k. 

Having just finished one myself, I have to say it was tedious but worth every penny if you find a good deal. You have access to any REO listing, and most of those listings now have a "first time buyer" grace period of about 10-20 days where they can only take offers from first time buyers, namely 203k program users. The institution I worked with was M&T and they were more than accommodating. Contractors got paid out fast, inspections were quick, and everyone was happy.

Hard money is tough, especially if you're new. They want a lot of collateral and probably rough terms to start off with, meaning you need to find some dirt cheap properties to get into. Also, to house hack properly, I suggest you finding properties that are already zoned for 2-4 units, unless you want to have a AirBNB type scenario and live with other people in  the same unit. 

Post: How should I take rent payments?

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

Thanks! I will definitely check out TurboTenant!

Post: How should I take rent payments?

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

Hey Guys - what is everyone preferred way of taking rent payment? Only own two units currently, so I don't need a robust system just yet. How should I have my tenants pay me? Up until this point I've just been taking check or cash. 

Post: Experience with 203k loans. NEED ADVISE

Matthew Porcaro
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 443
  • Votes 327

Just finished mine. The bank was very accommodating, and the HUD consultant was a pleasure to deal with.

The only thing you need to make sure with your contractor is that they are licensed and insured (duh) and that they are able to float the construction costs for the initial start of construction etc. The first payment to the contractor doesn't come until a month after closing. So, if you want to get started ASAP just keep that in mind. Once the HUD consultant does the inspection, I received payment within 5 days via FedEx 2 day.