Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Mitch Franklin

Mitch Franklin has started 7 posts and replied 15 times.

I'm seeking funding options to purchase fix/flip properties in the Cleveland / Cuyahoga Co. area through my self-directed IRA. This will be my 1st investment so understand I'll need a higher than normal down payment and am good with it. If possible, I'd like to include the rehab costs and monthly mortgage payments, but by no means is this a dealbreaker.

I'll have checkbook control of the SDIRA and would like to place my funds in a local bank that is investor friendly. If anyone has any recommendations for an area or national bank, I'd greatly appreciate reading your responses. My long term plan would be to also purchase buy and hold properties in this area and purchasing them outside my SDIRA. I'm thinking my best shot is getting in with a local bank that does this type of portfolio lending. 

Thanks in advance for your responses. Much appreciated,

Mitch

Quote from @Bob E.:

@Mitch Franklin  We have several properties in those markets and I think you are going to have issues getting the numbers to work right now.

Typical property price is @ 85k right now and that will likely need some love to be rent ready / sale ready.  Taxes will run 2k a year and insurance will run another $75 a month.

If you sell this on a 15 year note, even at 85k at 5% your payment is going to run $672 a month.  Add in $241 for escrows and your payment becomes $913 a month.  This is a breakeven sale price with a below market rate on what is essentially a subprime loan, you could buy Verizon stock and likely get a better return with way more liquidity and less risk..  To get this profitable you are going to have to increase the rate and the term likely driving the payment to be more than rent.  you then miss out on appreciation.  Also keep in mind that when you resell, depending on the municipality, you may get to experience the joy of POS again.

If you are thinking you will sell the note most investors are going to want to see an LTV of <65% meaning you can get out 55k of your sale price, and they are going to want that discounted to bring the yield up closer to 10%.

@Bob E.E.

Thanks for the detailed reply. 

This strategy would require getting the property at a discount from either a distressed seller or wholesaler. Let's say you acquire the home at a 12.5% discount for all cash - $74,375 (Purchase $)

Turn around and sell it with owner financing for $90,000 and create 2 notes. 1 note to flip in 6 months and 1 to hold for cashflow.

Buyer down payment 10% - $9,000

Note 1 - 80% of loan - $72,000 - TERMS: 9% for 15 years - (I will sell this in 6 months after seasoning)  Monthly Payment - $730.27 (Principal is $536 [6 mo. avg] Interest is $194.27 [6 mo. avg]

Note 2 - 10% of loan - $9,000 - TERMS: 9% for 15 years - (I will keep this for cash flow)                      Monthly Payment - $91.28 (PI)

Acquisition / Holding / Selling Costs - $10,000

Taxes - $116 / Insurance - $40 / Loan Servicing Fee - $20 (I pulled taxes and insurance off a Redfin listing for $89k.

Total monthly for home buyer- 730.27 + 91.28 + 116 + 40 + 20= $997.55

Sell Note 1 in 6 months at a 10% discount: 6 months of principal paid is $3,216 (536 x 6)

---Note 1 Balance in 6 months: $68,784 >>>  95% of note value = $65,344.80

Total Cash Invested (TCI) - $84,375 - $9,000 (down payment) - $8,854.61 (value of note 2 at 6 months) = $66,520.39

RETURN:  65,344.80 - 66,520.39 = -$1,175.59

+   $4,381.62  (730.27 x 6 months of Note 1 payments)

+   $547.68  (91.28 x 6 months of Note 2 payments)

= $3,753.71 PROFIT + 174 payments (14.5 years) for Note 2 at $91.28 >>> Payments of $15,882.72

ROI:  3,753.71 /  84,375 = 4.44% in 6 months >>> 8.88% Annualized and you're cash flowing $91.28 for 174 more payments.

I would suspect you can get costs (acquisition / holding / closing) down below $10k. I haven't dug in yet on those details but please let me know where I may be off on my numbers. I would appreciate the input.

I feel the note 1 buyer is in a good position as the balance of the note is only 75% of the market value of the house. 68,784 (owed on note 1 in month 6) / 85,000 (market value of house)

As for POS, since I will have just bought the house, it appears the POS inspection and correction would be performed by the seller I just bought the house from. I realize that a distressed seller may not be able to pay for these, but you could back it out along with the repairs from the offer price.

Interested to hear your comments Bob as well as anyone else in this forum. Thanks in advance.

I'm looking for referrals for both a title company and real estate attorney in the Cleveland area. I'm looking for experience in the following respective areas below. Thanks in advance for your recommendations.


Title Company:

-investor friendly

-ability to assist in developing purchase and sale agreements utilizing creative financing

-strategic and interested in employing ideas to reduce investor costs

-help make numbers work at closing

Attorney:

-SDIRA- creating an LLC that has the SDIRA as the member.

-Seller financing strategies where I am creating the note

-Purchase off market or through wholesalers

-Foreclosure process; both acquiring a house through foreclosure and foreclosing on an existing homeowner

Quote from @Harrison Silverstein:
Quote from @Mitch Franklin:

I'm originally from University Heights / Cleveland Heights, live in Hawaii now and am beginning to research purchasing properties in the Maple Heights, Warrensville Heights, and surrounding areas. 

My plan is to both reach out to both motivated sellers (marketing / text / direct mail) and wholesalers to purchase houses with cash, then sell the house (possibly after a small repair) and carry the note long enough for seasoning so I can sell the note at a reasonable discount. I also like the idea of building a bit of cash flow by carrying a 2nd note and hang onto it for the monthly income.

Deal specs to include:

*Down Payment – 20% or more (10% Min.)

*Credit Rating – 650+ ideal, 600 minimum

• Interest Rate – Fixed 9-10%

• Term – Fully Amortizing (10 to 15 years)

• Income – Ability to Repay (45%+/- Debt to Income Ratio)

• Reserves – Taxes & Insurance

• Servicing Through A Licensed Third Party rolled into payment

Another potential strategy would be to acquire houses and then fix and flip. I haven't begun building out a team so I'm a bit away from jumping into this strategy.

I'd like to connect with other investors who are doing this in the Cleveland area to compare notes and refine strategies. Please reach out as I'd love to hear your thoughts or at the very least talk some Cleveland Browns football.


 Hi Mitch,

I currently have a Performing note in Dayton, OH. I wasn't originally planning on keeping it for the cash flow, but it quickly became one of my favorite investments to hold on to. If you're looking to eventually sell the note, having the contract underwritten by a service such as "Call the Underwriter" could help add value for those looking to buy.


 @Harrison Silverstein

Thanks Harrison for the response. I checked out calltheunderwriter.com and it appears to be a good resource for information and possibly for services. They definitely detail all the considerations you should be thinking about to be Dodd Frank Act compliant. Have you used them in the past? How was your experience?

@Nicholas Misch - It's definitely an interesting angle that is gaining momentum as there doesn't appear to be the same competition as flipping houses. If you'd like to learn more, @Jorie Aulston and @Kevin Jimeno do a great job of covering the process and benefits in their podcast "Shut Up and Invest". Their content would be a great resource to get familiar with it.

I'm originally from University Heights / Cleveland Heights, live in Hawaii now and am beginning to research purchasing properties in the Maple Heights, Warrensville Heights, and surrounding areas. 

My plan is to both reach out to both motivated sellers (marketing / text / direct mail) and wholesalers to purchase houses with cash, then sell the house (possibly after a small repair) and carry the note long enough for seasoning so I can sell the note at a reasonable discount. I also like the idea of building a bit of cash flow by carrying a 2nd note and hang onto it for the monthly income.

Deal specs to include:

*Down Payment – 20% or more (10% Min.)

*Credit Rating – 650+ ideal, 600 minimum

• Interest Rate – Fixed 9-10%

• Term – Fully Amortizing (10 to 15 years)

• Income – Ability to Repay (45%+/- Debt to Income Ratio)

• Reserves – Taxes & Insurance

• Servicing Through A Licensed Third Party rolled into payment

Another potential strategy would be to acquire houses and then fix and flip. I haven't begun building out a team so I'm a bit away from jumping into this strategy.

I'd like to connect with other investors who are doing this in the Cleveland area to compare notes and refine strategies. Please reach out as I'd love to hear your thoughts or at the very least talk some Cleveland Browns football.

Post: In person Real Estate Meetup _Hawaii

Mitch FranklinPosted
  • Kailua, HI
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8

Hi Gilbert,

Is this for this upcoming Tuesday, 11/16? Looks like you posted this yesterday after 11/9. I'm in Kailua but am always willing to travel to talk REI.

@ Bo Bond

@ Dave Schmidt

Thanks for the detailed insight. It's much appreciated. 

Are there pros and cons beyond just the level of security between having a contractor list your LLC as a certificate holder as compared to being additionally insured? Do you mind shedding some light on what the benefit would be to have them list your LLC as a certificate holder only?

Have you guys had much success in getting contractors to list your LLC as additionally insured or obtaining their own builders risk policy for your project?

Aloha BP community!

I’m curious to hear everyone’s mindset regarding obtaining insurance for your fix and flip LLC and coverage levels.

I’m on Oahu and planning on handling some of the rehab work myself while contracting out the heavier jobs. At minimum I’m thinking:

*General liability

*Personal injury

Possibly thinking errors and omissions but that may be overkill.

Please let me know your experiences and if you worked with a solid insurance company, both on island and off, as I will appreciate the feedback. Definitely stories where it came in handy.

Thanks in advance for your responses.

Mitch