Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Alexander Szikla

Alexander Szikla has started 37 posts and replied 785 times.

Why not a 3 or 4 unit for comparable pricing? 

Post: The Great Realignment: How Job Market Shifts Are Reshaping Real Estate

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

The commercial real estate landscape is experiencing a dramatic geographic pivot, with traditional powerhouses losing steam while overlooked regions emerge as institutional favorites.

The Midwest's Moment Has Arrived

Forget the "flyover" stereotype—Midwest cities are commanding serious attention from multifamily investors. Chicago leads with 4.2% year-over-year rent growth (third nationally), while Indianapolis (2.6%) and Madison (2.3%) significantly outpaced the national average of 1%.

Major institutional players are placing substantial bets. Morgan Properties committed $500 million while Clear Investment Group deployed $300 million, recognizing the region's demographic stability, job growth, and constrained supply. Chicago multifamily sales more than doubled in Q1, with Class-A prices jumping 33% above the 2022-2024 average.

Article content

Texas Stumbles as Competition Intensifies

Meanwhile, Texas metros—long the job creation champions—are showing vulnerability. Dallas and Houston each slipped two spots in rankings despite adding nearly 29,000 positions over 12 months. Austin fell out of the top 10 for the first time since February.

The broader picture reveals nationwide cooling. The top 10 job-growth markets added 335,200 positions—an 18.4% decline from the previous year. No market has exceeded 100,000 job gains since January.

Investment Implications

This economic reshuffling directly impacts investment flows. As Sun Belt markets face construction challenges, investors are discovering value in overlooked regions. The Midwest benefits from limited supply—Chicago has just 1,200 Class-A units scheduled for delivery over three years—while construction costs constrain competition elsewhere.

Many Midwest deals involve "broken capital stacks"—healthy properties strained by rising rates—creating acquisition opportunities. However, with 23 of the top 150 metros reporting job losses, careful market selection becomes critical.

Geographic diversification is no longer optional. As traditional growth markets face headwinds, investors recognizing opportunities in previously secondary markets may find the best risk-adjusted returns.

The commercial real estate map is being redrawn. Smart capital is already repositioning.

Post: Real Estate Reckoning: Is the Market Signaling a Turning Point?

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628
🚨 Housing Market Emerges as Recession's Leading Threat


The American real estate market is sending a clear warning signal: we may be witnessing the early stages of an economic downturn. As economists at Moody's and J.P. Morgan put recession odds as high as 65%, analysts have shifted their focus from tariff fears to housing sector weakness as the most immediate threat to economic stability.


The warning signs are mounting fast:

  • 77% of Americans say it's a bad time to buy a home (Fannie Mae, April 2025)
  • Mortgage rates hovering near 7% are crushing demand (old story)
  • Home Purchase Sentiment Index shows a net-55% rating for buying conditions
  • Inflation-adjusted residential investment remains flat

Citi Research expects housing activity to contract in Q2 after a sluggish start to the year, with the combination of falling permits, rising inventory, and slipping prices painting a picture of a market running out of steam. The pain isn't limited to residential either—MSCI's RCA index recorded price declines across all major commercial property types for the first time since 2010, with multifamily assets taking the biggest hit at -12.1% year-over-year.


While the Fed remains on the sidelines for now, Citi suggests it could be forced to accelerate rate cuts if housing market declines start hitting employment metrics. As one analyst put it: housing may not cause the next recession, but it's likely where we'll see it first.

💼 Commercial Real Estate Hits Historic Slowdown


The residential warning signs are reverberating through commercial real estate, where March 2025 recorded the lowest monthly transaction volume in nearly a year. Deal activity fell 3.9% as investors shifted into full "wait-and-see" mode amid policy uncertainty and economic headwinds.


The sector breakdown tells a stark story:

  • Retail led declines at -40%
  • Office fell 11.4% (though lending surged 205%)
  • Apartments dropped 9.6% but still topped volume at $9.2B
  • Industrial bucked the trend, rising 25.7%

Investor sentiment reflects this widespread caution: 70% now recommend "hold" strategies—up 14 points from last quarter—while only 23% favor buying and just 7% are selling. Apartments stood out as the only sector with more buy than hold recommendations, driven by demand for stable cash flow in uncertain times.


Yet beneath the surface caution, contradictory signals emerge. Despite slower deal flow, CRE returns actually rose 40 basis points in Q1 to a near three-year high, with one-year returns hitting 2.7%. Retail led at 1.8%, while apartments and industrial each posted 1.3%. Even office returns turned positive, though they remain negative year-over-year.


The contradiction deepens with financing: CRE originations jumped 42% year-over-year in Q1, driven by that massive 205% surge in office lending. Narrowing yield spreads and rising property prices for five straight quarters suggest a potential pricing floor may be forming.

🏗️ Development Pipeline Reveals Geographic Rebalancing


While investors pause and buyers retreat, developers are quietly reshaping the multifamily landscape in ways that reveal the market's next chapter. New Census data shows a fascinating convergence: Austin, Orlando, Phoenix, and Atlanta each posted remarkably similar annual permit totals between 11,400-12,300 units—but the underlying trends tell a story of dramatic geographic rebalancing.


Pandemic hotspots are cooling fast:

  • Austin: -7,910 units (steepest decline nationally)
  • Phoenix: -5,891 units
  • Atlanta: -3,088 units
  • Miami: -3,000+ units (dropped to #16 nationally)
  • Los Angeles and Washington DC: -4,000 to -4,500 units each

Meanwhile, emerging markets are heating up:

  • Orlando: +4,351 units (strong growth despite regional trends)
  • Columbus, OH: +22% year-over-year
  • Chicago and Anaheim showing renewed strength
  • Smaller metros like Fayetteville, Omaha, Des Moines, and Augusta all gained 1,200-2,200 units

This shift suggests developers are chasing opportunities beyond traditional pandemic winners, spreading growth to up-and-coming markets with better fundamentals and less frothy pricing. Construction across all sectors has hit multi-year lows, potentially setting up stronger rent growth when demand returns.

🔮 The Inflection Point


What emerges from this data is a picture of a real estate market in fundamental transition. We're witnessing residential weakness, commercial caution, and shifting development patterns that suggest the market is recalibrating after years of pandemic-driven volatility—but not necessarily collapsing.


The contradictions tell the story: While transaction volumes hit 12-month lows and consumer sentiment craters, returns are rising, originations are surging, and tariff-driven market turmoil has revived CRE's attractiveness as a safe haven alongside cash and bonds. Fresh capital is eyeing opportunities as the market potentially finds its footing.


What to watch in the coming months:

  • Whether Fed intervention becomes necessary if housing weakness hits employment
  • If CRE's recent return improvements can sustain amid transaction volume declines
  • How emerging multifamily markets absorb new supply as coastal hotspots cool

Post: Class B Office: A Hot Commodity?

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

Manhattan's Class B office buildings have unexpectedly become the city's most coveted leasing opportunity just as this inventory begins to disappear. With premium Class A towers reaching near-capacity, leasing momentum has cascaded into B-plus properties—those older, well-located buildings with just enough upgrades to attract quality tenants.

The numbers tell the story: these spaces recorded an impressive 8 million square feet leased in Q1 2025, representing the strongest post-pandemic performance and exceeding the 10-year average by nearly 25%.

This surge comes at a critical moment as recent zoning changes and tax incentives accelerate office-to-residential conversions, with Class B buildings bearing the brunt of this transformation. More than 6.5 million square feet have already been converted since 2020, and pending projects could triple this figure in the coming years. These conversions not only reduce available inventory but often displace existing tenants, further intensifying competition for remaining space across the market.

The tightening supply is evident in the data—sublease availability has declined for eight consecutive quarters, reaching just 3.33 million square feet, its lowest level since July 2020. With fewer companies relinquishing space and more implementing return-to-office policies, Class B availability is evaporating quickly. This trend mirrors the broader U.S. office market revival, which saw approximately 115 million square feet leased in Q1 2025—up 13% from the previous quarter and the highest quarterly total since mid-2019.

The financial calculus makes these properties particularly attractive for tenants, as Class B spaces rent for up to $25 per square foot less than Class A properties in prime areas like Midtown South. However, this affordability poses challenges for landlords as tenant expectations evolve. Today's occupiers demand turnkey buildouts that push landlord costs toward Class A levels, squeezing margins for all but the most well-capitalized owners and creating a precarious balance between demand and profitability in this segment.

Major tenants are validating this trend with substantial commitments. Amazon (via WeWork) has secured 303,741 square feet, while IBM has taken 92,663 square feet at One Madison. Horizon Media has made perhaps the most significant statement with a 360,000-square-foot, 17-year lease commitment. Even traditional firms like Goodwin Procter have embraced the B-building renaissance, leasing 250,000 square feet in a 116-year-old property. BuzzFeed, Capital One, A&E, and even the Archdiocese of New York have made similar moves, underscoring the broad appeal of these properties across diverse industries.

Yet this promising recovery now faces significant headwinds. The administration's renewed tariff threats—particularly targeting China—have stoked recession fears, causing many firms to pause their leasing plans. Brokers report a growing reluctance to commit to long-term leases with economic uncertainty looming. This hesitation could derail momentum just as landlords were beginning to regain leverage. Beyond immediate economic concerns, structural challenges persist: obsolete buildings, sluggish conversion efforts, and an oversupply of underused space continue to plague the market. Many potential office-to-residential conversions remain on hold due to prohibitive capital costs.

While Class B space currently reigns as Manhattan's hottest commodity, the sustainability of this trend remains an open question. The business model faces thin margins and depends heavily on capital-intensive upgrades that not all property owners can afford. Any technology sector pullback or broader economic slowdown—potentially triggered by trade tensions—could rapidly cool this momentum. For now, only landlords with robust balance sheets are positioned to weather these crosscurrents, potentially creating a widening gap between successful and struggling properties within the same classification. Industry veterans are advised to proceed with caution as 2025 unfolds.

Post: Tariff Proof? Why Multifamily, Self Storage and Industrial Could Win While Other Sect

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

The Trump administration's tariff policies are creating both challenges and potential opportunities for real estate investors. While Wall Street has expressed concerns about the impact of tariffs on corporate earnings and inflation pressure, the multifamily, self storage and industrial sectors may actually benefit from these trade policies. Tariffs on building materials will likely increase construction costs, further constraining new supply and potentially supporting rent growth in existing properties.

The tariff situation could also accelerate "friendshoring" trends, where companies relocate operations to politically aligned countries, potentially boosting regional economies where multifamily demand is already strong. However, President Trump's demeanor towards Canadian and, to a lesser degree, European economic integration which adds another layer of complexity.

At the same time, rising inflation due to tariffs may limit how much the Federal Reserve can cut interest rates, affecting financing costs for developers and investors. Analysts project that in a high-tariff scenario, U.S. exports could flatten in 2025, with some economists modeling a scenario where average tariff rates on goods imports increase by 10 percentage points—equivalent to a 25% tariff on Mexican and Canadian imports.

Despite these headwinds, industry experts anticipate a potential rebound in the multifamily sector later this year. With new multifamily permits having dropped 20% in 2024 and completions expected to fall another 15% in 2025, this supply slowdown is projected to push rents higher, especially in high-demand markets like Atlanta, Phoenix, and Dallas. Many major multifamily markets should see positive rent growth and stable vacancy rates by mid-2025, with only a few laggard markets taking longer to recover.

February's housing data painted a picture of contrasting trends in the multifamily sector, with permits continuing to decline while starts showed surprising resilience. Multifamily permits fell by 4.3% from January to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 404,000 units—down nearly 16% year-over-year. In contrast, multifamily starts jumped 12.1% from last month to 370,000 units, though still 6.6% below last February's pace.

This mixed performance suggests the market may be approaching a turning point after months of contraction. The number of multifamily units under construction has stabilized at 754,000, though still down 21% from last year, while completions fell 20.7% month-over-month and 15.8% year-over-year to 512,000 units.

The single-family sector also shows mixed signals, with permits dropping 3.4% annually to 992,000 homes, while starts fell 2.3% year-over-year but climbed 11.4% month-over-month to 1.108 million units. Completions rose 7.1% for the month but remained slightly down from last year.

This evolving housing landscape unfolds against a backdrop of solid but potentially vulnerable economic growth. The U.S. economy expanded at a 2.4% annualized rate in the fourth quarter of 2024, slightly better than previous estimates due to higher net exports. However, this economic resilience comes as Moody's warns that America's fiscal strength is deteriorating due to widening budget deficits and mounting debt, projecting that U.S. debt-to-GDP will rise from nearly 100% in 2025 to around 130% by 2035.

The bottom line: While multifamily permitting continues to slide, the recent rebound in starts and steady construction levels hint that the market may be approaching a bottom. Developers are treading carefully, but demand-side factors like high mortgage rates and persistent rental demand, combined with supply constraints partially driven by tariff policies, could set the stage for renewed momentum in the sector by late 2025, particularly in markets with favorable supply-demand dynamics.

Post: Cap Rate Clarity: National Trends & NYC’s Multifamily Spotlight

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

Commercial real estate markets are showing signs of stabilization as CBRE’s latest survey reveals most investors believe cap rates have peaked. Despite Treasury yield volatility throughout 2024, cap rates remained steady with industrial and multifamily sectors even experiencing slight declines.

After a 51% drop in transactions during 2023, CRE sales volume rebounded 9% last year — signaling improving investor confidence.

The New York City multifamily sector presents a particularly interesting story. CMBS issuance quadrupled to $6.7 billion in 2024 — reaching its highest level since 2019 and representing 27% of nationwide multifamily issuance.

However, this surge comes alongside rising distress levels, particularly in pre-1974 buildings where distress rates hit 25.1%, compared to just 2.9% for properties built after 2000. The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 continues to challenge owners of rent-stabilized properties.

By year-end 2024, the distress rate for NYC multifamily conduit loans reached 8.5%, contributing to an overall conduit distress rate of 14.4% citywide. Multifamily properties now account for 43% of the city’s total distressed commercial loans.

Office properties face ongoing challenges across the country, with cap rates for premium Class A properties now exceeding 8%, while distressed Class C properties see rates climbing into the low teens. This reflects investors pricing in higher risk premiums for the sector.

Looking ahead, 2025 appears poised for increased transaction activity as the market adjusts to the current interest rate environment. Strategic investors focusing on quality assets with strong fundamentals will likely find attractive opportunities as the market continues to normalize.

Post: Looking for the best book about real estate

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

Shameless plug: https://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Hacks-Working-Smarter-Harder-e...

Probably not the best, but I think it is good! If you DM me, I'll happily provide a copy. 

Post: Young Professional Looking to Get into Real Estate Investing

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

Why not focus instate? Plenty of opportunity within driving distance. 

As we welcome 2025, we’re grateful for your continued trust in our market insights. This year promises fresh opportunities in commercial real estate — and we’re here to help you navigate them. Over the last year, we noticed a few key trends worth highlighting:

Market Recovery Signs:
  • Loan volumes reached $539 billion in 2024, up 26% year-over-year. This included some landmark deals including Rockefeller Center’s $3.5B loan and Miami Beach’s Fontainebleau $1.2B refinancing
  • Alternative lenders filling traditional banking gaps with short-term solutions which has already begun a cycle of consolidation that will likely continue and accelerate in 2025
The Office Sector Divide:
  • CBD property values are down 50.7% from 2021 peaks
  • Class A office properties seem to be in their own vacuum of prosperity with trophy properties commanding premium rents ($100+ PSF nationally, up to $247 in top markets) with strong occupancy
  • Hybrid work continues impacting older building valuations which have not faired as well, but this may begin to rebalance as more companies are instituting mandates to return to physical offices
Challenges & Opportunities:
  • $1 trillion in loans maturing by 2026
  • Interest rates up from 3.5% (2021) to 6.74% (2024)
  • Experts such as AEW’s Michael Acton and Blackstone’s Nadeem Meghji see the best entry point in the last 15–20 years and we agree
Market Outlook:

Current market conditions present unique opportunities, with inflation-adjusted prices at historic lows and yields at decade highs. Industry experts suggest the current uncertainty creates ideal investment conditions for those willing to enter the market.



As we step into 2025, we wish our valued readers prosperity in their investments, clarity in their decisions, and success in seizing the opportunities ahead. May this year bring you strategic wins and profitable ventures in an evolving market landscape.


Post: Housing Market Outlook 2024: Harris vs. Trump

Alexander SziklaPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • New York City
  • Posts 796
  • Votes 628

The 2024 presidential election presents two distinct visions for America's housing market. Historical data shows housing prices have averaged 4.84% growth during election years since 1987, but the specific policies of each candidate could significantly influence future market dynamics.

Vice President Harris will likely focus on supply-side solutions, representing a continuation of Biden administration policies, emphasizes affordable housing expansion through several key initiatives:

1. Affordable Housing Focus: Expanding programs to increase housing availability, particularly targeting urban rental affordability

2. Supply-Chain Strategy: Shifting from demand-side solutions to active development of new housing units

3. Tax Policy: Proposed revision of high-income tax cuts to fund housing programs and economic stability initiatives

4. Down Payment Assistance: Proposed up to $25K in down-payment support for 1st-time homebuyers

Market implications under Harris include potential stabilization of home prices through increased housing stock, enhanced affordable housing options, reducing competition in rental markets with a greater focus on urban development and rental price controls.

Savvy investors may want to focus on affordable housing opportunities and urban renewal projects under a Harris administration.

Former President Trump will likely focus on deregulation and private sector growth, emphasizing market-driven solutions and reduced government intervention. This could be reflected across a few signature initiatives:

1. Deregulation Push: Streamlining housing development regulations and approval processes

2. GSE Reform: Moving toward privatization of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

3. Tax Strategy: Making the 2017 tax cuts permanent to stimulate investment and consumption

Market implications under Trump include potential for accelerated price growth in existing homes, increased private sector development opportunities, and more flexible lending standards through GSE privatization.

Similarly, clever allocators of capital may want to focus on market rate housing and more aggressive development opportunities while considering GSE privatization impacts under a Trump administration.

Regardless of who you support or which way you lean, both candidates acknowledge the need for increased housing supply. Ultimately, the impact on housing markets will depend not only on who wins but also on their ability to implement proposed policies and the broader economic environment during their term.

Your Voice Matters

The future of America's housing market will be significantly influenced by the outcome of the 2024 election. Whether you're a homeowner, investor, renter, or real estate professional, your stake in this decision is real and lasting. Make your voice heard - be sure to check your registration status and make a plan to vote this November. The housing market's future depends on engaged citizens like you.