Originally posted by @Joel Owens:
Jason Powell's comment:
"buy a number of these houses, let tenants pay the individual mortgages down for you and ultimately pay it off, then live off the cash flow on the back end thanks to the portfolio of properties that you now own outright."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If someone makes 50,000 a year and buys 1 or 2 of these house to hold long term there is not enough cash flow there to replace income.
If rent in the hood was 1,000 a month for a 50,000 house paid cash for and took away half expenses you get 6,000 a year. To equal 50,000 a year plus you would need 9 of these house for 450,000 cash investment.
As someone who owns nearly that many houses altogether in C-D neighborhoods here is how you do it without 450K investment using my own version of BRRR.
1st house purchased with my mother in 2011. Paid 15K, took 25K to rehab. Appraised a year later for 50K. Wells Fargo gave a HELOC for 30K. House currently rented for $900 a month. HELOC payment less than $150 a month. 15K from HELOC loaned to my son to buy 3bdrm 1ba. Most of the rest went to purchase another home for 35K. Less than 5K needed for rehab (needed paint, flooring and a water heater.) It only appraised for what I paid for it a year later but I got a HELOC on it for 21K. Currently it is rented for $825 and I pay less than $90 on the HELOC. I now have three houses but out of money to buy more. That is when I opened a solo401K for which i was eligible by a little consulting work I do on the side. I rolled over my IRAs worth roughly 100K into my solo401K. With half of that money I purchased two houses, one for 30K in a C neighborhood and another for less than 16K for a neighborhood which has now declined a D to an F neighborhood. Not a war zone, but too many empty houses. I put nearly 14K into rehabbing both houses which are now rented Section 8. I get $868 a month on one house and $770 on the other. (HUD gave me 10% over the market value for building a ramp for my disabled tenants.) The remaining 50K in my account? Well, 30K I loaned myself to buy a house which is now my principle residence. (Had trouble convincing Fannie Mae I really intended to live in this house since I owned a bigger one three blocks away.) For that 30K I bought that house free and clear and rented out my old house for $950 a month. (I bought that house for 73K from HUD in 2001 but sadly it is now underwater.) Now I owe my 401K 30K amortized over 15 years at 4.5% interest. That leaves 20K in my 401K which I again loaned myself (amortized over five years.) Meanwhile my son had bought his second house and refinanced his first house and turned it into a rental, so I got my 15K back. Now I had money for another house. This time I found a property with two houses on a piece of land with a combined square footage of over 3200. This was my first and only purchase from a wholesaler. I bought it for 32K. Front house wasn't bad, back house was a mess but I figured I got it for free. I spent probably 18K fixing both up and now get $1500 a month renting both houses to an extended family. My latest property is my condo in California which I purchased for 110K with a conventional mortgage and 20%. Currently it is rented at $950 but my plan is to eventually make it my retirement home.
Bottom line: Total rents on all my properties come to $6783 per month. Mortgage payments come to around $1750 a month. Amount of my own money invested? I figure that comes to maybe 150K altogether. If we subtract the mortgage payments from my rent that still leaves me with about $5000 a month and if we assume that I will only see half of that after taxes, insurance, maintenance all that other stuff, I'm still left with $2500 a month minimum income from 150K investment. Where are you going to get those kinds of returns?