Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Tip Mallick

Tip Mallick has started 3 posts and replied 14 times.

Quote from @Mike Lambert:

@Tip Mallick

You're very welcome and you're correct but have to be careful when talking about "these countries".

For example, I bought multiple properties in Mexico over the years. They all were pre-construction and I wouldn't have it any other way. This is why:

1. Pre-construction are the best deals in that you can buy much cheaper if you buy early enough, which gives you a much higher ROI and give you equity from the get-go. Unlike in Thailand, you get capital gains in Mexico and they can be substantial and quick, depending on the market, specific development, market conditions, ...

2. Pre-construction has been a cornerstone of Mexico's construction industry and economy for decades. It's well organized, tried and tested. American, Canadians and other investors have invested billions of dollars that way for decades and it's only be accelerating over recent years.

3. There's no discrimination against foreign investors in Mexico's law or otherwise. There were fears when the leftist just retired president AMLO came to power a few years back that foreign investors would get hurt but he turned out to be very friendly to us and made Mexico's economy its best ever and one of the best in the world. By the way, the US dollar has crushed most other currencies but it's been itself crushed by the Mexican peso.

4. It's very easy to book a quick flight to Mexico at the taxpayer's expense and go and check on what's going on the ground. Oh and poor you, you might feel compelled to show up at the beach club and have a tequila or two ;).

Also, I understand you're a fellow Canadian. I'm not suggesting that that's what you're doing but I think that us and Americans should be careful not to be condescending about "these" countries, whether we talk about Thailand, Mexico or any other country. Did you see the report on CBC news yesterday about the thousands of empty condos in Canadian cities that were just built and find neither buyers nor renters? What an unmitigated disaster.

Finally, to be fair to Thailand, that construction license situation could happen anywhere and of course it's sad for the buyers/investors involved but I suspect they didn't do proper diligence, in which case they likely have themselves to blame too.

Indeed, the problem is that many people are too lazy too cheap and/or don't have the right knowledge or understanding to do proper due diligence. When people here send me private messages or ask me on a call, one of the many things I'd tell them if they want to buy pre-construction is to check the developer's construction license and that it complies with the zoning rules (and I'll tell them if I know what those are).

You woudn't believe the amount of people that are ready to put a sizeable amount of cash on the table but won't spend the little extras needed to make sure they don't lose it.

If anyone is getting better returns in Mexico and these types of countries, good for them.

Quote from @Mike Lambert:

@Andrew Bosco

Yes, the rule is that foreigners can't own land, which means that, in a condo building, foreigners can't own groundfloor condos. Also, foreigners can't own more than 49% of an entire building. So foreigners can own a condo but normally, they own a share of the land with it but, in Thailand, foreigners don't. Would anyone who know what they're doing want to own a building and having somebody else own the ground? Do you think promoters of Thai real estate to foreigners explain that to unsuspecting potential buyers?

The above rules show that Thai law discriminates against foreigners. Given that, should you ever be involved in a lawsuit in Thailand against Thai individuals or entities, how likely are you to win, even if you're right?

These are huge risks to take just to get an 8 - 12% ROI and no chance at capital gains in my humble opinion. Moreover, is the 8 - 12% ROI calculation made by the developer. That would be typical and I'd always do my own calculations.

As you mentioned, these rules are similar in most Asian countries and that's one reason enough for investors like me to stay away.

Thank you. Navigating Thai law is another issue. I heard about a condo construction that was stopped by the government because they built more floors than approved. Very common in these countries. The developer declared bankruptcy. Sorry for those who invested pre-construction.
Quote from @Andrew Bosco:

I lived over in Thailand for a bit. It's my understanding that you need someone that is local to be a majority owner (for many of the Asian countries). I could be wrong though. I would say to only invest overseas if you enjoy the actual travel to that destination. Otherwise, there are 8-12% ROI deals - you just need the network to tap into them.


 Thank you.

Quote from @Mike Lambert:

@Tip Mallick

I think there is an international forum but not that many people invest internationally here and probably even less in Thailand anyway.

It depends on your objectives (we all have different ones) but didn't you already answer your own question? I invest exclusively overseas as I can get better returns than at home in the right places but I wouldn't touch Thailand with a 10-foot pole, unless it's for lifestyle. The lack of capital gain would already be a huge no no for me but so is the inferior property title (foreigners can't own land in Thailand).

There are so many better ways to make a 10 - 12% ROI, which by the way you're not guaranteed to get (which would be ok if you could get capital gains)! I don't know if you're aware but luxury hotel rooms are often super cheap in that country so I'm not sure how you'd compete and make any decent income. I'd never trust the figures of a promoter and do my own calculations.

Thanks for the insight.  It would be interesting to see other views.

I couldn't find an international forum, so I am posting this here.

Has anyone invested in condos in Thailand? Did you get superior returns than investing in US Real Estate?

From what I gather, the capital appreciation is little to none.
At the moment, I am getting a 7% return from dividend-paying US ETFs with practically little time and effort.

Would you consider investing in condos in Thailand that don't show more than 10 to 12% ROI and I'm talking about ROI as rental income.

Just came across an article. The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) has been declared unconstitutional by the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama. The CTA required information about the beneficial ownership of companies registered to do business in the US starting Jan 1, 2024.

Link to article:

https://www.natlawreview.com/article/us-corporate-transparen...

Post: Market Analysis Charts and Maps

Tip MallickPosted
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 5

@Bryce Muller Would you be able to share the Tableau and Sql files?

Post: Taxes question for LLCs

Tip MallickPosted
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 5
Quote from:

- just curious when do you think a C-Corp would be necessary? 

@Jackie Linne - SM LLCs will report directly on your personal return, some states have additional filings and fees you should look into. Then, if you ever add a partner, it may or may not require a seperate 1065 partnership tax return depending on if you live in a community property state or not. 

@Nate Meeker. I did not say that a C-corp is necessary. A single-member LLC can elect to be taxed as a C-corp. 

There are pros and cons for each entity type, depending on circumstances.

Post: Taxes question for LLCs

Tip MallickPosted
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 5
Quote from @Jackie Linne:

I recently created a Single Member LLC, mainly because I don't have trusted partner(s), so I didn't have a choice.

Is it true that SM LLCs do not have to report federal taxes and all profit/loss activities should be reflected on my personal federal tax return? 

Will this void the liability protection an LLC offers?


You can also elect to be treated as a C Corp. In that case the LLC is a separate legal entity for Federal tax purpose.

C corps are not pass-through entities. The C Corp pays taxes on the profits.

It's true that a single-member LLC is a disregarded entity and you have to report the income and loss in your tax return as well as pay self-employment taxes on the net earnings. Whether you report the income and loss in Sch C or Sch E depends on whether the income is active or passive respectively.

Post: First Post - Landlord friendly states

Tip MallickPosted
  • Posts 14
  • Votes 5
Quote from @Bradley Buxton:

@Tip Mallick

Nevada is a landlord friendly state and with some of the lowest property taxes combined with strong job growth from companies leaving California. I work with investors wanting to invest out of CA but wanting to stay a bit closer to CA due to their jobs, family or other ties to the state.  Check out the Tahoe Reno area we find some solid cash flow properties with all the signs of appreciation. 


 Thank you.