Quote from @V.G Jason: All your bets were on consistent and linear returns it seems right?  

In addition, take a look at the renters themselves - you can't squeeze blood out of a turnip, so if they are essentially judgment proof, then getting the property back in your name and moving on with your life will be your best bet. 

Quote from @Ernesto Galindo-Doucette: Real estate investors usually fall into one of two camps: Appreciation-focused – playing the long game, betting on property values to rise over time.

Counterpoint: The President will name a new Fed Chair in May, who will very likely be dovish.

Silly question here but just to confirm.....if you transfer a property from your name to an LLC does the LLC become the new borrower on the mortgage or does it stay in the individuals name?

I bet it will be a substantial yearly cost. 

Would be your best bet 

That’s the best bet.

Although your name is less likely to be found in the docket if the property is owned by an LLC or another entity.Also, regardless of whether you own the property in your name or as an LLC, the same coverage exclusions will apply in your GL policy.  

I bet they are pounding on this guy hard to.