What are some creative avenues I can take to find off-market properties that would fit this criteria, or good connections I could make to find some of these deals more organically?

So its all organic .. its pretty cool really..  

If your stuff is local you might want to consider managing it yourself for a while (just have some good vendors lines up to help) while you look for a new PM, you might find out how EASY it really is if you are organized and have good systems.

Maybe figure out what you “need” to live on (I have a pretty liberal definition of need: loans/taxes/food/insurance/housing/internet/phones/etc. ) and how much of a safety margin you have on top of that. 

We spend about $300-400 every two weeks on variable expenses (food, gas, household items, etc.)

Perhaps refer the victim to the proper organizations that can help them.  

Where you go to set one up depends on the jurisdiction you choose to organize the LLC in.

Both organizations mandate their members complete ethics training specific to the Codes of each organization. 

I began this approach by: - documenting every task that is done by my company - working with my assistant so she documents in fine detail how each task is conducted - (next step) is to organize the tasks into categories and create a table of contents - (then), Mind Map each task and organize the visual representation into a booklet.

How on earth would we possibly have any idea what your chances for a refund are not knowing what your agreement says or which shyster organization you signed up with?