To find a good title company ask some seasoned and successful investors...not the sloppy investors who are cool with the sloppy title companies.  

Quote from @Maya Jones: This type of thing is like trash companies, you will hear it right away from your tenants if their car is blocked in by snow.

I'd encourage any investors (with positive or negative feedback) to contribute.https://investclearly.com/sponsors/mc-companies

One of the things that sucks in real estate in general is the crappy companies usually charge the same as the good companies.

Could you please recommend a company to take a look at it?

Denver is a great market and there are also several great PM companies here, just sayin! 

We handle everything through the phone, email, and text.

.  Go and call around to other landlords in the area or property management companies and get copies of leases and act as a renter and trying to understand what the requirements are and their best practices.  in our area, it is common to pre-lease 9 to 10 months in advance before the academic year begins and for tenants to pay every utility including water .

My wife spent hours on the phone with Buildium customer service and kept getting bounced around to different people, but eventually ended up on the phone with the 3rd party company Buildium uses to run their backgrounds.

There are a lot of things that need to address for a PM company between compliance with the state, local rent control in a lot of your area you'll be covering, a lot of competition that is in your area, marketing/ads, and so much more.