Nothing quick about getting rich with real estate
A real estate seminar promoter promised to create 1,000 new millionaires, but so far none are in sight. See what happened to his believers.
By MP Dunleavey = http://moneycentral.msn.com/Content/contributors.asp#Dunleavey
Like a lot of people these days, Marjorie Stark wouldn't mind making a little extra cash -- or even a lot of it. So when she attended an information session for Robert Allen's "Creating Wealth Through Real Estate" seminar in New York last year, she was more than willing to pay $2,495 for Allen's intensive three-day course on real estate investment strategies.
Concerned about not having enough to retire on and wanting to pass along some wealth to her kids some day, the 62-year-old New York City educator said to me then: "I am convinced that real estate is the way to go."
I was there that night, too, and I could scarcely resist the mouth-watering idea that those three days could make me rich. As the guy leading the session announced: "We are on a mission to create 1,000 new millionaires in 12 months!"
A year later, Stark isn't any closer to being a millionaire. She hasn't bought any new property nor made any money on real estate -- except for the rental property she owned before and bought "the hard way" (with cash and bank loans). She even admitted that when she saw Robert Allen's newest venture was in vitamin sales, "I thought I was going to puke. I was very disillusioned."
But Stark is undaunted and still believes there are fortunes to be made in real estate. She just enrolled in another seminar at a local college on how to buy distressed and foreclosed properties, she says. "With a full-time job, I'm not sure how I can do it, but, boy, am I itching to go!"
There's something about real estate
Stark is not alone. The National Association of Realtors = http://www.realtor.org/rodesign.nsf/pages/HomePage?OpenDocument doesn't track independent real estate investment seminars or how many people attend them, but their allure springs eternal like the get-rich hopes of those who sign up for these courses.
The odds of winning are not high. Robert Allen's "1,000 new millionaires" never materialized in the last year, for example. Allen operates what's called The Enlightened Millionaire Institute. Its Millionaire Hall of Fame Web site = http://www.millionairehalloffame.com/ lists only 50 millionaires (defined as having generated gains averaging $2.6 million). A spokesman admits not all of them exclusively used the Allen method of real estate investing. (And, in a disclaimer, the site notes, "No information has been verified or authenticated. Results vary. All successes are subject to one's own knowledge and effort.")
Despite all that, the Robert Allen Institute = http://www.robertalleninstitute.com/ still conducts two or three seminars a week in different cities and says it reaches about 1,200 people each month. (That's 1,200 x $2,495 = $2.99 million a month, in case you left your calculator home.)
Allen is just one of dozens of artful salesmen who preach fancy financing, "no money down," flipping properties quickly and numerous other strategies to get rich buying and selling real estate.
And the question all this preaching raises is, do these investment techniques, systems and strategies really work? Can they actually make you rich? After all, would people keep trying it if it couldn't be done? Or are hundreds of thousands of people simply seduced by expert sales pitches and swindled out of hundreds and sometimes thousands of dollars?
Weighing the evidence
Like so many things in life, it depends on whom you talk to. Or whose Web site you believe.
John T. Reed is a real estate investment coach himself, based in Alamo, Calif. He's also a self-appointed watchdog for this industry. He keeps the most exhaustive list I could find = http://www.johntreed.com/Reedgururating.html of dozens of so-called gurus, along with reviews of their techniques, books and other products.
Although Reed's Web site = http://www.johntreed.com/, where you also can buy his various books for $29.95, reads a bit like he has a chip -- a very big chip -- on his shoulder, he was recommended by the National Association of Realtors as a serious investigator in the industry. Not that he's against real estate investment, or some of the reputable folks who teach their own hard-won wisdom. But those have been degraded by "the endless parade of B.S. artists coming into the real-estate-investment-advice field. It is an embarrassment to the good people in the business."
And many people believe his grousing is justified. Norm Bour is the host of "The Real Estate and Finance Hour" on KLSX in Los Angeles, a top talk radio station. He's worked in real estate as a mortgage lender and describes the proliferation of real estate seminars, workshops and scams as "a major pet peeve."
"Case in point: foreclosures," he begins. "Real estate in California has gone berserk in the last few years so people are looking for foreclosures to buy." The idea being you can buy a foreclosure more cheaply than other property and potentially gain a windfall when you sell it.
But, as Bour notes, "You can count on one hand how many actual foreclosure properties there are (for sale). Yet there's no lacking of people who are offering real estate foreclosure lists." One might pay $35 for a list, but it may be peppered with properties in other states. "It's not fraudulent, but it's certainly deceptive."
The shady gray area
Well-known personalities like Robert Allen or Carleton Sheets = https://www.carletonsheets.com/ , who have extensive marketing organizations, are a little different, Bour says. "They offer some very solid basics, but the number of people who can do what they propose is very small -- because they make it sound so much easier than it is."
That's what Josh Kelinson, a freelance advertising consultant in New York, found when he and two friends tried to follow the Sheets method.
The three pals pooled their resources to master what Sheets preached, which is similar to the Allen method: buying property with no money down (or some other creative financing method) and flipping later on for a profit.
One of his pals took the seminar, another bought the 8-CD set, etc. Thus inspired and determined, they tried to buy a building suitable for five apartments in Massachusetts, not far from where they'd all grown up.
Kelinson says the actual experience of trying to buy an income property proved eye-opening. "We spent a ton -- and I mean a ton -- of time on it. There was the approval process, the paperwork, getting lawyers." It took two to three hours a day, not including weekend travel time and unexpected snafus. "I found it impossible to do with a full-time job."
Ultimately, the project bogged down because of a major zoning problem. The building was in an area zoned for three apartments, and the building had been illegally converted into five apartments. The zoning authorities refused to grant an exception to the rules. Then, the building owner refused to return their deposit. The three were out $35,000.
Still, Kelinson doesn't feel misled or duped by the Sheets method, and he and his friends are sure they can make it work with their next deal. "There are a lot of other things out there that are scams, but this definitely can be done," he says.
But investing in real estate is not nearly as easy as it looks, he says. "Make sure you have the time to do it," he advises wannabe investors. "If you don't allocate the time, it probably won't work."
We want the system to work so much
And therein lies the fundamental appeal, and ultimate trouble, of get-rich-quick (GRQ) strategies. "It's the jackpot mentality," says psychologist Patricia Farrell, author of "How to Be Your Own Therapist.= http://shopping.msn.com/search/detail.aspx?pcId=14939&prodId=1987899&ptnrid=18&ptnrdata=1101040329" Just like the schmoe who buys a winning lottery ticket -- every once in a while, someone, somewhere really does use these edgy real estate investment techniques to make millions.
"It's not the principles that are flawed," says Bour. "It's the simplicity and ease that are overstated."
Most of these courses are so seductive, Farrell says, because they operate according to a tried-and-true principle of behavioral psychology called the variable ratio reinforcement schedule. Basically, people (and rats) will persist in doing something, even with little or no return, if they are given the tiniest bit of hope of a coming reward.
So the fact that some people do succeed at "no money down" strategies acts like a financial aphrodisiac for all those watching, waiting, hoping.
So could the Starks and Kelinsons of the world be next? Is it just a matter of reapplying the Robert Allen/Carleton Sheets techniques until they work?
Mark Wilson, one of the millionaires created by the Robert Allen Institute, would say yes. The president of Southeastern Housing Partners in Hickory, N.C., Wilson started investing in real estate in the late 1980s. "We were doing OK, but nothing to write home about."
Then in 2002, after hearing Robert Allen speak, Wilson paid $5,000 to join a one-year intensive coaching course. It changed his life, his business and, above all, his cash flow, he says. Although he'd read Allen's "No Money Down" in college, the seminar focused more on another Allen signature strategy: developing multiple streams of income (from rentals, rehabs, buying foreclosed properties, commercial properties, etc.). Now, Wilson says, he's about to close a deal that will put his net worth at $8.5 million.
He believes anyone can make big bucks from real estate if he or she is willing to take action -- not just sit on the sofa listening to tapes.
Before you sign up, count to a million
Of course, Wilson admits that it was easier for him to take the Robert Allen techniques and run with them. He had a lot of experience in real estate already. Most people, Bour points out, don't have those skills. And few people have the time or the diligence to acquire them. ("Some skill sets you need to have -- and the course can't teach it to you," agrees Kelinson.)
Bob Underwood of Stafford, Va., is one person who can testify to the fact that investing in real estate is not for those steeped in fantasy. Underwood bought an e-book from yet another author and teacher by the name of Joe Crump. http://www.realestatemoneymaker.com/
Crump, who hails from Indianapolis, teaches a no-money-down technique, but he told me that he does it "legally and ethically."
Underwood, 43, has a wife and family and a full-time job -- and no time to muck about in real estate with no return. He paid Crump about $500 for one-on-one coaching in 2002 and, after a rocky start, has managed to buy three properties in the last two years. He's sold one of them, made about $10,000, after taxes, in the process and is hoping to rehab and sell another this year.
One deal Underwood did alone, the next was with a partner. He says there's no cookie-cutter method that works. What works, he says, is getting out into the market, investing the time to learn about the business, not neglecting your wife and kids (or day job), learning from your mistakes, making friends and getting advice from others as you move forward. Slowly, steadily and not particularly wealthily.
"Remember, you have to pay capital gains (taxes)" on the profits, he says, "so it's not a lot of money in the end."
But that, of course, isn't what people want to hear. "People are lead to believe that all you need is the right plan and you'll make a million, that if you use this system you'll be rewarded," says psychologist Farrell. "They don't realize that the possibility of getting that big reward is so remote."
**End of Article**
My thoughts: Learn the trade before you jump - Seeking unbiased direction on Gurus and Courses can be most difficult at best, as it becomes subjective to:
It's based upon if the student liked the teacher or not.
It's based upon if they where successful or not.
It's based upon if the student even had the aptitude to even understand the lessons.
You and only you can make this decision and it's done by research.
I'm not talking posting in forums as you will get so many varied opinions you will never get what you are looking for. I would suggest taking a step back and set in your mind on two or three strategies of real estate investing.
The best way to do this is use the REI forums and search subject matter by reading all post on the subject of interest and evaluate your own abilities and make a determination if you have the ability and means to do it.
Next research your public library on the subject, study the materials, and if it still peaks your interest
Go to a used bookstore and study even more materials on the subject and if it still peaks your interest seek out the teacher that reaches you deep down inside, the one that speaks to your mind and heart but before you take the plunge for the mega course order the cheapest item they have book, ebook or course and if it works take the mega course.
I have people who want to take my mentor course all the time but many can not even get past the application process! I look at it this way - why let them spend their hard-earned money on something they can not do or are simply not ready to do! They loose and I loose! Simply not a WIN - WIN
You need to seek a teacher that can speak to your inner person not just make you feel good, a teacher that has a passion for their students and most importantly a passion for your success.
I do speaking for one Guru who's only passion is the money, not the deals, not to help students but to profit from their lack of education. Many ask why I teach his people? My reply is vary simple because I know that what I teach is sound and if I reach a student and they apply their newfound knowledge they will be a success.
I am not trying to plug me at all so please do not mis-read this.
Education works like this:
The university that I went to had some of the best professors around so I chose the best professor for a subject from his credentials, facility, staff and student recommendations and I failed - he did not reach me so I had to repeat the same class but with another professor with less credentials, not liked well from facility, staff and students but you know what, this guy brought it home for me - his teachings clicked with me and I learned more from this one man than I ever did with most of my professors.
So, let me boil this down!
Finding the correct teacher, guru, course or book is all about trial and error! Welcome to the world of real estate education.
Sheer and Utter Brilliance!
You've really hit the nail on the head with this one! I cannot even tell you how many people I know are frothing at the mouth over real estate, with no concept of what is really required. Its amazing how the infomercials have really taken the hearts and minds of the public. I know real estate is a real way towards wealth, but it is not as easy as it sounds on TV. And it is certainly not as quick as they make it seem.
I'm happy to hear that you mentioned using forums and spending time reading and learning. It is amazing how much I've learned from forums around the net. They are an instrumental tool.
By working slowly and steadily with a definate business plan, everyone can do well in real estate, but I am one who truly believes that that plan is a necessity. Patience is a really important attribute in this field.
Anyway, thanks for writing that. It was great!
Free eBook from BiggerPockets!
Join BiggerPockets and get The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing for FREE - read by more than 100,000 people - AND get exclusive real estate investing tips, tricks and techniques delivered straight to your inbox twice weekly!
- Actionable advice for getting started,
- Discover the 10 Most Lucrative Real Estate Niches,
- Learn how to get started with or without money,
- Explore Real-Life Strategies for Building Wealth,
- And a LOT more.
Sign up below to download the eBook for FREE today!
We hate spam just as much as you
You must be a BiggerPockets member to post on the forums
Join the world's largest, most open Real Estate Investing Community online, 100% free forever!