Updated over 2 years ago on . Most recent reply

Trying to analyse selling of home for purchase of investment property
Hello, looking for guidance on my particular situation.
I have a well done, fully remodelled home in Carlsbad, CA in a very desireable neighborhood. It was my primary residence before I took an overseas assignment and we love the house and neighborhood. I owe $1,100,000. Mortgage (rate is 2.85%), interest, insurance, property management, and hoa is $6500/month. Current rent is $6800, as it was locked in 2 years ago. I think it can raise to $7500-$7800. I've been "soft offered" $2.7m, which is over current valuations. We have been considering not returning to CA due to high costs and taxes. I have another residence in ID that we are planning to move into upon returning from overseas.
I would like to retire in 10 years and am considering selling the house which could produce about $1.4M after realtor fees, then use that to buy ~3ish rental properties cash in an 1031 exchange so I minimize the tax exposure and start producing monthly cashflow that can provide the basis for a retirement in 10 years. Thinking to buy cash to simplify closing everything on time, then refi them later to pull some cash out and add some additional rentals.
Am I thinking through this correctly or missing something significant? CA has always been a strong realestate market, so should I opt for less cash flow, have the option to live in my house, and potentially better appreciation, or should I move on with generating additional cash flow in a different market?
Appreciate any guidance. Thank you to the community.
Most Popular Reply

- Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges
- St. Petersburg, FL
- 9,529
- Votes |
- 9,200
- Posts
@Stinson McElhinney, If you can move in for another half a year in the next year and a half you'll be able to take 250K of profit tax free or $500K if you're married. A much better deal because you can allocate the money whenever and however you want.
But if you have to sell then a 1031 exchange will still allow you to indefinitely defer all tax on profit and depreciation recapture.
And the holy grail would be if you could move in for another half a year. and then back out for a bit and then sell you'll not only get the first $500K tax-free. You can 1031 exchange the remainder. So you'll have some tax free and the rest tax deferred.
- Dave Foster
