HELP! JV financing, partnership or just plain crazy. You decide

HELP! JV financing, partnership or just plain crazy. You decide

Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes

Ok BP universe.I really need help on this one or I'm going to lose my mind.This post is aimed specifically at the people who are very familiar with either JV funding/ Partnerships, private money or all 3.

The names and details have been slightly changed to protect the innocent (and also so I don’t possibly violate my non-disclosure).  I will also will try to be as brief but thorough as possible, but it’s still gonna be long.

Ok, Lets say I have a seller, that’s selling 4 large apartment buildings.The units could use some upgrades, and the occupancies are lower than industry norms because the current owner doesn’t advertise or go out of his way to fill the vacancy once people leave.  He would rather be fishing, and as long as money’s trickling in to put gas in the boat, keep the lights on and buy some food he’s good. He wants to sell and be done with it once and for all. All 4 buildings, all at once, no piece mealing.

His price tag is 3 million cash. NO Owner financing, all cash or nothing.If you were to take the shape of the buildings into account and the surrounding land plus the current and pro-forma rent rolls 2 million to me seems to be a very fair price, and I see where he is coming from. (Viewing it as a seller) .For all the units that need an update, I have the experience, a trained crew and the tools and some capital for said improvements. What normally would be a huge expense for the avg investor, I already have in place. So for me I’m chewing at the bit to get this deal done.

HOWEVER I run it by the loan brokers, and because of actual NOI vs the sale price will only lend up to 50%.I say ok, I'll try private money, private money says essentially the same thing! I try the hard money route and they start talking cap rates are under 8 and if seller comes down 1.5 mil they'll consider doing the deal, but otherwise no too much risk for them.

I’m either just not understanding something, or I’m talking to the wrong people for what I’m trying to do.   If these buildings were fully occupied or even 85%, and even remotely updated. the value would be 10+Million or up.  So what gives?   They can't all be beautiful and fully occupied.  Sometimes we have to pay a little extra to get what we want for a bigger payoff down the road.  Right?  

So WHY can’t I find a private money lender that will take somewhat of a risk. Everyone is telling me to walk away from the deal. Whats keeping me from doing that, is all my smaller past deals that everyone else passed on, I turned around and made a profit on them. So it’s kind of hard for me to walk away, until I know I exhausted everything.

So assuming I can't find a PML or HML, I was going to ask the seller for a partnership. My labor, my capital injection, my running things on a day to day basis. For added incentive, increase the sales price from 3 million to 4M Work my *** off, bring the buildings back to where they should be, dissolve the partnership on year 5 and reli the seller/partner off and cash him out in full.All the partnership details obviously drafted by a partnership / acquisition attorney.

Has anyone done some like this? Pro’s / Con’s.  Am I crazy?  Should I really just push this deal out of my mind?  

Again just so you know where I’m coming from.I have been involved in so many deals in the past that others passed on only for me to swoop in and make money off of it.The sellers were motivated, and it was using my funds. But now I’m at a different tier, so I get the differences.  I just have a gut feeling again that I can turn these around.

Again sorry for the longer than normal post,hoping the universe is kind with bringing me some answers from my fellow BP’ers  Have an excellent day everyone!

0Reply
50 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Investor · Encinitas, CA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
9y
Jonathan Jewell You might want to state the actual NOI! I've gone across apartment buildings that were mismanaged and (based on their asking price --- which should be adjusted for horribly low NOI) that would easily lose money on a 75/25 loan. If I'm a lender I see a property that a.) loses money as-is, b.) takes money to renovate, c.) where will you find that money? d.) rehab dollars aside, how will you handle the carrying costs before the NOI improves, e.) your reserve fund will be based (at a minimum) on 6-9 months of debt service --- which the NOI may not cover. So there are a litany of issues that don't even involve the rehab risk factors that any prudent lender will want to take into account. But I'm no lender, that's just me looking at it from the perspective of what I'd look at if I was going to JV with someone.
See this reply in the discussion

18 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Encinitas, CA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y
    Jonathan Jewell You might want to state the actual NOI! I've gone across apartment buildings that were mismanaged and (based on their asking price --- which should be adjusted for horribly low NOI) that would easily lose money on a 75/25 loan. If I'm a lender I see a property that a.) loses money as-is, b.) takes money to renovate, c.) where will you find that money? d.) rehab dollars aside, how will you handle the carrying costs before the NOI improves, e.) your reserve fund will be based (at a minimum) on 6-9 months of debt service --- which the NOI may not cover. So there are a litany of issues that don't even involve the rehab risk factors that any prudent lender will want to take into account. But I'm no lender, that's just me looking at it from the perspective of what I'd look at if I was going to JV with someone.
  • Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    @Cody L.   I would really, like to hear your input on this.  I know you purchased some deals in past that others turned their noses up and you ended up making bank on those deals.

  • Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    @Andrew Johnson Thank you.  Good points.

  • Santa Rosa, CA · Member since 2017 · 325 posts · 701 votes
    9y

    I have no experience in any of the things you are asking for, but I wanted to throw this out to you to see if it resonates.   Your question was "Why wont they take even a small risk?"   Now put yourself in the lenders shoes

    - If you are successful they get paid + interest

    - if you are unsuccessful they get 3 large under performing apartment buildings they have to deal with.   Not worth it unless they get them for a screaming deal (hence the 50% offers)

    - Your pitch for being successful (at least in this post) is that you have a gut feeling.  You have no experience in turning around apartment buildings.

    - reading between the lines you dont have any capital (or a low amount) to put into the deal (hence the partnership with the seller)

    So I have 3 million dollars to invest.   Do I give it to the guy with a deal and a dream, or to an experienced person with a moderate deal.   Risk...reward.    My risk with you is higher (lack of experience, turnaround, etc) but my reward is the same (principle + interest).   So any logical person would pick the lowest risk for the same reward.   You may be 100% right that you can turn this around, but why would a lender take that chance....they get nothing for taking an increased risk.  

    You need to partner with an experienced syndicator or apartment investor.  Then the risk reward equation changes.   If it turns around, they get more benefit.  And they know how to do it and have credibility with the lender.

    Just a thought.

  • Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    @John Nachtigall  I hear what your saying.  Yes funds are limited at the moment, and just enough for capital improvements, and pay work crews.  But slight risk is why private and money money exists. Right?   Risk is determined on many levels some can stomach it more than others.  If I were a newbie starting out working a 9-5 asking for this money, then yeah I would be viewed and rightfully so as a maximum risk.  But the reality I have a proven track record for turning things around, excellent credit, pay my bills on time, and have an excellent business reputation. I see myself as low risk for this type of deal.  But point taken and feedback appreciated.  I think I should go the partnership route, if the seller balks, then that will be the final nail in the coffin I think

  • Real Estate Investor · Encinitas, CA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @Jonathan Jewell This might be an edge case but you also might not be talking to the right HMLs. I don't know how much capital they have access to or how much you're asking for but the HML that's comfortable doing $100K loans or $300K loans isn't going to be nearly as comfortable doing a $2.5MM loan. They might not have access to that much cash or they might look at it in the context of a portfolio and they just can't afford to have such a high percentage of their capital tied to a single deal.

    But you also haven't said what the NOI on the deal is currently. It's probably not zero of the current owner won't be able to put gas in the boat. But if it's just enough for gas in the boat I have no clue if that means he's making $100/month off of his apartments, $1,000/month, or $10,000 per month. If you looked at it as a standard 25% down deal and you wanted a decent cash-on-cash return (call it 10%) you'd put down $750K, look to make $75K (roughly $6K per month after debt service). So if you bought today, financed the $2.25MM on a 5%, 20 year amortization loan the payment is roughly $15K per moth. With super-quick and highly inaccurate math you'd need to show NOI of $21K per month today ($6K in desire cash-flow and $15K to service the debt). Annualize that and it's $250K NOI, you haven't stated what the NOI for the deal but if all of the HMLs are passing I'm guessing it's nowhere near $250K. Those HMLs might be point to the risk of paying for tomorrow's performance with today's dollar (which is, in this case, their dollar).

  • Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    @Andrew Johnson. Yes I believe I am talking to the wrong folks. A few of them mentioned they max at 1M 2M under special circumstances.  So where do I find the (forgive the pun) bigger pockets!?  I hesitant to put any more financials out there due to the ND but your figure is close. Right now pushing a 6 cap.   

    Im looking at a perspective of buying an existing business. There is cash flow there are assets great location, horrible management thats running it into the ground.  Pay the management to go bye bye, roll up the sleeves and steer the business back to printing money.   I have ready many of the posts and the books in the BP library and theres one story after another of the regrets for not buying a particular deal and later regretting it because someone else took the chance and made it work.  I would like to tell this story in 10 years about the deal that almost got away.  Ya know?

     Btw. Very informative reply. Thank you.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Jonathan Jewell:

    @Cody L.   I would really, like to hear your input on this.  I know you purchased some deals in past that others turned their noses up and you ended up making bank on those deals.

    1) Ask if he'll seller finance it for just 12 months.  That'll give you enough time to fix it, occupy it, time to close with new lender.  If you have enough to put down 30+%, then he should be happy with near $1m in his pocket plus income from your note.  
    I've had people say "No" to seller financing because they didn't quite get what I was offering.  Talk him into it.  Use your charm dude.

    2) Risky, and people in here will say no, but you could offer to put it under contract with a 1 year close date. Tell him you'll stat working on the property using your own money and lease it up. See if you can basically "take over" and manage the property. Tell him you'll pay him per month whatever NOI he's getting now. Then as you fill it you'll get income from the improvements you make. And you'll be in a better position to buy it in 12 months as you have your hands in the property and can supply financials vs asking him for them.

    3) Find a lender with a brain. People buy empty buildings with leverage that have $0 NOI. There is such thing as "distressed properties" and lenders that lend. Your leverage won't be as high but you could always get a crappy low LTV loan and refi as soon as it improves.

    If this were in Houston I'd finance it for you.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Jonathan Jewell:

    @John Nachtigall  I hear what your saying.  Yes funds are limited at the moment, and just enough for capital improvements, and pay work crews.  But slight risk is why private and money money exists. Right?   Risk is determined on many levels some can stomach it more than others.  If I were a newbie starting out working a 9-5 asking for this money, then yeah I would be viewed and rightfully so as a maximum risk.  But the reality I have a proven track record for turning things around, excellent credit, pay my bills on time, and have an excellent business reputation. I see myself as low risk for this type of deal.  But point taken and feedback appreciated.  I think I should go the partnership route, if the seller balks, then that will be the final nail in the coffin I think

     You don't even know how much I feel your pain man.  I've literally said the same thing you just said in my head (and to lenders) 10000x when I was starting out.  It would drive me crazy.  I'd see a SCREAMING deal.  Know I could make a KILLING on it.  But couldn't finance it.  

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Jonathan Jewell:

    @Andrew Johnson. Yes I believe I am talking to the wrong folks. A few of them mentioned they max at 1M 2M under special circumstances.  So where do I find the (forgive the pun) bigger pockets!?  I hesitant to put any more financials out there due to the ND but your figure is close. Right now pushing a 6 cap.   

    Im looking at a perspective of buying an existing business. There is cash flow there are assets great location, horrible management thats running it into the ground.  Pay the management to go bye bye, roll up the sleeves and steer the business back to printing money.   I have ready many of the posts and the books in the BP library and theres one story after another of the regrets for not buying a particular deal and later regretting it because someone else took the chance and made it work.  I would like to tell this story in 10 years about the deal that almost got away.  Ya know?

     Btw. Very informative reply. Thank you.

    Sorry, commenting as I go down the thread. It's a 6 cap TODAY with TODAYS financials? That should be easy to finance. Unless it's in a war zone, 6+ CAPs are hard to find. Well, they're not so hard to find w/o upside but if it's a true 6 CAP with it's current financials AND there is upside, that's a great deal. You'll find someone to get it done.

    Buy this place man!   If you don't get it I'm going to be pissed at you.

  • Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    @Cody L. Brother you have no idea how much I needed to hear that.  And your abandoned building what if was dead on. How many of thoae bldgs have noi? None. Yet they are purchased rehabbed and resold or held and cashed out later. 

    If you know theres a deal and money to be made, take no prisoners and keep moving forward mentality.  Love it. I knew you would get it.  Called selling agent waiting on a call back. I'll share details in update.  

    Thanks my man, I needed that shot in the arm. You have no idea.

  • Real Estate Investor · Encinitas, CA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y
    Jonathan Jewell Whew, okay, so you are pricing/buying on today's performance. I'm not like Cody L. in that I don't think I could stomach a non-producing asset. I'd want to pay for today's performance because it's my risk (and work) that generates the reward. But that's why he has 1,000 units and I haven't cracked 40 🤷🏻‍♂️ I'm always reticent to say a current owner has butchered a property. I mean, I know it happens, but I've heard realtors use it as an excuse when the real reason is the area, condition of the property, etc. Let's face it, I lack vision. From what you're saying it sounds like the HMLs (and I have no idea how to find "bigger" ones) are turning their max loan amounts into your purchase price. Consequently, it doesn't sound like you're getting a pseudo-second-underwriting-opinion. Basically, their objection isn't "6-cap" it's basically their max loan amount. I don't know if there's a delicate way to discern that. I don't know how the heck you find the person but I still think a JV partner is the way to go. Get that second underwriting opinion (it never hurts) and someone who sees a similar vision to you when it comes to the property. From what your saying, there's more than enough spread in the deal.
  • Real Estate Agent · Souderton, PA · Member since 2016 · 591 posts · 414 votes
    9y
    Shot you a PM. Is this deal in PA? Would be happy to talk about some options.
  • Investor · Bensalem, PA · Member since 2011 · 146 posts · 93 votes
    9y

    Good Morning all!  @Andrew Johnson just so you know, I value your input immensely.  I read a lot of your posts and you really do provide some excellent information.  Just wanted to clear the air on that.  @Cody L.  has more of my personality and style of investing.  I'm striving to be at his level in a few short years.  I think we also share the same philosophy.  "If it makes sense, looks good and you know you can do it, then go for it!"  

    When I started my mobile home renovation company everyone, I mean everyone said I was nuts, and laughed.  Get a real job, is what I heard a lot, mostly from family. The only person who actually believed in me was my girlfriend at the time.  Its funny but some of those same people that laughed and called me crazy have asked me for a job.  (Lifes funny that way isnt it)  and all it was, was just an idea.  I didn't have a book, or a teacher, because it was never done before.  (Later I found out about Lonnie Scruggs) ,but my concept was more large scale and re-configuring Trailers to make them look like house's inside.  But it met the criteria (If it makes sense, looks good and you know you can do it then go for it!).  and I knew, I just knew I could make money doing it contrary to what others were telling me.  You should have seen the bankers faces when I tried to get a loan.  LOL,  All I heard was " You do what?"   lol

    So now for the update on current deal:

    I have determined this deal wont work with brokers, or hard/private money of any kind.  I don't like to beg for anything... especially money for a deal, which I found myself doing just that.   If the seller really wants to sell, he will work with me.  So last night I called the listing agent for my last and final offer.   I proposed a mutually beneficial short term partnership.  One which would would make the seller a silent partner of sorts, where I would use my own capital and resources to do fix up/ marketing/ increase occupancy and take over day to day operations.  Make the places and numbers attractive enough for a cashout-refi, dissolve the partnership and seller can eventually cash out.  Simple, clean mutually beneficial.

    If he doesn't go for it that this isn't the deal for me, the universe is telling me to move on, or the seller is up to no good or both.  But thats ok, because as the universe is kind, another deal plopped in my lap last night, and I'm meeting with the listing agent and seller this Sunday.  Best of all its a pocket listing, so maybe this other deal was meant to fall through.  I just don't like giving up when I set my mind to getting something, it actually physically pains me to do so...lol    I'll let ya know what seller says if anything at all.  Thank you :-)

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    9y

    Keep me in the loop if you don't mind.  my first name at my company .com

  • Lender · Lake Park, GA · Member since 2016 · 37 posts · 10 votes
    9y

    I'm a broker, BUT, to get in with little money, you could contract for a master lease until you've brought the property up to snuff and can get the loan done, but I hope you would bring it to me at RLT Private Capital, LLC when you're ready to go all in down the road.

  • Real Estate Agent · Souderton, PA · Member since 2016 · 591 posts · 414 votes
    9y
    I'd be interested in partnering with the cash if it would help you get it done. Let me know.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.