Just curious really. Once you determined you want to buy the property and have an idea of it's real worth, how much under will you offer just to see if they will take it? How successful have you been with it?
Do you often counter offer if they refuse or stick to your guns and see if they come crawling back?
We don't low-ball much either. Once we know our max buying price, we just offer enough below it to leave some room for negotiation (counteroffers, etc.).
For my market it depends on the area, DOM, and my buying formula for the property. I tried the low-balling approach when I first started and get zero offers accepted. In my farm area the average REO discount if any, is around 1%-3%.
We don't low-ball much either. Once we know our max buying price, we just offer enough below it to leave some room for negotiation (counteroffers, etc.).
It really depends on who the seller is (REO or private party), what their goal is (most money or trying to solve another problem), high much above your target price the property is listed at, how badly you want the property, how much competition there likely is, how desperate the seller likely is, etc.
I've had properties where I've made offers at 60% of list price knowing that I'd get a counter-offer and eventually close the deal; and then there were other properties where I knew if I offered anything less than 10% above list price, there is no way I'd ever have an opportunity to acquire the property (and so I did that).
Without a LOT more information, it's impossible to answer this question in a general form...
Btw, I wouldn't recommend ever trying to get the other party to "come crawling back." When a negotiation stalls, it takes a very good negotiator to realize that reopening discussions is often the best move, and there is absolutely no shame in coming back (or having the other party come back) and say, "Let's try this again..."
This thread reminded me of a quote which I believe is an excellent one.
J. Paul Getty:
My father said: "You must never try to make all the money that's in a deal. Let the other fellow make some money too, because if you have a reputation for always making all the money, you won't have many deals.
We buy most of our homes from hud so we always start at 80 to 85 percent of what they are asking with out closing. We also work with a local bank in the rural part of town. They will sometime give us a call about a property in the city that they have taken back. Price is a little higher, but they will get the property rent ready before we buy. It is a case by case situation.
I mostly bid on REO's. I go in with numbers that work for me. I look at my costs and how much I want to make and most of the time I put in my best offer right of the bat.
If there is a property that I am not too interested in, then I will throw in a low-ball offer to make it worthwhile to me. However, never been able to get one of those yet.