I'm going to start doing buy/rehab/sell deals with a money partner. We'll be 50/50 profits and losses. The purchase and rehab will be funded 100% from his money. I will be doing all of the finding and project management.
1) I'm trying to figure out the best way to make cash offers that require proof of funds and earnest money checks without having a joint bank account. I'll be making a lot of offers.
I don't think that we want to form a new joint entity yet. We want to keep it simple and inexpensive for now to do business together. He trusts me enough to just have a joint account, but I'm a bit uncomfortable that it doesn't offer him any protection.
Should I just put both our businesses on the offer and the proof of funds would just be from his business?
2) I also need to figure out what the best way is for me to handle all of the financial transactions on the ground of the rehab projects. e.g. buying supplies, paying contractors and misc expenses.
Thanks for your input.
Ian
i took a hiatus and getting back into the business now. However unlike you i will be funding the rehab and i intend to have my partner fund the purchase( i will pay him a fixed return on his investment, ~ 8%), way better than he is getting on a CD or REIT dividend. I just dissolved my investment company so we will be doing this in our names for at least the next year, will change if we pick up the pace.
I don't think that we want to form a new joint entity yet. We want to keep it simple and inexpensive for now to do business together. He trusts me enough to just have a joint account, but I'm a bit uncomfortable that it doesn't offer him any protection.
Should I just put both our businesses on the offer and the proof of funds would just be from his business?
Your suggestion might work but the problem is that you probably don't want to put down a name of a buyer (entity wise) on an offer unless you plan on buying the property in that name. Particularly if it's a listed property as your offer is in the form of a purchase and sale contract executed by the buyer. Hence unless you want the 2 businesses on the deed and other paperwork when you buy the property, I would go with another solution.
I would go ahead and fork over the few dollars for an LLC formation (or something similar - I am NOT an attorney or CPA so please consult one). It cost $135-150 to form one here in NJ. Then stipulate in the LLC's operating agreement who is putting in what money (I think it's referred to as 'Capital contribution' in the OA). You can also stipulate in the paperwork at the bank that only your partner can withdraw money or that both of you have to sign in order to withdraw funds.
I think you have to demonstrate some level of seriousness and form an LLC if you're going to be putting in offers. It's a $200 investment for a venture that will hopefully be dealing with hundreds of thousands of dollars. Personally I'd form the entity now.
Maybe it's late but how does your post help the OP or relate to his situation Des N?
Thank you Ibrahim S.
To clarify, my comment about keeping things simple and inexpensive for now was not so much about the cost of forming another LLC with his LLC and mine listed as managers. It was more about the increased complexity and addition attorney and accountant cost for the additional layer of business. you're right though even if it cost us $2000 for everything, it's not that big of a deal considering the amount of money we'll be working with.
My original intent was to for such an entity, with the operating agreement listing him as making the capital contribution. The rub for me came with the bank account and both of us having access to the funds. He is out of state. A double signature account does absolutely zero to protect one person against the other person forging signature, vacuuming the account and flying to a third world country. My Partner has total trust in me and is down for what ever, but I guess I'm operating on a matter of principle that I wanted him to be as protected as possible.
I'm not clear on you comment regarding not putting a name of a buyer on an offer unless we planned on purchasing the property in that name. what other name would one put on an offer? Can you offer an example scenario?
1) If both of our LLC's were on the offer, then we would both be buying, and both be deeded. What's the drawback of having two businesses on a deed? Is it unlike having two individuals on a deed?
2) If we buy under a joint entity, then we are both essentially deeded on the property anyway. Is this different in some way?
Ian
Ian Clayton,
You want to consider that you need to be sure that you both trust one another.
Also feel free to ask if you have any tax or structure questions.
-Steven
Thank you Steve.
Our trust for each other is total and complete.
Considering that he will be putting all the money in from out of state and I am going to be the face of the deals and handling prject management.....
From your perspective, should we be doing these types of transactions as two entities co-buying and co-selling or as one entity with one bank account?
Thanks.
I have done quite a few deals with money partners, where I did the rehab and someone else funded the project.
Couple structures I have used that are pretty simple, the key is that there is a high level of trust among the partners and there is a basic agreement written up. Mine are always a one page ducument written in plain english. Sometimes written by me sometimes by an attorney depending on the partner relationship.
My typical deal.
Offers are written in my name, property is deeded in my name (now my llc name) I use my checking account for all purchases (except the property).
My "partner" provides the proof of funds letter that I submit with my offers. My "partner" funds the deal and brings the money to closing just like a bank would.
My "partner" then gives me the rehab money, or gives me money in draws depending on our agreement.
.... that one postyed before I was quite done.
I then track all my reciepts in an excell spreadsheet. In the beginning with a couple guys I sent them weekly spreadsheet with all the exenses to date. That gives a "partner" a comfort level initially that you8 are on top of things and tracking your expenses well.
When the property sells we do a final analysis of profits and funds are split based on our agreement.
The "partner" gets a mortgage against the property and is named as an additionial insured to protect his interest.
... have a crew showing up ... ill run a couple other scenarios later
hope that helps
Hey Ian,
You may be able to accomplish this with the following:
1. Proof of funds from your partner;
2. Letter from your partner indicating that you're partnering and the money is available for the purchase of the property (perhaps provide a JV agreement between you guys).
Most sellers (including banks) are reasonable if they don't believe there is anything funny going on, and I think you should be able to convince them that's the case.
On another note, I think you left me a voice mail several months back. Around the same time, my phone got dropped in a toilet and I got a new carrier (and lost my messages). Sorry I didn't return your call (didn't have your number) -- feel free to give me a call again if you still want to chat!
Dell Schlabach Thank you very much for you input. Very helpful.
Can you clarity a few things?
How is your partner protected if the property is deeded in your name? Is it something in the agreement?
You've never had trouble having cash offers accepted with POF not being in your business name?
Thanks.
J Scott ... Yep, I let you a message, sorry to hear about the phone thing, that stinks. No pun intented, hahaha.
Thank you for your suggestions.
I"m trying to build a step by step process for how to handle each step of the process with an out of state partner, while providing as much protection for him as possible.
I'll pm you about talking.
Ian
When my account is short on funds, I submit offers as cash/private money and I show my account statement and my private lenders account (with a letter stating they are lending to me). Its not as strong as an all cash offer, but I rarely get push back on it. A strong earnest with little contingency helps as well.
The partner is protected via a first mortgage.
And no I haven't had any problems getting offers accepted with a "partners" proof of funds.
You’re wise Ian Clayton, to be concerned about protection. I’ve flipped properties out of town with a partner and was careful not to share ownership or a bank account. Of course, you never want to do business with someone you don’t trust, but this is not about trust. It’s about the prudent financial controls you seem to sense.
I worked with an agent/flipper in Cincinnati several years ago. We agreed he would find the properties and manage his contractors. It was very informal. I owned the homes outright in my name and I paid all the bills. We got along great. He would make a percent of the profit and represent the sale… until he was killed in a car accident. It was a long and painful story, but I came out financially whole -- barely.
I can’t imagine what would have happened if we held title jointly in any form. His family would have likely gained a windfall and/or we’d be locked in lawsuits about responsibilities and ownership.
Similarly, there was never any need for him to pay anyone or have access to any money. That was my job. He would email me the invoices, lien releases, an occasional photograph, and I would send him checks to distribute.
You never want either party in any kind of tempting or compromising position and you both want to be able to walk away cleanly if things don’t work out. In my view, sharing ownership in a property that one partner buys is dangerous and without any practical benefit. Same for sharing a bank account. Do your job and let your partner do his.
Jeff
Dell - I guess I've been too hung up on my offers being clearly cash offers with no letters of commitment or anything in order to make them as strong as possible. Maybe I should try to submit the offers with LOC from private lender and see how they do.
Jeff - Thank you for your input. Based on what I am hearing from you, your points seem to suggest that I make offers in the name of my business with LOC and POF from private money and purchased properties are deeded in my business's name only, with the money guy holding primary lien. Then I manage the project and sale. Proceeds of the sale would satisfy his lien first and the remainder distributed to us based on the terms of our agreement.
This leaves two unresolved challenges for me.
1) I want to be fast and nimble on the ground with buying materials , paying contractors and misc expenses. How do I do that with his money in his account?
a) I could use my cash and submit for reimbursement checks frequently. But this would significantly complicate our bookkeeping.
2) I want to keep closings in and out of the deal as inexpensive, simple and quick as possible. All of these get messier when there are lien holders involved.
Thanks.
Ian
I think you misunderstood me, Ian. Your partner would bring the property and money to the table and you would bring the subs and your management skills. Even if you are finding and vetting the homes, your money partner would make the offers in his name or entity and hold 100% of the ownership. He would also provide whatever proof-of-funds are customary in your area to close a deal.
At minimum, you should have a partnership agreement between the two of you and you’ll need a real estate lawyer for this. He'll likely discuss entities with the two of you as well. Talk to your CPA.
Don’t do either. Wells Fargo’s “Direct Pay” will enable your partner to transfer money to you in 24 hours once you have your accounts setup. Check it out but also see what other banks offer.
Don’t go into this thinking that working with an out of town money partner will be as easy as working with someone local, Ian. Your systems will have to be more flexible. Also, don’t try to make this so simple or inexpensive that you compromise all financial controls or expose yourself or your partner to unnecessary liabilities.
Jeff
Thank you again Jeff S.
I very well expect that doing business with a money partner who is out of state will be more complex than than doing them with my own cash or with a local partner.
When I'm saying that I want things to be as simple quick and easy as possible, I guess I mean that as no more complex or cumbersome than they need to be.
I have a top shelf REI focused accountant and great RE attorney also and full well intend to use them both generously in this situation.
It's really funny, I started out months ago thinking exactly what you just said about my partner buying the property and retaining 100% ownership of it and I wound up trying to think about all these other ways of doing it because he doesn't want anything to do with the deal process.
He's not always very accessible, so moving quickly might be challenging.
I have to figure out how to make frequent offers and counters on his behalf.
I have done several JV deals and here are my thoughts.
First off, if you each have your own entities, and each of your entities will be on title, then you each open your property up to liability issues today and in the future so that must be protected.
Second, if one party has the money (and the POF), then he should be on the vesting of the offers to not toss out any red flags to the seller. It is hard enough getting the deal, don't make it harder.
Funding the ongoing rehab and holding costs can be done by whomever sends in funds and is reimburesed by the JV, of course you will need a JV agreement for all of this.
Since you have not made any offers yet and are talking about future here, I would strongly suggest the following:
Form the entity (if an LLC, and you plan to flip, then elect S-corp taxation elections) with each of you as partners. The operating agreement should spell out each of your duties and responsibilities, both financially and managerial as well as all the legal like if someone dies, if someone commits fraud, etc.. Then of course for each property you will want adequate insurance coverage including a liability policy.
It is a small price to pay to do business right and safe. Don't skimp and this includes having your operating agreement written by an attorney.
He's not always very accessible, so moving quickly might be challenging.
Now I see why you’re jumping through the small hoops, Ian. To me, these are red flags – especially his limited accessibility. It sounds like your partner really wants to be so hands-off he might be better off in a RE syndication or some other more passive investment. You, on the other hand, are taking risks that a 50/50 split might not pay you for.
While I admire your initiative and determination to do a deal, I fear you’re trying to drive a square peg into a round hole. At some point, you might consider just borrowing the money and doing this alone.
Borrowing, in place of 50/50 partnering, would generally be in your financial interest as a rehabber. The risks are greater, but you seem to be taking these anyway.
Good luck.
Jeff S is correct that you need to see a an accountant and be sure you understand record keeping requirements and such to be sure you are preparing a correct tax return.
You need a partnership agreement.
As far as tax elections go, depending upon your full situation you could have a wide range of situations that make the most sense.
Ian Clayton, Remember that once you bring your accountant and your lawyer into the equation they become the accountant and lawyer of the business.
Will Barnard, be careful about tax advice, as the S-election may not be the best scenario for the OP. Otherwise you are right on.
-Steven
-Steven
Legal Disclaimer: I am not a CPA or attorney and my posts in this thread are not to be construed as legal or tax advice, they are based solely on my experience and opinion.