Hello everyone,
I own two properties in Tennessee. The first property is a condo, and my wife and I own 90% of it, and my brother-in-law owns 10%. The condo was purchased March 2019. We lived there until September 2021. In September 2021, my wife and I moved overseas and, we are still living abroad. My brother-in-law has remained living in the condo the entire time (not sure if this is important). I need to know if we would receive a tax break if we sold the condo before the end of this year. Our intention would be to roll the money from that sale directly into our second-home property. I recently discovered the 2 out of 5 year rule where you must live in the property for two out of the last five years in order to get a tax break. I would like to speak to a tax professional regarding this situation in Tennessee. Our primary address according to our 2021 tax return is the property in question (even though we technically moved in September 2021). Has anyone done this before?
Thanks!
-Alex
Hi Alex,
You're correct about the 2 out of 5 year rule. Since you and your wife lived in the condo until September 2021, you can sell it and potentially exclude up to $500,000 in capital gains (as a couple) if sold before September 2024. Your brother-in-law’s 10% ownership won’t affect your ability to claim this exclusion on your portion.
Unfortunately, the option to roll proceeds into another property (like a 1031 exchange) only applies to investment properties, not personal residences.
You’re likely eligible for the exclusion, but I recommend confirming with a Tennessee tax professional for any specific state tax issues and to verify your status with overseas residency.
Let me know if you need more guidance on this or related financing!
Best,
Drago
Hi Alex,
You're correct about the 2 out of 5 year rule. Since you and your wife lived in the condo until September 2021, you can sell it and potentially exclude up to $500,000 in capital gains (as a couple) if sold before September 2024. Your brother-in-law’s 10% ownership won’t affect your ability to claim this exclusion on your portion.
Unfortunately, the option to roll proceeds into another property (like a 1031 exchange) only applies to investment properties, not personal residences.
You’re likely eligible for the exclusion, but I recommend confirming with a Tennessee tax professional for any specific state tax issues and to verify your status with overseas residency.
Let me know if you need more guidance on this or related financing!
Best,
Drago
Hi Alex,
You're correct about the 2 out of 5 year rule. Since you and your wife lived in the condo until September 2021, you can sell it and potentially exclude up to $500,000 in capital gains (as a couple) if sold before September 2024. Your brother-in-law’s 10% ownership won’t affect your ability to claim this exclusion on your portion.
Unfortunately, the option to roll proceeds into another property (like a 1031 exchange) only applies to investment properties, not personal residences.
You’re likely eligible for the exclusion, but I recommend confirming with a Tennessee tax professional for any specific state tax issues and to verify your status with overseas residency.
Let me know if you need more guidance on this or related financing!
Best,
Drago
Hello everyone,
I own two properties in Tennessee. The first property is a condo, and my wife and I own 90% of it, and my brother-in-law owns 10%. The condo was purchased March 2019. We lived there until September 2021. In September 2021, my wife and I moved overseas and, we are still living abroad. My brother-in-law has remained living in the condo the entire time (not sure if this is important). I need to know if we would receive a tax break if we sold the condo before the end of this year. Our intention would be to roll the money from that sale directly into our second-home property. I recently discovered the 2 out of 5 year rule where you must live in the property for two out of the last five years in order to get a tax break. I would like to speak to a tax professional regarding this situation in Tennessee. Our primary address according to our 2021 tax return is the property in question (even though we technically moved in September 2021). Has anyone done this before?
Thanks!
-Alex
Hello everyone,
I own two properties in Tennessee. The first property is a condo, and my wife and I own 90% of it, and my brother-in-law owns 10%. The condo was purchased March 2019. We lived there until September 2021. In September 2021, my wife and I moved overseas and, we are still living abroad. My brother-in-law has remained living in the condo the entire time (not sure if this is important). I need to know if we would receive a tax break if we sold the condo before the end of this year. Our intention would be to roll the money from that sale directly into our second-home property. I recently discovered the 2 out of 5 year rule where you must live in the property for two out of the last five years in order to get a tax break. I would like to speak to a tax professional regarding this situation in Tennessee. Our primary address according to our 2021 tax return is the property in question (even though we technically moved in September 2021). Has anyone done this before?
Thanks!
-Alex
@Alex Boulger while I've never done this personally (yet) I don't see anything that will disqualify you as long as you meet the 2 of 5 year criteria for Federal purposes. From my topical research, Tennessee doesn't levy any state income taxes at all, so, acknowledging that I don't have all of the information, you may owe no state income tax.
Also, I would like to clarify that failure to qualify to a 1031 exchange would be irrelevant to you if you qualify for the 2 of 5 year exclusion.
While not in TN specifically, I have assisted clients do as you have described: live in a property as a principal residence for 2 years, rent it out for 3 years, then sell.
Based on the situation described, you would appear to be eligible for the MFJ joint exclusion on principle residence on your 90% share.
However, in order to retain that ability, the house will very likely need to be sold (ie, sale closed, not just under contract) by the end of this month.
The two years of residence would tick back from when you lived in the home, which concluded in Sept 2021.
The other piece to keep in mind, and again, I don't know where abroad you are living, but I would also consult a tax accountant familiar with the tax laws of that country, and the US tax treaty with that country, to confirm a gain wouldn't be inadvertently triggered for your country of residence.
Usually treaties tax the sale of real estate to the country in which the property is located, so there likely won't be an issue, but it's always a good idea to confirm.
@Alexi Galica-Cohen
Thank you for your advice! I know we are cutting it very close on the 2 out of 5 year. It’s basically impossible for us to sell it before the end of September (5 days), but do you know if we could still qualify if we sell it before December 2024 since our permanent residence for our 2021 tax returns was the address in question. I’m not trying to break the rules! I’m just trying to figure out what is allowed!
@Drago Stanimirovic
I’m not trying to purchase another property, I’m trying to use the profits from the sale to pay the remaining balance of my loan off for my second investment property. I guess what I do with the money is not relevant in this case. I thought maybe there is something similar to an exchange for this.
I’m still not entirely sure if I am too late to qualify for the 2 out of 5 rule because I would only be able to sell by the end of the year realistically, not September when I moved. So I’m not sure if I’d even get this tax break. I may have to look for other alternatives. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Hello everyone,
I own two properties in Tennessee. The first property is a condo, and my wife and I own 90% of it, and my brother-in-law owns 10%. The condo was purchased March 2019. We lived there until September 2021. In September 2021, my wife and I moved overseas and, we are still living abroad. My brother-in-law has remained living in the condo the entire time (not sure if this is important). I need to know if we would receive a tax break if we sold the condo before the end of this year. Our intention would be to roll the money from that sale directly into our second-home property. I recently discovered the 2 out of 5 year rule where you must live in the property for two out of the last five years in order to get a tax break. I would like to speak to a tax professional regarding this situation in Tennessee. Our primary address according to our 2021 tax return is the property in question (even though we technically moved in September 2021). Has anyone done this before?
Thanks!
-Alex
@Alex Boulger
Glad to help!
For a sale before the end of the year, I would recommend running that by the accountant you would be working with for your 2024 return.
Most will likely stick to the technical limit of Sept 2021 when it ceased being a primary residence, but some may be comfortable going by the address on the 2021 return and others may explore a partial exclusion, depending on the reasons for your move abroad.
If you'd like to read up on the technical rules, the IRS publication 523 gets into more detail than most people would like to know, but it does have some helpful tables and examples for different scenarios.
@Alexi Galica-Cohen
Ok well since it looks like we are unlikely to qualify for the 2 out of 5 rule, since selling in September is impossible, do you have any recommendations that would help reduce the tax burden for the sale of the property? Something that maybe we can do to offset the amount.
We don’t make any active income in the US, only passive. So our income bracket is already very low. But with a potential 200k profit from the sale, what is the potential taxes we’d owe? Since TN has no state income taxes, it would only be Federal.
Well, this is where the classic tax answer of "it depends" comes into play.
This could be a good opportunity for loss harvesting, if you have underperforming assets in your portfolio.
This could also be a good opportunity for that 1031 exchange mentioned in your original post (since it doesn't sound like the timing may be 100% for the primary residence exclusion), but only if you want to acquire a similar rental/investment property. There are also very stringent timing requirements and receipts of the proceeds from the sale around 1031's.
So if this is the route you'd like to go, please consult whomever you would be using for your 2024 tax preparation. Most firms can recommend a qualified intermediary for the 1031.
As for potential taxes, without knowing the full picture, I can't really speak to it.
The house would be considered a capital asset, so to be conservative, I would estimate 20% of the gain for tax, plus an additional 3.8% for the net investment income tax if your total adjusted gross income (worldwide) is over 250k.
@Drago Stanimirovic
I’m not trying to purchase another property, I’m trying to use the profits from the sale to pay the remaining balance of my loan off for my second investment property. I guess what I do with the money is not relevant in this case. I thought maybe there is something similar to an exchange for this.
I’m still not entirely sure if I am too late to qualify for the 2 out of 5 rule because I would only be able to sell by the end of the year realistically, not September when I moved. So I’m not sure if I’d even get this tax break. I may have to look for other alternatives. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Hi Alex,
You're right that what you do with the sale profits (like paying off another loan) doesn’t impact your capital gains tax treatment. Unfortunately, there’s no direct equivalent to a 1031 exchange for using sale proceeds to pay off another property.
Regarding the 2 out of 5 year rule, it allows you to exclude up to $250,000 (or $500,000 for married couples) of capital gains on the sale of your primary residence if you've lived there for at least two of the last five years. If you moved in September and sell by year-end, you may still qualify, but timing is tight. If you hit the two-year mark before selling, you should be eligible for the exclusion.
If you don’t meet the two-year requirement, you could look into partial exclusion for certain circumstances, such as job relocation or health reasons. Consulting with a tax advisor is your best move here, as they can assess your specific situation and explore all possible tax-saving options.
Let me know if you need further clarification or financing advice!
Best,
Drago
Hi Alex - The law is clear and you have to complete 2 years of stay and 5 years of ownership.
Although you moved overseas in September 2021, the IRS still considers your primary address based on where you lived. Since your primary address was the condo as of your last tax return, you could argue that you maintained a primary residence there, even while living abroad.
In case if you don't complete the desired period, I guess you will be able to claim partial exclusion as from your question I understand that you left the residence due to employment purpose.
@Alex Boulger Yes, the 2 out of 5 year rule could help you avoid paying capital gains taxes on the sale of your condo. Since you and your wife lived in the property from March 2019 to September 2021, you meet the requirement of living there for at least two out of the last five years before the sale, as long as you sell before September 2024. This would allow you to exclude up to $500,000 in capital gains as a married couple filing jointly, or $250,000 if filing individually.
Since your brother-in-law owns 10%, that portion of the sale might not qualify for the exclusion, and you'd need to discuss the tax impact with him.
This post does not create a CPA-Client relationship. The information contained in this post is not to be relied upon. Readers should seek professional advice.