I'm sure you've seen me post about this before, but don't be afraid to go non-local. You will expose yourself to a wider pool of expertise which is critical for real estate investors.
Many of us service clients all over the US and even world. We utilize various forms of technology to collaborate seamlessly with our clients and rarely have issues.
If you are set on using someone local, search the BP forums for investors local to you and reach out to ask for a referral. Or join a local FaceBook/ REIA group.
Just following up on your above post...recently moved to Bucks county Pennsylvania and i am in search for a CPA familiar with real estate as well. I am open to exploring non local options but was wondering how things worked out with the person you found.
as a member of DIG, there are a few accountants that are involved with DIG and as such have real estate investor clients. Ray Minich and John Hepner are just two such accountants (both are in Bucks County or really close), and there are others.