Off-Market Opportunity – Seminole Heights, Tampa, FL

[Brody Algier]

This 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-family home offers a newer construction option in one of Tampa’s hottest historic neighborhoods. Built in 1997, the property sits on a 5,605 sq ft lot and features 1,404 sq ft of living space. It’s surrounded by early-1900s homes, providing a strong value position for investors seeking a modern layout in a high-demand area.

Delivered vacant at closing. The roof was replaced in 2016. The structure appears sound with no reported foundation or major system issues. Property requires a moderate+ rehab to reach full market potential — including full interior cosmetic renovation, kitchen and bath modernization, flooring, paint, fixtures, and exterior updates for curb appeal.

Comparable renovated homes in Seminole Heights trade between $290–$330 per sq ft, supporting an ARV in the $410,000–$460,000 range.

Asking Price: $289,000
Projected ARV: $410,000–$460,000



Rehab Scope:

Full cosmetic overhaul — kitchen and bath modernization, new flooring, paint, fixtures, and curb appeal upgrades. Systems appear serviceable with no known major structural issues.



Comparable Sales – Seminole Heights

204 W Fern St (2005 | 1,563 sf) – $499,900 ($320/sf) Updated

918 W Knollwood St (2003 | 1,564 sf) – $460,000 ($294/sf) Updated

213 W Jean St (1920 | 1,087 sf) – $344,500 ($317/sf) Updated

101 W Fern St (1924 | 1,144 sf) – $369,900 ($323/sf) Updated

206 W Minnehaha St (1928 | 1,140 sf) – $415,000 ($364/sf) Updated