Dealing with a tenant that does not want to pay rent increase in New Jersey

Dealing with a tenant that does not want to pay rent increase in New Jersey

Member since 2025 · 16 posts · 7 votes

I inherited a tenant who was paying $1000 a month which is way below the SAFMR market rate of $2300 for a 2 bedroom Apartment. I offered them a new lease at $1500 a month and the tenant informed me that he would be leaving at the end of the lease. Two months later he has changed his mind and wants to stay until the end of August. They did not want to sign anything so we verbally agreed to this. The day before rent was due they called me to explain that they will not pay more than $1200.From my research the rent increase is conscionable as it is still way below the market rate so the increase is justified.
I'm not sure if I should just take the $1200 and hope they leave at the end of August or if I should start the eviction proceedings. I have already served them with a notice to quit and provided a 60 day notice. Should I start the eviction proceedings? 
 

3Reply
131 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · The Vampire State · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
1y

I'm not familiar with NJ law, but I would move on and issue a notice of non-renewal in writing, and properly served.    Inherited tenants very seldom work out, and he is so far below market that he has "what's fair" anchored at the old rent.  Raising rent will just piss him off and embitter him (sounds like that has already happened).

Hire a lawyer and rip off the band-aid with an eviction if he stays a day longer than the lease.  The money you spend on this now will repay you many times over when you look back on this in a year.  The longer it takes to disentangle yourself from this party, the less profitable and enjoyable this stabilization will be.  He will do everything to hold on to this sweetheart deal and tell you anything you want to hear to delay the inevitable.

Everyone is free to run their business how they wish, but that's what I would do.

See this reply in the discussion

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · The Vampire State · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1y

    I'm not familiar with NJ law, but I would move on and issue a notice of non-renewal in writing, and properly served.    Inherited tenants very seldom work out, and he is so far below market that he has "what's fair" anchored at the old rent.  Raising rent will just piss him off and embitter him (sounds like that has already happened).

    Hire a lawyer and rip off the band-aid with an eviction if he stays a day longer than the lease.  The money you spend on this now will repay you many times over when you look back on this in a year.  The longer it takes to disentangle yourself from this party, the less profitable and enjoyable this stabilization will be.  He will do everything to hold on to this sweetheart deal and tell you anything you want to hear to delay the inevitable.

    Everyone is free to run their business how they wish, but that's what I would do.

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    1y

    I agree with Wes.  I'd let the tenant know, so they have the option of moving out now before you start with the eviction and start that process ASAP.

  • Investor · Costa Mesa, CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Lot's of lessons here. NEVER have a verbal leasing agreement. If tenant won't sign a lease they need to go. Set a fair rent and don't negotiate. If you struggle with any that, use a PM.

    • Member since 2025 · 16 posts · 7 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Eric Gerakos:

      Lot's of lessons here. NEVER have a verbal leasing agreement. If tenant won't sign a lease they need to go. Set a fair rent and don't negotiate. If you struggle with any that, use a PM.


       Yes this is true, the verbal agreement was 2 months ago. Lease expired yesterday and that when I went to go give them the new two month lease and was handed a check for less than the agreed upon amount. I gave them several copies of the new lease over 2 months ago with the new rate.

    • Mark F.Pro Member
      Rental Property Investor · Northern NJ · Member since 2019 · 673 posts · 678 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Michael Carlson:
      Quote from @Eric Gerakos:

      Lot's of lessons here. NEVER have a verbal leasing agreement. If tenant won't sign a lease they need to go. Set a fair rent and don't negotiate. If you struggle with any that, use a PM.


       Yes this is true, the verbal agreement was 2 months ago. Lease expired yesterday and that when I went to go give them the new two month lease and was handed a check for less than the agreed upon amount. I gave them several copies of the new lease over 2 months ago with the new rate.


       The most important part of your post is missing and that is where in New Jersey are you? A number of towns have their own rent ordinances which dictate how much you can increase rent. A judge could easily say $500 a month raise is not reasonable and rule against you. Either way, you need to read this and hire a lawyer. And never do verbal agreements. At bare minimum do it over email or text so there is record of it.

      https://www.nj.gov/dca/codes/publications/pdf_lti/t_i_r.pdf

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2013 · 120 posts · 77 votes
    1y

    I agree with the other posters move expeditiously to have him removed and now he can go out and see where he can live with $1200 a month in Nj.

  • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    PUT IT IN WRITING! Learn from your first mistake and do not let the tenant take advantage of the situation. Stick to what if fair for you. If that means letting them stay until Aug then do that. Not sure where you are but typically, summer is the busiest season to acquire tenants, and you may want get them out sooner than later.

  • Shawn McenteerBusiness Member
    Realtor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Hi @Michael Carlson are you owner occupying the property?  What City is this in? Do you have proof  60 day notice was given?  Typically best to send by mail and require a signature to receive, other wise tenant can easily say they did not receive notice.  

    House Hacking New Jersey561 Reviews
    • Member since 2025 · 16 posts · 7 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Shawn Mcenteer:

      Hi @Michael Carlson are you owner occupying the property?  What City is this in? Do you have proof  60 day notice was given?  Typically best to send by mail and require a signature to receive, other wise tenant can easily say they did not receive notice.  

       I have texts from him confirming this and that he will vacate in August. I was thinking that since he's refusing to pay the full increased rent amount I can start the eviction process with an attorney. This is near Boonton township so there are no rent control laws and the new rent is almost $1000 below SAMR. I am not occupying the property.

    • Shawn McenteerBusiness Member
      Realtor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Michael Carlson:
      Quote from @Shawn Mcenteer:

      Hi @Michael Carlson are you owner occupying the property?  What City is this in? Do you have proof  60 day notice was given?  Typically best to send by mail and require a signature to receive, other wise tenant can easily say they did not receive notice.  

       I have texts from him confirming this and that he will vacate in August. I was thinking that since he's refusing to pay the full increased rent amount I can start the eviction process with an attorney. This is near Boonton township so there are no rent control laws and the new rent is almost $1000 below SAMR. I am not occupying the property.

      Near Boonton Township or In?   In New Jersey there is no state wide rent control laws but when rent is raised over 10% there are ground for judge to consider that unreasonable increase.  Not saying a judge will rule for or against you just let it be know that 10% increase or more tends to be the make or break number if tenant brough you to court.  

      Have you been in touch with them? Checking in on how the search is going, they should be able to provide an update that they have a location to move to.
      House Hacking New Jersey561 Reviews
  • Don KonipolBusiness Member
    Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    1y

    Samuel Goldwyn: A verbal agreement is not worth the paper it’s written on”. 

    Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
  • Realtor · McAllen, TX · Member since 2025 · 141 posts · 58 votes
    1y

    I do not know the laws in NJ, but in my opinion some rent is better than no rent. However I understand that you are running a business and make money. You always want to have everything in writing. 

  • Member since 2025 · 16 posts · 7 votes
    1y

    Just wanted to provide an update incase anyone stumbles across this in the future. I spoke with a lawyer and I followed the proper steps. I paid a few hundred to send a certified letter with the new lease and notice to quit for not adhering to the new terms. The tenant accepted the new terms and provided back pay plus the fees for the previous months.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.