What to do with $3 million in equity

What to do with $3 million in equity

Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes

Hi everyone

My business partner and I have 25 - 30 single-family homes and multi-tenant properties.  

-  All of the homes/properties have been renovated and have been in service for a number of years (meaning we have a strong history as successful  property owners/investors)

-  All of the homes are higher-end rentals in very good neighborhoods 

- All but 4 homes are completely paid off with no mortgage overhead or LOC debt

-  All homes have a very consistent rental history with very low vacancy

-  All homes are turning a profit and our pre-door numbers are very good

Because the homes are almost completely paid off, we have a good deal of equity in just sitting around.  We would prefer not to sell anything off at this time and plan on owning these properties for a few more decades (although we have considered selling some for various reasons). 

A rough back-of-the-napkin calculation yields about $3.2 million in available equity across the entire portfolio.  

Q1.  What would you do with that equity?  

Q2.  How would we go about getting cash from the equity?

Q3.  With interest rates as they are, and knowing they are probably going to start dropping over the next few quarters, is it best to wait on any kind of finance for a year'ish or are the rates not going to come down enough over that period to make a huge difference?

Thoughts? 

Thanks in advance

2Reply
358 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe VilleneuvePro Member
Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
2y

If you don't want to sell the properties, then sell the equity.  Take on cash (silent,...VERY silent) partners.  They buy in and get part of the cash flow, you get the cash.

The alternative, and the best one at this point, is to refi.  The cash you get coming out isn't income, it's a loan, so you have very favorable (non-existent) tax issues.  If the properties can handle (as in still have positive CF) a 15 year mortgage, do that...and refi 2 properties every year.  This way, you get that Freelike cash every year on 2 houses at a time, every year for 15 years. Then, since year 16 will have payoffs of the first pair of properties, you start the rotation all over again.

See this reply in the discussion

52 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    2y

    If you don't want to sell the properties, then sell the equity.  Take on cash (silent,...VERY silent) partners.  They buy in and get part of the cash flow, you get the cash.

    The alternative, and the best one at this point, is to refi.  The cash you get coming out isn't income, it's a loan, so you have very favorable (non-existent) tax issues.  If the properties can handle (as in still have positive CF) a 15 year mortgage, do that...and refi 2 properties every year.  This way, you get that Freelike cash every year on 2 houses at a time, every year for 15 years. Then, since year 16 will have payoffs of the first pair of properties, you start the rotation all over again.

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y

    Thanks so much Joe

    That second option is really looking very interesting; frankly, I hadn't thought of that.  I was thinking of doing a block refi on all of the homes but maybe doing 2 houses at a time is the better option now that you mention it. 

    I guess that would mean each property would basically be used as income for that year, then?  Like if we have a $200k refinance we could take that money as income without the tax hit and as long as the debt service is covered by the rental amount we would be covered. 

    Am I reading that correctly?

    And how common is this approach?  Is this something that people do a lot?  That's a new idea to me. 

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:

    Thanks so much Joe

    That second option is really looking very interesting; frankly, I hadn't thought of that.  I was thinking of doing a block refi on all of the homes but maybe doing 2 houses at a time is the better option now that you mention it. 

    I guess that would mean each property would basically be used as income for that year, then?  Like if we have a $200k refinance we could take that money as income without the tax hit and as long as the debt service is covered by the rental amount we would be covered. 

    Am I reading that correctly?

    And how common is this approach?  Is this something that people do a lot?  That's a new idea to me. 

    It's one of the things I do/teach as part of a system.  
    Yes, that's tax free income, from two properties a year...continuously.  Don't forget the cash flow that's left from those two properties, and all the others.
  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:

    Thanks so much Joe

    That second option is really looking very interesting; frankly, I hadn't thought of that.  I was thinking of doing a block refi on all of the homes but maybe doing 2 houses at a time is the better option now that you mention it. 

    I guess that would mean each property would basically be used as income for that year, then?  Like if we have a $200k refinance we could take that money as income without the tax hit and as long as the debt service is covered by the rental amount we would be covered. 

    Am I reading that correctly?

    And how common is this approach?  Is this something that people do a lot?  That's a new idea to me. 

    It's one of the things I do/teach as part of a system.  
    Yes, that's tax free income, from two properties a year...continuously.  Don't forget the cash flow that's left from those two properties, and all the others.

     Love it, thank you very much again Joe.  I think that's a very good idea. 

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:

    Thanks so much Joe

    That second option is really looking very interesting; frankly, I hadn't thought of that.  I was thinking of doing a block refi on all of the homes but maybe doing 2 houses at a time is the better option now that you mention it. 

    I guess that would mean each property would basically be used as income for that year, then?  Like if we have a $200k refinance we could take that money as income without the tax hit and as long as the debt service is covered by the rental amount we would be covered. 

    Am I reading that correctly?

    And how common is this approach?  Is this something that people do a lot?  That's a new idea to me. 

    It's one of the things I do/teach as part of a system.  
    Yes, that's tax free income, from two properties a year...continuously.  Don't forget the cash flow that's left from those two properties, and all the others.

     Love it, thank you very much again Joe.  I think that's a very good idea. 

    PM me if you have any questions
  • Alan AsriantsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    Use a cash out refi to reinvest into more long term rental properties

    Take out a HELOC for a flip/other short term gain opportunities

    Alan Asriants - New Century Real Estate 591 Reviews
    View Page
  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Alan Asriants:

    Use a cash out refi to reinvest into more long term rental properties

    Take out a HELOC for a flip/other short term gain opportunities

    I don't think he needs, or want to add properties.  He doesn't need to.  He can refi for the cash (loans, not income) and have better tax situation, much greater income, without adding properties.  He's in a great position.  Adding properties at this point just adds headaches for no reason.
  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:
    Quote from @Alan Asriants:

    Use a cash out refi to reinvest into more long term rental properties

    Take out a HELOC for a flip/other short term gain opportunities

    I don't think he needs, or want to add properties.  He doesn't need to.  He can refi for the cash (loans, not income) and have better tax situation, much greater income, without adding properties.  He's in a great position.  Adding properties at this point just adds headaches for no reason.
    This is kind of what we are thinking as well.  We can add properties, but honestly, there just aren't that many deals out there.  I might be a little biased because we started purchasing places around 2009/2010 and we were picking up screaming deals all over the place (3/4 of our portfolio is made up of homes we purchased for ten's of thousands of dollars that are now worth hundreds of thousands). 

    We know what we are doing, we have a lot of experience at this point so adding properties wouldn't be that hard.... but the deals are not there and as Joe mentioned, there is still overhead in terms of time and just general PITA.

    I really like the idea of cashing out as long as we can sustain at a solid income.  I don't need to have fancy cars and a new boat every year, I just want to live comfortably without having to maintain a 9 to 5 gig. 
  • Accountant · San Diego, CA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 552 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:

    Hi everyone

    My business partner and I have 25 - 30 single-family homes and multi-tenant properties.  

    -  All of the homes/properties have been renovated and have been in service for a number of years (meaning we have a strong history as successful  property owners/investors)

    -  All of the homes are higher-end rentals in very good neighborhoods 

    - All but 4 homes are completely paid off with no mortgage overhead or LOC debt

    -  All homes have a very consistent rental history with very low vacancy

    -  All homes are turning a profit and our pre-door numbers are very good

    Because the homes are almost completely paid off, we have a good deal of equity in just sitting around.  We would prefer not to sell anything off at this time and plan on owning these properties for a few more decades (although we have considered selling some for various reasons). 

    A rough back-of-the-napkin calculation yields about $3.2 million in available equity across the entire portfolio.  

    Q1.  What would you do with that equity?  

    Q2.  How would we go about getting cash from the equity?

    Q3.  With interest rates as they are, and knowing they are probably going to start dropping over the next few quarters, is it best to wait on any kind of finance for a year'ish or are the rates not going to come down enough over that period to make a huge difference?

    Thoughts? 

    Thanks in advance


     Hey Michael,

    Congrats on the impressive portfolio accumulated so far. I would wait for interest rates to drop if you need liquidity. The metric I would suggest you focus on is debt to equity ratio, and depending on your risk tolerance when interest rates go down, taking out more equity accordingly. Then taking that liquidy and investing in uncorrelated assets would be my suggestion like stocks or things that are more liquid. Hard to give great advice since I don't know your entire portfolio picture, but that's the general idea I have that comes to mind 

  • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    1. I would by real estate in cities that have seen large negative decreases in sales prices but are still positioned for population growth.

    2. A portfolio loan sounds like a very good option for you.

    3. I do not wait for others to determine my destiny. Waiting for rate drops is not my idea of playing the game in a smart manner. My opinion is that rates will be reduced in by 1/4 pt in Sept with the intent of shinning a positive light on the democratic party. I doubt that there will be many decreases next year but if there are then they are likely to be small. I do not wait for others to determine 

  • Josh C.Pro Member
    Property Manager · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2010 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    I know you said they are high end rentals in good neighborhoods, and I don’t know where you live, but 3MM in equity with 25 paid off house means the houses are worth 120k each. Is that correct? What are the average rents? In most of America, even Midwest where I am, that’s pretty low grade house with a fair amount of capex and headaches. If so maybe transition to something easier or if they really are high end and $1500+ rents live off that. After expenses should be 10k a piece for you and your partner most likely tax free, which in the Midwest is a very good start.

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    2y

    What you describe here @Michael Gonda is the perfect scenario for Turn-Key offerings, right. 

    But you want to keep going for a couple decades, and mention interest rates. PERFECT! That all paint's 1 very nice picture. 

    How about we put it all together and evolve your position UP to "Bank".     Offer the properties Turn-Key, to upstart investors, on seller financing (C4D). 

    Now, you've "evolved" yourself in things where your no longer involved in the operations or the operational expenses. Gained capital via the assorted down payments. Retained cash-flow. Profited from current rate environment. Can be structured in a way that you retain maximum flexibility in ability to refinance, sell notes, or utilize as colterol for future endeavors etc etc.. 

    We all know the term OPM, and the profit potential of Other Peoples Money, well take a page out of the Banks playbook and tap OPL Other Peoples Labor..... 

    20% down, that's a fair bit of capital. And best part, it doesn't cost you a dime in interest, right. And, you have all that TIME restored, for other deployment. 

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Josh C.:

    I know you said they are high end rentals in good neighborhoods, and I don’t know where you live, but 3MM in equity with 25 paid off house means the houses are worth 120k each. Is that correct? What are the average rents? In most of America, even Midwest where I am, that’s pretty low grade house with a fair amount of capex and headaches. If so maybe transition to something easier or if they really are high end and $1500+ rents live off that. After expenses should be 10k a piece for you and your partner most likely tax free, which in the Midwest is a very good start.


     Hey Josh

    Yeah, my numbers above are really conservative.  We have spent a good chunk of our lives building up this portfolio, so I am being extra cautious with numbers as you can expect.

    Our rents are generally in the $1,400 to $2,000 a month range, and the street value is probably between $230k and $300k for the SFHs. But we do have a few duplexes, four units, and townhomes in the mix that skew the appraisal values and per-door numbers. 

    With most of the homes paid off we are almost but not quite making enough to retire now from rents alone so we are thinking of tapping into the equity to make up the difference (of course the debt service is going to eat into the rental income). 

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @James Hamling:

    What you describe here @Michael Gonda is the perfect scenario for Turn-Key offerings, right. 

    But you want to keep going for a couple decades, and mention interest rates. PERFECT! That all paint's 1 very nice picture. 

    How about we put it all together and evolve your position UP to "Bank".     Offer the properties Turn-Key, to upstart investors, on seller financing (C4D). 

    Now, you've "evolved" yourself in things where your no longer involved in the operations or the operational expenses. Gained capital via the assorted down payments. Retained cash-flow. Profited from current rate environment. Can be structured in a way that you retain maximum flexibility in ability to refinance, sell notes, or utilize as colterol for future endeavors etc etc.. 

    We all know the term OPM, and the profit potential of Other Peoples Money, well take a page out of the Banks playbook and tap OPL Other Peoples Labor..... 

    20% down, that's a fair bit of capital. And best part, it doesn't cost you a dime in interest, right. And, you have all that TIME restored, for other deployment. 


     Hi James

    That's a really interesting idea but.... 1. I wouldn't know how to start on this and 2. it makes me a little nervous giving over our proprites to someone else like that. 

    But I see the value in the idea. 

    So how does something like this typically work?  It seems to me that someone would be purchasing a business not just rental properties right?  As the value of that arrangement would be above the appraisal amounts alone, someone would be purchasing the whole shooting match. 

    And then they would still be paying interest in the properties also.  Would that be more or less interest than a typical bank loan?  I would assume it would be a good bit more than a bank's interest rates. 

    This seems interesting but I would need to think it over a good bit. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @James Hamling:

    What you describe here @Michael Gonda is the perfect scenario for Turn-Key offerings, right. 

    But you want to keep going for a couple decades, and mention interest rates. PERFECT! That all paint's 1 very nice picture. 

    How about we put it all together and evolve your position UP to "Bank".     Offer the properties Turn-Key, to upstart investors, on seller financing (C4D). 

    Now, you've "evolved" yourself in things where your no longer involved in the operations or the operational expenses. Gained capital via the assorted down payments. Retained cash-flow. Profited from current rate environment. Can be structured in a way that you retain maximum flexibility in ability to refinance, sell notes, or utilize as colterol for future endeavors etc etc.. 

    We all know the term OPM, and the profit potential of Other Peoples Money, well take a page out of the Banks playbook and tap OPL Other Peoples Labor..... 

    20% down, that's a fair bit of capital. And best part, it doesn't cost you a dime in interest, right. And, you have all that TIME restored, for other deployment. 


     Hi James

    That's a really interesting idea but.... 1. I wouldn't know how to start on this and 2. it makes me a little nervous giving over our proprites to someone else like that. 

    But I see the value in the idea. 

    So how does something like this typically work?  It seems to me that someone would be purchasing a business not just rental properties right?  As the value of that arrangement would be above the appraisal amounts alone, someone would be purchasing the whole shooting match. 

    And then they would still be paying interest in the properties also.  Would that be more or less interest than a typical bank loan?  I would assume it would be a good bit more than a bank's interest rates. 

    This seems interesting but I would need to think it over a good bit. 


    There can be a lot of details to this, and one can easily get lost in the details but pull-back and keep vision of the fundamentals as it really is rather simple. 

    You'd be selling an investment property or properties to a buyer, value based upon what it is, turn-key investment property, and instead of going to a bank for financing, you are the "Bank" financing there purchase. 

    The details can be many, but all stands upon this fundamental basis. 

    Now keep in mind everything is negotiable, because this is where things can really get fun with math. 

    Say fair market value today is $250k, and a person doing DSCR will be around let's say 8% all said and done. Well, what if you say $350k but at 5%. Too many get tunnel vision on just the % and completely forget there is 3 factors to how the #'s wash-out; the rate, over what time, on what total amount. Yes, you can make a lot more doing a lower rate on a bigger amount. Or or or..... There is so many ways to spin the math it's almost endless.

    When I approach these I start with looking at what it would cost one, the current fair market value, to obtain such a property. That's my base price. Now, I equate a value or "premium" for the benefit of the Turn-Key status, things are know, renter in place, things are done, we have removed theory and projections to provide a buyer a known, that holds value. What is the value premium? 

    Next, by providing financing option to buyer, again that holds value. What value do we assign this value Premium? 

    Now terms value premium, what value do we assign to the interest rate given? To the length of this conveyed financing? You mention long term, ok let's say 10yr which is a really long time, that certainty of a decade has value does it not, ok let's assign that value. 

    Now we ask, is this offering market viable? What do the numbers look like end of day? 

    As mentioned, it's changing one's seat from a landlord Investor to being a $-investor. 

    Yes, you could take on new financing, start doing that manner of things. your still a Landlord, still in those operations. This above mentioned strategy is a way to fundamentally change that picture, that is a kind of middle road approach. You are transferring various liabilities, namely maintenance and operations aspects from you too a buyer. gaining some liquid capital (down payments), while retaining control of assets. 

    Risks, for most part are similar to any tenant placed. The various "what-if" on neglect, just like with a tenant it's violation of contract terms and you take the applicable legal actions. 

    The biggest "risk" is them performing, because at end of term that means they complete purchase of property. And reality is, EVERYONE sells only question is when, ya never see a u-haul follow a hurst..... 

    So if you really wanted to, this is a potential option. 

    Or, you could just sell, now, today, standard sale. I think that's foolish given your position, but hey it's an option. You could sell now and try to 1031 into something "next". 

    Or, rearrange debt, refinance things which there is many options to this. 

    A lot hinges on what your desire for your next chapter is. Some just want to call it a day, hire manager, there happy getting what they got, paying down debt, that's it, done.     Some others seek to 1031 into that centralized apartment complex and end there journey there. 

    What's your "next"? Do you like being a Landlord as you are now? Would you rather be the guy who facilitates the next best Landlords and profits from such? Or getting into commercial? 

    C4D is a very powerful land of investing few ever speak of because the barrier to entry is high for the "noob", and because fact is who want's to groom competion, lol. There is a reason Black Rock has an entire division dedicated to just selling C4D. 

  • Specialist · Atlanta Metro Area, GA · Member since 2020 · 38 posts · 23 votes
    2y

    @Michael Gonda If you’re not interested in selling your properties, consider selling a portion of your equity instead. You can bring in cash partners—silent partners who stay in the background—who will invest and receive a share of the cash flow, while you benefit from the upfront cash infusion. Another strong option is to refinance. The money you receive from refinancing isn’t taxed as income, since it’s considered a loan, making it a very tax-efficient strategy.

    For potential partners, focus on individuals with cash looking for returns, inflows, and tax benefits. When pitching the deal, highlight these aspects. Whether through refinancing or bringing on partners, it’s ideal to play in the multifamily market or look for distressed single family package deals to continue expanding your portfolio.

  • Jaron WallingPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y

    @Michael Gonda You guys really hustled. Congrats on the success. Cash-out refinance a few like @Joe Villeneuve mentioned and enjoy. I'd do the same thing if we had 25 units!

    How did you pay off the properties so quickly? We make an extra payment on each rental per year (doesn't help the numbers) but we want to get them paid off faster.

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Jaron Walling:

    @Michael Gonda You guys really hustled. Congrats on the success. Cash-out refinance a few like @Joe Villeneuve mentioned and enjoy. I'd do the same thing if we had 25 units!

    How did you pay off the properties so quickly? We make an extra payment on each rental per year (doesn't help the numbers) but we want to get them paid off faster.


    Hey Jaron

    Thanks for the kind words and yes, I am really liking Joe's idea (but we are working on modeling this out over time to see what it will look like in the future). 

    As far as paying off the properties, I think it was part timing and part willingness to see the long game.  

    The timing comes down to the fact that many of our properties were purchased during the downturn in the 2009 / 2010 era.  We were purchasing foreclosure homes back then for $50k and $60k that are worth $200k to $300k now.  We also had the good fortune of quality labor for really good prices due to a family connection so our rehab costs were a touch lower than average. 

    As far as the long game goes, I chalk that up to two main ideas. 

    1.  We did higher-end rehabs on every home.  Marble backsplashes, all new kitchens, bathrooms, HVAC, electrical, refinished hardwood flooring, etc, all with the idea that we would get better tenants, higher rents, lower vacancies, and less maintenance/repair requests. 

    Generally speaking, this is exactly how it worked out for us: our rents are always on the top end of the market, we have very little turnover, and our tenants tend to be young professionals (doctors, lawyers, etc.), so we have zero hassles, with very few repairs during/post occupancy.  

    In fact, our tenants often tell us at the end of their stay that being in our homes is the single best rental experience of their lives... a couple have come back to us after renting other places because they missed the relationship (after they realized "other landlords suck" ha!  ).  You would be amazed by how helpful it is to have that kind of relationship with our people.  I just send over new potential tenants for tours without having to show up myself and the current tenants usually rent the place for us.

    Anyway... 

    2.  We have never once touched any of the rental income.  In fact, we both took our first $15k out last week (the first time ever taking any rental income) to help with the purchase of a new (used) vehicle.  Our personal lives have been supported by our 9 to 5 gigs.

    Initially, every penny we made went into purchasing homes on our own, so a third of our portfolio was never under a mortgage to begin with. When we stopped finding good deals about 5 or 6 years ago, we just started throwing every penny into paying down the principal across our fleet (paying off higher interest rates first, obviously).

    Looking back, we probably should have invested that money in the stock market because our interest payments were about 4 or 5%, and we could have doubled that with fairly safe stocks, but that's water under the bridge I guess. 

    But yes, we put a TON of work into this and we have never received a penny of income until last week (even ended up paying the income tax out of our own pockets) so it's time to collect on the work!

    Hope this helps....

    Thanks again
     

  • Ken BuckPro Member
    Specialist · Crested Butte, CO · Member since 2015 · 105 posts · 25 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:

    Thanks so much Joe

    That second option is really looking very interesting; frankly, I hadn't thought of that.  I was thinking of doing a block refi on all of the homes but maybe doing 2 houses at a time is the better option now that you mention it. 

    I guess that would mean each property would basically be used as income for that year, then?  Like if we have a $200k refinance we could take that money as income without the tax hit and as long as the debt service is covered by the rental amount we would be covered. 

    Am I reading that correctly?

    And how common is this approach?  Is this something that people do a lot?  That's a new idea to me. 

    It's one of the things I do/teach as part of a system.  
    Yes, that's tax free income, from two properties a year...continuously.  Don't forget the cash flow that's left from those two properties, and all the others.

     And do what with the cashout? Skimming through here so pls excuse if I missed that part

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Ify (Bobby) Anizoba:

    @Michael Gonda If you’re not interested in selling your properties, consider selling a portion of your equity instead. You can bring in cash partners—silent partners who stay in the background—who will invest and receive a share of the cash flow, while you benefit from the upfront cash infusion. Another strong option is to refinance. The money you receive from refinancing isn’t taxed as income, since it’s considered a loan, making it a very tax-efficient strategy.

    For potential partners, focus on individuals with cash looking for returns, inflows, and tax benefits. When pitching the deal, highlight these aspects. Whether through refinancing or bringing on partners, it’s ideal to play in the multifamily market or look for distressed single family package deals to continue expanding your portfolio.


    Thanks Bobby

    As to the partners, thanks for the idea but we really aren't looking for in a cash infusion. We could fund the purchase of more homes on our own right now. We have a LOC with our main banking contact for rehabs/updates and we are making enough in rental income that we could probably purchase a couple of homes a year free and clear.

    The issue is that after 15 or so years of doing this I would just like to relax a little and retire from the 9 to 5 grind.  

    An extra $100k or $200k is kind of in the noise at this stage for us.  Not saying that money is meaningless, it's just that we can't retire on that number either.  We need a solution that will let us live our current lives without the added workload required to get more prorperies on our books and in service and even if we got $500k from a partner it wouldn't be enough to make that happen.

    In short, I can't keep up the 9 to 5 thing on top of a full rental portfolio for another decade.  

    :  )

    I am starting to really like the refi option.

  • Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    2y

    Nice work.  You know you've made it when you don't know the exact number of properties you own!

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @James Hamling:

    What you describe here @Michael Gonda is the perfect scenario for Turn-Key offerings, right. 

    But you want to keep going for a couple decades, and mention interest rates. PERFECT! That all paint's 1 very nice picture. 

    How about we put it all together and evolve your position UP to "Bank".     Offer the properties Turn-Key, to upstart investors, on seller financing (C4D). 

    Now, you've "evolved" yourself in things where your no longer involved in the operations or the operational expenses. Gained capital via the assorted down payments. Retained cash-flow. Profited from current rate environment. Can be structured in a way that you retain maximum flexibility in ability to refinance, sell notes, or utilize as colterol for future endeavors etc etc.. 

    We all know the term OPM, and the profit potential of Other Peoples Money, well take a page out of the Banks playbook and tap OPL Other Peoples Labor..... 

    20% down, that's a fair bit of capital. And best part, it doesn't cost you a dime in interest, right. And, you have all that TIME restored, for other deployment. 


     Hi James

    That's a really interesting idea but.... 1. I wouldn't know how to start on this and 2. it makes me a little nervous giving over our proprites to someone else like that. 

    But I see the value in the idea. 

    So how does something like this typically work?  It seems to me that someone would be purchasing a business not just rental properties right?  As the value of that arrangement would be above the appraisal amounts alone, someone would be purchasing the whole shooting match. 

    And then they would still be paying interest in the properties also.  Would that be more or less interest than a typical bank loan?  I would assume it would be a good bit more than a bank's interest rates. 

    This seems interesting but I would need to think it over a good bit. 


    There can be a lot of details to this, and one can easily get lost in the details but pull-back and keep vision of the fundamentals as it really is rather simple. 

    You'd be selling an investment property or properties to a buyer, value based upon what it is, turn-key investment property, and instead of going to a bank for financing, you are the "Bank" financing there purchase. 

    The details can be many, but all stands upon this fundamental basis. 

    Now keep in mind everything is negotiable, because this is where things can really get fun with math. 

    Say fair market value today is $250k, and a person doing DSCR will be around let's say 8% all said and done. Well, what if you say $350k but at 5%. Too many get tunnel vision on just the % and completely forget there is 3 factors to how the #'s wash-out; the rate, over what time, on what total amount. Yes, you can make a lot more doing a lower rate on a bigger amount. Or or or..... There is so many ways to spin the math it's almost endless.

    When I approach these I start with looking at what it would cost one, the current fair market value, to obtain such a property. That's my base price. Now, I equate a value or "premium" for the benefit of the Turn-Key status, things are know, renter in place, things are done, we have removed theory and projections to provide a buyer a known, that holds value. What is the value premium? 

    Next, by providing financing option to buyer, again that holds value. What value do we assign this value Premium? 

    Now terms value premium, what value do we assign to the interest rate given? To the length of this conveyed financing? You mention long term, ok let's say 10yr which is a really long time, that certainty of a decade has value does it not, ok let's assign that value. 

    Now we ask, is this offering market viable? What do the numbers look like end of day? 

    As mentioned, it's changing one's seat from a landlord Investor to being a $-investor. 

    Yes, you could take on new financing, start doing that manner of things. your still a Landlord, still in those operations. This above mentioned strategy is a way to fundamentally change that picture, that is a kind of middle road approach. You are transferring various liabilities, namely maintenance and operations aspects from you too a buyer. gaining some liquid capital (down payments), while retaining control of assets. 

    Risks, for most part are similar to any tenant placed. The various "what-if" on neglect, just like with a tenant it's violation of contract terms and you take the applicable legal actions. 

    The biggest "risk" is them performing, because at end of term that means they complete purchase of property. And reality is, EVERYONE sells only question is when, ya never see a u-haul follow a hurst..... 

    So if you really wanted to, this is a potential option. 

    Or, you could just sell, now, today, standard sale. I think that's foolish given your position, but hey it's an option. You could sell now and try to 1031 into something "next". 

    Or, rearrange debt, refinance things which there is many options to this. 

    A lot hinges on what your desire for your next chapter is. Some just want to call it a day, hire manager, there happy getting what they got, paying down debt, that's it, done.     Some others seek to 1031 into that centralized apartment complex and end there journey there. 

    What's your "next"? Do you like being a Landlord as you are now? Would you rather be the guy who facilitates the next best Landlords and profits from such? Or getting into commercial? 

    C4D is a very powerful land of investing few ever speak of because the barrier to entry is high for the "noob", and because fact is who want's to groom competion, lol. There is a reason Black Rock has an entire division dedicated to just selling C4D. 


     Hummmm.... this really is an interesting idea, James.  Thank you!

    Lots to think about.

    My first question is, where do you even find a buyer like this?  I am not sure how to advertize this as an option out on the market.


    And is something like this fairly common?  I mean, from a buyer's standpoint it seems like the numbers would be a little tight... but probably workable I suppose.  Our business model back in the day was to use hard money lending for start-up costs. Eventually, we became self-funded, so this isn't something I have any experience with. 

    Very interesting idea though if we could find buyers. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @James Hamling:

    What you describe here @Michael Gonda is the perfect scenario for Turn-Key offerings, right. 

    But you want to keep going for a couple decades, and mention interest rates. PERFECT! That all paint's 1 very nice picture. 

    How about we put it all together and evolve your position UP to "Bank".     Offer the properties Turn-Key, to upstart investors, on seller financing (C4D). 

    Now, you've "evolved" yourself in things where your no longer involved in the operations or the operational expenses. Gained capital via the assorted down payments. Retained cash-flow. Profited from current rate environment. Can be structured in a way that you retain maximum flexibility in ability to refinance, sell notes, or utilize as colterol for future endeavors etc etc.. 

    We all know the term OPM, and the profit potential of Other Peoples Money, well take a page out of the Banks playbook and tap OPL Other Peoples Labor..... 

    20% down, that's a fair bit of capital. And best part, it doesn't cost you a dime in interest, right. And, you have all that TIME restored, for other deployment. 


     Hi James

    That's a really interesting idea but.... 1. I wouldn't know how to start on this and 2. it makes me a little nervous giving over our proprites to someone else like that. 

    But I see the value in the idea. 

    So how does something like this typically work?  It seems to me that someone would be purchasing a business not just rental properties right?  As the value of that arrangement would be above the appraisal amounts alone, someone would be purchasing the whole shooting match. 

    And then they would still be paying interest in the properties also.  Would that be more or less interest than a typical bank loan?  I would assume it would be a good bit more than a bank's interest rates. 

    This seems interesting but I would need to think it over a good bit. 


    There can be a lot of details to this, and one can easily get lost in the details but pull-back and keep vision of the fundamentals as it really is rather simple. 

    You'd be selling an investment property or properties to a buyer, value based upon what it is, turn-key investment property, and instead of going to a bank for financing, you are the "Bank" financing there purchase. 

    The details can be many, but all stands upon this fundamental basis. 

    Now keep in mind everything is negotiable, because this is where things can really get fun with math. 

    Say fair market value today is $250k, and a person doing DSCR will be around let's say 8% all said and done. Well, what if you say $350k but at 5%. Too many get tunnel vision on just the % and completely forget there is 3 factors to how the #'s wash-out; the rate, over what time, on what total amount. Yes, you can make a lot more doing a lower rate on a bigger amount. Or or or..... There is so many ways to spin the math it's almost endless.

    When I approach these I start with looking at what it would cost one, the current fair market value, to obtain such a property. That's my base price. Now, I equate a value or "premium" for the benefit of the Turn-Key status, things are know, renter in place, things are done, we have removed theory and projections to provide a buyer a known, that holds value. What is the value premium? 

    Next, by providing financing option to buyer, again that holds value. What value do we assign this value Premium? 

    Now terms value premium, what value do we assign to the interest rate given? To the length of this conveyed financing? You mention long term, ok let's say 10yr which is a really long time, that certainty of a decade has value does it not, ok let's assign that value. 

    Now we ask, is this offering market viable? What do the numbers look like end of day? 

    As mentioned, it's changing one's seat from a landlord Investor to being a $-investor. 

    Yes, you could take on new financing, start doing that manner of things. your still a Landlord, still in those operations. This above mentioned strategy is a way to fundamentally change that picture, that is a kind of middle road approach. You are transferring various liabilities, namely maintenance and operations aspects from you too a buyer. gaining some liquid capital (down payments), while retaining control of assets. 

    Risks, for most part are similar to any tenant placed. The various "what-if" on neglect, just like with a tenant it's violation of contract terms and you take the applicable legal actions. 

    The biggest "risk" is them performing, because at end of term that means they complete purchase of property. And reality is, EVERYONE sells only question is when, ya never see a u-haul follow a hurst..... 

    So if you really wanted to, this is a potential option. 

    Or, you could just sell, now, today, standard sale. I think that's foolish given your position, but hey it's an option. You could sell now and try to 1031 into something "next". 

    Or, rearrange debt, refinance things which there is many options to this. 

    A lot hinges on what your desire for your next chapter is. Some just want to call it a day, hire manager, there happy getting what they got, paying down debt, that's it, done.     Some others seek to 1031 into that centralized apartment complex and end there journey there. 

    What's your "next"? Do you like being a Landlord as you are now? Would you rather be the guy who facilitates the next best Landlords and profits from such? Or getting into commercial? 

    C4D is a very powerful land of investing few ever speak of because the barrier to entry is high for the "noob", and because fact is who want's to groom competion, lol. There is a reason Black Rock has an entire division dedicated to just selling C4D. 


     Hummmm.... this really is an interesting idea, James.  Thank you!

    Lots to think about.

    My first question is, where do you even find a buyer like this?  I am not sure how to advertize this as an option out on the market.


    And is something like this fairly common?  I mean, from a buyer's standpoint it seems like the numbers would be a little tight... but probably workable I suppose.  Our business model back in the day was to use hard money lending for start-up costs. Eventually, we became self-funded, so this isn't something I have any experience with. 

    Very interesting idea though if we could find buyers. 


     Yes, it's just a melding of 2 common things; Turn-Key and Seller Financing, both of which have been around for generations. 

    How to BEST do it, well as a professional who works in such I am going to say get with a professional who specializes in such. Because we know what were doing, no guess work involved, and we have those established connections for how to best connect with such buyers. network, network, network, right. 

    Heck, depending on what ya got, where, I got buyers now for ya. 

    But yes, many many potential buyers for such. Various HNW persons not a fan of the documentation prostate exam for financing, professional athlete's, those with small biz and really great at write-off's, all kinds of potential buyers.

    As the saying goes, do what you do best and hire the best, to do the rest. 

    So I'd say start by connecting with the "Pro" at this in your market...... ideally there is one I should say, not sure where you are. 

    I assume next question would be how to identify one like myself, well versed and experienced in such?     For that I'd say Title Closing Agents, if someone called in my markets and spoke with my primary ones about who does these "jazy" things I bet they'd point me out, or would at least pass on your info. Best way to find who's actually doing things. 

  • Member since 2024 · 18 posts · 8 votes
    2y
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:
    Quote from @James Hamling:

    What you describe here @Michael Gonda is the perfect scenario for Turn-Key offerings, right. 

    But you want to keep going for a couple decades, and mention interest rates. PERFECT! That all paint's 1 very nice picture. 

    How about we put it all together and evolve your position UP to "Bank".     Offer the properties Turn-Key, to upstart investors, on seller financing (C4D). 

    Now, you've "evolved" yourself in things where your no longer involved in the operations or the operational expenses. Gained capital via the assorted down payments. Retained cash-flow. Profited from current rate environment. Can be structured in a way that you retain maximum flexibility in ability to refinance, sell notes, or utilize as colterol for future endeavors etc etc.. 

    We all know the term OPM, and the profit potential of Other Peoples Money, well take a page out of the Banks playbook and tap OPL Other Peoples Labor..... 

    20% down, that's a fair bit of capital. And best part, it doesn't cost you a dime in interest, right. And, you have all that TIME restored, for other deployment. 


     Hi James

    That's a really interesting idea but.... 1. I wouldn't know how to start on this and 2. it makes me a little nervous giving over our proprites to someone else like that. 

    But I see the value in the idea. 

    So how does something like this typically work?  It seems to me that someone would be purchasing a business not just rental properties right?  As the value of that arrangement would be above the appraisal amounts alone, someone would be purchasing the whole shooting match. 

    And then they would still be paying interest in the properties also.  Would that be more or less interest than a typical bank loan?  I would assume it would be a good bit more than a bank's interest rates. 

    This seems interesting but I would need to think it over a good bit. 


    There can be a lot of details to this, and one can easily get lost in the details but pull-back and keep vision of the fundamentals as it really is rather simple. 

    You'd be selling an investment property or properties to a buyer, value based upon what it is, turn-key investment property, and instead of going to a bank for financing, you are the "Bank" financing there purchase. 

    The details can be many, but all stands upon this fundamental basis. 

    Now keep in mind everything is negotiable, because this is where things can really get fun with math. 

    Say fair market value today is $250k, and a person doing DSCR will be around let's say 8% all said and done. Well, what if you say $350k but at 5%. Too many get tunnel vision on just the % and completely forget there is 3 factors to how the #'s wash-out; the rate, over what time, on what total amount. Yes, you can make a lot more doing a lower rate on a bigger amount. Or or or..... There is so many ways to spin the math it's almost endless.

    When I approach these I start with looking at what it would cost one, the current fair market value, to obtain such a property. That's my base price. Now, I equate a value or "premium" for the benefit of the Turn-Key status, things are know, renter in place, things are done, we have removed theory and projections to provide a buyer a known, that holds value. What is the value premium? 

    Next, by providing financing option to buyer, again that holds value. What value do we assign this value Premium? 

    Now terms value premium, what value do we assign to the interest rate given? To the length of this conveyed financing? You mention long term, ok let's say 10yr which is a really long time, that certainty of a decade has value does it not, ok let's assign that value. 

    Now we ask, is this offering market viable? What do the numbers look like end of day? 

    As mentioned, it's changing one's seat from a landlord Investor to being a $-investor. 

    Yes, you could take on new financing, start doing that manner of things. your still a Landlord, still in those operations. This above mentioned strategy is a way to fundamentally change that picture, that is a kind of middle road approach. You are transferring various liabilities, namely maintenance and operations aspects from you too a buyer. gaining some liquid capital (down payments), while retaining control of assets. 

    Risks, for most part are similar to any tenant placed. The various "what-if" on neglect, just like with a tenant it's violation of contract terms and you take the applicable legal actions. 

    The biggest "risk" is them performing, because at end of term that means they complete purchase of property. And reality is, EVERYONE sells only question is when, ya never see a u-haul follow a hurst..... 

    So if you really wanted to, this is a potential option. 

    Or, you could just sell, now, today, standard sale. I think that's foolish given your position, but hey it's an option. You could sell now and try to 1031 into something "next". 

    Or, rearrange debt, refinance things which there is many options to this. 

    A lot hinges on what your desire for your next chapter is. Some just want to call it a day, hire manager, there happy getting what they got, paying down debt, that's it, done.     Some others seek to 1031 into that centralized apartment complex and end there journey there. 

    What's your "next"? Do you like being a Landlord as you are now? Would you rather be the guy who facilitates the next best Landlords and profits from such? Or getting into commercial? 

    C4D is a very powerful land of investing few ever speak of because the barrier to entry is high for the "noob", and because fact is who want's to groom competion, lol. There is a reason Black Rock has an entire division dedicated to just selling C4D. 


     Hummmm.... this really is an interesting idea, James.  Thank you!

    Lots to think about.

    My first question is, where do you even find a buyer like this?  I am not sure how to advertize this as an option out on the market.


    And is something like this fairly common?  I mean, from a buyer's standpoint it seems like the numbers would be a little tight... but probably workable I suppose.  Our business model back in the day was to use hard money lending for start-up costs. Eventually, we became self-funded, so this isn't something I have any experience with. 

    Very interesting idea though if we could find buyers. 


     Yes, it's just a melding of 2 common things; Turn-Key and Seller Financing, both of which have been around for generations. 

    How to BEST do it, well as a professional who works in such I am going to say get with a professional who specializes in such. Because we know what were doing, no guess work involved, and we have those established connections for how to best connect with such buyers. network, network, network, right. 

    Heck, depending on what ya got, where, I got buyers now for ya. 

    But yes, many many potential buyers for such. Various HNW persons not a fan of the documentation prostate exam for financing, professional athlete's, those with small biz and really great at write-off's, all kinds of potential buyers.

    As the saying goes, do what you do best and hire the best, to do the rest. 

    So I'd say start by connecting with the "Pro" at this in your market...... ideally there is one I should say, not sure where you are. 

    I assume next question would be how to identify one like myself, well versed and experienced in such?     For that I'd say Title Closing Agents, if someone called in my markets and spoke with my primary ones about who does these "jazy" things I bet they'd point me out, or would at least pass on your info. Best way to find who's actually doing things. 


     Very helpful... thanks.  Yes, I am very familiar with seller financing (we have done one or two of these deals ourselves in the past), but I have never done the "turn-key" part, so that's the area I am most unsure of. 

    We are going to look into this option as well. 

    Thanks again!

  • Encinitas, CA · Member since 2011 · 192 posts · 252 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Gonda:

    Hi everyone

    My business partner and I have 25 - 30 single-family homes and multi-tenant properties.  

    -  All of the homes/properties have been renovated and have been in service for a number of years (meaning we have a strong history as successful  property owners/investors)

    -  All of the homes are higher-end rentals in very good neighborhoods 

    - All but 4 homes are completely paid off with no mortgage overhead or LOC debt

    -  All homes have a very consistent rental history with very low vacancy

    -  All homes are turning a profit and our pre-door numbers are very good

    Because the homes are almost completely paid off, we have a good deal of equity in just sitting around.  We would prefer not to sell anything off at this time and plan on owning these properties for a few more decades (although we have considered selling some for various reasons). 

    A rough back-of-the-napkin calculation yields about $3.2 million in available equity across the entire portfolio.  

    Q1.  What would you do with that equity?  

    Q2.  How would we go about getting cash from the equity?

    Q3.  With interest rates as they are, and knowing they are probably going to start dropping over the next few quarters, is it best to wait on any kind of finance for a year'ish or are the rates not going to come down enough over that period to make a huge difference?

    Thoughts? 

    Thanks in advance


    You know, I used to worry about an ever increasing deterioration in income to equity ratios but as I get older, I am more and more comfortable with dead equity. Yes, I can take cash out and try to invest in higher return projects, a sort of carry trade, but the reality is that increasing return on equity generally involves more risk. 

    So If I were you I would congratulate myself on success and question do you really want to take on additional risk or incur not insubstantial transaction costs to transition from what you have. Putting credit lines in place might make sense to have the capital available if a sure fire opportunity comes your way, but I would learn to get a certain level of comfort with paid off mortgages too.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.