All
Members
Companies
Blog
Forums
Podcast
Webinars
    User Log in  /  Sign up
  • Start here
  • Education
    Forums

    Learn from and contribute to 658K+ real estate discussions

    BiggerPockets Podcast

    Listen to weekly interviews with investors & entrepreneurs

    BiggerPockets Blog

    Delve into 8,800+ articles by experienced investors

    Member Blogs

    Read original articles by BiggerPockets members

    Guides

    Master the ins and outs of fundamental real estate topics

    The Money Show

    Listen to weekly interviews that will help get your financial house in order

    Webinars

    Sign up for this week's free webinars hosted by experienced investors or view previously-held webinar recordings in the Archives

    Videos

    Browse our library of real estate related video content

    Free Course

    Experience The Financial Independence Blueprint video series - a free four-part video series

    Topics
    Property Management Property Types Finance Strategy Finding Deals Business Operations
  • Network
    Members

    Search over 1,270,000 members across BiggerPockets

    Companies

    Explore over 31,000 real estate-related companies

    Real Estate Agents

    Find an investor-friendly agent near you

    Hard Money Lenders

    Pinpoint lenders near you with our nationwide database

    Events

    Find upcoming real estate events and meetups near you

    Jobs

    Browse real estate job opportunities in your area

  • Tools

    Calculators

    • Fix and Flip
    • Rental Property
    • BRRRR
    • Rehab Estimator
    • Wholesaling
    • Mortgage Payment
    • 70% Rule
    • Airbnb Calculator

    Services

    Find a Contractor Get a Mortgage Loan Tenant Screening External Link

    Additional Tools

    FilePlace

    Download presentations, spreadsheets, contracts & more

    REI Resources

    Dig into thousands of curated real estate tools & resources

    Calculators
  • Marketplace
    Properties For Sale

    Buy and sell real estate deals or seek out partners, financing, etc.

    Find Foreclosures External Link

    Search this comprehensive database of nationwide foreclosures

    Ads, Jobs, and Other

    Advertise your real estate business, deals, financing & more

  • Bookstore

    Featured Book

    Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing book cover

    Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing

    This easy-to-follow guide will show you how to make money during all of the market’s twists and turns! Accomplished investor J Scott dives into the theory of economic cycles and the real-world strategies for harnessing them to your advantage.

    Get the book now

    Real Estate Books

    • Flipping and Estimating Bundle
    • How to Invest in Real Estate
    • How to Sell Your Home
    • See All Books
    Real Estate Books

    Shop books covering real estate investing and personal finance.

    Lease Agreement Package New

    Don't spend $1,000 on a lawyer!

    Real Estate Forms

    Lease Agreement Package New

    Don't spend $1,000 on a lawyer!

  • Plans
Log In Sign up
User
Quick search links
Podcast Hard Money Lenders Books Washington
ForumsArrowRehabbing and House FlippingArrowUsing a self directed IRA for rehab.
  • Newest Posts Arrow Down Light
    • Newest Posts
    • Unanswered Discussions
  • Trending Arrow Down Light
    • Top Discussions
    • Trending Discussions
  • Strategies Arrow Down Light
    • Local Real Estate Forums

      Real Estate Forums near you

      • New York City Real Estate Forum 1.3K Posts 191 Discussions
      • Norfolk Real Estate Forum 350 Posts 35 Discussions
      • Baltimore Real Estate Forum 1.8K Posts 223 Discussions
      • Norwalk Real Estate Forum 7 Posts -1 Discussions

      View all Local Real Estate forums

    • General Info
      • BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area 16K Posts 3.0K Discussions
      • New Member Introductions 488K Posts 56K Discussions
      • Real Estate Not-So-Successful Stories 523 Posts 41 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Summer Reading List 92 Posts 14 Discussions
      • Real Estate Quizzes 696 Posts 21 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Money Podcast 675 Posts 50 Discussions
      • FAQ Forum 132 Posts 9 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Webinar Discussion Forum 459 Posts 15 Discussions
      • Questions About BiggerPockets and Official Site Announcements 42K Posts 4.1K Discussions
      • Real Estate Success Stories 77K Posts 3.7K Discussions
    • General Real Estate
      • Buying & Selling Real Estate Discussion 423K Posts 58K Discussions
      • Investor Deal Diaries 17K Posts 864 Discussions
      • Completed Deal Diaries 5.6K Posts 1.9K Discussions
      • Renters Discussion 44K Posts 5.1K Discussions
      • Military Investing 5.4K Posts 530 Discussions
      • Construction & Remodeling Diaries 6.1K Posts 1.0K Discussions
      • Do it Yourself 32K Posts 3.5K Discussions
      • Get Foreclosure Help - Stop Foreclosure Forum 6.6K Posts 910 Discussions
      • Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum 6.2K Posts 910 Discussions
    • Reviews & Feedback
      • Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice 131K Posts 18K Discussions
      • Ask About A Real Estate Company 24K Posts 2.7K Discussions
      • Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions 28K Posts 2.9K Discussions
    • Investor Basics
      • Starting Out 290K Posts 41K Discussions
      • General Real Estate Investing 144K Posts 19K Discussions
      • Real Estate Investor Marketing Help & Advice 46K Posts 6.5K Discussions
      • Investor Psychology 21K Posts 1.6K Discussions
    • Landlord & Tenant Forums
      • Landlord Forums & Rental Property Questions 358K Posts 39K Discussions
      • Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing 19K Posts 2.3K Discussions
    • Foreclosures
      • General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums 33K Posts 5.2K Discussions
      • REOs 17K Posts 2.2K Discussions
      • Short Sales Questions 17K Posts 2.1K Discussions
      • HUD, VA, and Tax Sales 10K Posts 1.5K Discussions
    • Real Estate Strategies
      • Real Estate Development & New Home Construction 19K Posts 2.6K Discussions
      • Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options 15K Posts 2.3K Discussions
      • Rehabbing and House Flipping 110K Posts 13K Discussions
      • Short-Term and Vacation Rental Discussion 22K Posts 2.0K Discussions
      • Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion 34K Posts 3.9K Discussions
      • Real Estate Wholesaling Questions & Answers 137K Posts 18K Discussions
      • Innovative Strategies 27K Posts 3.4K Discussions
      • 1031 Exchanges 8.7K Posts 1.4K Discussions
    • Commercial Real Estate
      • Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Forums 96K Posts 10K Discussions
      • Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum 36K Posts 4.8K Discussions
    • Business Basics
      • Goals, Business Plans & Entities 25K Posts 3.5K Discussions
    • Real Estate Technology and the Internet
      • Real Estate Technology, Social Media & Blogging 16K Posts 2.3K Discussions
    • Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines
      • Creative Real Estate Financing Forum 50K Posts 7.5K Discussions
      • Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice 105K Posts 14K Discussions
      • Real Estate Crowdfunding Forums 5.6K Posts 384 Discussions
    • Financial, Tax, and Legal
      • Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA 100K Posts 15K Discussions
      • Personal Finance Forum 18K Posts 2.0K Discussions
      • Property Insurance Questions & Discussions 11K Posts 1.8K Discussions
    • Real Estate Professionals
      • Contractors 18K Posts 3.7K Discussions
      • Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers 12K Posts 1.9K Discussions
      • Real Estate Agent Forums 47K Posts 7.0K Discussions
    • Real Estate Marketplace
      • Real Estate Events and Happenings 57K Posts 12K Discussions
      • Marketplace 227K Posts 88K Discussions
    • Off Topic
      • BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit 2.0K Posts 107 Discussions
      • Off-Topic 43K Posts 5.3K Discussions
      • Housing News & Real Estate Market Discussions 15K Posts 1.8K Discussions
Start a Discussion

Using a self directed IRA for rehab.

49 Replies

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
Rotate Log in or sign up to reply
  • 1
  • 2
Greg Wright
  • 30 posts
  • 1 votes

Greg Wright
Investor from Wolcott, Connecticut

posted almost 4 years ago

Has any rehabber used a self directed IRA for rehabbing houses? How do you handle the profit. Does it have to go back into the IRA which would seem to defeat the purpose as you couldn't make any money to live off. If you keep the profit out does it get taxed at a higher rate than normal or is there a penalty? Thanks for any input.

Jeff S.
  • 1.0K posts
  • 1.1K votes

Jeff S.
Lender from Los Angeles, CA

replied almost 4 years ago

An IRA is an Individual Retirement Account, @Greg Wright. The money invested grows tax-free or tax deferred until you retire. You can't use IRA investment returns "to live off" until that time. These must stay in the account.

The general rule is that you cannot personally profit from your IRA until you retire. While a Roth IRA allows you to withdraw your initial investment anytime, since you already paid taxes on these funds, you generally can't withdraw any profits or traditional IRA contributions until age 59 ½. Early withdrawals can result in substantial penalties and interest.

Brian Eastman
  • 2.0K posts
  • 1.4K votes

Brian Eastman
Self Directed IRA & 401k Advisor from Boulder, Colorado

replied almost 4 years ago

@Greg Wright

There are two options. With a "self directed IRA" (or 401k), the plan is the investor, not you. You can choose to diversify your retirement savings into real estate, but everything must be done at arm's length and you may not derive any income personally. You can have your IRA flip houses, but you would need to hire 3rd party contractors (or JV with a contractor). The gains go back into the IRA or 401k, and in the case of flipping houses - which is considered a trade or business activity - there is a tax implication on the profits from the flip through UBTI (look it up).

Flipping houses and paying UBTI can still be more profitable for your IRA than investing in stocks, or even passive real estate options such as holding rentals or being a hard money lender. So, do not dismiss the strategy out of hand. Do some research by contacting a professional self directed firm and your tax advisor.

The other option is what is referred to as a Rollover as Business Startup (ROBS) plan. In this structure, you form a company personally and that company sponsors a profit sharing or 401k plan. You can rollover a prior IRA or 401k into the plan, then the plan can purchase shares of the parent company with an Employee Stock Option Purchase (ESOP). In this format, you have used your retirement plan to capitalize your business, and you can be directly involved in flipping houses, take a salary etc.

Linda Weygant
  • 2.4K posts
  • 2.8K votes

Linda Weygant
Investor and CPA from Arvada, Colorado

replied almost 4 years ago

Yes, you can use a SDIRA to invest in houses for rehab/flipping or rehab/renting.

There are plenty of forum topics here regarding using your Self Directed IRA to invest in real estate.

The topics you'll want to research are Prohibited Transactions and Disqualified People.  

However, the short version is - you are unable to do any of the rehab work yourself.  In other words, no sweat equity allowed.  There are those who interpret the IRS regulations to mean that you can't even go over and change a light bulb, so be very careful about this.

Secondarily, there are others who also cannot have any financial gain, including going over to change light bulbs, such as pretty much every family member you have.  But do your research on this as well.

To answer your questions directly - yes, all profits have to go back to the IRA and that's sort of the point. Your IRA isn't a fund for you to invest and make money off of to live - the IRA is there for your retirement, so all profits and other income go back into the fund for that purpose and that purpose only.

There are people who have tried to circumvent this by "hiring" themselves or a family member through any number of layers of legal entities to either rehab the property or manage it after it is a rental.  Those people end up disqualifying their entire account and end up in a world of tax mess.  Be careful.  Make sure you understand all the rules.  This is a truly passive activity.  Many would say the only thing you're permitted to do is check your account periodically to make sure all the deposits are coming in.  Self Directed IRAs are under extra scrutiny from the IRS these days - or at least as much as they can be with reduced personnel and budget.

Rodney Marcantel
  • 189 posts
  • 120 votes

Rodney Marcantel
from Coppell, Texas

replied almost 4 years ago

I'm in the process of converting my father-in-law's 403(b) account into a Self Directed IRA. He has Alzheimer's and my wife is POA. His wife passed away last year so she is the sole beneficiary of all his accounts including this 403(b) account. With that said, we can use our new SDIRA to fund a rehab project. But like stated above, all work must be done and documented by 3rd party sources which means invoices from all trades.

Our advantage is that we can as needed pull funds out without penalty to move money under his name to his bank account that we use as needed to care for him. All other retirement funds he has including his social security check, are already taxed with exception to profits from the investments and we use that money as his income.

The penalty for withdrawals from an IRA or 401K are 10% penalty plus ordinary income taxing if taken out before you turn 59 1/2 years old. Having a father-in-law that we take care of and is over 59 1/2 helps us use funds as needed as long as we don't go over his 15% tax bracket at the end of the year.

What we do with the money we take out is put in a Roth IRA periodically. I leaned a lot from these webinars in Dallas:

www.questira.com/all-events/dallas-events/

Robert Leonard
  • 1.3K posts
  • 788 votes

Robert Leonard
Specialist from Lafayette/Baton Rouge, LA

replied almost 4 years ago

@Greg Wright no one mentioned the self-dealing rule, so I'll add the following: if a person buys a property in their name (or that of an entity they or a disqualified person own) they cannot use their SD-IRA funds for the rehab portion of the financing. That would be considered self-dealing and it is a prohibited transaction. That's my $.02!

Rodney Marcantel
  • 189 posts
  • 120 votes

Rodney Marcantel
from Coppell, Texas

replied almost 4 years ago

Any self directed IRA must be formed as an LLC before investing else you'll be subject to penalties.

Brian Eastman
  • 2.0K posts
  • 1.4K votes

Brian Eastman
Self Directed IRA & 401k Advisor from Boulder, Colorado

replied almost 4 years ago

@Rodney Marcantel

Your statement is not correct. Self dealing is determined by how one transacts with IRA funds, not how the IRA is deployed.

An IRA held by a trust company serving as custodian may transact in real estate. The Trust Co will hold the funds and pay for expenses per your instructions.

Alternately, that IRA may be invested into a specially formed LLC where the IRA is the sole member and the account holder or someone they designate serves as the manager. That manager has to be careful to follow the rules against self dealing - just as would an account holder transacting via a custodian - but they are allowed to administer the LLC and do things like sign contracts, pay for expenses and receive income into the LLC on behalf of the IRA.

The LLC is not a requirement, simply a way to gain more direct control over the administration of the IRA's investments.

In either case, one may not have any direct or indirect benefit - in either direction - between the IRA and a disqualified party (which I will simplify somewhat as the account holder, their spouse and lineal family). Benefit would include financial transactions, lending of capital or provision of goods or services, among other things. I'm staying high level to make the basic point that the LLC does not change the underlying nature of the IRS rules.

@Robert Leonard

I did not specifically detail self-dealing, but did in my prior post indicate that the use of a self directed IRA/401k must be done "at arm's length". Thank you for your extra emphasis on this point however, as it is critical.

Bottom line is that when you invest using IRA funds, you are really serving as a fund manager for those funds, not adding them to your pool of real estate investing capital. Self directed IRA & 401k plans are about having different choices to diversify your retirement savings into alternatives such as real estate - but that retirement savings is very much bundled up in the tax code so as to be reserved for your post 59 1/2 future. But, an IRA or 401k of the Wall Street variety (common model) is equally tied up as far as your access, and even more restricted because of the limitation on publicly traded investments only.

Mark Nolan
  • 13K posts
  • 1.3K votes

Mark Nolan
Professional from Carlsbad, California

replied almost 4 years ago

If you are looking to use retirement funds to finance a real-estate rehab business (for example, a real-estate operating company), then a ROBS 401k/PSP (rollover as business startup plan) might be a good fit as you will be able to draw a salary. 

Rodney Marcantel
  • 189 posts
  • 120 votes

Rodney Marcantel
from Coppell, Texas

replied almost 4 years ago

@Brian Eastman , you are right but my point was that to protect you as the investor, an LLC is very much required, else you risk "self dealing" and IRA scrutiny. IRS penalties can be as high as 40% on top of ordinary income if they find that you've been self dealing.

Craig Brooksby
  • 156 posts
  • 21 votes

Craig Brooksby
Investor from Cary, NC

replied almost 4 years ago

Jim Hitt American IRA is your man. Google him. He has managed and built funds, invested in real estate extensively. He manages over $300,000,000.00 in these types of accounts.

He helps many of my clients get set up.

I also like Brians input. He is spot on.

Greg Wright
  • 30 posts
  • 1 votes

Greg Wright
Investor from Wolcott, Connecticut

replied almost 4 years ago

Thanks for all the advice. Does anyone know if the UBTI tax is on top of regular income tax? Example I rehab a house sell for $20000 profit pay UBTI tax do I still owe regular income tax on the $20000?

Jon Holdman
  • 22K posts
  • 14K votes

Jon Holdman (Moderator) -
Rental Property Investor from Mercer Island, WA

replied almost 4 years ago

@Greg Wright if you do a fix and flip inside your IRA and it earns $20K on the deal, your IRA will need to pay UBIT on the $20K of gain. That works out to $6228.70 (quick and dirty, may be a little less.) That leaves you $13,771.30 in your IRA. When you withdraw that $13,771.30 from your IRA it will be subject to your ordinary income tax, the same as if you had earned that money.

This may seem like double taxation. And it is. But this is no different than any other business. If your IRA owned stock in a business that did fix and flips, that business would be paying income tax before it distribute any dividends to its shareholders. The UBIT tax is specifically intended to level the playing field and avoid entities like IRAs (IRAs are not the only entity subject to this tax) from having an unfair advantage over normal businesses.

Greg Wright
  • 30 posts
  • 1 votes

Greg Wright
Investor from Wolcott, Connecticut

replied almost 4 years ago

Jon,

Can I keep that $13771.30 out of the IRA.

Doreen Chaisson
  • 175 posts
  • 101 votes

Doreen Chaisson
Professional from Portsmouth, New Hampshire

replied almost 4 years ago

Any income derived by an IRA-owned asset must flow back to the IRA. If you purchase the property outright with IRA funds, rehab it with IRA funds and then sell it at a profit, ALL proceeds from the sale flow back to the IRA. Your IRA can do this process directly or insert a single member LLC, but it is not a requirement and makes no difference in the prohibited transaction rules.

With regard to UBIT - this may not always apply. If your IRA leverages the purchase and rehab of the property, it definitely will. If you purchase it outright with your IRA and rehab it with IRA funds, and only rehab one or two properties per year, you may not owe any UBIT if there's no leverage. Each state has regulations on when an IRA account that is buying/flipping reaches "dealer status" (usually more than a handful of transactions per year, check with your own state) at which point it is no longer involved in passive investing, but will be considered a real estate operating company, subject to UBIT whether or not there is leverage in the picture.

Shop around for a good custodian who knows the regulations. There are many Self-Directed IRA custodians out there. It is advisable to do your due diligence and ask about such things as how long have they been in business, are alternative assets their sole focus, are they BBB accredited and rated, are they a regulated financial institution, have they ever been sanctioned by any regulatory bodies, how many accounts and how much in assets do they administer?

Brian Eastman
  • 2.0K posts
  • 1.4K votes

Brian Eastman
Self Directed IRA & 401k Advisor from Boulder, Colorado

replied almost 4 years ago

@Doreen Chaisson

State dealer status does not impact whether UBTI applies.  The federal language in IRS publication 598 refers to "engaging in a trade or business activity on a regular or repeated basis".  That gives the IRS a good amount of leeway to determine that more than one flip in a few year period meets that criteria.  The idea that one or two per year does not meet this threshold is less than conservative, as two per year would certainly be both regular and repeated.  One per year would even meet that criteria in the right facts and circumstances.

If your intention is to flip houses in an continued fashion, factor in UBTI as part of the equation.  

The key thing when considering UBTI is to look at the ROI the investment creates. If you flip a house and net $30K and give up about a third of that to taxation then you are left with $20K. If your total cost on the transaction was $100K, then that still represents a 20% return. Most folks are not earning 20% in their IRA buying indexed mutual funds or even holding rental properties.

"Double taxation" is moot. When you take money out of an IRA, you pay taxes on that money, regardless of whether the IRA originally earned 1.5% from a CD or 20% post-UBTI from flipping houses. If you were flipping houses (successfully), you'll have a much bigger pot from which to draw on in retirement. Sure, you'll pay more in taxes, but in this case, that is the good news.

Will Barnard
  • 13K posts
  • 7.7K votes

Will Barnard (Moderator) -
Developer from Santa Clarita, CA

replied almost 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Greg Wright :

Jon,

Can I keep that $13771.30 out of the IRA.

No you can't without paying the taxes plus the 10% additional early withdrawal penalty. Any profits or income from IRA investments must go back into the IRA account. Think of the account as another person. You certainly can not go into another person's bank account and withdraw funds without consequencs.

DISCLAIMER TO ALL READERS: There are several incorrect statements in this thread, readers should be advised to consult a tax professional knowledgable in retirement account (specifically self directed varieties) tax rules and law including UBIT.

In the example of the father in law having a 403b, your wife, the account holder's daughter, is a disqualified party and as such, these funds can not be invested into YOUR rehab projects.

You do NOT need, nor are you "required" to have an LLC for self directed IRA's where you want to invest in rehab flips or any other investment for that matter. Also, the statement that you are required to have it to avoid self dealing or scrutiny by the IRS is also incorrect.

The comments regarding "arms length transactions" is 100% correct and spot on. That means you can not self deal (invest IRA funds from your account into properties you own) and you can not invest those funds with any disqualified parties.

Will Barnard
  • 13K posts
  • 7.7K votes

Will Barnard (Moderator) -
Developer from Santa Clarita, CA

replied almost 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Doreen Chaisson :

With regard to UBIT - this may not always apply. If your IRA leverages the purchase and rehab of the property, it definitely will. If you purchase it outright with your IRA and rehab it with IRA funds, and only rehab one or two properties per year, you may not owe any UBIT if there's no leverage. Each state has regulations on when an IRA account that is buying/flipping reaches "dealer status" (usually more than a handful of transactions per year, check with your own state) at which point it is no longer involved in passive investing, but will be considered a real estate operating company, subject to UBIT whether or not there is leverage in the picture.

This too is not entirely correct, though, there are situations where it could be correct. "Intent" is a major factor that comes into play. If you flipped 2 houses in a calendar year and you had no other RE investments, the IRS would consider both transactions as subject to UBIT as the intent was clear as to what you were doing, on the flip side, if you bought several rentals and sold one or two that where intended to be holds but circumstances changed and warranted to need to sell, you may avoid UBIT for that one or two that turned into flips. I do say "may" because you may still get hit with UBIT. Point is, factor in that tax to arrive at your true ROI on a flip completed inside a qualified retirement account.

@Brian Eastman's responses to this issue were spot on.

Jon Holdman
  • 22K posts
  • 14K votes

Jon Holdman (Moderator) -
Rental Property Investor from Mercer Island, WA

replied almost 4 years ago

@Doreen Chaisson perhaps you know something I don't.

With regard to UBIT - this may not always apply. If your IRA leverages the purchase and rehab of the property, it definitely will. If you purchase it outright with your IRA and rehab it with IRA funds, and only rehab one or two properties per year, you may not owe any UBIT if there's no leverage. Each state has regulations on when an IRA account that is buying/flipping reaches "dealer status" (usually more than a handful of transactions per year, check with your own state) at which point it is no longer involved in passive investing, but will be considered a real estate operating company, subject to UBIT whether or not there is leverage in the picture.

Sorry, but I believe this is just flat wrong. "Doing one or two a year" is irrelevant. State laws are irrelevant. The IRS documentation on when UBIT applies is pretty clear. If you're engaged in an active business, and fix and flipping absolutely is, then your business is subject to UBIT. That's not just my opinion, that's also the opinion of the attorney I've worked with on SDIRA issues.

If you were to buy a house to be a rental and then received an offer that's too good to pass up, you could avoid having that designated as an active investment. In my case, I had a property my IRA made a loan on that ended up being repossessed. The CPA I worked with on that also advised there would be no UBIT because there was never any intent to buy and sell property. But if your intent is to fix and flip houses inside your IRA, even one or two a year, then the proceeds are subject to UBIT.

If you can provide a pointer to IRS documents or case law that supports your opinion, I'd be interested in seeing that.

Doreen Chaisson
  • 175 posts
  • 101 votes

Doreen Chaisson
Professional from Portsmouth, New Hampshire

replied almost 4 years ago

Hence my use of the word "may" - as a passive SD IRA custodian and administrator, we always encourage our clients to seek the counsel of a qualified attorney and/or CPA before engaging in any transaction with their Self-Directed IRA. Based on my 14 years' experience, we have not seen anyone rehabbing 1 - 2 properties per year pay UBIT tax. However, and again, the calculation of UBIT tax is not the responsibility of the SD IRA custodian.  I was merely trying to correct some misinformation on this threat about UBIT always applying, about funneling income out of the IRA, and about LLCs being required.  I apologize if my comments added any confusion.

Jon Holdman
  • 22K posts
  • 14K votes

Jon Holdman (Moderator) -
Rental Property Investor from Mercer Island, WA

replied almost 4 years ago

@Doreen Chaisson have you had one of your customers who's doing one or two rehabs a year, not paying UBIT get audited?  What was the outcome?  I do not believe any such exception exists.  As a friend once told me, "everything works until you get caught". 

Doreen Chaisson
  • 175 posts
  • 101 votes

Doreen Chaisson
Professional from Portsmouth, New Hampshire

replied almost 4 years ago

As I said, custodians do not get involved with UBIT calculations. When UBIT tax calculations and tax bills are presented to us for payment, we send the tax payment out of the IRA. It is the responsibility of the IRA owner and his or her attorney/CPA to be sure they are not running afoul of any IRS regulations.

Adam A.
  • 222 posts
  • 124 votes

Adam A.
Investor from Toledo, Ohio

replied almost 4 years ago

How about borrowing from a Solo 401K to invest in RE and pay it back in at the end of the first year?  For example, flip costs $50K and profited $20K for a total $70K.  Paid the loan @ 5% by the end of the first year about $41K (monthly payment about $1K).  Would I pay UBIT on $20K, $29K (20K profit + 9K left over paid off first year).

I hope I explained it right.

Will Barnard
  • 13K posts
  • 7.7K votes

Will Barnard (Moderator) -
Developer from Santa Clarita, CA

replied almost 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Adam A. :

How about borrowing from a Solo 401K to invest in RE and pay it back in at the end of the first year?  For example, flip costs $50K and profited $20K for a total $70K.  Paid the loan @ 5% by the end of the first year about $41K (monthly payment about $1K).  Would I pay UBIT on $20K, $29K (20K profit + 9K left over paid off first year).

I hope I explained it right.

 If you use borrowing provisions from a 401k, then the borrowed funds become "outside the plan" and may be used for any purpose you wish. If profits are made, then you would only owe income tax on the profits. This of course is under the assumption that all principle and interest from the loan is paid back in full. If not, it would be considered a distribution and be subject to taxes and early withdrawal penalties.

Greg Wright
  • 30 posts
  • 1 votes

Greg Wright
Investor from Wolcott, Connecticut

replied almost 4 years ago

Thanks for all the responses. It seems the self directed IRA is best suited for buy and hold. From the responses flipping is looked at it as a ongoing business by the IRS subjecting yourself to UBIT, 10% early withdrawal penalty and then regular taxes on top of that. Seems very little profit left if any after all the costs.

  • 1
  • 2

Top Contributors

Russell Brazil
Russell Brazil
Rockville, MD
7.11
Score
William C.
William C.
Souderton, PA
3.67
Score
Greg Dickerson
Greg Dickerson
3.13
Score
Kuba F.
Kuba F.
Los Angeles, CA
2.87
Score
Anthony M.
Anthony M.
South Bend, IN
2.66
Score

Trending Discussions

  • Should I report this agent to the Board of Realtors or?
    108 Replies
  • California to make "Solar "mandatory for new Homes!!!!!!
    62 Replies
  • Does Number of Days on MLS affect your buying decisions?
    82 Replies
  • Should we wait or go for it?
    39 Replies
  • How many of you have bought a note this year ?
    29 Replies
Close Thin

Create Lasting Wealth Through Real Estate

Join the millions of people achieving financial freedom through the power of real estate investing

Start here

Already have an account? Click here to log in

Log in Sign up

Log in

Forgot password?

If you signed up for BiggerPockets via Facebook, you can log in with just one click!

Log in with Facebook

Let's get started

We just need a few details to get you set up and ready to go!

Use your real name

Use at least 8 characters. Using a phrase of random words (like: paper Dog team blue) is secure and easy to remember.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.

Why create an account?

Receive a free digital download of The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing.

Connect with 1,000,000+ real estate investors!

Find local real estate meetups and events in your area.

Start analyzing real estate properties, we do the math for you.

It's free!

Explore

  • Membership
  • Community
  • Education
  • Marketplace
  • Tools
  • Perks
  • iOS App
  • Android App

Company

  • About Us
  • Press
  • Advertising
  • Careers
  • Stats
  • Contact Us

Important

  • Terms of Use
  • Rules
  • Privacy
  • FAQ

Social

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
© 2004-2019 BiggerPockets, LLC. All Rights Reserved.