So, I'm looking at HUD's fair market rent for the area I just purchased a property in. It is a few hundred below what my inspector friend [who is also a landlord] told me I could get for the place.
What exactly does fair market rent mean? Is it what HUD has determined is fair? Is it unlawful for me to ask for more? Is it a minimum? I feel like this is a "explain it like I'm 5" question.
Fair marker rent from HUD point of view is just an encapsulated survey of realtors and other industry people of what an average place of x size will rent for. It cannot cover all micro areas anywhere. It also provides subsidized housing parameters so that they aren't paying inflated figures for section 8 renters. You can rent on the free market for a million dollars as long as it is not rent controlled or paid through a program like section 8.
If you are not doing section 8, you can charge whatever you want and if someone is willing to pay it, great. If you're not doing Section 8 all of the below is useless so stop reading here. If you ARE doing section 8, keep reading.
Section 8 has a maximum that they won't pay over and no amount of persuading will get them to come up. Also, realize that each state Section 8 treats FMR differently in their calculations. In my state, they use the gross FMR value and then subtract whatever utilities you don't include (which they also have published rates for). So, let's say FMR value is 1200 for my house the published utilities are 300, I could get 900/month for a home. However, my local inspectors will only give that amount for a house they think has all the 'amenities' meaning washer/dryer/fridge/dispoal/dishwasher/stove/oven/etc. So, in my state, those FMR values would be for a brand new home with all the amenities in the best neighborhood.
I could not find any type of 'formula' online, at least not an officially published one to help figure out what they'd be willing to pay. But apparently in my state things like total square footage and age of the property come into play (despite their website saying they rent by number of bedrooms). I know for a fact that the local section 8 inspectors go by what is already rented in the neighborhood. I've negotiated a little with inspectors and they will work with me if they can.
Unfortunately, regular market rents aren't published like sales prices are (at least to my knowledge, someone chime in if they are), so inspectors tend to go by what other section 8 properties are rented for. If you want to get top dollar for your section 8 rental, see if you have a connection with a realtor or property management company that is willing to tell you what their rentals in your neighborhood go for (and include stats like bedroom size, square footage, year built, utilities or appliances included). They have to be willing to confirm this with Section 8, but I've simply forwarded emails in the past and sometimes that is accepted (sometimes not, depends on inspector).
@Lois Stern An excellent question, with a long, complicated answer :-).
First off, before I give a short and long answer, I'll echo what others have already said: FMRs for your area may or may not reflect what you can actually rent your place for. Your own homework or other expert opinions on what your exact place in your exact location are going to be much more valuable than the broad numbers your local PHA uses for a much larger area. That said, here's a short and long version on how they come up with numbers for your area and how they may be helpful to you.
SHORT ANSWER: Your local FMRs are calculated by HUD periodically to reflect the 40th or 50th %ile of rents+utility costs borne by the tenant. In other words, they seek to reflect what HUD would expect a solidly blue collar American renting a foursquare, adequate place to pay in the PHA's area. This can be a helpful # if you want a safe estimate of what a B class property can rent for in an area you're not familiar with, provided comps for the neighborhood aren't way off. As the number includes utilities, you'll need to knock it down $50 to $150 depending on unit size and utility costs in your area to reflect just the rent HUD calculates, minus the utilities.
LONG ANSWER: Your local FMRs are the result of a mindbogglingly complex formula that usually reflects a multi year rolling 40th %ile of rents+utilities borne by the tenants in a PHAs area. If that seems like an overly broad, one size fits all neighborhoods number that could lead to a lot of areas where that number is ether way too high or way too low, that's because it is. If you live in a large city (top 10 type city), your PHA probably uses the 50th %ile to help open up more of the city to Section 8 voucher holders. This helps a bit, but still runs into the same issue of being a one size fits all number. In recent years, about half a dozen PHAs in large urban areas have piloted zip code specific FMRs to tailor rents more specifically to neighborhoods rather than just the whole city. These efforts have shown decent promise, and there is currently a proposal to expand the program to the top 20-40 cities nationwide.
Now, where on earth does HUD get enough info to plug into this formula to spit out the FMRs for an area, and whats a more simple way to explain how they actually get the FMR? HUD uses data from rent surveys for 2 bedroom units, supplemented by general rent trends in smaller areas that may not generate enough data in rent surveys on an annual basis, to calculate the amount of rent paid. HUD then also partners with NOAA and utilities to estimate how much utilities cost and whether weather is a substantial factor in those calculations. They then use set %ages up and down to give you FMRs for other size units. This obviously has the potential limitation of being inaccurate if rents for a particular unit size are skewed high or low in your area, but in general are surprisingly accurate.
But wait! There's more! HUD is the first to raise their hand and admit that a single number isn't a great reflection of rents across all neighborhoods, so they give local PHAs some tools to help ensure they have flexibility to make sure vouchers are able to be used in decent areas of the city, as well as make sure they're not paying 150% market rent for a unit in a war-zone. The first is a broad strokes tool where the PHA can adjust the FMR for the whole area by up to 5-10% up or down. The main purpose of this is usually for small areas to tweak their FMRs to better reflect rents where the lack of data hampered a good initial calculation, to chase a skyrocketing or plunging market more closely (remember the 3 year rolling set of data HUD uses) or to soften big swings in FMR for current tenants. The PHA also can assign FMRs by neighborhood (outside of the pilot program I mentioned), provide exceptions for tenants to rent places above FMR if they require reasonable accommodations, and is required to not spend more than market rent for a unit, even if the unit is under the FMR cap (ie don't pay top dollar for war-zone units). There are other tools as well, but those are the easy to explain ones. PHAs use some or all of them in different ways, sometimes giving the impression to landlords like @Amy E. that inspectors are just taking a guess at things. The bottom line is your local PHA has a lot of leeway to make sure that they have a good process to assess whether a tenant/the gov't is overpaying for a unit.
Now, practically speaking, what are some of the things an inspector might take into account when checking whether you're way above market or not on a unit? Ask your inspector! It really does vary quite a bit locally as to how much your PHA digs to see if your place s above market. In some places, like Baltimore, we have landlords on the boards talking regularly about how they're able to achieve a good premium above market renting to Section 8 tenants. Clearly, those inspectors are choosing housed tenants over worrying about spending too much. Conversely, there are locales which will use sq ft, amenities, neighborhood, comps and condition to see what your place is worth to them, in an effort to save the taxpayers some money.
A few final notes, the HUD website always publishes all of their data and FMRs for all areas here: http://www.huduser.org/portal/datasets/fmr.html
Your local PHA will give you a copy of their FMRs and local utility values if you go into the office and ask. Many also have them on their websites, but not all. Some are still stuck in the Stone Age. They are separate non-profit entities from HUD, so small town PHAs can seem pretty backward sometimes.
You can always calculate what the max someone with X income and a voucher can rent your unit for using the Happy Software rent calculator. Someone posted it in the downloads section of BP. Not the most intuitive to use, so if anyone ever has questons, shoot me a PM and I can walk you through it. Easy once you get the hang of it though.
Final caveat, while FMRs are the max you can charge for rent, and reflect the maximum a PHA is willing to subsidize your unit for rent+utilities, you can usually get closer to that FMR number for your rent due to the "40% rule" and sometimes through some extra, more complicated tricks as well. If any of those last two sentances confused you, forget I mentioned them. They're worth another book length post and math lesson in and of themselves :-).
Hope this helped!
Thank you all. I love that @Bradley Bogdan , you seem to write the way you speak. I could hear your imaginary voice trying to help lead me thru the information. Nothing is ever simple when it involves government.
Free eBook from BiggerPockets!
Join BiggerPockets and get The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing for FREE - read by more than 100,000 people - AND get exclusive real estate investing tips, tricks and techniques delivered straight to your inbox twice weekly!
- Actionable advice for getting started,
- Discover the 10 Most Lucrative Real Estate Niches,
- Learn how to get started with or without money,
- Explore Real-Life Strategies for Building Wealth,
- And a LOT more.
Sign up below to download the eBook for FREE today!
We hate spam just as much as you
Create Lasting Wealth Through Real Estate
Join the millions of people achieving financial freedom through the power of real estate investing