Cash out now (DSCR) or wait until next spring (conventional)?

Cash out now (DSCR) or wait until next spring (conventional)?

Rental Property Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2019 · 38 posts · 13 votes

Not my first BRRRR, but have some concerns with the current state of local values, mixed with a few personal factors. Just looking for some differing opinions, while I fully understand there isn't a "right or wrong" answer here.

I wrapped up my latest renovation project a few months back, and now we have a great renter in place. Here are some rough numbers on the deal.


Purchase = $118k

Rehab = $65k

Rent = $2000/month

Mortgage = $900/month (conventional 7.8% rate)

ARV = $250k (very few recent sales/comps have me questioning this number more than my past deals)

My plan was to cash out with a DSCR loan in September, but with rates high and values low, I am not considering waiting until next spring to conventionally cash out, saving money up front and getting a lower rate. In addition, with market and appraisal uncertainty, I don't want to go 0/3: appraised value (lower cash out), interest rate (higher rate) and closing costs (paying more). The benefit is pulling my cash out quicker and putting it into another deal. Or, putting it towards a contingency fund for our family (below)...

We are expecting our first child in September, and as much as I'd love to have the extra cash on hand in case our primary residence or rentals have any emergency issues that need swiftly handled to alleviate stress while on new dad duty, I don't want to rush into the DSCR cash out and end up not using the funds before next spring anyway. In that case, waiting and going with a conventional cash out in Spring 2026 (with hopefully lower rates and/or higher appraised values) would be the best move.


The current cash flow on this property alone is fantastic, and I do also work a full-time W-2 job, but I am torn between expediting the cash out process or waiting a few more months to hope to improvements to all 3 of the aforementioned items.

Any advice, considerations or ideas to get my plan set would be much appreciated!

2Reply
165 views

Most Popular Reply

AJ ExnerPro Member
Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 665 posts · 320 votes
1y

Hey Robert,

Congrats on the news! Definitely makes things more interesting!

As for the refinance, you are probably seeing prices dip because of the current rate environment we find ourselves in. With higher rates, less people are buying which is keeping supply up. That, in turn, brings prices (comps and ARVs) down, supply-demand.

That being said, I don't think that time is going to make anything much better. **OPINION - NON EDUCATED ALERT** Rates might be a little better, but values might not be.

I think you might have to wait too long if you did that, and in my experience, money 'now' is better than money 'later'. Obviously it is your decision but if you are in a good debt vs. equity position, it might be worth dipping your toe in the water to try.

Good luck though, happy to connect and talk through it more if you would like.

See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • AJ ExnerPro Member
    Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 665 posts · 320 votes
    1y

    Hey Robert,

    Congrats on the news! Definitely makes things more interesting!

    As for the refinance, you are probably seeing prices dip because of the current rate environment we find ourselves in. With higher rates, less people are buying which is keeping supply up. That, in turn, brings prices (comps and ARVs) down, supply-demand.

    That being said, I don't think that time is going to make anything much better. **OPINION - NON EDUCATED ALERT** Rates might be a little better, but values might not be.

    I think you might have to wait too long if you did that, and in my experience, money 'now' is better than money 'later'. Obviously it is your decision but if you are in a good debt vs. equity position, it might be worth dipping your toe in the water to try.

    Good luck though, happy to connect and talk through it more if you would like.

    • Rental Property Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2019 · 38 posts · 13 votes
      1y
      Quote from @AJ Exner:

      Hey Robert,

      Congrats on the news! Definitely makes things more interesting!

      As for the refinance, you are probably seeing prices dip because of the current rate environment we find ourselves in. With higher rates, less people are buying which is keeping supply up. That, in turn, brings prices (comps and ARVs) down, supply-demand.

      That being said, I don't think that time is going to make anything much better. **OPINION - NON EDUCATED ALERT** Rates might be a little better, but values might not be.

      I think you might have to wait too long if you did that, and in my experience, money 'now' is better than money 'later'. Obviously it is your decision but if you are in a good debt vs. equity position, it might be worth dipping your toe in the water to try.

      Good luck though, happy to connect and talk through it more if you would like.


      AJ, thank you for this! I agree about money now > money later, which is why this was my plan all along. Still, I'm hoping rates ease within 6 months or so, causing a more sales in my area. The other issue is, I'm used to having several solid comps within 6 months to go off before cashing out, but there are so few direct/recent comps right now that I'm not sure whether an appraiser would go back past 6 months to find a direct comp (4 bed/2 bath, OR use recent sales but try to adjust versus a 3/2, for instance. If they're more likely to use direct (but >6 month) comps, then my value should be strong. However, if the appraiser pulls recent 3/2 or 4/1 sales, I think the values will (unfortunately) reflect the slightly "down" current local market. Not sure if you or anyone has insight on this aspect, but anything is appreciated. Thanks!

  • Member since 2025 · 19 posts · 15 votes
    1y

    Robert, I would see what rate I could get and how much cash out while keeping the LTV rate steady. Time value of money says that you get the money now invest or just put in a HYSA to draw interest for you until you decide your next move. I'm currently near the same predicament. I brought a MF for 65k rehab is expected to be complete in 2 weeks which my guest rough estimate will appraise for 300-320k. Once I lock in my move I'll provide an update!

    • Zachary DealPro Member
      Lender · Member since 2023 · 465 posts · 425 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Beauford Jefferies:

      Robert, I would see what rate I could get and how much cash out while keeping the LTV rate steady. Time value of money says that you get the money now invest or just put in a HYSA to draw interest for you until you decide your next move. I'm currently near the same predicament. I brought a MF for 65k rehab is expected to be complete in 2 weeks which my guest rough estimate will appraise for 300-320k. Once I lock in my move I'll provide an update!


       Think this is great advice. With the market shifting to more of a buyers market it's nice to have cash on hand in case you want to purchase another rental

  • AJ ExnerPro Member
    Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 665 posts · 320 votes
    1y

    In my recent experience, I'm seeing appraisers lean on recent comps with adjusters. 

    Actually had a client lately who was refinancing a quadplex up in Pittsburgh that ran into a similar issue. We ended up doing two appraisals and they both came in lower than we expected.

    Unfortunately we are in the 'dating' phase, dating the rate, marrying the property. We know that a solid, cash-flowing property will appreciate well over the next couple of years, so taking on the rate environment with a DSCR loan with a reduced Prepayment Penalty has been a good solution for a few folks that I know that are taking it on right now.

    Best of both worlds

  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Robert Kohnfelder:

    Not my first BRRRR, but have some concerns with the current state of local values, mixed with a few personal factors. Just looking for some differing opinions, while I fully understand there isn't a "right or wrong" answer here.

    I wrapped up my latest renovation project a few months back, and now we have a great renter in place. Here are some rough numbers on the deal.


    Purchase = $118k

    Rehab = $65k

    Rent = $2000/month

    Mortgage = $900/month (conventional 7.8% rate)

    ARV = $250k (very few recent sales/comps have me questioning this number more than my past deals)

    My plan was to cash out with a DSCR loan in September, but with rates high and values low, I am not considering waiting until next spring to conventionally cash out, saving money up front and getting a lower rate. In addition, with market and appraisal uncertainty, I don't want to go 0/3: appraised value (lower cash out), interest rate (higher rate) and closing costs (paying more). The benefit is pulling my cash out quicker and putting it into another deal. Or, putting it towards a contingency fund for our family (below)...

    We are expecting our first child in September, and as much as I'd love to have the extra cash on hand in case our primary residence or rentals have any emergency issues that need swiftly handled to alleviate stress while on new dad duty, I don't want to rush into the DSCR cash out and end up not using the funds before next spring anyway. In that case, waiting and going with a conventional cash out in Spring 2026 (with hopefully lower rates and/or higher appraised values) would be the best move.


    The current cash flow on this property alone is fantastic, and I do also work a full-time W-2 job, but I am torn between expediting the cash out process or waiting a few more months to hope to improvements to all 3 of the aforementioned items.

    Any advice, considerations or ideas to get my plan set would be much appreciated!


     Hey Robert, 

    Where would rates need to be in order for a refinance to make sense for you? DSCR pricing is not too far off from conventional loans.

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
  • Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1y

    The rates really aren't hight at all for DSCR's right now. They are in the mid-to-upper 6%s. They have been more favorable than Fannie/Freddie lately.

  • Lender · Member since 2021 · 500 posts · 131 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Robert Kohnfelder:

    Not my first BRRRR, but have some concerns with the current state of local values, mixed with a few personal factors. Just looking for some differing opinions, while I fully understand there isn't a "right or wrong" answer here.

    I wrapped up my latest renovation project a few months back, and now we have a great renter in place. Here are some rough numbers on the deal.


    Purchase = $118k

    Rehab = $65k

    Rent = $2000/month

    Mortgage = $900/month (conventional 7.8% rate)

    ARV = $250k (very few recent sales/comps have me questioning this number more than my past deals)

    My plan was to cash out with a DSCR loan in September, but with rates high and values low, I am not considering waiting until next spring to conventionally cash out, saving money up front and getting a lower rate. In addition, with market and appraisal uncertainty, I don't want to go 0/3: appraised value (lower cash out), interest rate (higher rate) and closing costs (paying more). The benefit is pulling my cash out quicker and putting it into another deal. Or, putting it towards a contingency fund for our family (below)...

    We are expecting our first child in September, and as much as I'd love to have the extra cash on hand in case our primary residence or rentals have any emergency issues that need swiftly handled to alleviate stress while on new dad duty, I don't want to rush into the DSCR cash out and end up not using the funds before next spring anyway. In that case, waiting and going with a conventional cash out in Spring 2026 (with hopefully lower rates and/or higher appraised values) would be the best move.


    The current cash flow on this property alone is fantastic, and I do also work a full-time W-2 job, but I am torn between expediting the cash out process or waiting a few more months to hope to improvements to all 3 of the aforementioned items.

    Any advice, considerations or ideas to get my plan set would be much appreciated!


    Robert, you are not the only one with this dilemma. I look back and think about clients that thought rates were gonna drop soon when they were 5% for example , a couple of year ago now. Unfortunately we can never perfectly time the market, the best you can do is find something that you can live with. Rates being in the 6's for many scenarios currently, could give you a nice boost. The other thing to consider is if your market will continue to soften, which could impact the value. I have also had clients wait to refinance and their market decreased, which inhibited their ability to accomplish a good BRRRR. Of course, both rates could drop and values could increase, but you only have the present circumstances.

    Good luck!

  • Alex HilemanPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2023 · 225 posts · 147 votes
    1y

    Hey Robert, congrats on the baby! 

    Here's some good news for you: mortgage rates just dropped to their lowest point in nearly a year at 6.57%. I would look at rates and property values with a long terms lens, instead of trying to time them week by week. Right now, rates are relatively low, and Pittsburgh property values have appreciated 10% just in the past 2 years. The Pittsburgh real estate market has been historically stable in appreciation. It is very likely that mortgage rates and property values will continue trending up. 

    From my experience of working with appraisers, they usually use more recent comps and adjust. Property values, demand, and inventory tend to dip in the winter and peak in the summer. 

    If you hold or sell, you're coming out on top either way. Looks like you picked a good investment!

  • Alex BekezaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    It sounds like you have a pretty good grip of your options and it really just depends on the opportunity cost is in terms of whether cashing out now would allow you to put another BRRRR in motion but on the other hand I'd imagine your lady would prefer your undivided attention over the next few months! (haha speaking as BRRRR investor who has had to answer deal emails from the delivery room)

  • Zachary DealPro Member
    Lender · Member since 2023 · 465 posts · 425 votes
    1y

    Rates have dropped to the lowest levels in quite some time so it could be a good time to explore the refi. Waiting for rates to drop further runs the risk of a market uptick. I think if you're happy with your options now I'd move forward 

  • Rental Property Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2019 · 38 posts · 13 votes
    1y

    Just a follow-up here: Decided to move pursue the DSCR cash-out refi and got the appraisal back at right around the initial expected ARV. Upon reviewing some recent sales, I pushed back and (for the first time in several attempts over the years) got the appraised value increased by about 5%. Moving forward with the cash-out process and looking for my next move -- after the new addition to the family!

    • Zachary DealPro Member
      Lender · Member since 2023 · 465 posts · 425 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Robert Kohnfelder:

      Just a follow-up here: Decided to move pursue the DSCR cash-out refi and got the appraisal back at right around the initial expected ARV. Upon reviewing some recent sales, I pushed back and (for the first time in several attempts over the years) got the appraised value increased by about 5%. Moving forward with the cash-out process and looking for my next move -- after the new addition to the family!


       Nice! Doesn't hurt to try for a reconsideration of value if you have strong comps to justify an increase

    • Investor · Member since 2025 · 5 posts · 3 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Robert Kohnfelder:

      Just a follow-up here: Decided to move pursue the DSCR cash-out refi and got the appraisal back at right around the initial expected ARV. Upon reviewing some recent sales, I pushed back and (for the first time in several attempts over the years) got the appraised value increased by about 5%. Moving forward with the cash-out process and looking for my next move -- after the new addition to the family!


       Congrats... What areas are you most active in... I'm from Pittsburgh as well... Great market as you can still get property at good prices compared to the rest of the country and still tremendous room for growth to the upside... 

  • Arman AhmedPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 976 votes
    1y

    @Robert Kohnfelder

    Hi Robert,

    Congrats on the new renter and the baby on the way! With strong cash flow, DSCR now gives quick access to funds for new deals or contingencies, but rates might be higher. Waiting for conventional could mean better terms but ties up your capital. Some investors split it: pull a bit now, then refinance later.

    Happy to chat more if you want to dive deeper into strategies!

  • Alex HilemanPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2023 · 225 posts · 147 votes
    1y

    @Robert Kohnfelder congrats!! Great job negotiating your appraisal and showing them updated comps. Now you can take it easy with the new baby!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.