Deal Snapshot (I'd like your take)

Deal Snapshot (I'd like your take)

Investor · Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2024 · 66 posts · 39 votes

Investment Info (2-unit buy & hold)

  • Purchase price: $155,000 (80% LTV - $124,000 loan)

  • Amortization / rate: 30-yr @ 8.420%, 5-yr prepay

  • P&I: $946.43/mo | PITIA est.: $1,266.43/mo (adds ~$320 T+I)

  • Cash to close (incl. points/escrows): ~$39.5k

Why I’m looking at it

  • Duplex in a rent-rising area; path to market rents looks plausible.

  • Bring both units to market

  • Exit flexibility: holds as C-class cash flow, or refi if rates ease.

Rents (current vs. market)

  • In-place: Unit 1 $1,100, Unit 2 $1,050 - $2,150/mo total

  • Market used in pro forma: $1,200/unit - $2,400/mo total

  • Rentometer trend (2BR/1BA, 1-mile): Avg ~$1,017 - $1,180 over 48-6 mo; median $1,000 - $1,395 (small recent sample).

  • My near-term view: Avg $1,200–$1,250, median $1,400–$1,450 (if demand holds).

How it pencils (high level)

  • At current rents ($2,150):

    • NOI: ≈ $15,006/yr | DSCR: ~1.32 | Cap: ~9.7%

    • Cash flow: ≈ $89/mo - very thin cushion.

  • At market ($2,400):

    • CF and DSCR improve

  • Lender view:

    • Uses $2,050 rent and $320 T+I - DSCR 1.62 on their calc.

    • Payment line: P&I $946.43; PITIA ~$1,266.43.

  • Fees: 2.5% origination + UW/doc + title + escrows push cash-to-close to ~$39.5k

What could go wrong (quick flags)

  • Execution risk: Thin cash flow at in-place rents; delays to $1,200/unit hurt.

  • Sample size: Recent rent comps are sparse - higher volatility.

  • Leverage & prepay: 5-yr prepay + 8.42% rate = limited exit flexibility near-term.

  • Ops assumptions: Vacancy ~7%, PM ~9–10% - small misses swing DSCR.

1Reply
46 views

Most Popular Reply

Zachary DealPro Member
Lender · Member since 2023 · 465 posts · 425 votes
1y

Rate seems high based on the numbers even for a DSCR loan. The DSCR does look solid even at the high rate

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Scott WolfPro Member
    Lender · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 960 votes
    1y

    Very thin margins, and are you accounting for reserves and vacancy there?

    Also, not sure where your FICO sits, but you should be able to get a better rate than that.

  • Jaycee GreenePro Member
    Real Estate Consultant · St. Louis MSA · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 728 votes
    1y

    Hey @Daniel M.! You lost me at 8.42%...that rate is WAY too high in this market. Should be closer to 6.42% in reality if your CS is over 720.

  • Zachary DealPro Member
    Lender · Member since 2023 · 465 posts · 425 votes
    1y

    Rate seems high based on the numbers even for a DSCR loan. The DSCR does look solid even at the high rate

  • Investor · Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2024 · 66 posts · 39 votes
    1y

    Appreciate the gut checks — here’s where I’m at and a couple asks:

    Margins/reserves

    • Yes, underwriting includes vacancy (7%), PM (~9–10%), taxes/insurance, and reserves for repairs/CapEx.

    • At in-place rents ($2,150/mo) the model shows ~$89/mo cash flow after debt + vacancy + reserves with DSCR ~1.32.

    • Getting to market ($2,400/mo) materially improves cushion, but I’m not banking on it Day 1.

    Rate / product

    • I have two current quotes from credit unions: 8.420% and 8.375% (30-yr amort, DSCR, 80% LTV, 5-yr prepay).

    • If ~6.4% is realistic today on a DSCR for a 2-unit at 80% LTV, I’d love intros to those lenders.

    • Jaycee GreenePro Member
      Real Estate Consultant · St. Louis MSA · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 728 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Daniel M.:

      Appreciate the gut checks — here’s where I’m at and a couple asks:

      Margins/reserves

      • Yes, underwriting includes vacancy (7%), PM (~9–10%), taxes/insurance, and reserves for repairs/CapEx.

      • At in-place rents ($2,150/mo) the model shows ~$89/mo cash flow after debt + vacancy + reserves with DSCR ~1.32.

      • Getting to market ($2,400/mo) materially improves cushion, but I’m not banking on it Day 1.

      Rate / product

      • I have two current quotes from credit unions: 8.420% and 8.375% (30-yr amort, DSCR, 80% LTV, 5-yr prepay).

      • If ~6.4% is realistic today on a DSCR for a 2-unit at 80% LTV, I’d love intros to those lenders.

      @Daniel M. Where is the property located? I assume it's not in Brooklyn...

    • Jay HurstBusiness Member
      Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Daniel M.:

      Appreciate the gut checks — here’s where I’m at and a couple asks:

      Margins/reserves

      • Yes, underwriting includes vacancy (7%), PM (~9–10%), taxes/insurance, and reserves for repairs/CapEx.

      • At in-place rents ($2,150/mo) the model shows ~$89/mo cash flow after debt + vacancy + reserves with DSCR ~1.32.

      • Getting to market ($2,400/mo) materially improves cushion, but I’m not banking on it Day 1.

      Rate / product

      • I have two current quotes from credit unions: 8.420% and 8.375% (30-yr amort, DSCR, 80% LTV, 5-yr prepay).

      • If ~6.4% is realistic today on a DSCR for a 2-unit at 80% LTV, I’d love intros to those lenders.

      6.42 is not realistic for a DSCR at 80% ona two unit without paying way too much in upfront interest (also called discount points) but 8.420 is also too high with a good credit AND a 5 year pre-payment penalty. Do not discount how much a PPP can cost you in a (likely) declining interest rate enviroment.

      PLUS,  PA does not allow for pre-payment penlaties for 1-2 unit properties with a loan amounts under 312k.  Another reason to look elsewhere. 

      Hurst Real Estate, INC4.986 Reviews
  • Investor · Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2024 · 66 posts · 39 votes
    1y

    I wish I could buy a duplex in Brooklyn for $155k. It's in Lansford, PA.

    • Jaycee GreenePro Member
      Real Estate Consultant · St. Louis MSA · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 728 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Daniel M.:

      I wish I could buy a duplex in Brooklyn for $155k. It's in Lansford, PA.

       @Daniel M. I'm doing loan consulting for another investor in Upstate NY and she got a local credit union to do a 79% LTV at a 7.24% fixed interest rate, and that was a month ago and rates have trended down since then.

      Also, a credit union charging a 2.5% origination fee is VERY high! The CU from above is charging $500! And that's for a cash out refi for a loan of $439,000.

  • Specialist · NJ · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 663 votes
    1y

    8.4% is high. I just closed a DSCR NY purchase for 1.25 Million at 7.06%. I wouldn't do that loan at all.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.