Skip to content
Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice

User Stats

6,200
Posts
4,337
Votes
Dawn Anastasi
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
4,337
Votes |
6,200
Posts

I paid off a house in just 3 years!

Dawn Anastasi
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
Posted Sep 22 2015, 19:11

I actually have 2 things to celebrate today:

1. This is my 5,000 post to Bigger Pockets!!!

2. The last payment was made on a property I bought in 2012 using peer to peer lending on a 3 year loan!

What better way to celebrate my 5,000th post than a success story of using creative finance to buy a house without much money?

Here's the story:

Back in late 2012, I found a 3 bedroom property that was on the MLS for just $23,000. I thought "Wow, I have to see that one!" (This was back in the days when more houses could be bought in the sub-$30k range.)

I contacted my Realtor and he contacted the seller's Realtor.  I didn't hear anything and tried to find out what was going on. My Realtor said "the listing agent said the tenants are being difficult and aren't letting anyone see the property".

So, being the type of person that doesn't let a little thing like that stop me, I drove over to the property and knocked on the door.  A woman answered and I let her know that I understood the house was for sale and I was looking to buy a property like this as a rental property.  I asked her if I could please see the interior.  She said sure, and gave me such a great tour.  She was friendly and personable and when I told her what the listing Realtor said, she said she's never been "difficult".  She did point out a few deferred maintenance items that the prior property manager (who was also the listing Realtor) never fixed.  I asked her what she was paying in rent and I told her I would lower her rent by $75/month and she hugged me, she was so happy! She said her and her husband are on a fixed income and that $75 would make so much of a difference in their lives.

I did an internet search and found the email for the seller directly (oh, the things you can find on the internet these days!) and emailed him and said "I would like to buy your house and I will pay your asking price and I will pay cash."  He seemed a little suspicious but said I would need to go through his Realtor.  So I had my Realtor write up an offer and submit it to the listing agent.  He then accepted the offer.

Meanwhile, I hopped on the Peer to Peer lending site Prosper, and requested a loan for $18,000.  (I had the other cash saved up to close.)  I deposited my earnest money and waited for my loan to fund which was extremely quick and I got a large deposit to my bank account within 2.5 weeks.  I then closed on the house!

After closing, I took care of the deferred maintenance items:

a) Water heater was extremely old, rusty, and leaky - replaced it.

b) Leaks in the shower and the toilet would always run.  Fixed both of them.

c) Insurance company required a railing be added to the front steps.  Added it.

d) Home inspection turned up that the chimney needed to be tuck-pointed.  Got that done.

Overall repairs cost me about $1,600 and in the 3 years I've owned the property I've also had one furnace repair that cost about $400.

So I paid $5,000 out of pocket for the hours, then $2,000 for repairs.  In the 3 years I've owned the house, I've collected $875/month in rent.  That's $31,500 in rent over the course of those 3 years, which is more than what I paid for the house and the repairs together!  Best of all, my Prosper loan payments were in essence paid for me by the tenants through their rent.

The same tenants are still with me to this day, and I've gotten compliments by the local landlord association on how nice they keep their house and yard. 

To me, this was a "home run" deal!

User Stats

48
Posts
23
Votes
Chelsea Ziss
  • Investor
  • Maumee, OH
23
Votes |
48
Posts
Chelsea Ziss
  • Investor
  • Maumee, OH
Replied Oct 31 2015, 16:37
@Dawn Anastasi

Glad to see you have some success - especially with prosper.com, since that's what we're doing too lol.  

User Stats

6,200
Posts
4,337
Votes
Dawn Anastasi
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
4,337
Votes |
6,200
Posts
Dawn Anastasi
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
Replied Oct 31 2015, 16:52
Originally posted by @Mark Spidell:

I like this because it is a win for some many different groups:

  • Tenants wins by getting a better landlord and lower rent
  • Seller wins by getting their price
  • Prosper investors win by enjoying a great loan / borrower
  • Neighbors / community wins by have a tenant in the house that can better take care of it with a better landlord and lower rent
  • Dawn wins on many levels.  Nice!

 Thanks Mark!

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

1,802
Posts
2,826
Votes
Karl B.
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Erie, PA
2,826
Votes |
1,802
Posts
Karl B.
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Erie, PA
Replied Nov 24 2015, 18:40

This is amazing. You did some extra digging and went the extra mile and got a great deal!

User Stats

1
Posts
0
Votes
Replied Jun 14 2021, 15:28

I was searching to see if anyone had used Prosper to help with a down payment on a first rental property as I am thinking about it. 

This is an incredible story. I cannot imagine finding a place in good condition for that price. Must have been the area and the time.

Congratulations on both and keep going you got this!

User Stats

6,200
Posts
4,337
Votes
Dawn Anastasi
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
4,337
Votes |
6,200
Posts
Dawn Anastasi
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
Replied Jun 17 2021, 13:23
Originally posted by @Zoila Perez:

I was searching to see if anyone had used Prosper to help with a down payment on a first rental property as I am thinking about it. 

This is an incredible story. I cannot imagine finding a place in good condition for that price. Must have been the area and the time.

Congratulations on both and keep going you got this!

 Yes, you really cannot find a property in this area right now for that price. Houses in this area are now going for at least 3-4x that amount. From that previous post about 5 years ago, the same tenants are still living in that house. I've had the house for over 8 years now and in that time collected in rent almost 4x what I paid for it.