What are your long term goals? If it’s to own a portfolio of rentals I wouldn’t sell. If it’s something else you may want to.
This post has been removed.
Since it does not sound like you are a driven investor and you are trying to make a decision between personal and investing there are many reasons why you would be best to sell.
Long distance investing has issues you are likely not prepared for, the property appears as though it will be cash flow negative especially after refinancing and your personal home appears to be your priority.
It is probably best if you unburden yourself of the property at this point in time.
Join the Largest Real Estate Investing Community
Basic membership is free, forever.