Best Strategies for a High-Value Market (NY, LA, SF, Seattle, etc...)

Best Strategies for a High-Value Market (NY, LA, SF, Seattle, etc...)

Member since 2024 · 12 posts · 5 votes

Curious to hear folks' thoughts on the recommended approaches for markets where home values are on the higher end. Trying to get started in the real estate investing space, and I live in Seattle where home prices are quite high (at least, in my opinion). I've heard flipping might be a good place to start, but would love to hear about people's opinions and experiences in these types of markets. What tends to work, watchouts, etc...

Thanks in advance!

2Reply
69 views

Most Popular Reply

Michael HaasBusiness Member
Real Estate Agent · Sammamish, 🌧️ Seattle Investor-Agent | 🤑 Helped 400+ Clients Invest in Real Estate | 🏘️ Owns 23 WA Rentals & Airbnbs | 🏗️ Built 5 DADU's | 📈 You Can Do It Too · Member since 2016 · 725 posts · 3k+ votes
2y

@Cameron Daste flipping is highly competitive, as a newbie your about as likely to lose money as make money. Have you considered HouseHacking? Some simple Math:

Lets say you do a Seattle 4plex HouseHack w/ 5% down conventional (a new loan option for multifamily that's better than 3.5% down FHA, just DM me if you want the full rundown on why).

That $70,000 could purchase you a property up to $1,400,000... and to get a 100% ROI on your investment all you need is 5% appreciation on the property. The average appreciation rate in Seattle over the last 40 years has been 5.5%. Cashflow / rents will provide additional ROI but in our experience over a long hold time appreciation will always contribute more to your total ROI than cashflow. Interest rates will also be .25% - 1% lower on an owner occupied property than on a rental property.

Contrast that with buying out of state / non owner occupied properties. That $70,000 now has to go into a 20 - 25% down mortgage, allowing you to purchase a property for $280,000 - $350,000. Now, to see 100% ROI the property would have to appreciate 20 - 25% in value. Cashflow / rents will provide additional ROI but not enough to overshadow the more favorable loan terms and higher value of the househacked property.

This is an oversimplification but I'm sure you get the point! Happy to talk about the strategy more - we're up to over 20 rentals owned in WA now and wouldn't have been able to scale to that level quickly without househacking.

HouseHack Seattle | Michael Haas & Team572 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

12 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Cameron Daste:

    Curious to hear folks' thoughts on the recommended approaches for markets where home values are on the higher end. Trying to get started in the real estate investing space, and I live in Seattle where home prices are quite high (at least, in my opinion). I've heard flipping might be a good place to start, but would love to hear about people's opinions and experiences in these types of markets. What tends to work, watchouts, etc...

    Thanks in advance!


     Flipping

    House hacks
    Live in flip


    …. Always works 

  • Member since 2024 · 12 posts · 5 votes
    2y

    Appreciate the reply here, Carlos! Nice to see what I've heard being validated.

  • Bradley BuxtonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · NV · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 720 votes
    2y

    @Cameron Daste

    Expensive markets require more capital and also have higher dollar value payouts. With any strategy make sure you have enough for reserves. Look on the areas that are on the edges of the priciest areas and the benefits of living there. For example is there new construction, sidewalks, and other transit improvements happening. House hacks are always great and especially if you can find something with a walkout basement or ADU already built.

  • Member since 2024 · 12 posts · 5 votes
    2y

    Thanks, @Bradley Buxton.

    Along this line of thinking, would it make sense to also look into a syndication model? I understand there's more legal ramifications in doing so (LLC creation?). But this model would help in getting together the necessary funds (especially for a down payment and minimizing the potential interest on a loan), while bringing in legal complexity. Thoughts here?

    Houses that I've been looking at are $500 - $750K range.

  • Bradley BuxtonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · NV · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 720 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Cameron Daste:

    Thanks, @Bradley Buxton.

    Along this line of thinking, would it make sense to also look into a syndication model? I understand there's more legal ramifications in doing so (LLC creation?). But this model would help in getting together the necessary funds (especially for a down payment and minimizing the potential interest on a loan), while bringing in legal complexity. Thoughts here?

    Houses that I've been looking at are $500 - $750K range.


    Syndication adds another layer of complexity. It might be easier to look for a partner to put up the capital if you find the deal manage the renovation and other time intensive activities. You still might want to form an LLC. By having only one partner you'll have better control over the asset.

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    2y

    I recently posted a reply on a different thread that is largely applicable on this thread.  

    There is variance in markets but I believe most high price markets are like my market with 2 primary plays 1) patience. RE appreciates. Rents rise. Most mortgages are fixed. 2) value adds. Higher cost markets produce more equity gain for the value add.

    assume both 1 & 2 are best path forward (not 1 or 2). What does this indicate? Unlike common mindset, the value add should be in high cost market to achieve highest return. I recently added a micro half bathroom to a little unit. Guess the value added? ~$40k of value. If I am in a 3 cap area, a dollar of noi equates to $33 of value add. What does half a bathroom equate to in increased rent in high rent market. Use $100/month, $1200/year at 3 cap get $39,600 of added value. In a lower price market, say 6 cap for ease of example that same half bath may only net $50/month increase to NOI, $600/year at 6 cap is $10k of added value. Same value add only produced 25% of the value added. Do you think it costs anywhere close to 4 times as much to add a half bath in high cost RE area than a low cost RE area?

    Ponder it. If you do not understand how NOI and cap rate determine value, learn it even if in theory it only applies to commercial RE.

    If you flip, you realize the gain in the short term.  You can be well compensated for your efforts, but you now have a job.  Stop flipping, stop earning money.

    Is BRRRR dead? I would say it is on life support because after refi the negative cash flow necessitates extra reserves. But what if you purchase with alternate financing (sub to, assumable (look at VA but requires OO), owner financing, etc) and only did buy, rehab, rent, and repeat (one less R - more precisely not a refi but maybe use 2nd or heloc)? I still need reserves for the value add. What if instead of refi there was a construction loan or, post rehab, 2nd or heloc was used to not lose the below market financing obtained at purchase via alternative financing. Can you imagine a scenario where this does not bleed cash?

    You are in a great market to achieve high returns via value adds.  In addition, long holds historically have produced good returns in that market.  The trick is to combine them without the initial negative cash flow.  I have shown some ways to do it.  

    More to ponder. lots to ponder.

    Good luck.

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Cameron Daste:

    Thanks, @Bradley Buxton.

    Along this line of thinking, would it make sense to also look into a syndication model? I understand there's more legal ramifications in doing so (LLC creation?). But this model would help in getting together the necessary funds (especially for a down payment and minimizing the potential interest on a loan), while bringing in legal complexity. Thoughts here?

    Houses that I've been looking at are $500 - $750K range.


     Syndication, to maximize return, still use financing.  They raise the money that is needed to purchase with the financing.  Any other way and the projected returns would typically be too low to generate much interest (it would be difficult to find LPs). 

    Finding LPs in this RE environment is challenging and would be even more challenging for a sponsor who has not yet brought a syndication to a successful exit.  My son recently talked to me about being a sponsor on a sophisticated value add.  I to,d him if he thought selling Cutco knives was challenging, imagine trying to sell a person on investing $50k or more with a sponsor that has yet to perform in this RE market (regardless if the value add is smart and likely to do well).  

    Good luck


  • Member since 2024 · 12 posts · 5 votes
    2y

    Appreciate the comments here, Dan!

  • Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    @Cameron Daste, I think you have a general sense here. If you cannot afford the buy in yourself, you bring in partners. A partnership is different and "easier" to setup than a syndication. Both require legal work, but when you are dealing with other active partners there is a little less in terms of setup costs and complexity. But if you think "LLC filing" is complex, then neither is a good option for you. For reference, your typical setup costs for a true syndication with all the regulatory filings and documentation is likely going to be around $10k or more. Partnerships can typically be setup for 3-5k, depending on the attorney. For many, the rule of thumb is syndication is not worth the expense unless you can raise $1mm or more.

    I am going to differ from Dan, a touch. While a flip is more intense, owning a rental is NOT just sitting back and collecting money. You will either need to manage tenants or manage property managers. In my limited experience managers are actually harder to manage than tenants. And typically, single family and small multifamily properties are not valued on cap rates and NOI.

    Where I agree is: if you are going to make a, say, 20% ROI on a flip, if you are flipping a $100k property, that is only $20k. If you flip a $1mm property, that is $200k. The return percentage is the same, but the impact to lifestyle is, presumably, vastly different. And when deals are slim to pick up anyways, if I had the financial wherewithal to swing a $1mm flip, I would take that one over trying to find 10 flips at $100k each.

    And for rentals, the same is generally true, with the caveat that cheap rentals get cheap tenants.  Cheap tenants, in my experience, create higher turn over costs and move out more frequently than higher rent tenants.  They are also a lot more price conscious when it comes to rent increases (both dollar amount and percentage).

  • Corby GoadeBusiness Member
    Investor · Boise, ID · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Cameron Daste:

    Curious to hear folks' thoughts on the recommended approaches for markets where home values are on the higher end. Trying to get started in the real estate investing space, and I live in Seattle where home prices are quite high (at least, in my opinion). I've heard flipping might be a good place to start, but would love to hear about people's opinions and experiences in these types of markets. What tends to work, watchouts, etc...

    Thanks in advance!


     Great question- I love that you are looking for HOW to make it work rather than having decided that it doesn't work, that attitude will serve you well. 

    I invest in Boise, ID, which has fairly similar ratios and returns to what you see in SEA. As a matter of fact, I connected lots of investors in SEA to invest here, so I have a decent handle on that market. 

    For me- finding opportunities where I can force at least 15% equity and be cash flow neutral the first year is an excellent deal. Do I see them every day? Nope, but I do see them regularly. As a matter of fact, I just bought a triplex off of the MLS that is cash flow positive and will have about $75K in equity when I'm done with rehab. Deals like that will be grand slams in 5-7 years- great cash flow and tons of equity.

    Honestly, the biggest challenge in your market won't be finding deals, it will be over regulation and lack of control over your property. That's why a lot of people on the west coast invest in states like Idaho- slightly better returns, but it's probably the most landlord friendly state in the nation. 

  • Michael HaasBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Sammamish, 🌧️ Seattle Investor-Agent | 🤑 Helped 400+ Clients Invest in Real Estate | 🏘️ Owns 23 WA Rentals & Airbnbs | 🏗️ Built 5 DADU's | 📈 You Can Do It Too · Member since 2016 · 725 posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    @Cameron Daste flipping is highly competitive, as a newbie your about as likely to lose money as make money. Have you considered HouseHacking? Some simple Math:

    Lets say you do a Seattle 4plex HouseHack w/ 5% down conventional (a new loan option for multifamily that's better than 3.5% down FHA, just DM me if you want the full rundown on why).

    That $70,000 could purchase you a property up to $1,400,000... and to get a 100% ROI on your investment all you need is 5% appreciation on the property. The average appreciation rate in Seattle over the last 40 years has been 5.5%. Cashflow / rents will provide additional ROI but in our experience over a long hold time appreciation will always contribute more to your total ROI than cashflow. Interest rates will also be .25% - 1% lower on an owner occupied property than on a rental property.

    Contrast that with buying out of state / non owner occupied properties. That $70,000 now has to go into a 20 - 25% down mortgage, allowing you to purchase a property for $280,000 - $350,000. Now, to see 100% ROI the property would have to appreciate 20 - 25% in value. Cashflow / rents will provide additional ROI but not enough to overshadow the more favorable loan terms and higher value of the househacked property.

    This is an oversimplification but I'm sure you get the point! Happy to talk about the strategy more - we're up to over 20 rentals owned in WA now and wouldn't have been able to scale to that level quickly without househacking.

    HouseHack Seattle | Michael Haas & Team572 Reviews
  • Lender · Seattle, WA · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 899 votes
    2y

    @Cameron Daste- thanks ....you will have a challenge with finding much in the KING COUNTY area for 500-700K range ...if you want to remain local - you will likely need to broaden to Pierce / Snoh County area . Before spending much time seraching - make sure you have the other elements addressed and in place ( funds for closing / finnancing / contractors etc...) . If you have no needs for financing - the process will be much easier . IF you need to get a loan - buying as a house hack strategy ( living in the property ) will be easier than buying as a rental . Getting a loan in the name of a LLC is much harder than getting a loan in your personal name . Get pre approved with a lender if needing to use financing - thanks

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.