All Forum Posts by: Brett Synicky
Brett Synicky has started 25 posts and replied 779 times.
Post: Using $$ from IRA as downpayment on a STR?

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Quote from @Brian Wendel:
I've been considering purchasing a vacation rental property, but I would be using money from my SDIRA account for the down payment in order to get started. It would be an early withdrawal so I know I would be hit with a 10% penalty in addition to being taxed on the money that I would be taking out. I'm looking in very well-established vacation rental markets. I've run various calculations on what the value of my downpayment money would be over a 5, 10, 15, and 20-year period based on just leaving it untouched in the IRA vs. using it to invest in a STR and in almost all cases the STR outperforms, unless it just massively underperforms. Has anyone ever done this before? Just looking to get some feedback from the community on if this is a good idea or not.
Nope. Set up a checkbook ira or solo 401k and invest in real estate if you want to use ira money. Or as @Nicholas L. stated just save up the money and then do it. Don’t rob your retirement account.
Post: Can a spouse be listing agent for my IRA property?

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
@Tidal Creek you and your immediate family are disqualified party's to your IRA. Having your spouse perform a service like that for a property your IRA owns would be a prohibited transaction and could disqualify your entire IRA. Don't do it.
Post: Non Recourse Lender Reccs

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Other retirement accounts. Also explore this list. https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/2810/50272-list-o...
Post: Self Directed IRA for Fix and Flip

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Quote from @Shango Collier:
When purchasing through SDIRA for a rental property would you also have to seek out commercial lending since you (yourself) can not personally guarantee it?
Additionally a seller carry would work as long as it’s non-recourse. Also a sub 2 would work even though technically the loan isn’t non-recourse since the ira owner didn’t guarantee the loan.
Post: Can a Husband and Wife with Separate IRAs Both Lend on the Same Property? If So, How?

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Quote from @Mitch Messer:
We've got an interesting private lending situation:
- Husband and wife, each with their own checkbook SDIRAs, want to lend on the same real estate deal.
- Borrower needs $100K.
- Each spouse can lend $50K.
First question: Is this even allowed?
Second question: If allowed, what's the best structure? A first and a second lien? A single shared co-loan? Something else?
I'm asking because the guidance we're getting from their IRA custodian sounds questionable. We'd like a second opinion.
Has anyone here done something like this?
Any advice and/or insight would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks in advance!
There are a few ways to do this. 1: create a multi-member LLC, both IRA's are the members and the LLC holds all the assets. 2: each have their own LLC that invests into one asset as "co-investors" so to speak. Option 2 is much better typically because you won't be restricted to that one LLC having to do the same investments at the same time with the same original 50/50%. Option 1 is not ideal unless both spouses or other people are only going to do one investment together like a $10 million apartment building or something. In the thousands of checkbook IRA's we've set up we've done less than 10 multi-member LLC's.On the other hand if they qualify for a Solo 401k now the 401k is the investor and much easier to "combine" both spouses funds without the restrictions that come with the multi-member LLC.In either case, all expenses and income related to a combined investment must be shared pro-rata throughout the life of that investment.
Post: Can you purchase a rental property with your IRA as a co-owner/partner?

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Good question.
Unfortunately, you and your immediate family are considered disqualified persons to your retirement plan. That means none of you can personally guarantee a loan used by the IRA or Solo 401(k)—any financing must be non-recourse.
Even if you plan to partner personally with your IRA, there are strict rules. It's not as simple as just going 50/50. The IRS prohibits self-dealing, so if either party (you or your IRA) enables the other to make the investment—meaning one couldn’t do it without the other—it would be considered a prohibited transaction.
One possible structure is to set up a multi-member LLC, where you are one member and your IRA is another. However, this setup comes with added complexity:
-
The LLC must file a Form 1065 partnership return, regardless of whether any taxes are due.
-
Because you (a disqualified person) are a partial owner alongside your IRA, there's a higher risk of engaging in a prohibited transaction, which could lead to your entire IRA becoming disqualified.
To stay on the safe side, it's generally best to keep all retirement account investments at arm's length—meaning your IRA should not co-invest with disqualified persons.
Consult a tax-advisor who's well versed in this area before proceeding.
Post: getting started with a self directed 401k/IRA

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
@Jason Braddock it is possible in some circumstances to partner with your IRA/401k though it's not the simplest thing to do and it increases the chance of a prohibited transaction. Better to use your retirement funds to make one or two investments instead of the down payment for several if your personal funds need to be involved. Or partner up your IRA with somebody that's not immediate family.
Post: getting started with a self directed 401k/IRA

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Quote from @Jason Braddock:
I have funds in a 401k from a previous employer that would cover a down payment for several investments I have looked into. I have read a few things about them and am just unclear of how to get that setup (through the institution they are sitting in or an institution that specializes in this?) what are the limitations on these and which I should go for (IRA or 401k). if anyone is experienced in this I would appreciate any advice.
The two options are SDIRA or Solo 401k. As a Solo 401k does not trigger UDFI tax on leveraged real estate it's the better option if you qualify. More info about checkbook IRA and Solo 401k below. Also study checkbook control versus basic custodial accounts.
Solo 401k
https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/2810/21298-solo-401k-advantages
Sdira self directed ira
https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/2810/blog_posts/28450-real-estate-ira
Post: Best SDIRA administrator?

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
Quote from @Kerry Noble Jr:
Quote from @Brad Hales:
@Kerry Noble Jr I have not heard of Quest. Are they local to the Tampa Bay Area?
I think TX
Post: Equity Trust held rental... Transfer apon death options?

- Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant
- Orange, CA
- Posts 805
- Votes 436
@Jen Ray Why is it unfortunate taht it's Roth?! There are no taxes in the non-spousal inherited Roth IRA so long as it's met the 5 year rule